Jonah Hex Blu-ray Review
Score: 45
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'Jonah Hex' disappoints with subpar execution and lackluster Blu-ray, advised to rent before buying.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 47
Jonah Hex's Blu-ray offers vivid colors and sharp details but suffers from inconsistent quality, particularly in poorly lit scenes, yet it still outperforms its DVD version.
Audio: 47
Jonah Hex's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track overpowers with loudness but suffers from imprecise directionality, underwhelming rear action, and a lack of immersive depth, failing to mask the film's storytelling and box office shortcomings.
Extra: 46
Jonah Hex's Blu-ray extras entertain with a director-led PiP experience and intriguing look into Hex's legacy, despite lackluster deleted scenes. Perfect for fans and DC enthusiasts.
Movie: 26
Jonah Hex is a chaotic, overstuffed adaptation with an underdeveloped plot, filled with outlandish action and a cast struggling against a disjointed script, embodying a misfire in the comic book movie genre.
Video: 47
The video presentation of "Jonah Hex" on Blu-ray, encoded in 1080p/VC-1 and framed at a 2.40:1 ratio, showcases a Hollywood blockbuster's usual visual pizzazz complemented by an ambitious color palette. Mitchell Amundsen's cinematography immerses viewers in a world of sun-drenched oranges, vibrant yellows, and intense reds, echoing the film's fervent atmosphere. Despite its fitting milieu, the presentation is not without its technical drawbacks. On the upside, the high-definition transfer elevates the clarity of fine textures and the intricacy of facial features, particularly the protagonist's marred countenance. Color consistency, especially in skin tones despite their slightly scorched appearance, maintains the narrative's blistering heat without detracting from overall visual fidelity.
However, the Blu-ray's visual feast is intermittently marred by technical mishaps. Issues such as noticeable ringing and sporadic noise reduction techniques—ostensibly used to enhance certain characters' skin textures—point more towards creative decisions rather than transfer flaws. More troublesome are the darker scenes: with aggressive shadow rendition and an evident black crush, nighttime visuals suffer from a lack of clarity and depth, turning potentially atmospheric moments into murky, detail-starved sequences. Although day shots exhibit remarkable depth and showcase the film's elaborate landscapes and detailed character visages impressively, these strengths are counterbalanced by the significantly weaker execution of night scenes.
In summation, while "Jonah Hex" on Blu-ray surpasses its DVD counterpart with a transfer that occasionally dazzles with spectacular detail and a bold color scheme fitting its fiery narrative, it falls short of expectations in maintaining consistency across various lighting conditions. The encode, despite displaying an admirable above-average effort, fails to consistently deliver, particularly in low-light conditions where detail becomes lost to shadow and darkness. This Blu-ray edition illustrates a mixed bag—a testament to the potential of high-definition presentation that, regrettably, does not fully realize its own ambitions due to varied technical missteps.
Audio: 47
The audio presentation of the "Jonah Hex" Blu-Ray, driven by its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, is a stark representation of brute force over subtlety. With an emphasis on volume, the LFE channel is aggressive, turning every action sequence into a deafening event. Gunshots and explosions are delivered with a ferocity that could easily shake the room, pairing well with the film's intense visuals. Despite this overwhelming power, dialogue retains its clarity across scenes, a testament to the track's ability to keep vocal tracks discernible amidst chaos. However, this sonic onslaught does come at the cost of a nuanced soundstage, with rear channels often left wanting, resulting in an experience that feels predominantly anchored to the front.
Ambience and directional effects seem to be the casualties of this approach, with the soundscape feeling less enveloping than one might hope for from a Blu-Ray of this caliber. The mix appears somewhat front-loaded, with ambient sounds and the subtleties of a lively environment getting lost behind louder elements. This imbalance sometimes undermines the potential for a fully immersive audio experience, where the lack of precise directionality and underutilized rear speakers detract from what could have been a more dynamically rich presentation.
The irony is palpable as "Jonah Hex" tries to compensate for its narrative shortcomings by ramping up the volume, mistaking intensity for quality. The result is a track that, while undeniably powerful, often glosses over the intricacies that could have enriched the film's world. Directional sound placement occasionally feels arbitrary, disrupting the cohesion between on-screen actions and their auditory counterparts. In essence, while the bass does pack an impressive punch, enhancing gunshots and explosions, it can overshadow finer details and atmospherics, leaving a somewhat hollow and unbalanced acoustic performance.
