Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio Blu-ray Review
DigiPack
Score: 86
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio delivers visually striking scenes but falls short in storytelling, yet the Blu-ray offers an outstanding technical presentation.
Disc Release Date
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 95
Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio on Blu-ray offers a sensational visual experience with its 1080p MPEG-4 AVC transfer and 1.85:1 aspect ratio, matching the native 4K release's impressive color reproduction and depth despite the expanded color gamut advantages of 4K. Requires a Region-A or Region-Free player.
Audio: 89
The English Dolby Atmos track on Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio Blu-ray is a dynamic and immersive experience. With excellent use of overhead channels during pivotal scenes, it offers 'reference quality' sound with impressive movement and separation, though a bit more activity in some scenes could enhance it further.
Extra: 76
The Blu-ray extras for 'Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio' provide an in-depth exploration of stop-motion artistry through a comprehensive documentary, insightful director discussions, and illuminating interviews with cast and crew, culminating in enriching panels moderated by Neil Gaiman and James Cameron, all enhancing the film's enchanting craftsmanship.
Movie: 66
Guillermo del Toro’s Pinocchio is a visually stunning stop-motion reimagining set in Fascist Italy, blending rich, overwhelming colors with themes of war, death, and sacrifice. It diverges from Collodi's novel, making bold yet polarizing character and narrative choices, offering both breathtaking animation and thought-provoking commentary.
Video: 95
Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio receives an exemplary video presentation on Blu-ray, preserving the film's original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 and utilizing an MPEG-4 AVC encode for its 1080p transfer. The visuals are meticulously rendered, offering a remarkable showcase of detail and color fidelity that impresses both in native 4K and 1080p. The Blu-ray admirably maintains these high standards, with superb depth and fluidity that competes closely with native 4K interpretations. Importantly, color reproduction, a defining element of del Toro's visual storytelling, remains vibrant and accurately captured even within the limitations of 1080p, providing a captivating viewing experience.
For those opting for the 4K Blu-ray version, the presentation takes full advantage of the expanded color gamut available in the format, enhancing every hue with stunning clarity and realism. The film's intricate textures and crafted environments are further brought to life by the 4K transfer's ability to handle dynamic range and contrast with precision. Viewers will be able to appreciate the nuances in each scene, whether viewed upscaled from 1080p or in native 4K. This attention to visual fidelity ensures that the transition between standard and ultra-high definition remains seamless and consistently impressive.
This Blu-ray release is Region-A locked, necessitating a compatible Region-A or Multi-Region player for playback, an essential consideration for international viewers aiming to enjoy this extraordinary presentation. Overall, the technical execution on both the 1080p and 4K formats guarantees a visually stunning experience that does justice to Guillermo del Toro's creative vision.
Audio: 89
The audio presentation of Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio on Blu-ray boasts a singular English Dolby Atmos track, complemented by an English Descriptive DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 option, and optional English SDH subtitles. This Atmos mix is a moderately active experience, standing out particularly in its effective incorporation of immersive elements aligned with the visual narrative. Notably, the overhead channels are utilized impressively during dynamic scenes such as the bombing raid and military training sequence, as well as during the dramatic encounter with the whale. While some quieter scenes like rain/thunder storms and underwater moments could have benefited from more overhead channel involvement, the overall balance of atmospheric soundscapes and discrete object placement provides a satisfying auditory experience.
The technical prowess of the Dolby Atmos track is remarkable, showcasing movement, separation, and a broad range of dynamic contrasts. This makes it a definitive 'reference quality' track, capable of demonstrating the full capacities of an audio system. The intricacies and directional effects create a rich audio field, delivering nuances even in scenes devoid of rapid action. This engaging and meticulously crafted sound design enhances the narrative depth without encountering any encoding issues. Such attention to detail results in an ultimately entertaining and high-caliber audio experience, underlining the film’s emotive storytelling with a robust auditory complement.
Extras: 76
The Blu-ray extras for "Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio" offer an immersive dive into the film's intricate production world, showcasing a meticulous approach to storytelling and animation. The comprehensive documentary "Handcarved Cinema" provides a profound insight into the creative journey, spotlighting interviews with the crew and del Toro himself. The supplemental content, including the "Directing Stop-Motion" and "Eight Rules of Animation" programs, elucidates the technical artistry and layered methodologies that define the film's unique stop-motion execution. Conversations with notable figures such as film critic Farran Smith Nehme and author Neil Gaiman further delve into thematic explorations and inspirations. Each feature is presented in English, without subtitles, emphasizing a rich tapestry of expert discussions and creative processes.
Extras included in this disc:
- Handcarved Cinema: In-depth documentary on production.
- Directing Stop-Motion: Discussions on stop-motion techniques.
- Eight Rules of Animation: Insights into animation principles.
- Guillermo del Toro and Farran Smith Nehme: Interview on film’s themes.
- Crafting Pinocchio for MoMA: Insight into museum exhibit creation.
- Q&A Sessions: Creator discussions, moderated by Gaiman and Cameron.
- Trailer: Original film trailer.
- Booklet: Essays by Zoller Seitz and Funke.
Movie: 66
Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio is a masterful reinvention of the classic tale, diverging significantly from Carlo Collodi's beloved novel to explore complex themes within Italy's fascist backdrop. This bold interpretation showcases del Toro's deft storytelling, weaving an intricate narrative that touches on war, death, and sacrifice. The film's stunning stop-motion animation—a marriage between del Toro's vivid imagination and Mark Gustafson's creative prowess—presents a rich tapestry of colors that, while dazzling, can occasionally overwhelm the senses. This visual intensity serves as a canvas for the reimagined setting but may feel disjointed, juxtaposing whimsicality with historical darkness.
