The Mexico Trilogy 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
El Mariachi BD Once Upon a Time in Mexico BD | Limited Edition
Score: 87
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Arrow Video’s 4K UHD Blu-ray of The Mexico Trilogy showcases Robert Rodriguez's impactful films with top-notch visual and audio quality, making it highly recommended for film enthusiasts.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
DTS-HD MA
Video: 86
The Mexico Trilogy's Blu-Ray presentation excels with 'Desperado' in stunning 4K UHD and Dolby Vision, showcasing vibrant colors and rich contrasts. 'El Mariachi' maintains its gritty charm with its 1080p restoration, while 'Once Upon a Time in Mexico,' though limited by its original digital format, still sees notable improvement in 1080p.
Audio: 83
The Mexico Trilogy offers an impressive audio presentation, with El Mariachi making the most of its stereo track, Desperado delivering phenomenal DTS-HD MA 5.1 dynamics, and Once Upon a Time in Mexico providing a rich DTS-HD MA 5.1 experience, despite its constant rear speaker activity. All films include optional English subtitles and stereo mixes.
Extra: 97
The 4K UHD Blu Ray release of "The Mexico Trilogy" by Arrow Video excels with abundant and varied supplements, both new and classic, that highlight Rodriguez's distinctive filmmaking style, complemented by an illustrated collector's booklet and reversible artwork, making it a must-have for fans.
Movie: 80
The Mexico Trilogy is a testament to Robert Rodriguez's audacious filmmaking journey, transforming micro-budget ingenuity into iconic cinema. Despite technical disparities, the films shine with relentless energy, standout performances, and pioneering action sequences, gaining new life in Arrow Video’s carefully crafted 4K UHD Blu-ray release.
Video: 86
The Mexico Trilogy’s 4K UHD Blu-ray release by Arrow Video offers a visually dynamic and technical presentation that adheres closely to the original aesthetics of each film. "El Mariachi," shot on 16mm film, retains its gritty, low-budget charm in a 1080p format. Its 1.85:1 anamorphic presentation exhibits a high degree of grain, characteristic of its original medium, yet shines with rich, vibrant colors that bring warmth to the screen. While the transfer remains sharp and clean, it preserves the film's rough-hewn edges by choice, paying homage to its homemade punk rock aesthetic.
"Desperado," the highlight of this trilogy in terms of video quality, receives a 4K UHD treatment with Dolby Vision. Sony Pictures’ 4K restoration from the original camera negative results in an immaculate display in 1.85:1 anamorphic ratio. The film stands out with its seamless blend of rich textures, spot-on skin tones, and intricate gradations in its dusty desert palette. The HDR grading enhances the visual depth and contrast, particularly in the film’s darker scenes and explosive sequences. The vibrant visuals set a new benchmark for home viewing experiences, feeling remarkably like watching it anew.
"Once Upon a Time in Mexico," shot digitally with Sony CineAlta cameras at 1080p resolution, has always been a step down visually. This version maintains its original 1.78:1 anamorphic format for authenticity. Despite its limitations, Arrow Video’s presentation is notably smooth and blemish-free for its time, although digital imperfections surface in close-ups. The refined Blu-ray encoding enhances its viewing quality beyond previous releases. Despite lacking 4K upscaling or HDR enhancement, this Blu-ray watch genuinely respects the original vision while acknowledging the film’s historical role in digital shooting’s evolution.
Audio: 83
The audio presentation of "The Mexico Trilogy" in 4K UHD Blu Ray leaves a lasting impression with its powerful and muscular soundscapes. El Mariachi, despite its modest budget and technical limitations, delivers a commendable uncompressed Latin-American stereo track. While the optional lossless English dub is available, the original language version stands out with its clear dialogue and ambient score that enhances the atmosphere of each scene. The gun battles are well-crafted with strategic LFE usage, offering depth without overwhelming the crisp audio. Robert Rodriguez's innovative post-production techniques contribute to the clarity and directness of the dialogue, setting a high standard for budget filmmaking.
