Premonition Blu-ray Review
Score: 51
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Premonition offers solid technical elements with a fine 1080p transfer and good uncompressed soundtrack, but its convoluted plot and limited impact make it more suited for a rental.
Disc Release Date
Video: 58
Premonition's Blu-ray features a high-quality 1080p transfer with a fine grain film-like texture, good detailing in medium and close-up shots, and a generally neutral color palette slightly leaning warm; however, the disc suffers from overly dark blacks and occasional banding.
Audio: 43
Premonition's PCM 5.1 uncompressed soundtrack is technically solid with crisp dialogue and smooth frequency response, but it falls short on immersive envelopment and memorable sonic chills, leaving rear channels underutilized except for occasional atmospheric elements like rain and thunder.
Extra: 56
Premonition's Blu-ray extras offer a mix of insightful commentary, unique narrative experiments, and engaging real-life stories, albeit marred by some underwhelming standard features like a short making-of documentary, an unexciting gag reel, and less impactful deleted scenes and alternate ending.
Movie: 41
"Premonition" stands as a technically proficient yet narratively uneven film, with Sandra Bullock's compelling performance anchoring an otherwise convoluted supernatural thriller that ultimately straddles the line between meditative drama and intense nail-biter without excelling at either.
Video: 58
Premonition's 1080p transfer, presented in its original 2.40:1 aspect ratio, maintains a high standard of quality and reflects Sony's meticulous approach to Blu-ray presentations. The fine grain structure offers a film-like texture that enhances the viewing experience. Notably, the detailing is impressive even from a distance, as evidenced by a long overhead shot displaying lifelike textures in concrete and brick building facades. Medium and close-up shots particularly stand out with clear depiction of skin, clothing textures, and even the shape and volume of water droplets during a shower scene. Colors favor a slight warm push, rendering flesh tones naturally. However, blacks can occasionally be too dark, obscuring finer details in shadowy scenes. Minor banding is present in a couple of shots but does not significantly detract from the overall polished image.
Despite the film’s subdued, somber visual style more akin to drama than thriller, the technical execution on this Blu-ray is commendable. The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode initially struggles with blooming and poor detail in the opening flashback sequence; however, the issue quickly resolves, and the remainder of the film benefits from controlled contrast and excellent blacks. The colors, while clean and stable, exhibit intentional desaturation that complements the film’s earthy production design palette. This choice might dull the visual 'pop,' yet it preserves strong fine textures and a pleasing sense of depth throughout. Sharpness is generally outstanding, although slight jaggies can be observed during slow pans over high-contrast surfaces. Overall, despite minor flaws, this is a robust and well-executed transfer representative of Sony’s commitment to high-quality video presentations.
Audio: 43
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray "Premonition" is anchored by a PCM 5.1 uncompressed soundtrack, offering a technically proficient yet somewhat uninspiring listening experience. Dialogue reproduction stands out with its precision and clarity, ensuring that every word is delivered crisply to the audience. The soundtrack does a satisfactory job of maintaining tonal balance across the frequency spectrum, with strings and choral elements from the score flowing gracefully from the front speakers. Low bass is generally solid, though it occasionally appears somewhat disconnected and lacks the cohesive impact expected from more dynamic audio tracks.
The primary shortcoming lies in the lack of envelopment and dynamic use of rear channels. While select atmospherics like rain, thunder, and wind make sporadic appearances in the back channels, they fall short of creating an immersive soundscape. These effects are most noticeable in specific chapters, such as 11 and 14, adding a touch of authenticity but missing the mark on liveliness. The surrounds are underutilized, limiting the sense of ambiance crucial for heightening the supernatural elements of the film.
Despite these drawbacks, the track remains technically sound with high-quality recording attributes. While it’s competent in its execution, delivering clean and accurate audio, "Premonition" does not present a particularly memorable or engaging auditory experience. The track is adequate by most standards but lacks the depth and complexity to truly captivate its audience.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "Premonition" deliver a comprehensive assortment of features that go beyond mere promotional fluff, delving into substantial behind-the-scenes insights and thematic explorations. The standout feature is the audio commentary by Director Mennan Yapo and Actress Sandra Bullock, though it occasionally suffers from slow pacing and sporadic silences. Nonetheless, it offers in-depth discussions on the film’s story, production challenges, and technical nuances. The disc also includes a fascinating documentary, "Real Premonitions," exploring real-life instances of premonitions in an even-handed manner. However, the deleted scenes are relatively minor, apart from the intriguing alternate ending. The "Making Order Out of Chaos" feature provides an innovative chronological re-edit of the film, enhancing understanding of the narrative structure. Noteworthy is the standard gag reel and a brief making-of featurette.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Mennan Yapo and Actress Sandra Bullock provide insights into the film's story, themes, and production.
- Deleted Scenes: Includes scene extensions and an alternate ending with optional director commentary.
- Gag Reel: On-set mishaps and practical jokes.
- Glimpses of the Future: Making Premonition: Cast and crew discuss the film's themes and production.
- Bringing Order to Chaos: A re-edited version of the film in chronological order.
- Real Premonitions: A documentary on real-life instances of premonitions.
- Previews: Additional Sony titles.
Movie: 41
'Premonition' tries to straddle a multitude of genres, threading existential drama with supernatural thriller elements. The narrative, led by Sandra Bullock as Linda Hanson, unfolds between realities, leaving audiences grappling with questions of time and fate. Bullock portrays Linda, a seemingly average mother whose life shatters upon learning of her husband's (Julian McMahon) tragic death in a car accident. Yet the film twists expectations; in a perplexing sequence of events, Linda continually oscillates between days where her husband is alive and others where he's dead, compelling her to untangle the surreal mystery of his ill-fated demise.
The primary strength and weakness of 'Premonition' lie in its storyline. Its fragmented, non-linear plot seeks to maintain suspense but frequently veers into convolution. Unlike genre counterparts such as 'Memento', 'Premonition's' chaotic narrative lacks a cohesive thread, resulting in a disorienting viewing experience. Mennan Yapo's direction manages to showcase technical proficiency, yet struggles with pacing, which diminishes the overall tension and suspense that the film aims to build. Additionally, while the plot hints at profound themes of morality and destiny, it ultimately wavers without delivering a substantial payoff.
Despite these flaws, Bullock's performance stands out, capturing Linda's emotional turmoil with authenticity. Her portrayal of Linda's fluctuating mental states—tinged with fear, confusion, and desperation—adds a layer of depth. While the film doesn't quite settle on being an intense thriller or a meditative drama, it provokes thought on existential queries that linger post-viewing. If one approaches 'Premonition' with tempered expectations, its exploration of time and reality, despite the scattered narrative, still offers an intriguing albeit not fully satisfying cinematic journey.
Total: 51
"Premonition" attempts to blend drama and thriller elements with a unique narrative structure, though it doesn't fully succeed in delivering a cohesive and gripping experience. The film offers a solid performance by Sandra Bullock, whose portrayal lends credibility and depth to the story. However, the plot is convoluted and occasionally unclear, impacting the movie's overall coherence. Despite these shortcomings, the film makes up for its deficiencies with some intriguing and thought-provoking moments that linger, albeit briefly, with the viewer.
The Blu-ray release of "Premonition" is commendable, presenting a fine 1080p transfer and an impressively uncompressed soundtrack that enhances the viewing experience. The added supplements are substantial, providing valuable insights and further engagement for those interested. While these technical aspects are well-executed, they do not significantly enhance the mediocre storyline of the film.
In conclusion, "Premonition" offers enough to warrant a watch, primarily due to Bullock's performance and the quality of the Blu-ray release. It's not a strong enough cinematic piece to earn a place in your permanent collection but might be worth a rental for fans of the genre or those looking for an undemanding thriller. It's a film that satisfies on a surface level while hinting at potential that remains largely untapped.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Detailing is quite good even at a distance; a rather long overhead shot near the beginning of the film reveals a crisp, lifelike texture in concrete, brick building fa�ades, and the like, but of course...
Audio: 70
Bass can be a little sloppy and unkempt, but some of the crashes and booms and heavier notes scattered around the score do tend to meander on into the back channels, which otherwise carry only select atmospherics,...
Extras: 60
Glimpses of the Future: Making Premonition (1080p, 15:51): Cast and crew speak on the story and the surrounding themes, the casting process and the work of the actors, Director Mennan Yapo's insistence...
Movie: 50
Premonition delivers the goods as a fairly mysterious Thriller that's not completely transparent; Linda's problem is not readily identifiable, and whether she's traveling through time, experiencing visions...
Total: 60
A solid performance by Sandra Bullock, some honest and not completely transparent plot developments, and a surprisingly fair and thought-provoking ending do make this movie worth a watch, even if most...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Likewise, the film's production design seems to favor browns and earthtones, which further dulls pop, but detail remains very strong, with fine textures clearly visible, along with a very pleasing sense...
Audio: 60
I simply expected more of an eerie, sustained ambiance given the spooky subject matter, but the rears are largely left silent....
Extras: 60
There is, however, an alternate ending among the scenes, which adds a horror film-like climax that the filmmakers were very wise to cut....
Movie: 40
It's the story's structure that invites us to constantly analyze even the most mundane, everyday details for clues, and the pay-off is a strong first act that's instantly riveting....
Total: 60
Although it posed some thought provoking questions, ultimately 'Premonition' failed to work for me as either a thriller or a drama....
Director: Mennan Yapo
Actors: Sandra Bullock, Julian McMahon, Amber Valletta
PlotLinda Hanson is a suburban homemaker who learns that her husband, Jim, has died in a car accident. Strange events unfold as she experiences an erratic sequence of days, where she alternates between waking up to find Jim alive and well, and other days where she confronts the harsh reality of his death. Her sense of time becomes jumbled, and she struggles to comprehend whether she is dealing with grief, losing her sanity, or encountering something supernatural. Each day presents new fragments of the truth, leading her to question her perception of reality.
Determined to uncover the truth behind the erratic timeline, Linda pieces together clues and faces various emotional and psychological challenges. She becomes more vigilant about her surroundings and the actions of her husband in an effort to change the possible future. The pressure mounts as Linda races against time to solve the mystery, seeking to prevent the tragic event and secure her family's future. Her journey reveals unnerving insights as she navigates through love, loss, and the power of premonitions.
Writers: Bill Kelly
Release Date: 16 Mar 2007
Runtime: 96 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English