The characters undergo significant transformations under del Toro's lens, presenting a fresh yet polarizing perspective. Geppetto, voiced by David Bradley, transforms from a loving father to a shattered, disillusioned figure, whose grief-stricken journey strays from the narrative innocence often attributed to him. Pinocchio, portrayed by Gregory Mann, diverges farther from his literary origins, embodying a puppet grappling with humanization—a core theme turned on its head with del Toro's unique take. Ewan McGregor’s Cricket emerges as a surprisingly humanized and endearing character, while the presence of ominous characters like Count Volpe, played by Christoph Waltz, enriches the film’s depiction of political demagoguery and child exploitation.
Despite these narrative shifts, Pinocchio captivates through its remarkable visual storytelling, ensuring that even the most indifferent viewer is seduced by its aesthetic brilliance. The film’s stop-motion execution is nothing short of a visual tour de force, magnifying del Toro's hallmark style reminiscent of works like The Devil's Backbone and Pan's Labyrinth. This adaptation harnesses its beauty in service of an evocative cinematic experience, recognized through its Oscar win for Best Animated Feature—a testament to its pioneering animation and storytelling.
Total: 86
Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio on Blu-ray is a technically remarkable release that perfectly showcases the film’s lush and vivid visuals, distinctively emblematic of del Toro’s cinematic style. While the narrative may struggle to deliver the complexity and depth associated with del Toro’s other mature works such as The Devil's Backbone and Pan's Labyrinth, the director’s ambitious retelling of the classic tale invites viewers into a world rich with imaginative detail. The Blu-ray presentation excels in delivering an exceptional visual and audio experience, making full use of the format's capabilities to highlight the intricacies of the film’s set design and animation.
The presentation shines with breathtaking clarity, capturing the finesse of each scene. The attention to detail is evident as it enhances ambient elements and vivid colors that characterize del Toro's palette, impressing upon viewers the grandeur of his vision. The audio performance complements this by providing a dynamic soundscape that immerses viewers, ensuring that both subtle sound details and sweeping musical scores elevate the viewing experience. Despite any perceived narrative shortcomings, this Blu-ray serves as a showcase for sophisticated home cinema systems looking to capitalize on high-quality mastering.
In conclusion, Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio Blu-ray release is an opportunity not only to experience rich visual storytelling but also to appreciate the technical prowess behind modern cinematic releases. This package should delight both fans of del Toro and aficionados of animated features, ultimately serving as a compelling addition to any film collection. Whether in pursuit of visual excellence or cinematic artistry, this release stands out as an exemplary offering in home media entertainment.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 100
In fact, I used the Blu-ray to do some 4K upscaling and then compare the presentation to the native 4K presentation and I think that the visuals are as impressive in 1080p as they are upscaled to 4K and...
Audio: 100
The movement, separation, and wide range of dynamic contrasts easily make it a 'reference quality' track that can test the muscles of your audio system....
Extras: 80
Directing Stop-Motion - in this program, Guillermo del Toro and Mark Gustafson discuss stop-motion direction and the work that was done during the production of Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio....
Movie: 60
The explosion of colors that provides the structure of the place where del Toro unleashes his imagination is so intense that after a while it truly overwhelms, which is a problem because it is difficult...
Total: 80
However, how del Toro and Mark Gustafson do the interpretation and where they send these characters while retelling Pinocchio's story makes it awfully easy to describe Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio as...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 100
Audio: 88
Be that as it may, overall, I enjoyed the balance of atmosphere combined with discrete object placement....
Extras: 80
Nehme New interview with curator Ron Magliozzi on The Museum of Modern Art’s 2022 exhibition devoted to the film New program on the eight rules of animation that informed the film’s production Panel discussion...
Movie: 80
Realized through boundary-pushing, breathtakingly intricate stop-motion animation, this dark rendering of the fable of the puppet boy and his maker—which won the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature—daringly...
Total: 87
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Director: Guillermo del Toro, Mark Gustafson
Actors: Ewan McGregor, David Bradley, Gregory Mann
PlotIn the heart of Italy during the interwar period's rise of fascism, a lonely woodcarver, Geppetto, mourns the loss of his son in a tragic accident. In his sorrow, he carves a wooden puppet from the same tree his child's memorial stands by, in an impossible wish for a second chance at fatherhood. One night, as Geppetto grieves, a magical event breathes life into the wooden figure, giving it a sentient, mischievous spark. The wood sprite who bestowed this miracle on the puppet mandates that it can become a real boy if it proves itself brave, truthful, and unselfish. Named Pinocchio, the puppet is bursting with childlike curiosity but lacks understanding of human norms and the dangers of the world.
Under Geppetto's care, the rambunctious Pinocchio embarks on a series of adventures, repeatedly challenging the woodcarver's patience and expectations. With the help of a philosophizing cricket, who tries to serve as the puppet's conscience, Pinocchio navigates the complexities of life, making friends and foes alike. His journey through a world filled with carnival-like wonders and dark threats teaches him the harsh realities beyond Geppetto's doorstep. Pinocchio's quest to earn his humanity is fraught with temptations and trials that test his burgeoning understanding of right and wrong.
Writers: Guillermo del Toro, Patrick McHale, Carlo Collodi
Release Date: 09 Dec 2022
Runtime: 117 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, Mexico, France, Australia
Language: English, Italian