Saw V Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Saw V disappoints yet thrills fans with its formulaic twists and high-quality production.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 60
Saw V on Blu-ray boasts a grim, stylistic visual presentation with a consistent yet eerie colour scheme, sharp contrasts in blood red, and detailed, dark cinematography. Despite minor softness, it's effectively immersive.
Audio: 65
A DTS HD Master Audio 7.1 track envelops with aggressive bass, clear dialogue, and immersive, detailed industrial soundscapes, perfectly complementing the film's intense atmosphere.
Extra: 61
Saw V Blu-ray offers detailed insights into film's traps, effects, and editing with commentaries and featurettes appealing to fans.
Movie: 46
Saw V, the goriest yet, lacks the signature revelatory twist but ties loose ends, elevating it in the franchise despite its formulaic plot and excessive gore.
Video: 60
Saw V's Blu-ray presentation in AVC encoded 1080p resolution, adopting a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, continues the series' established aesthetic with striking consistency. The video retains the characteristic yellowish/green hue dominating the landscape, crafting an atmosphere that’s both unsettling and quintessentially Saw. This color grading occasionally challenges the assessment of skin tones, though they largely appear natural, without artificial enhancement. The meticulous balance between the deep, inky blacks and the carefully illuminated scenes contributes to a brooding, grim atmosphere. The transfer excels in portraying dark sequences with substantial clarity in shadow details, adhering to an artistic choice that emphasizes darkness as a border rather than an element to be fully explored. This approach underpins the film’s thematic elements of fear and the unknown, cocooning them within its visually consistent world.
The color palette is deliberately subdued, barring moments that call for visual emphasis. When colors are allowed to break through the otherwise murky visual style—especially the stark, cherry red of blood—they do so with a surprising intensity that stands in sharp contrast to their surroundings. Despite occasional critiques of the blood's overly vivid representation, it seems a deliberate choice to accentuate the film's visceral aspects. The film's grain structure is handled with such finesse that it enhances its cinematic quality without becoming obtrusive. Subtle softness appears in certain scenes, but given the overall high quality of presentation and the film’s modest budget, this minor inconsistency hardly detracts from the viewing experience.
Lionsgate's Blu-ray transfer showcases high detail fidelity, especially in scenes laden with gore, where the prosthetics' quality is rendered with remarkable clarity. Colors like vomit-toned greens and yellows punctuate the grizzly atmosphere, while blacks vary in intensity—fluctuating between deep gray and solid black—which might slightly affect visual depth in darker scenes. Flesh tones are convincingly natural across various lighting conditions, and a consistent grain overlay ensures the film's texture remains intact. Although sharpness levels somewhat fluctuate, the transfer ultimately presents Saw V with commendable fidelity, encapsulating its dark and dank cinematography effectively while paying homage to the series' legacy of grim but gripping visual storytelling.
Audio: 65
The Blu-ray release of "Saw V" presents its audience with a remarkable audio journey, courtesy of a DTS HD Master Audio 7.1 track that showcases an impressive layering of sound. The mix is a intricate balance of low and high frequencies, forcefully engaging the LFE channel to produce a strong, authoritative bass that compliments the film's intense atmospheric tension. Yet, this is not merely a bass-driven soundscape. The surround channels are masterfully employed to envelop the audience in a cacophony of industrial clamor—metal clanging, machines whirring, and blades slicing through the air—intensifying the experience of the film’s numerous harrowing sequences. This immersive soundstage is further enriched by the detailed and terrifying sounds of screams and distress, coming from all directions, making the viewers feel as if they are right in the middle of the unfolding nightmare.
Lionsgate has indeed outdone itself with this audio representation, making full use of the DTS-HD MA 7.1 lossless soundtrack in creating an environment that is as sonically rich as it is horrifying. Every speaker plays a pivotal role in crafting an enveloping atmosphere, with the bass lines rumbling with a fervor that underscores the film's relentless, industrial score. Rear channel activity is both nuanced and dynamic, ranging from the subtle ambience of a bustling hospital corridor to the aggressive dissemination of the score and terror-inducing echoes across the back channels.
Crucially, amidst this dense orchestration of sound, dialogue clarity is never compromised. Voices remain distinct and crisp against the backdrop of the film’s complex acoustic environment. There’s a certain finesse in capturing the resonance and nuance in each character's voice, ensuring that the narrative thread remains coherent and engaging throughout. The audio mix does an outstanding job at enhancing the overall viewing experience, situating the audience at the very heart of "Saw V's" chilling and suspenseful journey without losing sight of narrative clarity amidst its robust sonic architecture.
