Silk Stockings Blu-ray Review

Warner Archive’s 1080p, AVC-encoded Blu-ray transfer of "Silk Stockings" represents a concerted effort to restore Robert J. Bronner’s widescreen cinematography, originally captured on Metrocolor stock. This new scan derived directly from the original camera negative was conducted in 4K, adhering to Warner’s modern restoration policies. However, inherent limitations of the early anamorphic lenses used and issues with the Eastmancolor stock have left noticeable impacts on the final image. Viewers will note a softness in the picture, especially pronounced in close-ups, which is uncharacteristic when compared to films shot just a few years later. Despite the challenges posed by yellow layer collapse—a deterioration affecting color and grain—the Blu-ray nonetheless manages to deliver quite vivid color representation, especially in the assertive costumes and vibrant hues.

The transfer particularly excels in balancing colors, with Janis Paige’s bright outfits and Cyd Charisse’s more subtle costumes both rendered impressively. Nevertheless, black levels remain inconsistent, occasionally appearing blue, which disrupts the visual cohesion.

Grain is visibly accentuated due to the aforementioned degradation, slightly amplifying the perception of softness. Yet, Warner Archive’s decision to refrain from applying heavy digital sharpening or grain reduction is commendable for preserving the image's authenticity. The result is an image that, while far from perfect, avoids artificiality. An oddity does exist at 1:10:05 where color values shift noticeably, an artifact of faded opticals left uncorrected. The Blu-ray is mastered at a robust bitrate of 35 Mbps, ensuring a technically proficient encode despite source challenges. The overall impression is that of a transfer that, while reflecting the inherent difficulties of its elements, remains a worthy representation of this Golden Age classic.

The lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track on the Blu-ray of "Silk Stockings" significantly enhances the auditory experience of this classic musical. The original stereo soundtrack has been meticulously remixed, delivering clear, crisp sound throughout. Instrumental separation is notably excellent, with the sound of the unseen orchestra filling the front channels. This wide dynamic range also extends to the vocal performances, capturing both Fred Astaire's smooth vocals and Janis Paige’s powerful belting with remarkable clarity. Dimensional shadings and fidelity are superior, lending a rich multi-channel presence that envelops the room.

Musical numbers truly stand out on this track. André Previn's lush orchestrations come alive without any distortion, resonating with a balanced bass and bright high tones. Specific sound design elements, such as the humorous echo in 'Stereophonic Sound' and the distinct clattering of Nina's typewriter, are effectively rendered with precision. Dialogue remains consistently clear and comprehensible, free from any age-related audio artifacts like hiss, pops, or crackles. Although some singing bears the artificial quality typical of pre-recorded dubbing, this is an inherent characteristic of the original source material and does not detract from the overall high-quality presentation.

The Blu-ray extras for "Silk Stockings" offer fans an enriching insight into this classic musical. Noteworthy is the seamless porting of all supplements from Warner's 2003 DVD release, now featuring improved resolutions. The centerpiece featurette, hosted by a still-glamorous Cyd Charisse, provides an engaging retrospective on the film’s production, with illuminating comments from key contributors like André Previn and Janis Paige. Vintage shorts, including “Paree, Paree” and “The Poet and Peasant Overture,” offer rare historical performances, presented in remastered HD quality. The theatrical trailer completes this robust selection, providing a nostalgic glimpse into the film’s promotion.

Extras included in this disc:

• Cole Porter in Hollywood: Satin and Silk: A 2003 featurette hosted by Cyd Charisse with insights from André Previn and Janis Paige.
• Paree, Paree: A 1934 Vitaphone short with Bob Hope performing Cole Porter songs.
• Poet and Peasant Overture: A 1955 MGM Symphony Orchestra performance in Technicolor and CinemaScope.
• Theatrical Trailer: Original preview highlighting the film’s musical and romantic elements.

"Silk Stockings," Fred Astaire and Cyd Charisse's final collaboration, delivers a visually splendid and musically rich cinematic experience. Adapted from the Broadway musical of the same name, which itself was inspired by Ernst Lubitsch’s 1939 classic "Ninotchka," this 1957 film skillfully brings Cold War era wit and charm to the screen. Faithfully produced by MGM’s Arthur Freed, with a sparkling score by Cole Porter, the film balances intricate dance sequences with pointed social satire. Rouben Mamoulian’s elegant direction showcases every stylish element, from the gorgeously choreographed dances to the lavish Parisian scenery where much of the story unfolds.

Aiding in its success is the undeniable chemistry between Astaire and Charisse, who reprise their roles with palpable synergy and finesse. Astaire, though perhaps a touch miscast as Hollywood producer Steve Canfield, shines in every dance number, floating through each sequence with his trademark grace. Charisse, stepping into a role first made iconic by Greta Garbo, exudes a winning combination of stern resolve and underlying vulnerability. In their dance duet "All of You," their elegant moves seamlessly complement Porter’s romantic melodies, while Charisse dazzles in solo numbers like the unabashedly sexy "Silk Stockings" ballet and the energetic "Red Blues."

The film cleverly updates Ninotchka's narrative to reflect Cold War tensions, making its comedic portrayal of Soviet officials all the more relevant to contemporary audiences of the 1950s. Porter’s incisively witty lyrics in songs like "Paris Loves Lovers" and "Siberia" delight in drawing contrasts between capitalist indulgence and communist austerity. Despite its critique of Hollywood superficiality in the number "Stereophonic Sound," "Silk Stockings" remains a quintessential Golden Age musical—a celebration of Astaire and Charisse's artistry that is both sophisticated and accessible, with each scene brimming with panache and exuberance.

Warner Archive’s Blu-ray release of "Silk Stockings" offers a delightful journey back to the elegance and charm of classic Hollywood musicals. Directed by Rouben Mamoulian, this adaptation of 'Ninotchka' is elevated by Cole Porter's timeless compositions, witty lyrics, and superb choreography. The on-screen chemistry between Fred Astaire and Cyd Charisse is palpable, delivering performances that blend ethereal style and grace. The production values are excellent overall, capturing the bubbly and fresh essence akin to a fine champagne cocktail.

Technically, the Blu-ray release does a commendable job. While the image quality is not as pristine as some other high-definition restorations, it remains a significant improvement over prior releases. The video and audio transfers are notable, preserving the film's vibrancy and auditory clarity. Additionally, the inclusion of all supplements from the previous DVD release is a welcome touch, offering a rich viewing experience for both dedicated fans and casual viewers alike. Despite minor technical imperfections, the presentation is sufficiently engaging to warrant a purchase recommendation.

In conclusion, "Silk Stockings" is a celebration of the classic musical genre and a testament to MGM's storied history in film. Though not as visually perfect as one might hope, this Blu-ray edition likely represents the best version of the film we will see. It stands as a must-have for musical enthusiasts and remains highly recommended for anyone looking to experience the last great era of Hollywood musicals. Buyer's choice.