Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands Blu-ray Review
Dona Flor e Seus Dois Maridos
Score: 63
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" Blu-ray impresses with strong audio-visuals, intriguing extras, and engaging humor, despite some provocative themes.
Disc Release Date
Video: 64
Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands' Blu-ray offers an organically filmic experience with its AVC encoded 1080p transfer, showcasing incredible detail for its era despite some technical imperfections like faded palettes, grain spikes, and print damage, making it the best rendering of the Brazilian classic to date.
Audio: 74
The Blu-ray audio of 'Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands' presents a choice between a 5.1 DTS-HD MA track, opening up the sound stage with dynamic ambient effects, and a 2.0 LPCM track with balanced, front-heavy audio; both options offer distinct advantages, with clean dialogue and engaging sound environments.
Extra: 36
Featuring English commentary by Bruno Barreto, an archival behind-the-scenes featurette with English subtitles, and a 16-page booklet with an insightful essay by Mary Jane Marcasiano, the Blu-ray extras of 'Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands' offer a compelling dive into the film's production and creative nuances.
Movie: 76
"Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands," a captivating blend of humor and passion reminiscent of Noel Coward's "Blithe Spirit," resurfaces on Blu-ray with a fresh remaster, spotlighting its cultural significance as Brazil's box office triumph while balancing madcap comedy and pacing issues; a rare find enhanced by insightful extras.
Video: 64
The Blu-ray release of "Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" by Film Movement Classics, featuring a 1.67:1 AVC encoded 1080p transfer, presents a mixed yet notably filmic viewing experience. Although lacking explicit technical specifications regarding the mastering or restoration process, the transfer achieves an organic aesthetic that has not undergone significant digital manipulation. This approach allows for natural texture retention, though it does bring about certain drawbacks such as sporadic vertical lines, mild print damage, and prevalent grain spikes, particularly in high-contrast scenes like those in the casino. The palette tends to lean towards faded browns, occasionally displaying a subtle blue tint, yet there are moments of vivid color and detail, especially visible in some costumes.
The video presentation demonstrates impressive fine detailing, notable for a 1970s Brazilian film of modest budget. While inconsistent in its handling of hue and contrast - at times resulting in crushed blacks or washed-out whites - the level of clarity vastly surpasses previous home video editions, like older VHS copies. However, some scratches and color inconsistencies persist throughout, suggesting limited restoration efforts. Despite these imperfections, this Blu-ray likely represents the best visual quality the film has achieved to date. The nuanced blend of grain and color provides a viewing experience that respects the original film's cinematic heritage, delivering a version that is authentically representative while highlighting its raw aesthetic charm.
Audio: 74
The Blu-ray release of "Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" presents two compelling audio options: a 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track in the original Portuguese and a 2.0 stereo track in LPCM. The 5.1 DTS-HD MA track excels at expanding the sound stage, effectively immersing the viewer with strategic use of ambient noise. This is particularly evident in scenes enhanced by environmental effects, such as nuanced details like background birdcalls during the burial scene. The surround track proves to be louder and more encompassing, giving outdoor sequences a noticeable advantage, while dialogue remains crisp and clear throughout.
Comparatively, the LPCM 2.0 track takes a more straightforward approach, emphasizing a balanced and front-heavy sound profile. This track is favorably appreciated for its balance and presence, catering to those who prefer a less enveloping audio setup. While the surround mix offers a broader auditory experience, the stereo track opts for clarity and simplicity. Optional English subtitles are available to facilitate comprehension.
Ultimately, both audio tracks are crafted to high technical standards, providing unique listening experiences that will cater to distinct preferences. Whether one chooses the immersive surround sound of the 5.1 DTS-HD or the structured clarity of the 2.0 LPCM, "Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" ensures audiences receive high-quality auditory enjoyment. The choice between these formats may largely depend on personal preference for either immersive ambient enhancement or balanced direct sound delivery.
Extras: 36
The Blu-ray extras for "Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" provide a comprehensive dive into the film's production and context. The audio commentary by director Bruno Barreto, presented in English, offers insightful perspectives and personal anecdotes that enrich the viewing experience. "Dona Flor Behind the Scenes," an archival featurette in Portuguese with English subtitles, gives a brief yet informative glimpse into the film’s creation, capturing the vibrancy on set through a concise 7:51-minute runtime. The package is complemented by a 16-page booklet containing a new essay by film producer and costume designer Mary Jane Marcasiano, adding depth to the film’s artistic and cultural significance. Additionally, the disc includes the original film trailer and trailers for other titles from Film Movement, accompanied by informational content about the company itself, providing a broader context of their distribution portfolio.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Bruno Barreto: Insightful commentary from the director in English.
- Behind-the-Scenes Featurette: Archival footage exploring the film’s production.
- Booklet: Essay enriching the film’s context by Mary Jane Marcasiano.
- Dona Flor Trailer: Original theatrical trailer.
- Film Movement Trailers: Trailers from other Film Movement releases.
Movie: 76
"Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" stands as a distinguished example of Brazilian cinema that has finally garnered a Blu-ray release, drawing in enthusiasts of world cinema who have long lamented its elusiveness. Originally released in 1976, this Brazilian comedy captures the essence of Brazil’s vibrant culture and dynamic storytelling. The film is a whimsical narrative centered around Dona Flor, portrayed brilliantly by Sonia Braga, and her romantic entanglements with her husband Vadinho, played by José Wilker, a ne'er-do-well with unsavory yet distinctly charismatic traits. Upon his sudden demise, Flor's life takes a new turn as she marries the reliable Dr. Teodoro, only to be visited by Vadinho's ghost, reigniting her internal conflict between sensibility and passion.
