Written on the Wind Blu-ray Review
Score: 81
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Sirk's quintessential melodrama shines in Criterion's Blu-ray with superb 2K restoration, riveting performances, and lush Technicolor cinematography. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 87
Criterion's Blu-ray release of 'Written on the Wind' showcases a pristine 1080p transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, derived from a 2K resolution scan of the original 35mm negative. Vibrant Technicolor hues, excellent clarity, and controlled contrast amplify Douglas Sirk's visually striking melodrama, offering a superior presentation for fans.
Audio: 87
The Blu-ray's English LPCM 1.0 audio track, remastered from the 35mm master, delivers clear dialogue and a wide dynamic range, though at times feels slightly compressed. Frank Skinner's score and distinct sound effects such as car engines are effectively rendered, with no distortion or age-related artifacts present.
Extra: 59
The Blu-ray extras include a compelling 2008 featurette, "Acting for Douglas Sirk," with interviews of collaborators and insights into the films' melodramatic themes. Critic Patricia White's 2021 interview delves into "Written on the Wind"'s profound melodrama and Brechtian influences. Enriching but sparse supplemental material.
Movie: 78
Douglas Sirk's 'Written on the Wind' on Blu-ray showcases his masterful visual style and exposes the turbulent lives of the wealthy with technicolor brilliance. Featuring Oscar-winning performances by Malone and a dynamic Stack, the film dives into themes of power, desire, and self-destruction in melodramatic excess.
Video: 87
The Criterion Collection Blu-ray release of "Written on the Wind" presents a superb restoration that elevates the film's visual fidelity to new heights. Rendered in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, the transfer is encoded with MPEG-4 AVC and benefits from a state-of-the-art 1080p presentation, sourced from a meticulous 2K resolution scan of the 35mm original camera negative. The use of a vintage 35mm dye-transfer print for color reference ensures a remarkable color fidelity that does justice to Douglas Sirk's vibrant and expressive use of hues.
The visual clarity is striking, revealing intricate details such as individual hair strands, skin pores, and the nuanced textures of clothing and set design. A fine grain structure maintains the filmic texture, enhancing authenticity without compromising image stability. The color palette is expansive, with vivid primary colors and deep blacks contributing to a rich visual experience. Iconic elements, such as Marylee’s red sports car and vibrant costumes, pop with intensity, while shadow delineation remains superior, preserving the intended dramatic visuals throughout.
Despite initial moments of softer contrast, the presentation quickly resolves into a lush, crystal-clear image free from distractions such as scratches or specks. While transitions occasionally show minor roughness, overall film quality remains pristine. The Criterion Blu-ray exhibits an exceptional reproduction of the film's sumptuous aesthetics, making it a definitive visual experience for enthusiasts of Sirk, Russell Metty, and classic mid-century cinema. This transfer is a testament to Criterion’s commitment to excellence, rendering "Written on the Wind" visually better than it has ever been seen on home video.
Audio: 87
The audio presentation of "Written on the Wind" on Blu-ray offers an English LPCM 1.0 track, faithfully maintaining this vintage film's original monaural sound. The dialogue is pristine and easily discernible, supported by optional English SDH subtitles. Notably, Robert Stack's slurred delivery as Kyle, designed to convey inebriation, is brilliantly captured without distortion. The soundtrack effectively conveys the era's ambiance, with Frank Skinner’s music complementing the narrative, albeit somewhat predictably at dramatic junctures. The sonic detail extends to the lively renditions of car engines and ambient sounds, providing a well-rounded auditory experience.
The audio fidelity benefits from remastering the original monaural soundtrack from a 35 mm magnetic master. This process has ensured clarity and preserved tonal depth, especially during dynamic sequences such as Malone's uninhibited dance accompanied by "Temptation." The mix highlights a broad dynamic range without any audible artifacts like hiss, crackle, or pops. Sound effects, from revving engines to screeching wheels and fisticuffs, are rendered with exceptional clarity and precision. The robust audio engineering ensures every element of the soundtrack contributes seamlessly to the film's storytelling.
Overall, while some minor compression is perceptible in certain scenes, requiring slight volume adjustments for optimal listening, the Blu-ray audio remains free from anomalies like dropouts or distortions. This LPCM 1.0 track exemplifies top-tier sound reproduction from the film's era, presenting audio elements—from dialogue to score and effects—in a balanced and engaging manner.