Extras: 46
The "Jonah Hex" Blu-ray extra features deliver an engaging yet mixed bag for both fans and newcomers. Starting with an exclusive Picture-in-Picture experience that offers a behind-the-scenes look with director Jimmy Hayward and key cast members including Josh Brolin and Megan Fox, the content, although somewhat shallow, provides entertaining insights into the film's production. Highlights include candid interviews and anecdotes that shed light on the efforts to balance the film's exaggerated elements with authenticity. Additionally, "The Inside Story of Jonah Hex" dives into the character's rich comic book history and evolution, featuring insights from prominent DC personalities, making it a standout for fans. However, the set is somewhat let down by a collection of lackluster Deleted Scenes that fail to add substantial value. This assortment of extras, ranging from insightful to uninspiring, encapsulates the essence of the supplemental material available on this release.
Extras included in this disc:
- Exclusive Picture-in-Picture Experience: Behind-the-scenes look with director Jimmy Hayward and cast.
- The Inside Story of Jonah Hex: A deep dive into the character's comic book history and evolution.
- Deleted Scenes: A compilation of cut scenes from the film.
Movie: 26
"Jonah Hex," a film adaptation of the lesser-known DC comic character, rides into the sunset of cinematic attempts with both barrels blazing but ultimately misfires due to its execution. The movie, starring Josh Brolin as the disfigured bounty hunter Hex and John Malkovich as his arch-nemesis Quentin Turnbull, tries earnestly to deliver a Western laden with supernatural elements and high stakes. Brolin's portrayal of Hex offers depth to an otherwise one-note vengeance quest, while Malkovich's Turnbull sneers his way through the film with villainous gusto. Despite their efforts, they're unable to salvage the film from its myriad downsides.
Structured around a shaky plot that focuses more on backstory and exposition than coherent narrative progress, "Jonah Hex" lumbers through its 77-minute runtime. The story, which pitches Hex against Turnbull in a battle to prevent the destruction of Washington D.C., is riddled with plot holes and weakly developed characters. Director Jimmy Hayward struggles with pacing, chopping through potential development to connect one action sequence to the next with little regard for tension or storytelling coherence. The action scenes, while ambitious with their stylized weaponry, fall flat, failing to invigorate or add meaningful excitement. Moreover, the underused Megan Fox, as the love interest Lilah, and the misuse of a talented supporting cast, underscore the film’s inability to utilize its resources effectively.
Technically speaking, the frailties extend to dialogue, special effects, and an overreliant hard-rock score that further divest any sense of period atmosphere or subtlety the film might have aspired to. "Jonah Hex" endeavors to blend Western genres with supernatural flair but gets lost in translation, serving up a dish of unintentional laughs and head-scratching moments instead. The ambition of reimagining a comic book world on screen is evident but ultimately thwarted by a lack of vision and poor execution. The result is a film that struggles to entertain or justify its existence in the pantheon of comic book movies, offering little in terms of narrative innovation or cinematic satisfaction.
Total: 45
The Blu-ray presentation of "Jonah Hex" leaves much to be desired, standing somewhat awkwardly between the realms of potential and disappointment. While the film itself, as directed by Hayward, introduces a variation of DC's iconic anti-hero that veers significantly towards a more comicbook-esque interpretation than the darker tones found within the original comics, this transition does not seem to have translated well into cinematic experience. Critics and fans alike may have envisioned a different outcome had the film seen the direction of esteemed filmmakers such as John Hillcoat or James Mangold. However, what remains is a production that struggles to maintain coherence and engagement. The technical aspects of this release only add to its challenges, with a video transfer that fluctuates between being visually impressive and notably problematic. Moreover, the DTS-HD Master Audio track fails to live up to expectations of delivering an immersive experience, crucial for films banking heavily on action-packed sequences.