Technically, the film bears resemblance to Noel Coward’s "Blithe Spirit," adapting the "dead spouse" trope into a more spirited and culturally rich farce. While some may draw analogies to Peter Sellers' comedic brilliance in "The Pink Panther," this film injects its humor with nuance, subtly interplaying with themes of romance and societal norms of the time. Despite some pacing issues—lingering over Vadinho's life versus the brisk progression posthumously—the narrative weaves a compelling tapestry of love and ethereal possibilities. It might benefit from structural adjustments to balance the timelines more equitably, but the movie remains irresistibly charming.
Musically accented with Brazil's own traditions, exemplified by Chico Buarque's "O Que Será," the film’s diegetic elements build an atmosphere that is both endemic and universally appreciable. Although its treatment of Flor’s desires might jar modern sensibilities with its portrayal of Vadinho's allure despite his flaws, the comedic energy flows refreshingly through the supernatural lens. This release will introduce "Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" to new audiences, providing an important cultural artifact in pristine audiovisual clarity.
Total: 63
"Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" arrives on Blu-ray with a respectable transfer that carefully preserves the film's visual charm, shot in a 1.67:1 aspect ratio using AVC encoding. The colors are vibrant, maintaining the warm palette that complements Bruno Barreto's lighthearted direction. The audio presentation, featuring Portuguese DTS-HD MA 5.1 and LPCM 2.0 tracks, provides a robust listening experience that encapsulates the film’s lively ambiance, while English subtitles ensure accessibility for non-Portuguese speakers. The film, rated R, explores themes of love and desire with a comedic flair, anchored by compelling performances from Sonia Braga and Jose Wilker.
The narrative balances between humor and provocative themes, reflecting its source material's distinctiveness. Some may find Vadinho's character discomfiting due to his capricious nature, yet this is counterbalanced by moments of genuine hilarity and insight. The release also includes new extras that enhance the viewer's understanding of the film, such as an insightful commentary and a thoughtful insert booklet essay, adding significant value for aficionados and newcomers alike.
In conclusion, "Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands" has finally secured a place in modern home video libraries with its Blu-ray release. This edition delivers both visual and auditory quality, ensuring that the film's essence is preserved. It is a must-have for enthusiasts of foreign comedies, deftly merging humor with sophisticated portrayals of relationships within its cultural context. Despite its R-rated elements, it aligns well with contemporary standards of erotic comedy, making it an essential addition for anyone interested in international cinema. Highly recommended.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 70
There are some vertical lines that pop up here and there, some mild print damage as well, but the end result is still a very natural and organically filmic experience....
Audio: 80
I really like how the 5.1 mix opens up the sound stage, allowing for a rather impressive use of the ambient noises to bleed in (though a few times I felt I detected some dialog bleed in the rears)....
Extras: 40
• Audio Commentary by director Bruno Barreto • Behind-the-Scenes Featurette • Booklet: 16-page booklet with new essay by film producer & costume designer Mary Jane Marcasiano....
Movie: 80
All complaints aside, Dona Flor and her Two Husbands is a hard to find diamond in the rough comedy that was a massive hit in Brazil, but basically unknown over the rest of the world....
Total: 70
Highly recommended to fans of subtle foreign comedies, and while it’s definitely on the R-rated side of things, is still well within modern standards for being an “erotic” comedy....
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
The bad news is that that can mean quite a bit of damage, including some pretty drastic scratching (mostly short lived, but recurrent), as well as some inconsistencies in palette and contrast that can...
Audio: 80
The surround track rather nicely opens things up both in terms of some of the music but also very noticeably in some of the ambient environmental effects (listen, for example, to the difference between...
Extras: 40
As with most Film Movement releases, the disc also offers an About Film Movement option on the Main Menu which leads to text about and a trailer for Film Movement....
Movie: 80
For fans who have only known of Feldshuh's work through more instantly "accessible" media like television, it may come as a surprise then that Funny Girl will not be Feldshuh's first musical on Broadway...
Total: 80
Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands can be occasionally discomfiting, especially in some of the callous behaviors of Vadinho, but it's also often very funny and maybe even a little provocative in its depictions...
Director: Bruno Barreto
Actors: Sonia Braga, José Wilker, Mauro Mendonça
PlotIn a vibrant Brazilian town, Dona Flor, a graceful and talented cooking instructor, is married to the charismatic but irresponsible gambler, Vadinho. Despite their intense passion, their marriage is tumultuous due to Vadinho's hedonistic lifestyle and frequent disappearances, leaving Flor to fend for herself amidst his reckless escapades. The undeniable chemistry between them is overshadowed by Flor's increasing sense of disappointment and hardship. She witnesses his audacious and carefree nature unravel before her eyes, culminating in a dramatic incident during Carnival that drastically alters her world.
Struggling to find balance after this turning point, Flor eventually remarries the stable pharmacist Teodoro, whose disciplined ways provide her with the security she longed for. Although she respects and cares for Teodoro, Flor finds herself yearning for the excitement and passion of her past. Her conflicted emotions lead to an unexpected and whimsical twist as she navigates the challenges of reconciling her desires. Thrust into a comedic juxtaposition between her past and present, Flor discovers that love can be as unpredictable as it is powerful. As she seeks to harmonize these opposites in her life, Flor's journey unfolds with humor and enchantment, capturing the essence of longing and fulfillment in a mixture of love and nostalgia.
Writers: Jorge Amado, Bruno Barreto, Eduardo Coutinho
Release Date: 21 Jun 1978
Runtime: 110 min
Rating: R
Country: Brazil
Language: Portuguese