Those Redheads from Seattle Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Those Redheads from Seattle receives a stellar Blu-ray 3D release with superb restoration, impressive audio, and engaging supplements—highly recommended!
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 69
The Blu-ray release of *Those Redheads from Seattle* impresses with a robust 1080p 3D transfer that masterfully handles depth and spatial clarity, despite some inherent source limitations. The 3D Film Archive’s restoration mitigates speckling, jitter, and alignment issues, offering rich colors and strong black levels. However, some color fluctuations persist. Overall, it's a highly commendable effort that brings this vintage film to life on modern displays.
Audio: 82
The DTS-HD Master Audio 3.0 track, fully restored by the 3-D Film Archive, delivers superior fidelity, balanced channel imaging, and rich atmospheric detail, making it the preferred choice over the serviceable yet unimpressive DTS-HD 2.0 mono track.
Extra: 70
The Blu Ray of 'Those Redheads from Seattle' boasts a wealth of insightful extras, including an engrossing audio commentary that delves deeply into the 3D process and restoration efforts, a fascinating restoration demo, a unique 3-Channel Stereo demo, a compelling interview with Rhonda Fleming, and the original trailer.
Movie: 63
Those Redheads from Seattle, the first 3-D musical and Paramount's first widescreen release, offers lighthearted entertainment with catchy tunes, whimsical 3-D effects, and engaging performances. Despite a simple plot and occasional overacting, its historical significance and visual flair make it an enjoyable ride.
Video: 69
The Blu-ray release of "Those Redheads from Seattle" by Kino and 3-D Film Archive offers an impressive visual presentation, with a robust 1080p 3D transfer that stands out significantly. The 2D presentation, while showing the age and condition of the original film elements with occasional speckles, pops, and heavier grain, manages to maintain a satisfying level of clarity and definition that brings out the best in the film's complex wardrobes and detailed furnishings. The restoration effort is commendable given the limited resources, achieving a balanced color palette that, while slightly washed out in places, generally conveys vibrant and nuanced colors. Although some micro-level details may be lacking and the image can appear soft at times, the overall texturing and essential definition are more than adequately handled.
The 3D presentation, however, is where this release truly shines. The 1.66:1 aspect ratio is faithfully rendered with the MVC/AVC codec, and the restoration expert Greg Kintz has done an exceptional job reviving the film’s original color, despite inherent fluctuations. From the unique title sequence that showcases different depth planes to scenes featuring characters moving through cluttered spaces, the 3D experience excels in creating a tangible sense of depth without causing eyestrain. The depth along the Z-Axis is well-maintained with strong black levels aiding in this effect. Instances of speckling, jitter, and color shifts do exist but are minimal and not overly distracting. Pops-out effects, such as the sled dog snout and other objects projecting forward, enhance the dynamic visual composition, making it an extremely enjoyable viewing experience that allows richly decorated sets to truly breathe.
Overall, the Blu-ray release is a testament to the painstaking efforts of the 3-D Film Archive team. While not flawless, it offers a rich and engaging visual experience that should appeal to fans of vintage 3D restorations.
Audio: 82
The Blu-ray release of "Those Redheads from Seattle" features two DTS-HD Master Audio tracks, a reconstituted 3.0 and an original 2.0 mono option. The 3.0 track, restored by the 3-D Film Archive, replicates the original three-channel stereo sound, successfully capturing the nuanced details of dialogue, sound effects, and music. Vocals are notably crisp and prominent, with effective channel imaging that delivers a dynamic auditory experience. Although the absence of the original three-channel tracks might have been a setback, this restored 3.0 mix compensates with its rich atmospheric coverage and balanced soundstage, particularly shining during the musical numbers.
In contrast, the DTS-HD MA 2.0 mono track, while generally clean and artifact-free, falls short of delivering the same immersive quality. The mono mix remains serviceable, offering clear dialogue and sound effects but lacking the spatial richness and fidelity provided by the 3.0 track. For viewers seeking an enhanced audio experience, the 3.0 track is undeniably superior with its responsive levels and vivid center vocal positioning. The stereo mix expands the film’s aural landscape effectively, making it the preferred choice for an authentic and engaging listening experience.
