Drunken Master II Blu-ray Review
Jui kuen II
Score: 26
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
While 'Drunken Master II' showcases Jackie Chan's exceptional martial arts and comedy, the Blu-ray release suffers from poor video, mediocre audio, and minimal extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 15
The Blu-ray of 'Drunken Master II' offers a subpar 1080p/VC-1 transfer riddled with excessive grain, dirt, and inconsistent clarity. Despite some improvement over older DVDs, significant issues like noise reduction, color muddiness, and numerous artifacts render it barely watchable. A disappointing effort for a beloved film.
Audio: 30
The Blu-ray edition of 'Drunken Master II' provides an English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track, but misses out on the original Cantonese audio, leaving fans with a mix that is loud yet lacks subtlety, directionality, and dimensionality. While clear, the dialogue and action sequences fall flat amidst a one-note, bass-heavy audio environment.
Extra: 11
The Blu-ray edition of Drunken Master II lacks significant supplemental content, featuring only a dated and uninformative promotional interview with Jackie Chan.
Movie: 76
"Drunken Master II," despite a thin plot, showcases Jackie Chan's unparalleled physical comedy and breathtaking martial arts, blending humor with intense action sequences free of wire work or CGI. With stellar fight choreography and standout performances, this film remains a captivating spectacle for Chan enthusiasts and martial arts fans alike.
Video: 15
The Blu-ray presentation of "Drunken Master II" offers a 1080p VC-1 transfer in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, and unfortunately, the results are deeply disappointing. Despite showing marginal improvement over previous home video releases, including the notably poor 2001 US DVD, the transfer is marred by severe technical shortcomings. The skintones range from lifeless to overly flushed, and the overall color palette remains muddy and monochromatic. Contrast levels appear artificially boosted but still fail to deliver any significant improvement, resulting in lackluster and indistinct visuals. Moreover, the fifteen-year-old print shows heavy wear with countless flecks, scratches, and inconsistent grain.
Detail quality suffers significantly due to the aged condition of the original print. The transfer struggles with considerable dirt, grain, and noise reduction that blurs fine textures. While daytime scenes occasionally exhibit decent sharpness and clarity, any scene in low light deteriorates dramatically. Though major issues like artifacting, aliasing, and edge enhancement are absent, these positives are overshadowed by the overwhelming dirt and grain on the film. Technical flaws like a jagged white blotch during a scene confirm the subpar nature of the transfer.
Overall, fans expecting a definitive high-definition presentation will find this Blu-ray release of "Drunken Master II" profoundly unsatisfactory. Noise reduction, muddy visuals, and inconsistent grain impact the viewing experience negatively. It is an injustice to such a beloved film and does not meet the expectations of contemporary home video standards. The lackluster presentation makes this Blu-ray a poor investment for its high price tag.
Audio: 30
The audio presentation of "Drunken Master II" on Blu-ray proves to be a mixed bag for discerning fans and audiophiles alike. Disappointingly, the release offers an English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 surround track without the option of the original Cantonese audio, which has seemingly been lost to time. This leaves us with Jackie Chan's English dubbing as the only means to hear his performance directly. Despite its lossless nature, the TrueHD track struggles to breathe new life into the film’s audio, delivering clear but often overblown and unnatural dialogue. The heavy bass does little to differentiate between action scenes, with punches and kicks merging into a unified thud.
While technically free of debilitating mishaps, the mix lacks finesse and dynamic range. Dialogue, although prioritized, risks being drowned out by the action's overbearing sounds, and directionality feels both sparse and formulaic. Rear speaker activity is minimal, contributing little to create an immersive experience. This results in a largely flat and uninspired soundstage that feels more like sonic wallpaper than a carefully crafted audio environment. Subtitles are available in multiple languages including English, French, Spanish, Portuguese, and Polish.
In summary, while the Blu-ray’s English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track doesn't suffer from severe technical faults, it fails to captivate or enhance the viewing experience due to its limitations in nuance and realism. The overall mix is a letdown, lacking depth, dimensionality, and polish—a missed opportunity given the film's potential for an engaging auditory presentation.
Extras: 11
The Blu-ray edition of "Drunken Master II" falls short in supplemental content, offering listeners only a single dated promotional interview with Jackie Chan. Despite the film's widespread acclaim and historical significance in martial arts cinema, the inclusion of just one extraneous feature is both minimal and disappointing. Fans were hoping for more insightful commentary or special features, especially considering the involvement of prominent figures like Bey Logan in similar past projects. The given feature, "Behind the Master," is a brief and somewhat frustrating promotional snippet made during the film's later US release, which adds little value to the experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind the Master: An Interview with Jackie Chan: A brief promotional piece with Jackie Chan discussing the film, but lacking substantial content or clarity.
Movie: 76
"Drunken Master II," also known as "The Legend of Drunken Master," showcases Jackie Chan at the height of his physical and comedic prowess. Released in 1994, this film is a directorial collaboration between Chia-Liang Liu and Jackie Chan himself. As an unofficial sequel to the 1978 classic "Drunken Master," it revisits the character of Wong Fei-Hong, a martial arts student who specializes in Zui Quan (Drunken Fist). The film combines jaw-dropping stuntwork, intricate fight choreography, and Chan's signature physical comedy to create a captivating viewing experience.
