RocknRolla Blu-ray Review
Score: 58
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
RocknRolla blends Ritchie's signature style with witty dialogue and fast-paced action, but extras lackluster.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 57
RocknRolla's Blu-ray features a VC-1 1080p transfer with a stylized sepia tone, affecting contrast and detail, but showcasing intentional directorial choices, supported by a clear, dynamic Dolby TrueHD soundtrack.
Audio: 63
The 'RocknRolla' Blu-ray delivers a solid, dialogue-centered Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack with crisp, clear voices but limited action scenes; visuals are uniquely styled yet lack sharpness.
Extra: 41
The RocknRolla Blu-ray extras include a lackluster commentary, brief featurettes on London and the film's making, a pointless deleted scene, and a digital copy with compatibility issues.
Movie: 76
Guy Ritchie rebounds with 'RocknRolla,' a complex yet entertaining British gangster flick echoing his early style with wit, violence, and a stellar cast.
Video: 57
"RocknRolla" makes a pronounced entry onto Blu-ray with a 1080p transfer that adheres faithfully to its original widescreen 2.40:1 ratio. Utilizing the VC-1 codec, its high-definition presentation maintains clarity and smoothness, with the absence of digital annoyances such as edge enhancement, halos, or noise, ensuring a clean visual experience. However, the artistic choice to overlay the film with a sepia-toned effect introduces a distinctive style that, while aiming for consistency and mood akin to that of Western genres, might not cater to all tastes. The effect dampens the vibrancy of colors and leaves them muted, affecting the overall expected sparkle of the high-definition image.
Notably, the blacks and contrast levels do not reach the depths and sharpness typically desired for a film shot in HD, leading to scenes that can appear washed out or lacking in detail. This peculiar lack of robust black levels and diminished contrast contributes to a somewhat flat visual experience in darker scenes or indoor settings. Despite these artistic choices, some scenes still manage to showcase vivid colors and details, particularly in daylight scenarios where the palette briefly diverges from its predominantly brownish hue. These moments highlight the potential for a more dynamic range that unfortunately remains underexploited.
The transfer significantly shines in terms of resolution and texture detail, especially noticeable in natural daylight settings and intricate backgrounds like London's brickwork, free from common issues like aliasing. The overall quality of this Blu-ray presentation of "RocknRolla" demonstrates a clear intention to retain the director's unique visual style. Although this results in a mixed reception regarding its color grading and contrast levels, the effort to preserve skin textures, clothing details, and urban landscapes speaks to a commendable level of attention to detail in the transfer process.
Audio: 63
The audio presentation of "RocknRolla" on Blu-ray is exclusively served with a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack in English, providing an audibly rich experience that ensures all dialogues come through with impeccable clarity and crispness, immensely benefiting the dialogue-heavy nature of the film. While French, Spanish, and Portuguese audiences might have to settle for the slightly less immersive Dolby Digital 5.1, the essence of the audio experience remains undiminished across languages. The soundtrack, though not without its faults—such as a tendency to require volume adjustments for optimal listening and occasionally unbalanced mix at higher volumes—does justice to the action sequences with well-rendered LFE touches that lend a solid backing to thumps, thuds, crashes, and the film's energetic musical score.
However, it's worth noting that the center and front channels are predominantly leveraged, directing the film’s extensive narrative and musical components effectively to the listener. This placement sometimes limits the surround sound effect, with rear channel utilization being sparse yet competent in delivering ambient sounds and depth when the action intensifies. The 16-bit encoding of the soundtrack might not make it a benchmark for audiophiles seeking demonstration-worthy tracks, but it successfully envelops the viewer in 'RocknRolla's unique atmosphere, particularly during its few but memorable action scenes where the dynamic range and deep bass come alive. Despite some minor shortcomings like car dialogue scenes being somewhat muted, this does not significantly detract from an otherwise solid auditory experience.
Moreover, the soundscape of 'RocknRolla,' from the ambient hustle of London to the gunfire and car wrecks of its more violent episodes, showcases an intriguing blend of sounds that maintain narrative focus and immersion. The soundtrack manages to preserve the distinctiveness of key audio elements—ensuring that even amidst a cacophony of sounds, dialogue remains king. The action sequences provide a satisfactory punch with machine gun fire and other effects rendered in a manner that adds dimensionality to the overall viewing experience. Despite this, viewers seeking out a fully surround sound experience may find the use limited but adequate for the film’s scope.