Extras: 70
The extras on the Blu-Ray release of "Those Redheads from Seattle" present a rich, informative experience for enthusiasts, effectively covering various aspects of the film’s production, restoration, and the transition to 3D. The audio commentary is exceptionally detailed and engaging, featuring insights from film historians and professionals involved in the restoration process, providing a deep dive into the 3D process and film history. The Restoration Demo offers a fascinating look at the technical challenges faced and overcome in restoring the original film elements, including alignment issues and sound restoration. The 3-Channel Stereo Demo showcases the film’s audio innovation with visual sound measurements across all channels. The interview with Rhonda Fleming is an excellent retrospective on her career and experiences during the film’s production. The Original Theatrical Trailer adds an authentic piece of history to the package.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: In-depth discussion featuring Hillary Hess and 3-D Film Archive members.
- Restoration Demo: Overview of restoration challenges and solutions.
- 3-Channel Stereo Demo: Demonstration of "Chicka Boom" with visual sound measurements.
- Interview with Rhonda Fleming: Insights from the actress on her career and 3D filmmaking experiences.
- Original Theatrical Trailer: Authentic vintage trailer for the film.
Movie: 63
"Those Redheads from Seattle," directed by Lewis R. Foster, holds a notable place in cinematic history as the first 3-D musical and Paramount Pictures’ first 3-D widescreen release. Set against the backdrop of the Yukon Gold Rush, the narrative follows the Edmonds family’s journey from Seattle to Alaska after the death of their patriarch, newspaper man Vance Edmonds. The family's arrival in Dawson City triggers a combination of romantic entanglements, family disputes, and moral dilemmas, culminating in an engaging mixture of song, dance, and melodrama. Key performances by Rhonda Fleming, Gene Barry, and Agnes Moorehead effectively convey the characters' depth, despite occasionally simplistic plotting and over-the-top acting.
The vibrant Technicolor visuals, combined with the meticulously restored 3-D effects by the 3-D Film Archive, offer an immersive viewing experience that enhances the film's playful, light-hearted atmosphere. The production skillfully meshes outdoor photography with studio backlot exteriors, adding to its visual appeal. Musically, "Those Redheads from Seattle" stands out with catchy tunes performed by Teresa Brewer and Guy Mitchell, seamlessly integrated into the storyline rather than as interruptions. Songs like “Mr. Banjo Man” and “Chick-A-Boom” enliven the film, aligning with its narrative while underscoring elements of subtle commentary on feminism through the characters' actions and motivations.
Though the story might not boast substantial dramatic tension or complexity, it maintains a compelling pace and entertains with its blend of romance, mystery, and spirited performances. The screenplay largely prioritizes the spectacle over narrative depth, yet it achieves an agreeable balance between cheerful escapism and earnest character moments. For those seeking a visually enriching and musically engaging cinematic escape, "Those Redheads from Seattle" delivers a charming and historically significant entertainment experience.
Total: 73
"Those Redheads from Seattle" Blu-ray release breathes new life into this classic 1950s musical, accentuated by its historical significance as Paramount's first 3D musical and widescreen film. The restoration by the 3-D Film Archive and Kino Lorber Studio Classics is nothing short of outstanding. The picture quality is exceptional, capturing the vibrant colors and depth that epitomized early 3D cinema. This Blu-ray edition goes beyond mere visual excellence, presenting a balanced entertainment experience that combines drama, whimsy, and memorable song-and-dance routines.
The audio quality complements the superb visual restoration, providing clear and immersive sound that enhances the viewing experience. The array of bonus features included in this release is impressive, appealing to both film historians and casual viewers alike. These supplements provide valuable insights and contextual depth, making the Blu-ray edition a must-have for collectors and enthusiasts of vintage 3D films.
