Goodbye & Amen Blu-ray Review
L'uomo della CIA | Limited Edition 3,000 copies
Score: 78
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Goodbye & Amen offers a fascinating look at political corruption through Damiani's intricate storytelling, backed by solid technical merits and engaging supplements.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 84
The 1080p AVC Blu-ray transfer of 'Goodbye & Amen,' scanned from the original negatives in 2K, showcases a clear and crisp visual presentation despite occasional color variations and minimal damage. The restoration highlights the film's natural palette and finely detailed textures, offering a commendable viewing experience.
Audio: 76
Goodbye & Amen's Blu-ray audio presentation features DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono, offering a vibrant Italian track with minimal hiss and well-rendered dialogue, contrasting the English track's sporadic quality issues due to damage, yet preserving historical value. Optional English subtitles enhance clarity in both tracks.
Extra: 70
The Blu-ray extras for 'Goodbye & Amen' include insightful audio commentary by Nathaniel Thompson and Howard S. Berger, dissecting its Euro Crime connections, and engaging interviews with editor Antonio Siciliano and actor Wolfgango Soldati, exploring their distinct experiences and creative processes in rich detail.
Movie: 82
Goodbye & Amen is an effectively offbeat Italian thriller by Damiano Damiani, known for its intricate plot and sharp twists, blending suspense, intrigue, and politics with a cynical undertone. Tony Musante shines as the ambitious CIA agent amid a cast delivering solid performances. The film features good cinematography and has been restored in 2K.
Video: 84
The Blu-ray presentation of "Goodbye & Amen" by Radiance Films showcases an impressive restoration that enhances the film's visual appeal. The movie benefits from an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, scanned from the original camera negative in 2K by Cinema Communications Laboratory in Rome. The transfer delivers a commendable blend of clarity and texture, with finely resolved grain that avoids any distraction. While slight color temperature variations are noted, the overall palette remains natural and well-suffused. The detail capture is precise, offering expressive fine details across facial features and fabric textures, though it falters slightly in dimly lit scenes like the nighttime rooftop sequence.
Colors are emphatically pronounced, with blues and reds demonstrating significant clarity, while colors such as brown and white maintain strength without overpowering. Black levels are also balanced, merging seamlessly with other hues to create a non-intrusive tonal harmony. The restoration of the original Italian mono soundtrack adds another layer of authenticity, though the English track suffers due to damaged materials but is preserved for novelty in its first-ever home media release.
Minimal passing damage can be spotted but holds no major consequence to the viewing experience. The expertly restored film provides a crisp and clear picture with only minor signs of age. The inclusion of three 2K scanned shots from 16mm elements further enriches the English version. Overall, the restoration effort, coupled with meticulous color grading and audio remastering by Radiance Films, establishes a visually solid and engaging presentation that revitalizes this lesser-remembered Damiani film for Blu-ray audiences.
Audio: 76
"Goodbye & Amen" presents its audio in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono, providing both Italian and English tracks. The Italian track emerges as the superior version, maintaining a consistent clarity and well-balanced dialogue alongside vibrant music cues. Despite minor crackles and hisses noticeable from the outset during production entity logos, these auditory imperfections are infrequent and non-disruptive. The Italian version also excels in channeling Guido and Maurizio De Angelis' lively score, enhancing the film's atmosphere with its resonant sound effects such as gunshots.
Conversely, the English track, though extremely rare and included as a point of interest by Radiance Films, exhibits considerable quality deterioration owing to age-related damage, which has prevented any successful restoration efforts. Here, dialogue clarity is inconsistent, with audible fluctuations leading to abrupt sound dropouts or sections afflicted by hissing and popping noise. Radiance Films prominently cautions viewers of these limitations and recommends the English subtitles to aid comprehension where audio falters. While this track exists more as a historical artifact than as the primary viewing experience, it still holds intrinsic value for enthusiasts seeking authenticity.