Extras: 61
The "Saw V" Blu-ray extras deliver a satisfying array of behind-the-scenes insights, primarily focusing on the film's elaborate traps and the technical wizardry behind them. The disc kicks off with two commentary tracks; Director David Hackl and 1st Assistant Director Steve Webb lead the first, offering a holistic view of the film's production, from trap conception to final edits. Although not groundbreaking, it’s informative for franchise enthusiasts. The producers’ commentary provides a similar experience, slightly dryer but equally detailed, emphasizing the traps and series continuity. A collection of featurettes dives deep into the design, execution, and filming of iconic traps like The Pendulum, Cube, and Coffin Traps, plus an extensive look at The Fatal Five’s challenges. "Slicing The Cube," focuses on editing intricacies. MOLOG offers interactive potential although functionality issues were noted. Extras conclude with trailers and a digital copy of the film, noted for its decent visual quality and surprisingly robust audio on compatible devices.
Extras included in this disc:
- Director's Commentary: In-depth discussion with Director David Hackl and First Assistant Director Steve Webb.
- Producer's Commentary: Insights from Producers Mark Burg and Oren Koules, with Executive Producers Peter Block and Jason Constantine.
- The Pendulum Trap: Crew explain trap creation using props and prosthetics.
- The Cube Trap: Details on the logistics of filming Agent Strahm's trap sequence.
- The Coffin Trap: Behind-the-scenes look at the final trap’s orchestration.
- The Fatal Five: Focuses on the construction and filming of four key traps.
- Slicing The Cube; Editing The Cube Trap: Director and editor discuss the technical editing process.
- MOLOG: BD Live feature for creating a virtual blog within the film.
- Bookmarks: Simple functionality for easy navigation.
Movie: 46
Saw V, building upon the extensive lore and intricate plot networks established by its predecessors, stands out as a structurally ambitious but somewhat flawed installment in the long-running horror series. This film, while delivering on the gory expectations that have become a hallmark of the franchise, falters in recapturing the narrative elegance and surprise elements that defined the earlier films, particularly the absence of a revelatory moment that effectively recalibrates the audience's understanding of the unfolding drama. Despite these narrative shortcomings, Saw V doesn't shy away from pushing the boundaries of on-screen violence and gore, making it arguably the most graphic entry in the series to date. The film's meticulous attention to the visceral reality of its death scenes ventures into territory that could unsettle even the most seasoned horror aficionados.
Set against the backdrop of Jigsaw’s (Tobin Bell) posthumous games, Saw V follows the investigative pursuit led by Agent Peter Strahm (Scott Patterson) as he seeks to unveil Lieutenant-Detective Mark Hoffman (Costas Mandylor) as the true successor of Jigsaw's grisly legacy. Concurrently, a new group of victims finds themselves ensnared in a series of traps that test their moral fibers in grotesquely innovative ways. Through a creative use of flashbacks, the film enriches its storyline by diving into previously unexplored chapters of Jigsaw's dark saga, providing context and adding layers to an already complex narrative. This technique not only serves to bind this installment to its predecessors but also attempts to set a foundation for future narratives within the Saw universe.
Despite its robust attempts at deepening the lore and upping the ante with unabashedly graphic content, Saw V struggles to deliver a cohesive and impactful narrative experience akin to its originator. While it commendably succeeds in maintaining a consistent thematic focus on punishment versus rehabilitation and explores intriguing ethical dilemmas through its trademark death traps, the film ultimately feels like a missed opportunity to evolve the franchise. It presents a conundrum for fans and critics alike: a viscerally intense yet narratively disjointed chapter that both fascinates and frustrates, showcasing the challenges of keeping a horror franchise fresh without straying from its foundational elements.
Total: 61
"Saw V" continues the intricate and gory narrative that has become a hallmark of the series, though it arguably does little to innovate within the franchise’s established formula. The film's attempts at character development and story progression feel underwhelming, with characters appearing two-dimensional and the plot twists somewhat predictable. Despite these narrative shortcomings, the movie's dedication to maintaining a cohesive storyline across the series is commendable. It bridges certain gaps and teases future developments, ensuring fans remain engaged and eager for subsequent entries. This installment might struggle to captivate newcomers due to its reliance on previous knowledge and its graphic content, which, while appealing to some, might alienate those less familiar with the series' brutal aesthetic. Nonetheless, "Saw V" excels in its technical presentation. The Blu-ray release is a testament to Lionsgate's commitment to quality, offering a visually stunning and audibly immersive experience that fans of high-definition horror will undoubtedly appreciate. The Blu-ray’s supplemental materials add value, making this edition a must-have for collectors and enthusiasts of the franchise.
