The Ice Storm Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of Ang Lee's "The Ice Storm" by Criterion offers a meticulously crafted 1080p transfer, encoded with MPEG-4 AVC. The video presentation is supervised by director Ang Lee and cinematographer Frederick Elmes, boasting a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The digital transfer was executed in 2K resolution on a Spirit 4K DataCine from a 35mm interpositive, involving comprehensive color correction via Autodesk's Lustre system. Throughout the process, MTI's DRS and Pixel Farm's PFClean addressed thousands of imperfections including dirt and scratches, while Image Systems' Phoenix targeted smaller artifacts like grain and noise. The collaborative supervision by experts such as Joe Gawler and Gregg Garvin ensured a technically proficient presentation.

The high-definition transfer showcases improvements over its DVD predecessor, albeit inconsistently. In certain scenes, details are sharp, exemplified by the textures in clothing and the precise depiction of ice. Despite generally stable colors, there are sections where light sharpening corrections lead to slightly harsh appearances and visible halo effects. Although contrast levels have been moderated for certain sequences, some scenes suffer from flat visual output, detracting from the immersive quality. On a positive note, excess degraining has been avoided, preserving natural film textures.

Throughout the film, there are well-defined moments where colors truly excel, particularly in daylight scenes. However, as the story unfolds, deliberate stylistic changes in cinematography augment the narrative, employing muted hues and softened blacks to align with character emotions. These choices sometimes result in diminished contrast and depth, particularly in dimly lit scenes. Despite these fluctuations, Criterion's release surpasses its DVD edition in clarity and detail. The Blu-ray is Region-A locked, necessitating compatible playback hardware to access its content. Overall, while the release represents an upgrade, there remains room for visual enhancement.

The Blu-ray release of "The Ice Storm" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 soundtrack, which has been remastered at 24-bit from the original 35 mm LT/RT magnetic track. This remastering process included manual removal of clicks, thumps, hiss, and hum using Pro Tools HD, while AudioCube's integrated workstation attenuated crackle. The resulting audio track stands as a significant upgrade from its DVD counterpart, enriching the viewing experience with its clear and crisp dialogue and enhanced sonic details.

The audio track provides a notable dynamic range, especially commendable for a family drama. It crafts a palpable sense of space, engaging the viewer with its nuanced soundscapes. From the subtle, quiet sounds of ice crunching beneath train wheels and branches tinkling in the wind to the impactful booms of fireworks that maximize the bass channel, the audio presentation is immersive. Moreover, Mychael Danna's poignant score, along with incidental sounds such as train movements across channels and individual car door closures, are smartly utilized and fill the speakers dynamically, further enhancing the film's atmosphere.

Criterion's attention to detail also extends to optional English SDH subtitles for accessibility, ensuring a comprehensive viewing experience. In summary, the audio presentation on the Blu-ray release of "The Ice Storm" significantly elevates the film's auditory appeal through its meticulous remastering efforts and thoughtful soundstage creation, making it a worthy upgrade from previous releases.

The Blu-ray extras for "The Ice Storm" present an insightful and comprehensive exploration of the film's creation and legacy. The material, originally from Criterion's 2007 DVD release, showcases exclusive interviews and discussions with the cast, director Ang Lee, and producer/screenwriter James Schamus. Noteworthy is the engaging commentary where Lee and Schamus delve into anecdotes from their collaboration, highlighting their dynamic partnership. The "Weathering the Storm" documentary offers depth with cast reflections on their roles and initial reactions to Lee’s distinctive directing approach. Deleted scenes, complete with commentary, provide additional layers to character development. The disc also includes a fascinating dialogue at the Museum of the Moving Image and discussions emphasizing the film's visual design components. Each piece is significant in understanding the nuanced craftsmanship and considerations behind this iconic film.

Extras included in this disc:

• Trailer: Original theatrical trailer.
• Weathering the Storm: Cast discussions on character experiences and working with Ang Lee.
• Rick Moody Interview: Insights on adapting the novel to film.
• Deleted Scenes: Four scenes with optional commentary.
• Lee and Schamus at MoMI: Discussion on creative partnership milestones.
• The Look of The Ice Storm: Audio interviews on film aesthetics.
• Commentary: Amusing discussion with Ang Lee and James Schamus.
• Booklet: Illustrated booklet with film critique by Bill Krohn.

Ang Lee's "The Ice Storm," adapted from Rick Moody's 1994 novel, delves deep into the lives of two suburban Connecticut families in 1973, capturing their struggle with dissatisfaction in a rapidly changing social landscape. The film's opening, featuring young Paul Hood (Tobey Maguire) reading The Fantastic Four, sets a tone of anticipated upheavals as it parallels familial tensions and foreshadows impending crises. Through polished cinematography by Frederick Elmes and a serene, atmospheric score by Mychael Danna, the movie presents a beautifully detached world that nevertheless feels intensely personal.

Character dynamics are intricately woven, with standout performances from Kevin Kline and Joan Allen as the disillusioned couple, whose fragile marriage is further complicated by infidelities and unmet desires. Sigourney Weaver's portrayal of Janey Carver as a bored yet assertive housewife is both captivating and deeply human. The younger cast, including Christina Ricci, Elijah Wood, and debutant Katie Holmes, adeptly navigate their roles as teenagers exploring their burgeoning sexuality amidst parental misdirection. This exploration is depicted with an honesty that remains impactful, making their struggles resonate with a lasting poignancy.

The film excels in its ability to pull viewers into the era, recreating it not just through visuals but through thematic elements that speak to timeless human conflicts. The narrative subtly underscores family dysfunctionality through delicately written scenes—such as an uncomfortable key party—that reveal more than verbal interactions ever could. Despite its initial lack of recognition at the Academy Awards, "The Ice Storm" stands out for its exceptional craftsmanship and narrative depth. Ang Lee, with a talented cast and crew, has crafted a cinematic piece that not only captures the specific zeitgeist of the early '70s but also timelessly reflects on personal identity and family crises.

"The Ice Storm," directed by Ang Lee and inspired by Rick Moody's novel, stands as a film of exceptional narrative and emotional depth. Lee's masterful direction weaves humor with melancholy in a reflection of 1970s suburban life that is both elegant and unsettling. This film's transition to Blu-ray, released by Criterion, enhances the visual experience compared to the earlier DVD version, though the upgrade may not fully meet the expectations of those familiar with modern high-definition standards. The presentation is adequate but could benefit from sharper clarity and more vivid colors.

Despite these minor technical shortcomings, the Blu-ray offers a satisfying package for fans and film scholars alike. The high-definition transfer, while not groundbreaking, thoughtfully preserves Lee's artistic vision. Criterion complements the film with existing extras that delve into its production, providing valuable insights into the creative process. These features significantly enhance the overall viewing experience for those interested in exploring the artistic and historical context of Lee's work.

In conclusion, while "The Ice Storm" on Blu-ray may not revolutionize your home theater experience, it remains an essential piece for any serious collector or fan of Ang Lee. The strengths of the film itself—layered storytelling, profound emotional impact, and exquisite direction—shine through any technical limitations. This release is recommended for viewers who appreciate nuanced narratives and the artistry behind cinematic masterpieces.