Ultimately, viewers are equipped with two subtitle options: one translating the Italian audio and another catering specifically to the deaf and hard-of-hearing community, respectively tailored for both audio tracks. The preservation of Claudia Cardinale's original voice looping in both tracks underscores a commitment to authenticity, mirrored by Tony Musante, John Forsythe, and John Steiner dubbing themselves in the English version. This Blu-ray release encapsulates a diverse audio experience for those interested in exploring film history in its multifaceted auditory dimensions.
Extras: 70
The Blu-ray extras for "Goodbye & Amen" enrich the viewing experience with in-depth insights. The dual audio commentary by Nathaniel Thompson and Howard S. Berger is an engaging exploration of the film's place in the Euro Crime genre, offering valuable information despite occasional dryness. The interview with Antonio Siciliano is an enlightening feature, presenting the veteran editor's career trajectory and collaboration with Damiano Damiani, enriched with personal anecdotes and spoilers, making it essential viewing post-film. Meanwhile, the archival interview with actor Wolfango Soldati provides an intriguing perspective on his role and experiences, contrasting Siciliano's stories and shedding light on the diverse filmmaking approaches. Each feature is professionally crafted, accompanied by English subtitles, ensuring both accessibility and an enriching context for this classic film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Experts discuss film details and its genre association.
- Antonio Siciliano: Interview with the film editor.
- Wolfango Soldati: Archival interview with the actor.
Movie: 82
Damiano Damiani’s "Goodbye & Amen" emerges as a compelling thriller, noted for its intricate storytelling and layered character dynamics. Set against the backdrop of organized espionage, this film intriguingly substitutes the Mafia with the CIA, orchestrating a narrative that melds suspense, intrigue, and political cynicism. The plot traces CIA agent John Dannahay, played by Tony Musante, whose mission to stage a coup on an African president is jeopardized by an internal leak and a rogue shooter's chilling actions at a Hilton hotel in Rome. John Steiner gives a standout performance as the unhinged gunman, providing layers of complexity with his cryptic motives and ever-escalating hostility. Claudia Cardinale and John Forsythe lend solid performances that enrich the film's tension-filled drama.
The film’s structure is marked by unexpected shifts and red herrings, drawing viewers into an almost satirical take on clandestine operations. Character study takes precedence as Damiani deftly balances storytelling with a dissection of agency dynamics reminiscent of mafia-like machinations within the CIA. Luigi Kuveiller's cinematography enhances the narrative with visual elegance, paired with a captivating score by Guido and Maurizio de Angelis. Despite disjointed plot transitions, the film sustains its engagement through palpable tensions and unforeseen character decisions, giving life to the narrative’s cynical undertones.
"Goodbye & Amen" navigates shifting thematic landscapes—from high-stakes international politics to intense hostage scenarios—without compromising its compelling examination of shadowy operative life. Considering its compelling cinematic qualities and the ensemble's strong performances, the film aptly represents Damiano Damiani's departure from his mafia-centric past, delving into a thriller landscape where deception and authority intersect vividly. This 2K restored Blu-ray edition underscores its place within contemporary explorations of Italian cinema on high-definition platforms, featuring pristine preservation of its visual and auditory elements for diverse region playback.
Total: 78
The Blu-ray release of "Goodbye & Amen" asserts itself as a compelling addition to Damiani's filmography, showcasing his adeptness at weaving intricate tales beyond Mafia-centric narratives. This riveting thriller navigates political corruption and the shadowy machinations of covert agencies like the CIA with an assurance that keeps viewers captivated from start to finish. Damiani’s intricate storytelling coupled with complex characters ensures a thoroughly engaging experience, maintaining a gripping tension throughout the intense hostage scenarios. Although it might not reach the pinnacle of his Mafia works, Damiani presents an unsettling yet authentic look into espionage and political landscapes, generating genuine intrigue.
Technically, Radiance delivers a solid presentation, with noteworthy supplements particularly enhancing the Blu-ray's appeal. Key features include a new audio commentary by Nathaniel Thompson and Howard S. Berger, enriching viewers’ understanding of the film’s layered elements. The release also offers fresh interviews with pivotal contributors like editor Antonio Siciliano and actor Wolfango Soldati, alongside a well-crafted 19-page full-color booklet featuring Lucia Rinaldi’s excellent insights. These enhancements provide valuable context and a deeper appreciation for Damiani's thematic exploration and narrative execution.