In conclusion, "Those Redheads from Seattle" should find new life on the Blu-ray 3D format as a timeless guilty pleasure. The film is agreeably balanced, delivering dramatic content within its lighter moments of frivolity and catchy, well-performed song-and-dance routines. Kino's Blu-ray 3D release, the beneficiary of another first-rate restoration from Bob Furmanek and 3-D Film Archive, is well worth watching. Audio is fine, and the supplements are impressive. Highly recommended; this is a hidden classic gem and a welcome escape from the bland 3D conversions and poor quality blockbusters that otherwise dominate the format.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Extremely fine nuanced detail is lacking at more of a micro level and the image is a touch soft in places, but again the disc nicely balances that fine line between its inherent limitations both at the...
Audio: 90
The Stereophonic 3.0 track, fully restored by the 3-D Film Archive, delivers the better listen, with improved fidelity, superior center vocal positioning in both dialogue and song, and it provides more...
Extras: 80
Restoration Demo (1080p, 5:27): An all-too-brief but nevertheless fascinating overview of the various problems the restoration artists faced when confronting the original film scan....
Movie: 70
The characters are largely simple vessels but through whom the film explores family dynamics through a number of evolving perspectives, as the girls (and their mother) deal with the logistics of the journey...
Total: 70
Highly recommended; this is a hidden classic gem and a welcome escape from the bland 3D conversions and poor quality blockbusters that otherwise dominate the format....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The 2-D presentation is fine if flat viewing is your thing, but the film really does come to life in 3-D. There are numerous scenes where the cast will frequently make use of the space of the room to walk...
Audio: 100
The English DTS-HD MA 3.0 track sounds fantastic capturing all of the dialogue, hustle-and-bustle of a boom town, and the song and dance numbers beautifully....
Extras: 60
Restoration Demo (HD 2-D/3-D 5:27) Hosted by Greg Kintz; if you want a full understanding of the effort that went into restoring this film, absolutely give this a look!...
Movie: 60
Director Lewis R. Foster and his co-writers Geoffrey Holmes and George Worthing Yates manage to craft a simple story that is compelling enough to invest your interest in the characters while also keeping...
Total: 80
With a terrific 3-D image transfer, an absolutely stellar audio presentation, and a fine assortment of bonus features, vintage 3-D film fans have a great reason to dust off their 3-D glasses with this...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 80
In addition to the outstanding negative parallax effects as feet, hands, spewing beer, a newspaper, a parasol, and other objects project forward, the sense of depth is wonderfully alive in this presentation,...
Audio: 90
While the center dialogue track seems a little underpowered in the opening reel, things get better and more balanced the longer the film plays, and the thrill of having the orchestra filling the front...
Extras: 80
Audio Commentary: film historian Hillary Hess enjoys an interesting and lively discussion of the film, its production, presentation, and restoration with three members of the 3-D Film Archive: Jack Theakston,...
Movie: 70
Rhonda Fleming gets top billing in the film, and she’s certainly stunning to look at with the bright blue eyes, flaming hair, and Edith Head’s attractive wardrobe accentuating her alluring physical attributes,...
Total: 80
Those Redheads from Seattle, the first 3D musical and the first widescreen film produced at Paramount, gets a valuable face-lift for home video courtesy of the 3-D Film Archive and Kino Lorber Studio Classics....
Director: Lewis R. Foster
Actors: Rhonda Fleming, Gene Barry, Agnes Moorehead
PlotA family of four redheaded women, led by their mother, travels to the rough-and-tumble town of Dawson in the Yukon Territory during the Klondike Gold Rush. Hoping for a new start after the passing of the father, they aim to set up a newspaper business. Upon arrival, they realize that gold fever has taken over the town, and they must navigate a male-dominated society to establish their livelihoods. They encounter a variety of challenges, from unscrupulous businessmen to corrupt officials, making their quest more difficult.
As they strive to make their newspaper a success, the women also come into contact with romantic interests and confront the harsh realities of life in a boomtown. Through determination and resilience, they begin to carve out a place for themselves in the community. Conflict arises when past secrets emerge and old debts must be settled, threatening the stability they've worked so hard to achieve. The family's unity and resourcefulness are tested as they face increasingly complex obstacles in their bid for success and happiness in the untamed North.
Writers: Lewis R. Foster, Daniel Mainwaring, George Worthing Yates
Release Date: 16 Oct 1953
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English