The New Daughter Blu-ray Review
Score: 53
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'The New Daughter': An overlooked, decent thriller needing word-of-mouth boost, held back by clichés and marketing missteps.
Disc Release Date
Video: 51
Anchor Bay's Blu-ray transfer of 'The New Daughter' impresses with vibrant, detailed visuals, though marred by inconsistencies like murky dark scenes and occasional banding, reflecting its mixed reception.
Audio: 61
The New Daughter's PCM 5.1 soundtrack vividly captures South Carolina's ambiance with immersive, intense sounds and effective bass, despite some mixing flaws.
Extra: 36
The New Daughter's Blu-ray extras feature insights from Director Luis Berdejo on filming techniques and aesthetic, behind-the-scenes explorations, 20 deleted scenes, and the HD theatrical trailer.
Movie: 61
Kevin Costner's 'The New Daughter' delivers atmospheric horror with a decent Blu-ray release, blending eerie sound design and suspense over gore, despite not redefining the genre.
Video: 51
The New Daughter" Blu-ray presents a visual experience that is both striking and frustrating in its inconsistency. Anchor Bay has delivered a 1080p, 2.35:1-framed transfer that showcases a blend of impressively detailed outdoor scenes, showcasing the beauty of the South Carolina estate with vibrant colors and exquisite detailing. Yet, this high-quality imagery is contrasted with scenes of diminished clarity, particularly in lower-lit interiors where details become muddled and colors sway towards the warm, introducing a mildly inconsistent color timing across the board. Despite these fluctuations, the transfer maintains a visually appealing texture, capturing the essence of both the natural and man-made environments within the film with striking clarity and depth.
Interior sequences vary greatly in quality, displaying a mixture of sharply detailed scenes and others where contrast levels lead to less-than-optimal delineation, swallowing up finer details in shadows. The visuals often carry a glossy sheen, complemented by a well-preserved grain structure that enhances the film-like appearance, albeit at the cost of sacrificing detail in darker sequences due to black crush. Furthermore, the color palette, while generally vibrant and adhering to director Luis Berdejo's vision, occasionally veers towards overly warm tones, particularly in flesh tones.
Technical imperfections are somewhat present but not overwhelmingly detrimental to the viewing experience. Instances of banding are noticeable, particularly in one of the film’s climactic scenes, alongside occasional source noise that detracts from the overall sharpness. These anomalies, however, do not pervade the entirety of the transfer. In sum, "The New Daughter" on Blu-ray offers a mix of visually captivating and underwhelming moments, encapsulating both the potential of high-definition transfers and the challenges in maintaining consistent quality across varied lighting and settings.
Audio: 61
The New Daughter" Blu Ray's PCM 5.1 uncompressed soundtrack showcases a commendable effort to bring the eerie and unsettling atmosphere of South Carolina right into the listener's environment. Not without its slight imperfections, the audio track nevertheless succeeds in immersing the audience with an array of environmental ambience and intricately designed sound effects that elevate the film's haunting aura. Scenes filled with thunderclaps or the unsettling creep of off-screen elements like creaking doors and snapping branches are brought to life with a precision that enhances the viewer's sense of immersion. The soundtrack leverages an effective use of the rear channels, ensuring that sounds like the natural reverberation of thunder or the nuanced musical cues are delivered with clarity and a significant support structure that engages listeners in a robust sonic experience.
While the audio mix excels in delivering tension through its smart use of sound effects and well-executed directional cues, it does exhibit some balancing issues, particularly with dialogue. Voices tend to be softer, requiring occasional adjustments to the center speaker, which may inadvertently amplify the intensity of sound effects and disturb the intended balance between dialogue clarity and ambient sounds. However, even with these mixing challenges, the soundtrack manages to maintain its integrity, providing a level of depth to the film's suspenseful moments through carefully timed eerie sounds and a strong low-end presence that punctuates the atmosphere with a subtle yet palpable bass when necessary.
In summary, although "The New Daughter's" audio presentation might not reach the pinnacle of demo-worthy soundtracks, it stands out as a solidly crafted mix that effectively supports the film's atmospheric tension and horror elements. The careful attention to environmental sounds, alongside a focused yet occasionally unbalanced mix, offers an audio experience that is both immersive and engaging, reflecting a commendable effort to complement the visual storytelling with an impactful auditory backdrop.
Extras: 36
The Blu-ray extras for "The New Daughter" offer an insightful glimpse into the making of this unique horror film. The highlight is a comprehensive audio commentary by Director Luis Berdejo, who delves into his innovative shooting techniques, the decision to film in South Carolina, and his ambition to present a horror story within a vividly brighter visual theme. This commentary is a treasure trove for fans eager to understand the film's creative direction. The behind-the-scenes featurette, albeit standard, provides a closer look at the cast's perspectives and the creation of the film's eerie creatures, satisfying those curious about the film's productional quirks. However, the deleted scenes feel somewhat superfluous, primarily serving to bulk up the special features section rather than adding significant value. Altogether, these extras blend technical details with personal insights from the film crew, offering a satisfying extension to the movie experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Luis Berdejo discusses his approach to creating a brighter palette for horror, filming locations, and cinematic techniques.
- The New Daughter: Behind the Scenes: A behind-the-scenes look into the film's production with cast and crew interviews.
- Deleted Scenes: A collection of 20 cut scenes, mainly excluded for pacing.
- Theatrical Trailer: High-definition preview of the film.