In conclusion, "Goodbye & Amen" offers a fascinating lens into covert operations intertwined with moral ambiguities. While it may disturb those staunch in their nationalistic views, its socio-political commentaries remain poignant. Despite some structural hiccups in its narrative flow, the film remains a captivating piece that resonates on multiple levels. Radiance's technical care coupled with insightful supplements makes this Blu-ray a recommended acquisition for both Deviani aficionados and general cinephiles seeking thought-provoking material.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Detail levels are commendable throughout, arguably faltering only slightly in some of the most dimly lit material, as in the nighttime sequence with the killer on the hotel rooftop....
Audio: 70
As alluded to in the verbiage above reprinted from Radiance's insert booklet, the English track has some intermittent issues where some listeners may need the help of the optional English subtitles, but...
Extras: 70
Audio Commentary by Nathaniel Thompson and Howard S. Berger Antonio Siciliano (HD; 38:49) is a new interview with the editor of the film....
Movie: 70
The first of these elements is the tribulations of Dhannay, who along with trying to get his assassination operation underway and solve a hostage taking, is also dealing with some familial strife involving...
Total: 70
The film has some structural issues that occasionally interrupt narrative flow, but it's a fascinating film on any number of levels, and Radiance provides generally solid technical merits and some very...
The Digital Bits review by Stuart Galbraith IVRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 90
Extras: 90
Movie: 85
Its unusual plot takes several unexpected sharp turns and, for a change, it’s unclear what it’s all leading up to, though attentive viewers will be able to figure out ahead of time how its intricate story...
Total: 90
Supplements consist of a new audio commentary track with Nathaniel Thompson and Howard S. Berger; a new interview with editor Antonio Siciliano (39 minutes); a 2013 interview with actor Wolfango Soldati...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The color black and black levels even out nicely with the other colors, not too strong and not too invasive....
Audio: 80
The Italian track has the better quality of the two, dialogue and music cues coming off clear, strong and evenly, little to no volume adjustment necessary....
Extras: 60
The two critics and Euro Crime experts discuss the film, its association to the Euro Crime genre, and cast and crew info....
Movie: 100
The first key thing that struck me was Damiani using a kind of fake-out on the audience in the first 20 minutes or so, making it look like we’re about to see the story of an ambitious CIA agent’s plot...
Total: 80
While certainly not as compelling as his Mafia stories and characters, Damiani nonetheless unveils the seedy underbelly of the world of spies, politicians, and other people with the same amount of ease...
Director: Damiano Damiani
Actors: Tony Musante, Claudia Cardinale, John Steiner
PlotIn the heart of Madrid, a complex tale of espionage and betrayal unfolds within the ornate confines of an international hotel. The story centers on the enigmatic CIA agent, John Dhannay, who arrives under the guise of a businessman. His purpose is to orchestrate and oversee a high-stakes exchange with a defector carrying crucial information on Soviet intelligence activities. The seemingly straightforward operation spirals into chaos soon after his arrival when Dhannay discovers a mysterious murder has occurred within the hotel. As Dhannay delves deeper, he becomes ensnared in a tangled web of deceit, mistrust, and political intrigue, struggling to discern allies from enemies. Loyalties shift, and motives murkily reveal themselves, complicating the already delicate exchange process.
Simultaneously, the lives of those around Dhannay are affected by his covert activities. Among them is Mara Iglesias, a journalist whose curiosity about the murder and connections to figures within the hotel pull her into the clandestine world surrounding Dhannay’s mission. Tension mounts as conflicting interests intersect, leading to a race against time to secure the defector's information amidst the backdrop of burgeoning Cold War tensions. Dhannay faces ethical and moral dilemmas as he attempts to navigate through layers of espionage and betrayal. The pressure intensifies as he must balance professional duty with personal integrity while trying to crack the secrets concealed within the hotel's opulent, yet treacherous corridors.
Writers: Nicola Badalucco, Damiano Damiani, Francis Clifford
Release Date: 06 Nov 1978
Runtime: 110 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Italy
Language: English, Italian