Desert Hearts Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Desert Hearts" features a meticulously restored 4K transfer supervised by acclaimed cinematographer Robert Elswit. Encoded with MPEG-4 AVC and presented in its original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.85:1 in 1080p high definition, the restoration is rooted in the work done by the UCLA Film & Television Archive, Outfest UCLA Legacy Project, and the Sundance Institute. The transfer was executed using a DFT Scanity film scanner from the 35mm original camera negative, with the 2K restoration executed by Roundabout Entertainment and Criterion Collection.

The new digital transfer delivers impressive detail, particularly in the film's outdoor sequences. The stunning desert scenery and sunrises are rendered with vibrant colors, strong black levels, and rich, natural tones, all underpinned by a pleasant layer of filmic grain. While some indoor shots exhibit minor inconsistencies regarding grain and detail, the overall image stability remains excellent. Occasional density fluctuations, particularly during darker footage, appear to be an organic part of the original cinematography rather than flaws. There are no signs of problematic degraining or sharpening, ensuring that the visual integrity of the film remains intact.

Given its vintage and budget constraints, "Desert Hearts" now looks exceptionally vibrant and healthy. The outdoor visuals, especially when viewed on larger screens, appear magnificent with pleasing depth and clarity. The restoration has eliminated large debris, cuts, damage marks, warps, and torn frames, making this Blu-ray release the best visual rendition of the film available to date.

The audio presentation of the Blu-ray release for "Desert Hearts" provides an impressive auditory experience, utilizing an uncompressed linear PCM 1.0 mono soundtrack. While it doesn't offer a vast breadth due to its inherent limitations, it succeeds in delivering a clear and coherent representation of dialogue. The atmospheric effects are engrossingly presented, with engine noises, bustling bars, and desert winds creating a rich ambiance. Noteworthy are the period songs from iconic artists like Elvis Presley, Ella Fitzgerald, Patsy Cline, Buddy Holly, and Jim Reeves, which are delivered with a decent resonance, though there is a slight hint of tinny sharpness at the upper end.

Despite the film's modest budget, the audio quality manages to impress. The balance and separation of the various organic sounds and noises are handled well within the lossless track, maintaining fidelity and coherence with no age-related anomalies detectable. The optional English SDH subtitles further enhance the overall listening experience for viewers. This meticulous attention to audio detail allows "Desert Hearts" to retain its classic charm and immersive atmosphere.

Criterion delivers an exceptional collection of bonus features for "Desert Hearts." The array includes a 2007 audio commentary by director Donna Deitch, exploring the film's production challenges and her collaboration with cast members, alongside compelling reflections on Jane Rule's novel. Newly created materials include insightful interviews with Deitch and Jane Lynch, who both discuss the film's impact on personal and professional lives, plus exclusive conversations with leads Helen Shaver and Patricia Charbonneau. Additionally, a featurette with cinematographer Robert Elswit and production designer Jeannine Oppewall, titled "Remembering Reno," delves into the visual style and on-location shooting. A notable inclusion is a documentary excerpt on Jane Rule, highlighting her literary influence. The overall presentation is augmented by Criterion’s beautifully designed booklet.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Extensive details on production and narrative insights.
• Donna Deitch and Jane Lynch: Discussion on book adaptation and film’s impact.
• Women in Love: Interviews with lead actors on their experiences.
• Remembering Reno: Insights into visual style and filming in Reno.
• Fiction and Other Truths: A Film About Jane Rule: Documentary excerpts on the author.

Donna Deitch's 1985 debut, Desert Hearts, set in the conservative 1950s Neveda, is a pioneering tale of forbidden love between two women, rendered with remarkable sensibility and audacity for its time. Adapted by screenwriter Natalie Cooper from Jane Rule's 1964 novel Desert of the Heart, the narrative revolves around Professor Vivian Bell (Helen Shaver) and a local free spirit, Cay Rivvers (Patricia Charbonneau). Bell's impending divorce sets the stage for an unexpected romantic entanglement that unfolds with palpable tension and magnetic performances. Deitch carefully captures the authenticity of the period with the backdrop of the moody desert setting, allowing the chemistry between the leads to flourish naturally and compellingly. The film remains tender and respectful, portraying a passionate yet restrained love story without sensationalism.

Helen Shaver’s portrayal of Vivian evolves beautifully as she transitions from a straight-laced academic into someone emotionally awakened by her risky liaison with Cay. Patricia Charbonneau shines, imbuing her rebellious character with palpable charisma and sincerity. Despite her subsequent lack of recognition in Hollywood, Charbonneau's contribution to Desert Hearts is substantial and memorable. Cinematographer Robert Elswit's work amplifies the narrative's emotional depths through serene yet striking visuals reminiscent of Wim Wenders' and Kelly Reichardt's styles, seamlessly blending natural beauty and authenticity. The production’s estimated budget of $350,000 was utilized to maximize the film’s aesthetic appeal, resulting in wide panoramic shots that stand out for their vibrant primary colors and lush nuances.

While the film has aged, its boldness and authenticity remain significant. Deitch, along with an invested cast and crew, navigates complex themes of identity and self-discovery with delicacy and resilience. Overall, Desert Hearts continues to stand as a rare and audacious portrayal of lesbian love, handled with nuance and reverence.

Desert Hearts is a rare example of lesbian love portrayed sensually but without sensationalism.

Criterion's Region B-locked UK Blu-ray release of Desert Hearts provides excellent 4K-remastered high definition video and strong mono audio as well as a hefty selection of decent extras, leaving this a must-have for fans.

The mainstream take on Donna Deitch's directorial debut has been that it is a moving romantic drama about two women that fall in love amidst the sand dunes and rocks of Reno. However, I see it as an even bigger film about the false identities many of us adopt and become comfortable with in order to become acceptable in the eyes of the people that have the power to shape up our lives. It is a fearless film that was truly ahead of its time. Criterion's Blu-ray release is sourced from a sparkling new 4K restoration that has given the film a new life. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.

The Criterion Collection’s Region B-locked UK Blu-ray release of “Desert Hearts” impresses with its exquisite 4K remastering, rejuvenating the visual and auditory elements to a level befitting modern home viewing standards. The high definition transfer captures the nuanced cinematography beautifully, from the sun-drenched Nevada landscapes to the intimate moments between characters. The mono audio track is clear and well-balanced, ensuring every word and note resonates with clarity. Additionally, the Blu-ray includes a robust selection of supplementary materials that provide deeper insights into the film’s making and its cultural impact.

Donna Deitch’s directorial debut is not merely a tale of romance; it delves into themes of self-discovery and authenticity. The film's portrayal of a lesbian relationship is handled with grace and sensitivity, distinguishing it from other more sensationalist portrayals. It’s as much about breaking through societal veneers and embracing one’s true self as it is about falling in love. These themes render it not just a historical piece but an enduring story relevant even today.

Criterion’s meticulous work on this release underscores their commitment to preserving seminal works of cinema. The 4K restoration breathes new life into “Desert Hearts,” allowing new audiences to experience its emotional and cultural significance. This release is highly recommended for both fans of the film and cinephiles who appreciate groundbreaking cinema.

In conclusion, "Desert Hearts" epitomizes a pioneering spirit in LGBTQ+ storytelling, captured elegantly through Criterion’s stellar Blu-ray edition. The exceptional 4K remastering, impressive audio quality, and valuable extras make this an essential addition to any serious film collection.