The plot, though admittedly straightforward, revolves around Wong's struggle to protect Chinese artifacts from being smuggled out of the country by a group led by a malevolent Brit, while also dealing with familial expectations set by his stern father. The narrative provides a basic but effective framework for a series of high-energy action sequences. These scenes are not for the faint-hearted; they showcase Chan facing off against various adversaries, including a high-kicking menace played by Ken Lo and a counter-intelligence officer portrayed by Andy Lau. Add a scene-stealing performance by Anita Mui as Wong's stepmother, and you have a film that balances comedy, drama, and breathtaking martial arts.
Perhaps the most memorable aspect of "Drunken Master II" is its action choreography. Unlike many modern films relying heavily on CGI and wirework, this movie emphasizes practical effects and real stunts. Chan's commitment to physical performance is evident in every frame, especially during the climactic fight scenes that demand multiple re-watches. The film’s meticulous choreography leaves an indelible mark on martial arts cinema, influencing later works like Stephen Chow’s "Kung Fu Hustle" and Quentin Tarantino's "Kill Bill." Overall, Chan's performance and the film's relentless pace make "Drunken Master II" a standout entry in action cinema, a must-watch for any martial arts aficionado.
Total: 26
The Legend of Drunken Master ranks high among Jackie Chan's most celebrated works, showcasing his unparalleled martial arts prowess intertwined with impeccable comedic timing. The film solidifies his reputation as a master of physical comedy and inventive fight choreography. However, the Blu-ray release severely disappoints in both video and audio quality. With subpar resolution and lackluster sound, it fails to do justice to the vibrant, action-packed sequences Chan is renowned for. Additionally, the disc's sparse special features add no value to the package, lacking in both quantity and quality.
Despite the film's brilliance, this Blu-ray edition does not justify its premium price tag. The absence of substantial high-definition features makes it difficult to recommend purchasing this version, especially for collectors and cinephiles who expect top-notch presentation. For those with previous home video editions, this offers nothing new or superior that warrants an upgrade.
In conclusion, while The Legend of Drunken Master is undoubtedly worth watching for its exceptional display of Chan's talents, this Blu-ray edition falls short in delivering a quality viewing experience. Its mediocre technical execution and minimal additional content suggest waiting for a better release or simply renting the film. This current edition fails to honor the vibrancy and dynamism of a true Jackie Chan classic.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 50
More distressingly, detail is at the mercy of the film's original print, fifteen years of dust and grime haven't left it in the best of shape, countless flecks and scratches appear, and an inconsistent...
Audio: 60
While dialogue is certainly clear and prioritized -- so much so that it actually enhances the film's comedy -- it ranges from overblown to overbearing, leaving some lines to flounder amidst the bass-heavy...
Extras: 10
The Blu-ray edition of Drunken Master doesn't include any significant supplemental content other than a dated promotional interview with Jackie Chan (SD, 7 minutes)....
Movie: 80
Before you can say get 'em Jackie, Wong is forced to contend with a long line of opponents (including a well-intentioned counter intelligence officer played by House of Flying Daggers' Andy Lau and a high-kicking...
Total: 50
His hyperkinetic display of martial arts mastery is as memorable as they come, his comedic timing is spot on (sometimes in spite of the film's dubbed audio), and the film itself is one of his more inspired...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 20
People love this movie, and as such, this could have really been a great place to find original source materials and put together a really wonderful transfer....
Audio: 40
Dialogue is flat and lifeless and often gets lost in the action, the surround elements don't add much to the overall atmosphere, with action sequences getting a lot of bang-boom-pow loudness without much...
Extras: 20
It's a complete waste of time and features an exuberant Jackie Chan, who explains things without making much sense or being very understandable....
Movie: 80
Watching them is a singular, breathless experience, and there are a few sequences in this film (one in which Jackie faces off against a series of hatchet wielding enemies, as well as the big finale) that...
Total: 40
This is one of the worst Blu-rays I've ever had the displeasure of watching, and I wish this was hyperbolic exaggeration....
Director: Chia-Liang Liu, Jackie Chan
Actors: Jackie Chan, Ho-Sung Pak, Lung Ti
PlotWong Fei-Hung, a talented martial artist, accidentally gets involved in a smuggling ring when he tries to retrieve a ginseng root for his father. The root is mixed up with an ancient Chinese artifact coveted by corrupt officials and British businessmen. Despite his father's disapproval of his drunken boxing style, Fei-Hung’s unique martial arts technique becomes crucial as he battles these nefarious forces. Their efforts to retrieve the artifact place Fei-Hung and his family in danger as they face numerous confrontations with powerful adversaries.
As tension escalates, Fei-Hung’s expertise in the Drunken Master style becomes his best defense. Navigating through intense and complex skirmishes, he uncovers deeper layers of corruption, realizing that more is at stake than he initially thought. His journey not only tests his physical prowess but also challenges his moral values and family bonds. Every fight brings Fei-Hung closer to understanding the true meaning of honor and responsibility, leaving an indelible mark on his path as a martial artist and a son.
Writers: Edward Tang, Man-Ming Tong, Kai-Chi Yuen
Release Date: 20 Oct 2000
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: R
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Cantonese, Japanese