The Chalk Garden Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Chalk Garden Blu-ray impressively showcases Hayley Mills, Deborah Kerr, and Edith Evans’s stellar performances with top-notch video-audio quality, staying faithful to the original play.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 82
The Chalk Garden on Blu-ray from Kino Lorber boasts a stunning 1080p MPEG-4 AVC high definition transfer in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, offering exceptional color reproduction and sharp detail with no print damage, delivering a visually majestic experience.
Audio: 77
The Blu-ray's DTS-HD Master Audio mono track delivers crisp, clear dialogue and a sharp sound, with no significant age-related issues. Despite minor channel phasing problems, the overall audio presentation is solid, beautifully blending dialogue, sound effects, and Malcolm Arnold’s romantic score.
Extra: 46
Tim Lucas delivers an engaging and insightful commentary with critical analysis on 'The Chalk Garden,' while the Blu-ray extras include an HD theatrical trailer and select trailers for other Kino Lorber titles, ensuring a comprehensive package for fans.
Movie: 81
"The Chalk Garden" is a remarkable cinematic adaptation of Enid Bagnold's play, boasting outstanding performances—especially by Hayley Mills and Deborah Kerr—enhanced by Malcolm Arnold's dramatic score and Arthur Ibbetson's stunning cinematography. Ronald Neame's direction ensures the film remains engaging, exploring themes of youth and maturity with nuance.
Video: 82
Kino Lorber’s Blu-ray presentation of "The Chalk Garden" is an impeccable visual treat, maintaining a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded high definition fidelity in its original 1.85:1 theatrical aspect ratio. The transfer is exceptionally clean, with no noticeable print damage throughout, ensuring a viewing experience free from dirt, debris or scratches. The film's colors are rendered with profound accuracy, delivering a vivid and engaging visual palette that does justice to the historical and emotional depth of the narrative.
The image quality is consistently sharp, bringing out intricate details in costumes, furnishings, and facial features, thus enhancing the overall authenticity of the period setting. The hues are rich and stable, providing a visually appealing experience that elevates both the cinematic aesthetic and the emotional impact of the film. This careful reproduction ensures that every scene conveys the director’s vision without any distractions from age-related issues, making it a joy for enthusiasts and casual viewers alike.
Overall, this Blu-ray transfer is a masterful example of how a film can be revitalized through high-definition technology, preserving its original charm while showcasing every visual detail with stunning clarity. It effectively embodies the superior standards expected from contemporary home media.
Audio: 77
The Blu-ray release of "The Chalk Garden" features a commendable lossless DTS-HD Master Audio mono track. This audio presentation complements the strong video encode impeccably. Dialogue reproduction is consistently crisp, clear, and easily intelligible. The track stands out remarkably for its sharpness, given the age of the source material. Notably, there are no significant issues such as hiss, crackle, warp, or other audio-related detriments, ensuring a smooth auditory experience.
Although the DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track is predominantly solid, a few instances of minor distortion hinting at possible channel phasing issues can be noted. Nevertheless, the overall integration of dialogue, sound effects, and Malcolm Arnold's romantic score is handled with finesse. The musical score blends seamlessly with the scenes, contributing to an immersive viewing experience. There are no noticeable age-related audio problems like hiss, crackle, flutter, or pops, demonstrating a robust audio encode for this release. Optional English subtitles are also provided.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray edition of "The Chalk Garden" boasts a well-curated selection of extras that cater to both casual viewers and ardent fans of the film. Highlights include an insightful and professionally delivered audio commentary by film historian Tim Lucas, who provides extensive background information on the production and critical analysis, while thoughtfully pausing during pivotal dialogue scenes. Additionally, the disc features the original theatrical trailer in high definition, which captures the essence of the film's era. Complementing these primary features is a compilation of trailers for other notable Kino Lorber releases, enhancing the overall value of the disc.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Film Historian Tim Lucas: Comprehensive insights and analysis.
- The Chalk Garden Theatrical Trailer: Original HD trailer.
- Kino Trailers: Promotional trailers for "Separate Tables," "Endless Night," and "Meteor."
Movie: 81
"The Chalk Garden" is a superb drama that excels in storytelling and performance. Hayley Mills shines as Laurel, a troubled teenager whose behavior has left her grandmother, Mrs. St. Maugham (Edith Evans), struggling. With a complex and layered script by John Michael Hayes, based on Enid Bagnold's play, this film delves deep into themes of youth, maturity, and personal growth. Deborah Kerr's portrayal of Miss Madrigal, the enigmatic governess, adds a captivating layer to the narrative, making each scene impactful and immersive.
The technical artistry behind the scenes heightens the film's overall quality. Arthur Ibbetson's cinematography masterfully captures the lush Sussex locations and the intrinsic beauty of Julie Harris' costume design. The vivid color photography adds to the film’s visual appeal, bringing out not just the setting but also the underlying emotional tones. Malcolm Arnold's evocative score provides added dramatic weight, enriching the viewing experience with its nuanced compositions.
Directed by Ronald Neame with meticulous precision, "The Chalk Garden" boasts well-paced narrative flow and an engaging screenplay. Neame’s direction ensures balanced performances and seamless editing, courtesy of Jack Harris, making sure no scene feels superfluous. The film also benefits from Carmen Dillon's art direction, which crafts an authentic and atmospheric backdrop that enhances the character drama. Overall, "The Chalk Garden" stands as a quintessential piece of cinema that skillfully combines narrative depth with exemplary production values.
Total: 73
The Chalk Garden is a film that effortlessly marries an engaging narrative with stunning visuals. Ross Hunter and Ronald Neame’s meticulous adaptation of the acclaimed Broadway and London play impresses through its faithful rendering and remarkable performances. Hayley Mills, Deborah Kerr, and Edith Evans deliver standout portrayals, with Evans's performance earning an Academy Award nomination. The production's attention to detail in set design and direction elevates the overall viewing experience, ensuring that both new audiences and returning viewers find much to admire.
The Blu-ray release of The Chalk Garden exemplifies top-tier video-audio quality. The transfer showcases crisp, vibrant imagery and a clear, immersive audio track that amplifies the film’s dramatic impact. Despite the film's age, the restoration work ensures that every scene is presented with maximum fidelity, allowing the nuanced performances and intricate details of the set design to shine. This release stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of classic cinema when treated with care and respect in the remastering process.
The Chalk Garden is a remarkable accomplishment on so many levels. The production features great performances by Hayley Mills, Deborah Kerr, and Edith Evans (who was nominated for an Academy Award for her stunning performance). The storytelling is invigorating from start to finish and never seems to lose steam. The Blu-ray release features an impressive video-audio presentation that showcases the film beautifully. Fans of The Chalk Garden will be enormously pleased with the results of the transfer. Recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 80
Despite the packaging not mentioning a new restoration, the scan of the film looks downright stunning: the presentation is free from egregious print damage (such as dirt, debris, and terrible scratches)....
Audio: 80
The release has a strong audio presentation which is an excellent match for the strong video-encode....
Extras: 60
The release also includes a selection of trailers promoting other releases available from distributor Kino Lorber: Separate Tables (SD, 2:27), Endless Night (SD, 3:15), and Meteor (SD, 3:36)....
Movie: 90
The exploration of youth and the maturity of growing up is a complex issue that is well explored here....
Total: 80
The Blu-ray release features an impressive video-audio presentation that showcases the film beautifully....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 100
The image quality is majestic as color is wonderfully hued and solidly consistent, and sharpness is everything one would want in a film of this age with lots of detail in the costumes, furnishings, and...
Audio: 90
Otherwise, the dialogue, sound effects, and Malcolm Arnold’s rather romantic score (which would sometimes seem to be more suitable for one of Hunter’s lush melodramas like Back Street or Imitation of Life)...
Extras: 40
Audio Commentary: film historian Tim Lucas offers an interesting and most professional commentary track providing plenty of background on the production and offering some critical analysis at crucial junctures...
Movie: 80
John Michael Hayes’ adaptation of Enid Bagnold’s drama retains the wry, dry wit in much of the banter and only makes a few nips and tucks along the way in telling its story of a troubled teen and her equally...
Total: 80
The cast is fantastic, the production design first-rate, and the direction smooth as silk in a movie that offers quite a few pleasures both for first-time viewers and for frequent returnees....
Director: Ronald Neame
Actors: Deborah Kerr, Hayley Mills, John Mills
PlotA troubled teenager named Laurel lives in her grandmother's isolated English manor, situated near a chalk garden. Laurel is known for her rebellious and destructive behavior, driving away one governess after another. Her wealthy grandmother, Mrs. St. Maugham, is determined to rehabilitate her and bring order to the household. The arrival of Miss Madrigal, a mysterious and composed new governess, starts to change the dynamics in the home. Unlike her predecessors, Miss Madrigal doesn't back down from Laurel's provocations and instead creates an environment of strict discipline balanced with understanding. Through various interactions, she begins to uncover disturbing secrets about the family's past that have influenced their present situation.
Miss Madrigal's influence gradually helps Laurel confront her inner turmoil and curiosity about her absent mother. Mrs. St. Maugham becomes increasingly wary of Miss Madrigal's unconventional methods, creating tension between them. As the story progresses, deep emotional bonds and conflicts come to light, centering around the struggles of trust, forgiveness, and understanding. The garden itself becomes a metaphor for growth and healing, gradually reflecting the transformations within the manor's household. With each character grappling with their personal grievances and finding resolutions in unpredictable ways, the narrative takes compelling turns that propel it towards a poignant conclusion.
Writers: John Michael Hayes, Enid Bagnold
Release Date: 21 May 1964
Runtime: 106 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English