Desperado elevates the auditory experience with an exceptional DTS-HD MA 5.1 sound mix that immediately commands attention. The energetic Los Lobos score and dynamic soundstage transform explosive gun battles into visceral experiences. With the ability to toggle between 5.1 and uncompressed stereo mixes, viewers have flexible options depending on their sound setup. The 5.1 mix is particularly impressive, allowing for immersive engagement through front and rear speaker placement, ensuring dialogue remains distinct amidst chaotic action sequences.
Once Upon a Time in Mexico maintains the series' strong audio tradition with its DTS-HD MA 5.1 surround mix. Though criticized for its constant activity in the rear speakers, it provides a robust auditory landscape. The action sequences deliver substantial immersion, despite some unnatural mixing choices. An interesting feature is the rear speaker whisper effects not found in the stereo mix, providing a unique listening experience. Thankfully, dialogue remains clear and intelligible across mixes. The trilogy offers versatile options with both surround and stereo tracks, ensuring a satisfying listening experience for various audio configurations.
Extras: 97
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "The Mexico Trilogy" by Arrow Video is a meticulous collector's package that shines with its comprehensive supplemental materials, catering to both fans and newcomers. This set not only compiles previously available bonuses but also introduces a variety of fresh content that enriches the viewing experience. Noteworthy are the exclusive new interviews with director Robert Rodriguez and key collaborators, providing insights into the trilogy’s inventive production process. Longtime supporters will appreciate the archival commentaries and beloved featurettes, such as "Ten Minute Film School" and "Ten Minute Cooking School." An illustrated booklet and various posters further adorn this package, adding a tangible layer of appreciation for the artistic journey depicted across these films.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary by Robert Rodriguez: Insight into his creative process.
- Big Vision Low Budget: Interview with Rodriguez.
- The Original Mariachi: Interview with Carlos Gallardo.
- Lean and Mean: Interview about Desperado's genesis.
- The Revolution Will Be Digitized: Discusses digital shift.
- Inside Troublemaker Studios: Behind-the-scenes look.
- Film is Dead: An Evening with Robert Rodriguez: Presentation on digital filmmaking's rise.
- Band of Misfits: The Music of El Mariachi: Interviews with film composers.
Movie: 80
Robert Rodriguez's The Mexico Trilogy, notably launched with the groundbreaking El Mariachi, profoundly influenced the realm of independent filmmaking. Shot for a mere $7,000, El Mariachi's raw ambition and frenetic energy proved captivating, establishing Rodriguez's deft skill in cinematic problem-solving. Its gritty narrative of a wandering mariachi mistaken for a killer, entangled with gangsters, demonstrated that a compelling story and resourceful execution could rival big-budget counterparts. The minimal production only underscored Rodriguez's talent, elevating El Mariachi to a must-see status for aspiring filmmakers and validating the art of cinema as accessible.
Desperado, the second installment and essentially a high-octane reimagining of El Mariachi, emerged with enhanced studio backing, boasting a $7 million budget. This allowed Rodriguez to transition to larger cinematic canvases, capturing electrifying performances from Antonio Banderas and Salma Hayek. Infused with Guillermo Navarro's cinematography and Los Lobos' vibrant musical score, Desperado stands out as an iconic 1990s action film. The palpable chemistry between Banderas and Hayek, combined with stylized action sequences and sharp comedic undertones, cements its position as a cornerstone in Hispanic cinema.
Once Upon a Time in Mexico concludes the trilogy on a divergent path, embracing Hollywood's shift towards digital filmmaking. While retaining Rodriguez’s signature action flair, the film experiments with a broader political narrative. Despite an ensemble cast that includes Johnny Depp and returning favorites like Banderas and Hayek, the film struggles with its ambitious plot and can feel disjointed at times. Notwithstanding these critiques, the trilogy's innovative approach sustains its place in cinematic history, with compelling energy and groundbreaking representation throughout. This release by Arrow presents the trilogy in impressive 1080p HD, with Desperado benefiting from 4K UHD treatment, accompanied by detailed reversible cover art and informative booklets.
