27 Dresses Blu-ray Review
Score: 56
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'27 Dresses' charms despite clichés, with solid Blu-ray quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 63
27 Dresses' Blu-ray dazzles with impeccable detail and vibrant colors, offering a top-notch image, despite minor softness and slightly unrealistic fleshtones.
Audio: 61
Fox's DTS-HD MA 5.1 rendition of '27 Dresses' impresses with immersive, well-reproduced music and effective sound placement, though dialogue can sometimes be overshadowed; contrasts with criticisms of lackluster sound design and underutilized surround capabilities.
Extra: 41
Fox's '27 Dresses' Blu-ray extras offer a promotional glimpse with wardrobe insights, light featurettes, and deleted scenes, mostly in HD but cater to a specific audience without deep filmmaking exploration.
Movie: 56
Despite praising '27 Dresses' as a refreshing standout in the genre, especially for skeptics of romantic comedies, another critique finds it falls flat, lacking in character depth and originality.
Video: 63
"27 Dresses" shines on Blu-ray in a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode, presented in an aspect ratio of 2.35:1, showcasing the film’s vibrant and detailed image quality. Fox has once again delivered a home viewing experience that inches close to perfection, with the movie boasting an impeccable level of detail. From scenes captured in the bustling cityscape to the intimate settings of a traditional Indian-Jewish wedding, every frame pulses with clarity and vibrant colors, where background elements are as finely detailed as the main characters. Although primarily a romantic comedy—a genre not demanding visual spectacle—this transfer elevates the film’s aesthetic appeal. The color palette is generally inviting, presenting vivid and dynamic hues during well-lit scenes and night sequences, enhancing the visual storytelling despite occasional underwhelming color performance in daylight scenarios.
Despite these strengths, there are minor inconsistencies that temper the visual feast "27 Dresses" aims to deliver on Blu-ray. Blacks are deep and generally well executed, yet they slightly falter from achieving perfection. Similarly, flesh tones vary in accuracy, at times appearing pristine and at other instances veering towards artificiality. These discrepancies, alongside sporadic softness and a somewhat over-bright contrast that can lead to a washed-out appearance, hint at a transfer that doesn’t consistently tap into its full potential. However, the overall presentation remains highly watchable, bolstered by a meticulous attention to detail and a fine layer of grain that contributes to a film-like authenticity.
On balance, "27 Dresses" on Blu-ray offers a pleasing visual experience that celebrates its genre while nudging closer to the high standards set by the best transfers in the format. The movie's interior scenes, especially those set in Jane's apartment, demonstrate how effectively this Blu-ray edition can render spaces with realism and depth, creating an immersive three-dimensional effect. Despite shortcomings in color vibrancy during certain sequences and issues with contrast and flesh tone realism, the movie succeeds in reproducing a theatrical look that will delight fans and cinephiles alike.
Audio: 61
The audio presentation of '27 Dresses' on Blu Ray is delivered through a DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack, which showcases a polished fidelity with a healthy dynamic range and adequate low bass, tailored specifically to suit the romantic comedy genre. The score by Randy Edelman, alongside the selection of pop songs, plays a significant role throughout the film, especially during vivid wedding scenes and montages. Though the music is critically acclaimed for its expertise in replication, creating an immersive and joyous experience that utilizes the rear speakers effectively, there have been criticisms regarding its dominance over dialogue in parts. This sometimes results in speech being overshadowed, despite dialogue generally being clear, well-balanced, and precisely aimed through the center channel for optimal clarity.
The use of surround sound has been noted as somewhat understated, with discrete effects being sparingly employed. The soundtrack has been described as front-heavy and, to an extent, unvaried or unexciting, indicating a missed opportunity to exploit the full capabilities of the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 Surround setup. Nevertheless, certain scenes, such as a notably crafted rainstorm, demonstrate the soundtrack’s potential for excellence. These moments offer a well-placed sonic experience that accurately mirrors the on-screen action, highlighting the careful consideration given to the mix's imaging and natural sound design. This showcases an effective but subtle use of ambient sounds in the rear channels to enhance the film’s atmosphere without resorting to flashy or overly ambitious audio effects.