Lionsgate exhibits its understanding of the "Saw" franchise's fan base with this Blu-ray release of "Saw V". The film itself may not represent the zenith of the series in terms of innovation or narrative depth, but it confidently delivers on the gruesome spectacle and intricate storytelling that fans expect. The technical aspects of the Blu-ray are particularly noteworthy, providing a superior audio-visual experience that enhances the film's grim ambiance and complements its visceral horror elements.
In conclusion, while "Saw V" may not be the most critically acclaimed entry in the series, its Blu-ray presentation reaffirms Lionsgate's ability to cater to its audience with exceptional quality. The film serves well as a bridge within the larger narrative arc, satisfying long-time fans with its continuity and attention to detail. Despite its narrative pitfalls, the Blu-ray edition of "Saw V" is a valuable addition for collectors, showcasing outstanding technical execution and ensuring that even the most discerning of the franchise's aficionados find something to appreciate.
avforums review by Mark BotwrightRead review here
Video: 80
Overall, things are as they should be, with the only slight caveat of an image that sometimes falls towards a slight softness, but this is only really apparent due to the crisp nature of the vast majority...
Audio: 80
There is a subtle resonance and airiness to the voices in their plight, emphasizing the hollow spaces the characters find themselves trapped within....
Extras: 70
More technical than the previous extras, this touches upon such things as the need for multi-camera setups due to lack of takes and how flash frames and editing clips backwards helped aid the overall feel...
Movie: 50
The film itself is formulaic, yet misses an essential part of the tried and tested blueprint laid down by the previous four chapters in the series - namely the final jaw dropping revelatory moment that...
Total: 60
Though perhaps laboured in aLostmanner of “let's throw another twist in that doesn't bear real scrutiny”, it does at least create a genuine reason to see the film for those interested in the previous four,...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Several scenes of immense gore, including bloody innards and body parts torn asunder, several times cover the screen in red, playing in sharp contrast to the dark, grimy interiors of the film....
Audio: 90
Bass rumbles with an impressive level of vigor and authority several times in support of a raucous, loud, and industrial-sounding track that compliments the dark, unforgiving look of the film nicely....
Extras: 60
This track is about on the same level as the Director's track; it's a bit lighter but equally informative, discussing again the traps, the five victims, the interconnectivity of the series (and the commentary...
Movie: 50
The film spares no expense, showcasing each death scene in meticulous detail that borders on being too much, and unlike some of the exploitative films of the 1970s and 1980s, for example, Saw V revels...
Total: 70
The film meshes grisly violence with good characterization and storytelling that will please the series' dedicated audience but will be lost on newcomers, save for those only interested in the gore, who...
Director: David Hackl
Actors: Scott Patterson, Costas Mandylor, Tobin Bell
PlotIn the grim continuation of a visceral saga, the story follows FBI Agent Strahm, who, having narrowly escaped one of Jigsaw's traps, is now hot on the trail of Detective Hoffman. With the notorious Jigsaw killer, John Kramer, now deceased, Hoffman emerges as the unchallenged successor to Jigsaw's legacy of twisted justice and brutal tests of survival. Strahm's obsession with uncovering the truth sees him delving deeper into the maze of horrors and machinations that define Jigsaw's world. Meanwhile, Hoffman meticulously crafts his next series of diabolical games to carry on the work of his mentor, ensuring his deadly puzzles remain a step ahead of the authorities.
Simultaneously, another game is set into motion as a group of five individuals find themselves trapped and forced to navigate a series of lethal trials. Bound by their choices and actions from the past, each trap is designed to test their will to survive and demands they make unimaginable sacrifices to proceed. As the group's dynamics shift under the pressure of their dire circumstances, their instincts for self-preservation come to the forefront, highlighting the core of Jigsaw’s philosophy—that of valuing life through the face of death. With the clock ticking, they must decipher the connections that bind them and confront the consequences of their actions if they are to escape their gruesome fates.
Writers: Patrick Melton, Marcus Dunstan
Release Date: 24 Oct 2008
Runtime: 92 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Canada
Language: English