Total: 87
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "The Mexico Trilogy" by Arrow Video celebrates the revolutionary journey of filmmaker Robert Rodriguez from indie maverick to mainstream powerhouse. This collection vividly displays the evolution of Rodriguez's cinematic style across its three installments, each contributing significantly to the shift in how budget constraints are transformed into creative opportunities. Arrow's release offers a comprehensive package enriched with outstanding technical features, formidable video and audio presentations, and a treasure trove of supplementary materials that will resonate with any audience appreciative of independent cinema and high-octane action alike.
Although rooted in low-budget origins, this trilogy encapsulates a pivotal moment for aspiring filmmakers of the 1990s, showcasing a newfound accessibility to previously unattainable cinematic ambitions. The meticulous packaging and commitment to quality in audio-visual representation reflect Arrow's dedication to honoring these films' enduring impact. The set includes multiple audio mixes, ensuring an immersive experience, while the abundance of extras provide a deeper exploration into Rodriguez's creative process and the films' cultural significance.
Conclusively, "The Mexico Trilogy" stands as a testament to Rodriguez's distinct filmmaking prowess and serves as a valuable slice of cinema history. Arrow Video’s craftsmanship in compiling this box set makes it an essential acquisition for fans of the trilogy, aficionados of action cinema, and anyone intrigued by the rise of indie filmmakers who reshaped the landscape of the industry. Highly recommended for those seeking both nostalgia and cinematic artistry, this release encapsulates the spirit and influence of an era.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
...
Audio: 80
...
Extras: 100
This limited edition has Arrow's typical assortment of non-disc swag, including an illustrated collector's booklet featuring some great essays....
Movie: 80
There's an almost feral and unkempt quality to the admittedly lo-fi and perhaps just slightly not ready for prime time ambience of El Mariachi, but there is also such an amazingly assured presence in the...
Total: 80
Robert Rodriguez continues to be a rather distinctive filmmaker in a number of ways, and this trilogy is an interesting document of sorts detailing his rapid rise from indie wunderkind to big budget A-lister....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There’s just something about it that looks warm and welcoming in the film tones, but also the various imperfections throughout, like losing focus during a chaotic action sequence, or some overblown highlights...
Audio: 80
Offscreen henchmen whisper to each other, in a rear speaker effect not available in its alternate 2.0 stereo mix, which is kind of neat, but the whisper is so over-the-top loud it sounds like I’m being...
Extras: 100
The Music of 'El Mariachi', a newly produced featurette on the music in the film, featuring interviews with composers Eric Guthrie, Chris Knudson, Alvaro Rodriguez and Marc Trujillo (HD, 12:41) Ten Minute...
Movie: 80
Sometimes Once Upon a Time feels more like a demo reel for digital video, but there’s so much energy and excitement, that all is forgiven, especially because Rodriguez is able to stretch his legs with...
Total: 80
The 1990s were an exciting time for writers and artists looking to break into film, with filmmakers like Robert Rodriguez riding a wave of independent talent breaking into the industry and redefining it....
Home Theater Forum review by soonercineasteRead review here
Video: 100
There are still moments where the digital seams show, particularly on extreme close-ups of faces and clothing, but on balance, this is arguably the best Mexico has ever looked on home video, which could...
Audio: 100
Desperado’s DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack is flat-out phenomenal, rendering the delicate nuance of plucked acoustic guitar strings (the film’s opening credits sequence, featuring Banderas crooning “Morena de...
Extras: 100
The film includes an archival Rodriguez commentary track, as well as a pair of all-new featurettes, created by Arrow Video exclusively for this release: “The Revolution Will Be Digitized” (12:41; presented...
Movie: 90
Once Upon a Time in Mexico, arriving in 2003 (nearly a decade after Desperado), is a transitional work, one caught in the messy evolution from celluloid to digital filmmaking, as Hollywood grappled with...
Total: 100
Although The Mexico Trilogy, as it is now called, seems to have been retconned into existence, the impact of the first two films, certainly, is undeniable....