Movie: 61
The New Daughter" presents a notably atmospheric foray into the Horror/Thriller genre, emphasizing a gradual build-up over immediate visual spectacles, directed skilfully by Luis Berdejo. The film intricately narrates the story of John James (Kevin Costner) and his two children, Louisa (Ivana Baquero) and Sam (Gattlin Griffith), as they relocate to a rural setting in South Carolina, only to find themselves amidst a chilling legend tied to their new home. The movie cleverly uses the dynamic within the James family, particularly focusing on the strain between John and his daughter Louisa, as a foundation to weave its horror elements, thus offering a fresh approach to familiar narrative arcs.
The screenplay, penned by John Travis, arguably attempts more than just a typical horror story; it subtly delves into the complexities of adolescence, especially the estranged relationship between parents and their teenage children, hinting at supernatural influences as metaphors for growing pains. Despite its limited scare tactics, the film's reliance on a dense atmosphere, coupled with the unsettling sound design, creates a lingering tension that effectively complements the storytelling. The movie's pacing is deliberate, ensuring the suspense and mystery incrementally build, avoiding cheap thrills in favor of a more psychological unease.
Kevin Costner's performance as a father grappling with his familial role amidst supernatural upheaval stands out, supported convincingly by Ivana Baquero and Gattlin Griffith. The director's choice to focus on the evolution of the familial bond in the face of unknown terror adds a layer of relatability that elevates "The New Daughter" above standard horror fare. Despite its conventional premise, the film manages to hold its ground through strong performances and a well-crafted atmospheric tension, making it a distinctive entry in the genre that might be better appreciated on home video.
Total: 53
The New Daughter" emerges as a somewhat hidden gem within the thriller/horror genre, primarily riding on the coattails of Kevin Costner's presence rather than enjoying the benefits of a robust marketing strategy or a significant theatrical release. This direct-to-video release, although saddled with the negative connotations typically associated with DTV films, stands out due to its high production values and quality. It offers a well-constructed and smart narrative that, while not delving deep into intellectual realms, delivers a commendably tense atmosphere full of chilling moments. Despite the potential limitations in its appeal, particularly towards the hardcore Splatter-Horror audience, it provides an engaging experience for viewers seeking a film that rewards patience with its carefully crafted suspense.
The Blu-ray presentation of the film is commendable, boasting an above-average audio-visual (A/V) quality that enhances the eerie ambience pivotal to the movie's chilling effect. The video quality, albeit predominately decent, suffers from occasional dips that detract from the overall viewing experience; however, the audio stands out, excellently amplifying the film's creep-infested atmosphere. The supplemental features on the Blu-ray may leave something to be desired, echoing a familiar sentiment of underwhelming additions that do little to add value for enthusiasts seeking more than just the film.
In conclusion, "The New Daughter" on Blu-ray is worthy of consideration for those intrigued by thriller/horror films that manage to offer more than just conventional frights. Despite its struggles with inconsistent video quality and lackluster bonus content, the film’s strengths in atmosphere-building and audio presentation make it a recommended watch for a niche audience. It shines as an example of how a movie can transcend its direct-to-video stigma with a compelling narrative and solid technical execution, making it a fitting addition to a Blu-ray collector's selection or a weekend viewing for those seeking suspenseful entertainment.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Anthills, a scaly-skinned frog, and various other outdoor elements are reproduced with a sparkling barrage of color and intricate details, qualities that remain throughout the picture....
Audio: 80
Indeed, the picturesque South Carolina exteriors are often abuzz in environmental ambience that does well to immerse the listener into the locale, and as the track picks up in intensity and begins delivering...
Extras: 40
The New Daughter: Behind the Scenes (480p, 10:53) is a nuts-and-bolts piece that features cast and crew delving into the picture's themes and the complexities of the plot, the work of Director Luis Berdejo,...
Movie: 70
Indeed, Costner seems to best excel when portraying more relatable "everyman" characters but with some extenuating circumstance tossed into the mix; his Ray Kinsella in Field of Dreams is the best example,...
Total: 70
Considering the lack of a wide theatrical release and little-to-no appreciable marketing behind it, The New Daughter is a film that's going to have to rely on word-of-mouth and the presence of Kevin Costner...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
While there are a few scenes in here that may give you reason to watch, most of the film is filled with soft shots, strange color timing, and unnoticeable detail....
Audio: 80
Extras: 40
The commentary isn't jaw-dropping in the information dispensed, but it should fill a need for people who like the movie and want to know more about it....
Movie: 60
Big house, nobody around, the dad's a writer who spends most his time at home, the townsfolk might be hiding something, creepy noises abound, people follow sounds and fasts moving things they ought not...
Total: 60
It's a somewhat decent thriller/horror film, but in the end it gets mired down in too many horror film clichés....
Director: Luiso Berdejo
Actors: Kevin Costner, Ivana Baquero, Samantha Mathis
PlotJohn James, a recently divorced novelist, relocates to a rural farm with his two children, Louisa and Sam, seeking a fresh start away from their past troubles. The transition is tough for the family, especially for the teenage Louisa, who struggles to adjust to her new environment and the absence of her mother. The isolated setting and the vast fields surrounding their home add to the family's sense of dislocation. John throws himself into his writing and the renovation of their new home, attempting to build a stable life for his children.
However, their attempt at a new beginning takes a sinister turn when Louisa discovers a strange mound in the nearby woods, exhibiting bizarre behavior thereafter. As her actions become increasingly alarming and inexplicable, John becomes deeply concerned for her well-being. He starts to investigate the strange occurrences, unearthing the dark history of the land they now call home. The deeper John digs, the more he realizes the danger his family is in, coming face to face with a chilling truth that threatens to destroy everything he holds dear. His quest for answers becomes a desperate race against time as he seeks to protect his children from the malevolent forces lurking in the shadows of their new home.
Writers: John Travis, John Connolly
Release Date: 07 Oct 2010
Runtime: 108 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English