Extras: 41
The Blu-ray extras for "RocknRolla" present a mixed bag of offerings that leave something to be desired for fans and newcomers alike. The commentary track led by Director Guy Ritchie and Mark Strong starts promising with occasional interesting insights but quickly devolves into a less engaging conversation, lacking depth and preparation. The two featurettes, "Blokes, Birds and Backhanders: Inside Rock-n-Rolla" and "Guy's Town," despite being presented in high definition, offer only a superficial glance behind the scenes. They recycle film clips excessively and miss the chance to delve into richer content or the film's production intricacies. The sole deleted scene featuring Gerard Butler feels inconsequential and doesn't add value to the overall package. However, the inclusion of a digital copy provides a tangible benefit, allowing for portable viewership. Sadly, these extras fail to explore the film's essence thoroughly or offer compelling reasons to revisit the disc.
Extras included in this disc:
- Feature Commentary with Director Guy Ritchie and Actor Mark Strong: In-depth yet sometimes meandering discussion.
- Blokes, Birds and Backhanders: Inside Rock-n-Rolla: Cast and crew share insights into the film's making.
- Guy's Town: Guy Ritchie’s exploration of London's influence on his work.
- Deleted Scene: Brief cut featuring Gerard Butler.
- Digital Copy: Includes a copy of the film for portable devices, though compatibility may vary.
Movie: 76
Guy Ritchie's "RocknRolla" marks a vital turning point in the director's career, weaving together a complex tapestry of humor, crime, and action that harks back to his critically acclaimed early work. Amidst the eclectic backdrop of London's criminal underworld, the film introduces us to an array of characters played by a notable ensemble cast including Gerard Butler, Thandie Newton, and Tom Wilkinson. Each character is embroiled in a convoluted plot involving a Russian oligarch, a corrupt British land deal, and a series of deceptions that cleverly intersect through the ownership of a luck-inducing painting. Ritchie crafts a narrative that is at once dense and engaging, challenging audiences to keep pace with its rapid twists and turns. The genius of "RocknRolla" lies in its ability to mesh Ritchie's signature directorial elements—sharp dialogue, dynamic storytelling, and character-driven humor—with a new level of sophistication and cinematic flair.
Despite its strengths, "RocknRolla" struggled at the box office, potentially due to its intricate plot and a plethora of characters that may have left viewers bewildered on first viewing. Nonetheless, Ritchie's film is an undeniable showcase of his filmmaking prowess, presenting a gritty, animated exploration of greed and power within the London underworld. The movie benefits significantly from repeat viewings, allowing audiences to fully appreciate the depth of its character development and narrative intricacies. The performances are particularly noteworthy, with Butler, Newton, Wilkinson, Jeremy Piven, and Chris Bridges (Ludacris) delivering memorable roles that capture the essence of Ritchie's unique world.
In essence, "RocknRolla" stands as a testament to Guy Ritchie's enduring talent as a filmmaker. Although it might not reach the iconic status of "Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels" or "Snatch," it serves as a critical juncture in Ritchie's career—reminding viewers of his capability to meld complex narratives with compelling character work. As the film finds its audience on Blu-ray, its virtues have become increasingly recognized, suggesting that it may yet assume its rightful place among Ritchie's more celebrated works. The movie's well-crafted balance of action and dialogue-driven scenes ensures that it remains engaging throughout, providing both insight into its characters and sufficient pace to keep audiences entertained.
Total: 58
"RocknRolla," directed by Guy Ritchie, returns to the familiar ground that fans of his earlier work such as "Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels" will recognize and appreciate. The film delivers a supercharged narrative, rich with clever dialogues and thoroughly entertaining character interactions set against a contemporary London backdrop. While it may tread over-exaggerated territories at times, it remains relatable, especially to those familiar with urban environments. The Blu-ray edition of "RocknRolla" enhances this experience with commendable audio and video quality. However, it's worth noting that the stylistic choices in video presentation may not appeal to all, potentially affecting the otherwise stellar transfer quality. The lack of substantial extras is a drawback, though the inclusion of a digital copy adds value by offering multiple viewing possibilities.
The technical execution of the Blu-ray presentation is evaluated using an array of high-end AV equipment, ensuring a thorough assessment. Despite being presented on a myriad of sophisticated setups - from JVC DLA-RS20 1080p High Definition Front Projector to Sony PlayStation 3 for Blu-ray playback, and a sound system complemented by high-quality components like Canton Ergo Series speakers and SV Sound PB-13 Ultra - the film remains consistent in delivering its cinematic experience. This rigorous testing highlights the Blu-ray's capability to stand up to demanding standards, offering a strong audio/visual performance that mirrors the film's dynamic pacing and stylish cinematography.