Extras: 59
The Blu-ray extras for "Written on the Wind" offer a compelling exploration of Douglas Sirk's melodramatic craftsmanship, although they are few. The standout feature is the "Acting for Douglas Sirk" program, where archival interviews from actors like Rock Hudson, Dorothy Malone, and Robert Stack, along with insights from producer Albert Zugsmith and director Allison Anders, provide a multifaceted view of Sirk’s work and influence. The emotional depth and poignant recollections serve as a testament to Sirk's contribution to cinema. Patricia White's insightful interview further enriches the collection by dissecting the film’s critical role in family melodrama and its thematic resonance. The package also includes a vintage theatrical trailer that captures the raw essence of the film, and a leaflet featuring an essay by Blair McClendon.
Extras included in this disc:
- Acting for Douglas Sirk: Archival interviews and discussion on Sirk’s films.
- Patricia White: A scholarly analysis of the film's melodramatic aspects.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original preview encapsulating the film’s intense drama.
- Leaflet: Illustrated essay and technical credits by Blair McClendon.
Movie: 78
Douglas Sirk's "Written on the Wind" receives a vibrant presentation on Blu-ray, highlighting its melodramatic flair and intricate storytelling. This film explores the volatile dynamics of the Hadley family, a powerful Texas oil dynasty, navigating pressing themes like wealth, power, and self-destruction. With vivid Technicolor cinematography by Russell Metty, Sirk skillfully juxtaposes the opulence of the Hadley empire against their moral decay, creating a striking visual narrative that remains timeless. The film's lush production design emphasizes its melodramatic roots, while its over-the-top performances remain impactful and resonant.
The narrative structure is driven by a compelling blend of dramatic tension and character complexity. Robert Stack's portrayal of the tormented Kyle Hadley stands out, capturing the essence of a wealthy heir besieged by personal demons. His sister Marylee, played by Dorothy Malone, adds a layer of scandalous intrigue with a performance that deservedly secured her an Oscar. Rock Hudson's Mitch Wayne embodies stability amidst chaos, offering a subtle yet crucial presence, while Lauren Bacall as Lucy Moore brings grace to the tumultuous proceedings. These characters navigate a labyrinth of emotional conflicts, exploring themes such as impotence, jealousy, and unfulfilled desires.
"Written on the Wind" undeniably pushes melodrama to its heights, delivering shocking revelations and dramatized excess that characterize Sirk's directorial style. His approach to storytelling offers both satirical humor and unflinching examination of societal norms, often critiquing the superficiality of affluence and influence. The film resonates through its exploration of human frailties, as characters grapple with their desires and consequences therein. A masterpiece of 1950s cinema, it reflects on its era’s societal taboos with a boldness that continues to engage audiences today.
Total: 81
Douglas Sirk’s Written on the Wind is an exemplary slice of 1950s melodrama that encapsulates the era's heightened emotions and grand narratives. The film artfully dissects the tumultuous lives of a wealthy, dysfunctional family, drawing viewers into a world rife with passion, conflict, and intrigue. The performances from Rock Hudson, Lauren Bacall, Robert Stack, and Dorothy Malone are thoroughly captivating, each actor seamlessly embodying the intricate layers of their characters. Hudson and Bacall deliver classically understated performances, while Stack and Malone command attention with their more volatile roles.
Criterion’s Blu-ray release of Written on the Wind serves as a masterful homage to Douglas Sirk’s compelling vision. Sourced from an exclusive 2K master, the transfer brings out the lush vibrancy of Russell Metty's Technicolor cinematography, highlighting every detail in exquisite clarity. The audio is crisp, enhancing the film’s dramatic soundtrack and dialogue. Furthermore, the release includes valuable supplements such as archival interviews with Sirk, Hudson, Malone, and Stack, providing insightful commentary on the film’s creation and legacy.
In conclusion, Written on the Wind transcends its status as a melodrama to offer a rich exploration of human imperfection and societal excess. This Criterion release elevates the viewing experience with its superior visual and audio quality. Anyone interested in cinematic history or storytelling through melodrama will find this Blu-ray an essential addition to their collection. Highly recommended for both newcomers and connoisseurs alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
Some of the darker interior footage in particular looks much, much better on the Blu-ray and reveals ranges of smaller nuances that are either awfully difficult or impossible to recognize on the DVD....
Audio: 90
It is hard to tell if this effect is an inherited limitation or something that was introduced during the restoration process, but I had to turn up the volume of my system slightly more than usual just...
Extras: 60
Acting for Douglas Sirk - this archival program takes a closer look at two classic films directed by Douglas Sirk, Written on the Wind and The Tarnished Angels....
