No Country for Old Men Blu-ray Review
Score: 65
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
A gripping, flawed western with deep characters; lacking final showdown, yet cinematically rich.
Disc Release Date
Video: 73
No Country for Old Men" shines in 1080p/AVC, with lifelike detail, natural colors, and deep contrasts elevating its filmic quality despite a subdued palette.
Audio: 59
The 'No Country for Old Men' disc delivers detailed audio with crisp dialogue and dynamic sound effects, though mostly front-loaded, with moments of immersive surround sound.
Extra: 50
The 'No Country for Old Men' Blu-ray disappoints with its lack of director commentary and only standard definition extras, despite insightful glimpses into the Coen brothers' meticulous craft.
Movie: 90
No Country for Old Men," a Coen Brothers' triumph, merges meticulous detail, profound performances, and intense drama in its portrayal of good vs evil, earning it 4 Oscars.
Video: 73
The Blu-ray video presentation of "No Country for Old Men" is rendered in a stunning 1080p AVC MPEG-4 encode that bathes the viewer in the visual prowess of the Coen brothers' masterpiece. The film, displayed in a 2.35:1 ratio, delivers a level of precision and depth that elevates its aesthetic. While the palette leans towards subdued, with washed-out colors that accentuate its western vibe and barren landscapes, this seems an intentional choice that enhances its thematic gravity rather than detracts. Skin tones are described as remarkably lifelike, contributing to the film's immersive quality. The level of detail is such that individual elements, whether the realistic portrayal of gunshot wounds or the nuanced textures of the environment, are presented with striking clarity. Scenes of particular note include the visceral depiction of a wounded character tending to his injuries, and sprawling vistas that showcase every shrub and leaf in sharp relief against the desolate backdrop.
Despite its visual splendor, the transfer isn't without its criticisms. Some early scenes exhibit grain and dot crawl, particularly in expansive shots of the sky and desert, which could distract viewers on larger, unforgiving screens. Blacks and contrast levels occasionally lack depth, impacting the visibility of detail in darker scenes. However, these moments are largely isolated, and the overall picture benefits from exceptional shadow delineation and stark contrasts that prevent blooming and crushing, even in the bleakest nighttime sequences or bright desert exteriors. The transfer consistently manages to capture the raw realism of the film's setting and characters; indeed, every element from facial lines to dusty plains is rendered with meticulous care.
Technically, this Blu-ray edition is a marvel of home video presentation, bereft of edge enhancement or compression issues, which positions it leagues ahead of the standard DVD version. Graininess observed in dimmer shots appears to be an artefact of the original film rather than a flaw in the transfer itself, underscoring a commitment to preserving the movie's filmic integrity. Such fidelity to detail and accuracy ensures that “No Country for Old Men” not only meets but surpasses expectations for video quality in home entertainment, making it a reference-quality release that showcases both the desolation and the detail of its unique visual narrative.
Audio: 59
The audio presentation of "No Country for Old Men" on Blu Ray offers both an English 5.1 Uncompressed (48KHz/24-bit) track and a 5.1 Dolby Digital option, catering well to purists and casual listeners alike. Despite the film's somewhat subdued action sequences, the dialogue clarity stands out as the uncompressed track delivers every line with pristine clarity, especially evident in Javier Bardem's menacing performance. The mix, however, tends to favor the front channels heavily, with rear surrounds being underutilized except for occasional bursts of activity, such as a notable sniper shot scene. The surround sound's sparing use does not fully embrace the potential for an immersive audio experience, despite competently handling the ambiance and action sequences when called upon.
The audio's fidelity is particularly impressive in its handling of the subtle details, from the nuanced sounds of nature and distant thunder to the more jarring noises of gunshots and squealing tires. The film's opening narrative by Tommy Lee Jones exemplifies the track's strength in delivering clear, detailed voice reproduction, alongside the authentic soundscapes that bring tension-filled scenes to life. The dynamic range is evident in intense sequences, offering a sparse yet impactful soundscape that adds to the film's gritty realism. However, this does not completely mitigate the slight constriction felt in the broader audio presentation, indicating room for improvement in exploiting the full capabilities of the surround setup.
Despite these minor shortcomings, the Blu Ray's audio presentation does an admirable job at maintaining a balance between clarity and atmospheric detail. While music and explosions may not be as prominent, the sound design shines through with realistic acoustics and powerful low-frequency effects that underscore the film's suspenseful moments. Fans will appreciate the PCM track’s effort to replicate the theatrical experience, particularly in its transparent pans and accurate sound positioning that never leaves the listener disoriented during the film’s more chaotic or intense scenes. However, an over-reliance on the front soundstage slightly restricts the sense of environmental depth and immersion that could have been achieved with more active surround channels.