On the supplemental front, the "Jonah Hex" Blu-ray offers a Picture-in-Picture experience among other extras, yet the entire package can be thoroughly explored in less than two hours, signaling a lack of depth in behind-the-scenes content and additional materials. This superficial approach to the film's supplementary elements mirrors broader issues surrounding its overall execution and coherent vision—or, rather, the evident lack thereof. Additionally, when juxtaposed with other DC comic film adaptations, "Jonah Hex" arguably struggles to find its footing, marred by a convoluted plot, lackluster performances, and an identity crisis that renders it neither sufficiently supernatural nor genuinely engaging within its intended genre.
In conclusion, "Jonah Hex" on Blu-ray serves as a stark reminder of what could have been but unfortunately wasn't. Despite occasional glimpses of visual impressiveness in its video quality, the overall package—from its lackluster audio experience to its scanty array of extras—fails to salvage a film that already suffers from significant narrative and executional flaws. Potential viewers might find themselves better served by approaching this release with caution, armed with tempered expectations or perhaps opting to skip it entirely. The advice to rent first and ask questions later has never been more pertinent than with this underwhelming addition to the DC cinematic landscape.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 70
Moon and fire-lit scenes tend to be murky and muddy, shadows are aggressive and ravenous, night skies are dull and sooty, delineation is dreary and disappointing, and intermittent crush puts a final bullet...
Audio: 70
The LFE channel, obnoxious and unruly as it can be, launches a full-scale assault on the listener, turning every shotgun blast into a violent explosion and every explosion into a torrential storm....
Extras: 50
Tracing the history of the scarred anti-hero, his various incarnations and his evolution as a western-comicbook savior, notable DC editors, artists and writers dissect the character and his legacy....
Movie: 40
Horton Hears a Who director Jimmy Hayward, in a fit of bulldog editing, hurries past anything and everything that requires proper development, pacing lurches and lulls, character interactions lack heat...
Total: 60
By hook or by crook, its video transfer teeters between impressive and problematic, its DTS-HD Master Audio track isn't nearly as immersive as action junkies will expect and its supplemental package, Picture-in-Picture...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Skin tones are burnt, yes, but they're consistent, and considering the heat of the film, it seems about right, so no complaints there....
Audio: 60
Bass can thump quite a bit, with some superb thunder beneath gunshots, but it can overwhelm the other elements of the film, particularly atmospheric effects and dialogue....
Extras: 0
Deleted Scenes (HD, 5 min) - Wander through the catacombs, get ambushed by horse riding soldiers, ride along in a carriage, and get bored to death with these deleted scenes....
Movie: 20
It's a good thing he doesn't die easily, because the newest treacherous plot from the maniacal Turnbull may change the very future of America as a whole....
Total: 40
With problematic video and audio for a new release, and only a fairly small pile of extras, 'Jonah Hex' has cemented its position in the "Skip it" pile....
Director: Jimmy Hayward
Actors: Josh Brolin, Megan Fox, John Malkovich
PlotIn the aftermath of the American Civil War, Jonah Hex, a disfigured bounty hunter with a shadowy past, finds himself in the middle of a personal vendetta against Quentin Turnbull, a vengeful and powerful enemy who was responsible for the death of Hex's family. Hex is unique not just because of his appearance or his ruthless efficiency in tracking down those he hunts, but because he possesses the supernatural ability to communicate with the dead. This skill allows him to extract crucial information from the deceased, giving him an edge in his quest for vengeance and justice. Driven by the pain of his past and his relentless desire for retribution, Hex navigates the violent and chaotic world of post-war America, where lawlessness reigns and corruption festers in every corner.
Tasked with stopping Turnbull, who is plotting an unimaginable act of terror that could shift the balance of power in the nation and destroy the very fabric of society, Hex allies with Lilah, a tough and enigmatic woman who has her own reasons for battling Turnbull's tyranny. As Hex confronts Turnbull's forces and unravels his sinister plans, the bounty hunter must also battle his inner demons and the moral complexities of his bloody campaign. The stakes become personal and national, as Hex's journey brings him face to face with the true costs of revenge and the possibility of redemption amidst relentless chaos and destruction.
Writers: Mark Neveldine, Brian Taylor, William Farmer
Release Date: 18 Jun 2010
Runtime: 81 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English