Movie: 90
At the end Sirk also gives its characters a chance to fully redeem themselves by blaming their misery on true love and this ultimately makes it look like Written on the Wind was always meant to be a lighter...
Total: 90
I think that Written on the Wind is a spectacular, often breathtakingly beautiful film whose stars are at the top of their game....
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 95
The presentation has excellent clarity and a great deal of detail, including individual strands of hair, pores in skin, and stubble on men’s faces....
Audio: 95
Dialogue is clear and crisp throughout, though Robert Stack’s Kyle often slurs his speech to suggest inebriation....
Extras: 75
The 2008 featurette Acting for Douglas Sirk discusses two of the director’s films, Written on the Wind and The Tarnished Angels....
Movie: 70
Its critical fortunes have improved through the years as director Douglas Sirk has been rediscovered and re-evaluated by modern reviewers who have given his 1950s pictures more scrutiny....
Total: 84
Director Sirk has filled every moment of the film with simmering tension, from Kyle’s initial appearance trying to seduce Lucy in their first meeting to the alcoholic stupor of his downfall....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Details like blowing leaves, costume and upholstery textures, wallpaper patterns, gleaming jewelry, the artwork and bumpers of a pinball machine, and faint wisps of swirling cigarette smoke are all crisply...
Audio: 80
A wide dynamic scale handles all of the blaring brass and crackling percussion of that sultry selection, as well as the strings of Frank Skinner’s music score, without a hint of distortion, and sonic accents...
Extras: 40
She analyzes the movie within its melodramatic context, citing the violent emotion and dark secrets that drive the plot, and examines playwright Berthold Brecht’s profound influence on Sirk in this intelligent...
Movie: 80
A slight relaxation of the Motion Picture Production Code allowed Sirk to examine once taboo topics with a modicum of frankness, and his exposés of the hypocrisy, dirty secrets, judgmental attitudes, and...
Total: 80
A celebration of melodrama and all the turbulent emotions, tangled relationships, and irrational actions that define it, Written on the Wind stands as one of Douglas Sirk's finest and most iconic motion...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 100
Universal has struck a new 2K transfer from the original camera negative resulting in a pristine image with the garish (but always controlled) hues typical of several of Douglas Sirk’s lurid 1950’s melodramas....
Audio: 100
Dialogue has been wonderfully recorded and has been mixed quite professionally into a single track with Frank Skinner’s lush background score (and with the Oscar-nominated title tune by Victor Young and...
Extras: 70
Acting for Douglas Sirk (23:23, HD): a 2008 documentary featuring director Allison Anders and vintage interviews with Dorothy Malone, Robert Stack, Rock Hudson, producer Alfred Zugsmith, and director Douglas...
Movie: 80
But the two Hadley children get the juiciest parts (and caught the Academy’s attention in the process): Robert Stack as the fabulously wealthy, handsome, but dissolute Kyle earned an Oscar nomination for...
Total: 80
Douglas Sirk’s Written on the Wind is the quintessential 1950’s melodrama with big stars, big emotions, and an overriding sense of doom that hangs over its pulsating narrative....
Director: Douglas Sirk
Actors: Rock Hudson, Lauren Bacall, Robert Stack
PlotA wealthy Texas oil family becomes tangled in a web of jealousy, desire, and self-destruction. Mitch Wayne, a stable and honorable geologist, finds himself caught between his lifelong friendship with the troubled scion of the family, Kyle Hadley, and his romantic feelings for Lucy Moore, Kyle's wife. Kyle, battling his own demons and insecurities amplified by an inherited fortune and a drinking problem, lives under the shadow of his powerful father. The family's decadent lifestyle and Kyle's reckless behavior strain his relationship with Lucy. Meanwhile, Marylee Hadley, Kyle's scheming sister, harbors unrequited love for Mitch, further complicating the family dynamics.
As Kyle's paranoia and emotional instability deepen, tensions in the household escalate. All family members must face the consequences of their choices, confronting feelings of inadequacy and betrayal. Lucy, who initially finds solace in Mitch's calm demeanor, struggles between her loyalty to Kyle and her growing bond with Mitch. The charged atmosphere reveals the destructive forces of wealth and passion. As secrets surface and the intensity heightens, each character must navigate personal rivalries and hidden desires. In this domestic tempest, questions about love's redemptive power and the clash between personal desires and familial duty rise to the forefront, setting all characters on a path poised to unearth deep-seated truths about loyalty and integrity.
Writers: George Zuckerman, Robert Wilder
Release Date: 25 Dec 1956
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English