Extras: 50
The Blu-ray extras for "No Country for Old Men" deliver a modest but insightful look into the creation and philosophy behind the Coen Brothers' adaptation of Cormac McCarthy's novel, despite being presented in standard definition with 2.0 Dolby Digital audio and lacking a much-desired director's commentary. Across the three main featurettes ('The Making of No Country For Old Men,' 'Working with the Coens,' and 'Diary of a Country Sheriff'), viewers receive a mix of informative and anecdotal content, from the Coens' meticulous production process and their team's loyalty to interesting character studies led by the cast. While 'Working with the Coens' offers some redundancy with its praise for the directing duo, it is partially redeemed by more personal moments shared by the brothers themselves. The absence of director commentary or a deeper comparison between key characters like Moss and Chigurh is felt, yet the available features do provide a worthwhile glimpse for fans and cinephiles into the film's crafted narrative and performances. The brief inclusion of unrelated trailers feels like a missed opportunity to further enrich the disc's offerings.
Extras included in this disc:
-
The Making of No Country for Old Men: A comprehensive look into the production, highlighting the Coen Brothers' approach, interview clips detailing design decisions, and cast reflections on the movie-making process.
-
Working with the Coens: Insights into Joel and Ethan Coen's on-set dynamics, featuring interviews with cast and crew about their experiences working on the film.
-
Diary of a Country Sheriff: An examination of the characters Sheriff Ed Tom Bell and Anton Chigurh, with Tommy Lee Jones and Javier Bardem discussing how they brought their roles to life.
-
Trailers: Collection of Blu-ray trailers for other Disney/Buena Vista releases, not directly related to "No Country for Old Men."
-
Movie: 90
"No Country for Old Men," directed by Joel and Ethan Coen, stands as a modern classic that transcends the boundaries of typical Hollywood storytelling to deliver an experience steeped in tension, moral ambiguity, and grim reflection on the human condition. Set against the desolate backdrop of 1980s West Texas, the film weaves together the lives of its three protagonists—Sheriff Ed Tom Bell (Tommy Lee Jones), Vietnam veteran Llewelyn Moss (Josh Brolin), and the psychopathic hitman Anton Chigurh (Javier Bardem)—into a gripping narrative that explores themes of fate, conscience, and the inexorable nature of evil. The Coens masterfully employ a minimalist narrative style, punctuating the bleakness of their setting with moments of shocking violence and profound existential pondering, earning the film four Academy Awards, including Best Picture.
The storytelling is complemented by Roger Deakins' cinematography, which captures the stark, unforgiving landscape of Texas in stunning detail, creating a palpable sense of isolation and looming dread. Every frame serves to enhance the narrative's mood, supporting the Coens' vision with a visual language that speaks volumes in silence. The film's deliberate pacing and lack of conventional closure challenge audiences while providing a canvas for extraordinary performances. Javier Bardem's portrayal of Chigurh sets a new benchmark for cinematic villains, bringing chilling depth to an already terrifying character. Meanwhile, Brolin and Jones deliver nuanced performances that embody their characters' struggles against the encroaching darkness of their world.
By eschewing Hollywood cliches, "No Country for Old Men" achieves a rare authenticity and complexity. It is neither a simple moral parable nor a straightforward crime thriller but an intricate mosaic of human stories caught in the unforgiving machinery of fate and circumstance. The film demands engagement from its audience, offering no easy answers but instead presenting a mirror to our own world's ambiguities and moral complexities. In doing so, it solidifies its place as a landmark achievement in filmmaking, a testament to the Coen brothers' prowess in crafting narratives that resonate with unyielding power and haunting resonance.
Total: 65
"No Country for Old Men" represents a standout addition to the Coen Brothers' oeuvre, intertwining intense storytelling with unmatched cinematic craftsmanship. The movie, taking on a distinct Western feel, dives deep into a cat-and-mouse narrative that grips viewers with its relentless pace and complex character dynamics. Anton Chigurh, portrayed brilliantly by Javier Bardem, emerges as a malevolent force of nature, bringing a layer of chilling fascination through his ruthless pursuit and lack of remorse, contrasting sharply with Llewellyn Moss's more morally ambiguous characterization. Their mirrored proficiency and enigmatic pasts add a thick layer of intrigue, avoiding the conventional showdown but delivering an intellectually stimulating and emotionally charged experience.