In conclusion, while "RocknRolla" might not represent Guy Ritchie's finest work, it stands as a must-watch for his aficionados and newcomers alike, particularly for its energetic rhythm and unique style. The Blu-ray version, despite its slight shortfall in video stylization and limited extras, presents a solid option for purchase due to its high replay value facilitated by robust technical quality. This release underscores the vital importance of second viewings to fully grasp the film’s intricate details, making it a worthwhile addition to any collection, albeit more recommended as a purchase for the enthusiasts rather than casual viewers.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 80
Whilst it is clear it's an impeccable transfer I can only assume the stylised effects were imposed through choice and design....
Audio: 80
You get the benefit of a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack but it's only in the English form....
Extras: 70
Unfortunately, this one has been done pretty much off the cuff with a lack of preparation....
Movie: 80
When Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels burst onto the scene in 1998 it set up Guy Ritchie as someone to really keep a look out for....
Total: 80
However, there is a caveat on the video side that the stylisation may not be to everyone's liking and in some ways has interfered with what would have been nigh on a flawless transfer....
Blu-ray.com review by Ben WilliamsRead review here
Video: 80
I can only assume that the look represented on this Blu-ray disc is representative of the intent of its creators, but it's just not a whole lot of fun watch....
Audio: 80
As such, much of the presentation is centered in the front soundstage and features a mix of music and dialogue....
Extras: 30
Inside Rock-n-Rolla" - "Guy's Town" - Deleted Scene - Digital Copy I wish that I could report on a slew of exceptional extras in conjunction with this Blu-ray release of RocknRolla, but that's simply not...
Movie: 80
Unfortunately for One Two and his gang, the missing seven million euros, a prized painting and a crackhead rock star will make life for this eclectic band of thieves extraordinarily difficult....
Total: 70
Fans of his terrific Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels and Snatch will find similarities between these earlier films and his latest, despite RocknRolla missing some of the creative spark that made his...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Since the transfer is devoid of any other defects, this contrast discrepancy seems to be the result of the director's choice for a softer, stylized color palette....
Audio: 80
Even with all the hustle and bustle of London and the thumping soundtrack, which uses some deep bass, we can hear each conversation clearly....
Extras: 20
They have very the type of wry senses of humor that the British are known for, which makes for an enjoyable commentary during the first half of the movie, even commenting on the porno magazines that Ludacris...
Movie: 80
Like Tarantino's 'Pulp Fiction,' where we don't actually care about the contents of the briefcase, the most enjoyable part of the movie is listening to the conversations between the characters....
Total: 60
The movie is filmed using some interesting cinematography, which adds to its classy style....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 80
Sounds mixed to the rear channels are well balanced and engaging which provides a good sense of depth when the action kicks in....
Audio: 84
Extras: 50
Behind the story: Commentary by Guy Ritchie and Mark Strong (HD) Blokes, Birds, and Backhanders: Inside Rock-n-Rolla – 15 minute making of feature (HD) Guy’s Town – 8 minute production feature 1 deleted...
Movie: 70
Now add a hard-as-ice accountant (Thandie Newton), a rocker playing dead to boost sales, wannabe music moguls (Jeremy Piven and Chris Bridges), a missing painting and a mad mosh of money and muscle, and...
Total: 71
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton...
Director: Guy Ritchie
Actors: Gerard Butler, Tom Wilkinson, Idris Elba
PlotIn London's gritty underworld, a Russian mobster orchestrates a lucrative real estate scam, attracting the attention of the local crime syndicate. The deal promises to flood the market with millions, drawing in not only the established criminal elite but also the smaller fish looking to elevate their status. Among these hopefuls is a small-time but ambitious gang led by a charismatic and clever man, his two lieutenants by his side. Together, they devise a plan to hijack the scheme, but quickly find themselves entangled in a web of deceit, betrayal, and violence. Their journey into the dark heart of London's criminal world reveals the precarious balance of power that exists there, with trust as a currency more valuable than money—and far more dangerous to trade.
As the story unfolds, the paths of various characters crisscross and collide. An old-school crime boss, desperate to hold on to his fading power, a lethal accountant with her own agendas, and a rock star presumed dead but very much alive, all play crucial roles in the chaos that ensues. The quest for wealth and power leads to unlikely alliances and brutal betrayals, setting off a domino effect of events that threaten to upheave the established order. Just beneath the surface of these criminal endeavors, there's a deeper exploration of loyalty, ambition, and the desperate search for a way out of the life that, once entered, is almost impossible to leave behind.
Writers: Guy Ritchie
Release Date: 31 Oct 2008
Runtime: 114 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom, United States, France
Language: English, Russian