Despite these criticisms, the overall execution of '27 Dresses' audio accompaniment on Blu Ray reflects a competent handling suited to its genre. While it may not push the boundaries of what is technically possible with modern home audio systems, it provides a satisfactory auditory experience that complements the film's content. The soundtrack does what it needs to do with proficiency, ensuring that voices are prioritized when necessary and engaging the audience musically in a manner that enhances the viewing pleasure, albeit with room for improvement in balancing and surround sound utilization.
Extra: 41
The Blu-ray release of "27 Dresses" comes with a selection of extras that seem mostly targeted at its core demographic, without offering much in terms of the filmmaking process or behind-the-scenes content that enthusiasts might hope for. The extras comprise a mixture of high-definition featurettes and standard-definition content, including promotional pieces like "The Wedding Party" and "You'll Never Wear That Again," which delve into the cast, plot, and, notably, the array of dresses featured in the film. "Jane's World" offers a glimpse into the production design, while "The Running of the Brides" provides a quirky look at a bridal dress sale event. The collection rounds off with a few deleted scenes, offering a peek at cut content, but notably lacks any theatrical trailers for "27 Dresses" itself. Overall, these supplements provide a somewhat surface-level complement to the movie, enhanced by multiple subtitle options but marred by a focus on promotion over depth.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Wedding Party: Cast and crew discuss the plot and characters.
- You'll Never Wear That Again: Exploration of the 27 dresses featured in the film.
- Jane's World: Insight into filming locations and set designs.
- The Running of the Brides: Featurette on a discount bridal dress event.
- Deleted Scenes: Three scenes not included in the final film.
Movie: 56
"27 Dresses" emerges as a distinctive offering within the romantic comedy genre, steering clear of the pitfalls that often render similar movies forgettable. Helmed by Anne Fletcher and elevated by the script of Aline Brosh McKenna, the film infuses a blend of emotional resonance and lighthearted humor, adeptly avoiding the trappings of melodrama or overt sentimentality. Its narrative, centered around Jane (played by Katherine Heigl), the perennial bridesmaid caught in the whirlwind of wedding fever, navigates themes of love, sacrifice, and personal growth with a commendable balance. Unlike many rom-coms that struggle to break free from genre clichés, "27 Dresses" succeeds in delivering a story that feels both fresh and engaging, anchored by the palpable chemistry between its leads, Heigl and James Marsden.
Praise for the movie extends to its well-curated ensemble cast, whose performances breathe life into characters that could have easily been relegated to one-dimensional tropes. Heigl shines as the endearing yet beleaguered Jane, bringing depth to a role that demands both comedic timing and emotional vulnerability. Marsden's portrayal of Kevin Doyle adds layers to the narrative, providing a counterbalance to Heigl's character with charm and wit. The dynamic between the characters, enriched by their complex personalities and relatable struggles, sets "27 Dresses" apart from its contemporaries, showcasing a rom-com that captures the audience's imagination without resorting to predictability.
However, it's not without its detractors, as some critiques point towards Jane's character arc as being somewhat conventional and the overall plot lacking in originality. Despite these criticisms, "27 Dresses" distinguishes itself through its sincere exploration of personal identity and romantic entanglements. The movie deftly navigates familiar territory with a refreshing perspective, ensuring that it resonates with viewers looking for both humor and heart. Its success lies not in reinventing the wheel but in providing a smartly written, well-acted film that reaffirms the enduring appeal of romantic comedies when executed with care and insight.
Total: 56
"27 Dresses" emerges as an unexpectedly delightful romantic comedy that defies the confines of its genre, blending charm and wit with a well-scripted story and characters. Despite traversing the familiar path of romantic comedies and bearing the burden of a formulaic plot, the movie manages to stand out through its engaging narrative and, most notably, its superior technical presentation on Blu-ray. While it might not dazzle with groundbreaking features or transform the romantic comedy landscape, the Blu-ray release excels in delivering excellent audio and video quality, marking it as one of the best-looking and sounding releases in its category. The special features, although not revolutionary, provide a satisfactory complement to the main feature, aligning with what's typically expected from a release of its caliber.
The combination of Katherine Heigl's performance and a series of touching scenes adds a layer of depth that might surprise viewers, especially those not typically inclined towards the genre. However, the chemistry between leads fails to ignite the screen in a way that elevates the story beyond its predictable beats. This aspect, coupled with a set of largely promotional supplements, positions the Blu-ray as more suitable for a rental rather than a must-own.
In conclusion, "27 Dresses" on Blu-ray presents a solid choice for fans of the genre or those seeking a lighthearted viewing experience, bolstered by its top-notch audiovisual presentation. While it won't redefine expectations or captivate those in search of originality, its charm and technical merits make it worth considering for a cozy night in. The movie’s appeal, underpinned by its quality presentation, ensures it earns a spot among the better romantic comedy releases available, albeit with some reservations concerning content originality and character chemistry.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
There is an ever-so-fine layer of grain present throughout the entirety of the film, a layer that adds a theatrical look and charm to the proceedings, never becoming intrusive or heavy....
Audio: 80
When the perspective shifts, so to does the position of the sound; the result is excellent imaging, the mark of a well-designed, natural-sounding mix....
Extras: 40
You'll Never Wear That Again (1080p, 6:46) examines the actual 27 dresses seen in the movie, the importance and role of the wardrobe of the "ugly" dresses found in Jane's closet, and the search for the...
Movie: 80
Instead, this movie defies convention and manages to create a believable, real-world atmosphere, one that might be just a bit overplayed and dramatic at times, but a world that we can easily and comfortably...
Total: 80
Easy to relate to, fun to watch, and fairly refreshing and original, 27 Dresses may not be the movie that will take Blu-ray into the mainstream of America, or even find its way into the majority of Blu-ray...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The film has the typically bright and bubbly look of a romantic comedy, but this one doesn't quite deliver the goods....
Audio: 60
Fidelity is polished, with healthy dynamic range and low bass that's adequate for the material....
Extras: 20
Featurette: "The Running of the Brides" (HD, 5 minutes) - A brief, bizarre vignette on the retail chain Filene's Basement, which holds annual events where they put tons of wedding dresses on the racks...
Movie: 40
Unfortunately -- and despite the photogenic good looks of both Heigl and Marsden -- we just never become invested in Jane's plight because she's such an unappealing, whiny character, and therefore Kevin...
Total: 40
That might have been fine had the leads generated great chemistry, but even the presence of Katherine Heigl can't elevate the rote script....
Director: Anne Fletcher
Actors: Katherine Heigl, James Marsden, Malin Akerman
PlotJane, a romantic yet perpetually single woman, has made a hobby out of being a bridesmaid. With 27 bridesmaid dresses in her closet, Jane seems to live to serve the brides in her life, embodying the go-to gal for wedding planning and emergencies. Her own desires and dreams, particularly her long-standing crush on her boss, George, take a backseat to her role as the perfect bridesmaid. In contrast to her romantic fantasies, Jane's reality is filled with organizing bridal showers and managing wedding crises, all while keeping her own feelings for George a secret.
Jane's life takes a turn when her younger sister, Tess, arrives in town and quickly captures George's heart, leading to their swift engagement. Jane is forced into the role of the wedding planner for the sister she envies and the man she loves. Meanwhile, a cynical newspaper reporter, Kevin, becomes interested in Jane's story of perpetual bridesmaid, seeing it as his ticket to a more prestigious journalism assignment. As Kevin spends more time with Jane under the guise of writing a feature about her, their initial antagonism turns into something more complex. Amid planning her sister's wedding and dealing with her growing feelings for Kevin, Jane begins to reevaluate her role as the perpetual bridesmaid and starts to envision a different path for her life.
Writers: Aline Brosh McKenna
Release Date: 18 Jan 2008
Runtime: 111 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English