The Blu-ray presentation of "No Country for Old Men" elevates this dark, gripping tale with its superior video quality and an excellent PCM audio track, albeit leaving room for improvement in the supplemental features department. The absence of directors' commentary is felt, as insights into the Coens' collaborative vision would have enriched the viewer's understanding. Additionally, while the film itself does not heavily rely on its soundtrack, a more inventive approach could have augmented the overall atmospheric tone. The stark departure from the Coen Brothers’ trademark humor marks a bold, successful gamble, immersing audiences fully into the story's grim reality without distraction.
In conclusion, though the Blu-ray edition might fall slightly short in offering a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look at the film's creation, it's an invaluable piece for aficionados of masterful storytelling and cinephiles alike. "No Country for Old Men" stands as a flawed classic—imperfect in its finishing strokes yet undeniably impactful. Its ability to challenge conventional narrative structures while remaining steadfastly engaging confirms its place as not only a cult classic but also as a significant work that resonates within the broader cinematic landscape.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 80
There are some scenes that really do stand out with some depth, such as the sequence in the river, where the flowing water is very natural and realistic....
Audio: 60
As a complete sound package though the disc essentially follows on from the video side of things and it's a pretty poor effort all round....
Extras: 50
Unfortunately, the extras are as disappointing as the video and audio aspects of this disc and the lack of a director's commentary is definitely a short coming....
Movie: 80
There is however, nothing revolutionary on offer here folks but what there is has been done extremely well....
Total: 80
The movie is not overly reliant on the audio so it's not a major problem, though a little more inventiveness in this department would have been welcome....
Blu-ray.com review by Greg MaltzRead review here
Video: 100
After one of the main characters suffers a shotgun blast to the leg, the camera shows the wound as the injured man cleans and disinfects it, injects the surrounding skin with lidocaine, removes pieces...
Audio: 90
When Moss reaches the river, other sounds filter in: flowing water, the initial barks and panting of the pitbull, the clicking of Moss' handgun as he emerges from the water, checks the chamber, blows into...
Extras: 80
It includes important discussions with Joel and Ethan Coen regarding their inspiration to adapt the book into a film, and some nuts and bolts of production....
Movie: 100
These props, places and people, molded by the skillful hands of filmmakers Joel and Ethan Coen, float on the surface of a deeper melodrama that has played out since the beginning of time: the battle of...
Total: 100
One can argue it is the first film from the Coens in which they despensed with the comic relief and made a movie that doesn't flinch from its own narrative flow or bend under its own weight....
High-Def Digest review by High-Def Digest staffRead review here
Video: 100
Compared to the standard DVD, the Blu-ray edition is a completely different animal -- it’s cleaner, more vibrant, and far more stable....
Audio: 90
Music and explosions may be at the bottom of the directors’ to-do list, but the sound designers manage to fill the soundfield with a series of deftly authentic acoustics, powerful LFE support, and crystal...
Extras: 30
-- While it trails off near the end, this straight forward featurette is packed with information about the production, the script, the cast, and the final editing of the film....
Movie: 100
While it takes place in the early ‘80s and features a horde of stoic, tight-lipped cowboys, it speaks to both the timeless nature of the human condition and the perils of modern society....
Total: 80
The Blu-ray edition is magnificent as well -- it may not have a compelling supplemental package, but it does have a striking video transfer and an excellent PCM audio track....
Director: Ethan Coen, Joel Coen
Actors: Tommy Lee Jones, Javier Bardem, Josh Brolin
PlotIn the desolate landscape of West Texas, Llewelyn Moss, a Vietnam War veteran and welder by trade, stumbles upon a grim aftermath of a drug deal gone wrong while out hunting antelope. He finds a pickup truck surrounded by dead bodies, a load of heroin, and a briefcase containing two million dollars in cash. Moss makes a fateful decision to take the money, triggering a chain of violent events as he becomes the target of various individuals seeking the lost fortune. Among those on his trail is Anton Chigurh, a relentless and psychopathic hitman who utilizes a captive bolt pistol to eliminate anyone connected to the money.
Meanwhile, Sheriff Ed Tom Bell, a World War II veteran nearing retirement, is tasked with investigating the drug deal massacre and the subsequent spiraling violence that seems to follow the stolen money. As the body count rises, Sheriff Bell contemplates the changing times and the new breed of criminal, which he finds increasingly incomprehensible and evil compared to the old days of law enforcement. In parallel to the pursuit of Moss by his pursuers, Bell's journey not only puts him on the trail of the chaos but also leads him to reflect on his own life, the history of violence in the region, and his feelings of disillusionment with the world that appears to be leaving men like him behind.
Writers: Joel Coen, Ethan Coen, Cormac McCarthy
Release Date: 21 Nov 2007
Runtime: 122 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish