The Midnight Meat Train Blu-ray Review
Score: 64
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
High-end home theater setup meets gory horror 'The Midnight Meat Train' acclaim.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 62
Lionsgate's Blu-ray transfer of 'The Midnight Meat Train' impressively balances high contrast, vivid colors, and detailed grit, despite some grain inconsistencies.
Audio: 67
Lionsgate's 'The Midnight Meat Train' Blu-ray delivers an impeccable 7.1 DTS-HD MA audio, mastering distinct, rich sounds across scenes with profound bass and clarity, making every detail immersive.
Extra: 58
The US BD of 'The Midnight Meat Train' offers rich extras including a candid commentary by Clive Barker and Ryûhei Kitamura, exploring film-making challenges and Barker's horror mythology, alongside featurettes on art and special effects, complemented by other Lionsgate previews.
Movie: 73
The Midnight Meat Train delightfully blends intense gore, suspenseful horror, and compelling performances into a vivid, nightmarish thrill ride with standout visuals and sound, despite minor flaws.
Video: 62
Lionsgate's Blu-ray release of "The Midnight Meat Train" presents the film in a 1080p, AVC MPEG-4 encoded transfer that meticulously captures its deliberately stark and chilling aesthetic. With a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, viewers are treated to an expansive canvas that brings the film's contrasting environments to life—from the icy, steel-colored confines of the subway to the warmer, albeit grimy locales, such as alleyways lit by streams of hazy light. The film’s visual style, defined by high contrast levels and a distinctive silver/chrome sheen, is excellently preserved. Grain is prevalent, lending a gritty texture that complements the narrative's tone, although it spikes in certain darker scenes, sometimes bordering on excessive noise in areas with subdued lighting or against uniform backgrounds.
The video quality of this release showcases fine details with impressive clarity, from the nuanced textures of human skin to the visceral gore of the film’s more gruesome scenes. Colors are handled with precision; the starkly muted color palette of greys and steels is punctuated by vivid reds of blood, creating a visually stunning contrast that underscores the film’s brutal elements without overshadowing finer details. Black levels are solid and deep, enhancing night scenes and dark interior spaces without loss of detail within the shadows. However, some minor issues include instances of edge enhancement and inconsistencies in grain texture, which distract but do not significantly detract from the overall high-quality transfer.
Despite these minor shortcomings, the Blu-ray's video presentation remains a testament to the film's grim and stylized vision. The attention to detail in both the colder, more desolate scenes aboard the train and the warmer yet equally forbidding urban environments outside it contributes to a deeply immersive viewing experience. The choice to retain a certain level of film grain and the carefully balanced color grading work together to maintain the director's original artistic intent, making "The Midnight Meat Train" a visually impactful journey for fans and newcomers alike.
Audio: 67
Lionsgate delivers yet another impressive audio experience with "The Midnight Meat Train" Blu-ray, featuring an enveloping DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 lossless soundtrack. This meticulously designed soundscape offers a dynamic range from the thunderous roar of the train to the visceral impact of blows, punctuated by a deeply resonant LFE channel that makes every scene throb with intensity. The soundstage is richly layered, allowing for an immersive experience where the meticulous detail in sound effects enhances the overall realism. The mix balances action sequences with quieter moments flawlessly, ensuring that dialogue remains crisp and clear amidst the chaos, and the film’s score is perfectly integrated, varying from ambient to aggressive as required by the scene.
Technical excellence in sound design provides a consistent sense of presence aboard the train, with the soundtrack making full use of the 7.1 channels to create a convincingly immersive environment. Sound effects are intricately woven into the mix, creating a textured auditory experience that engages listeners directly, placing them at the heart of the action. This includes well-crafted ambient sounds that contribute to the setting's atmosphere, whether it be the eerie silence of a massive meat freezer or the lively background of a street scene. The bass is potent without overwhelming, adding depth to every thud and crash without compromising on clarity.
Lionsgate's dedication shines through in the balanced and harmonious sound mix, which excels in creating an engaging listening experience that complements the visuals without overshadowing them. Every aspect, from the subtlest ambient noise to the most jarring sound effect, is given its due, ensuring that viewers are not just watching but feeling every moment. The rear speakers come alive with activity, seamlessly integrating with the front channels to produce a showy but refined surround sound that elevates each scene. With its exemplary audio presentation, "The Midnight Meat Train" Blu-ray proves once again that Lionsgate is committed to delivering high-quality home entertainment experiences.
Extras: 58
The Blu-ray extras for "The Midnight Meat Train" offer a comprehensive and insightful look into the making of the film, headlined by a revealing audio commentary with Clive Barker and Director Ryûhei Kitamura. This duo delves deep into the genesis and development of the film, sharing candid thoughts on the adaptation process, studio interventions, and the differences between the director's cut and the theatrical release. Complementing this are several featurettes including a profile on Clive Barker that explores his influence on modern horror and his passion for painting, a closer examination of the character Mahogany through cast and crew insights, and a detailed breakdown of one of the film's most brutally iconic murder scenes. Additionally, the disc boasts a selection of high-definition trailers for other Lionsgate horror films, rounding out an extras package that is as informative as it is enthralling for fans.
Extras included in this disc:
Audio Commentary with Clive Barker & Director Ryuhei Kitamura: An honest and informative track that goes beyond the typical scene-by-scene commentary to explore the film's backstory, adaptation challenges, and more.
Clive Barker: The Man Behind the Myth: A documentary that splits its focus between Barker's seminal influence on horror literature and his compelling work as a painter.
Mahogany’s Tale: A featurette offering insights into the film's antagonist, with input from the actors and production team.
Anatomy of a Murder Scene: A behind-the-scenes look at crafting one of the movie's goriest sequences, detailing everything from makeup effects to filming techniques.
HD Theatrical Trailer & LionsGate Previews: High-definition trailers for "The Midnight Meat Train" and a selection of other Lionsgate horror titles, showcasing the studio's range in genre filmmaking.
Movie: 73
"The Midnight Meat Train" presents itself as a visceral odyssey into the heart of urban horror, marrying Clive Barker's knack for the macabre with Ryûhei Kitamura's sleek direction to deliver a film that transcends typical genre expectations. Despite its roots in Barker's short story, the adaptation sprawls expansively into the realm of cinematic gore and suspense, anchored by powerful performances, especially from Vinnie Jones as the enigmatic assassin Mahogany. The film's narrative thrust, driven by struggling photographer Leon's (Bradley Cooper) descent into darkness as he pursues the perfect subject, interweaves a chilling critique of artistic obsession with urban legend to create a compellingly grimy tapestry of fear.
Technically, "The Midnight Meat Train" is a feast for genre aficionados, striking a delicate balance between stylized violence and psychological terror. Kitamura's decision to favor elongated, uninterrupted shots adds a layer of aesthetic grace to the carnage, creating a viewer experience that is as artistically engaging as it is horrifying. This approach, coupled with judicious use of CGI and practical effects, crafts memorable scenes that linger long after the film ends. Notably, the special effects, while occasionally leaning on CGI, mostly utilize practical methods to profound and gruesome effect, enhancing the film's tactile realism and augmenting its underlying sense of dread.
At its core, the performances breathe life into the nightmare. Jones delivers a tour-de-force as Mahogany, embodying a silent yet profoundly terrifying presence that ranks among horror cinema's most memorable antagonists. Cooper and Bibb provide the emotional grounding necessary to invest in their spiral into darkness, while Shields offers an intriguing counterpoint as the imperious art curator. The ensemble's efforts are crucial in realizing the film's thematic explorations of voyeurism, ambition, and human depravity. Yet, it’s the film’s refusal to shirk from the visceral realities of its titular massacre that solidifies its place as a standout in modern horror, noting it as much an introspective journey into obsession as it is a relentless bloodbath on rails.
Total: 64
"The Midnight Meat Train," presented on Blu-ray, revitalizes the horror genre with its visceral thrills and a standout performance by Vinnie Jones as one of the most compelling horror villains in recent memory. The film, rich in barbarity and relentless gore, satisfies the hunger of hardcore horror aficionados craving for substance over mere shock value. Its technical execution on home media is nothing short of exemplary. With equipment such as the JVC DLA-RS20 1080p High Definition Front Projector and Oppo 970HD universal disc DVD Player, among others, the film's gritty aesthetics and chilling audio are showcased in unparalleled clarity, providing an immersive viewing experience that's destined to leave a lasting impression. Lionsgate's production values shine, particularly in the audio and video presentation, even if the extras package might seem underwhelming in quantity but not in quality.
Despite behind-the-scenes distribution challenges, including a limited theatrical release, "The Midnight Meat Train" emerges as a must-watch for horror enthusiasts. The Blu-ray version benefits greatly from its high-quality audio setup, including gear like the Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor and Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player, which amplifies the film's suspenseful atmosphere and intense violence. Furthermore, the inclusion of insightful extras adds to the overall package, offering a deeper appreciation for the film's craftsmanship.
In conclusion, "The Midnight Meat Train" Blu-ray is a top-tier addition to any horror fan's collection, marked by its stellar technical presentation and a riveting narrative that breathes new life into the genre. Vinnie Jones delivers a memorable performance that anchors the film's savage elegance, making it an essential piece for those captivated by the darker facets of cinematic storytelling. Coupled with strong support from Lionsgate, despite initial distribution hiccups, this release is a testament to the enduring appeal of meticulously crafted horror cinema.
avforums review by Chris McEneanyRead review here
Video: 80
Wounds are crystal clear, except for the moment when Mahogany is deftly, clinically removing a victim's eyeballs, when the image then seems to bathe some of the proceedings in vague shadow....
Audio: 90
Dialogue is clear and warm, as is the score - which can be ambient, aggressive or rich depending on the scene - and the track also benefits from terrific seamless panning right around the environment....
Extras: 70
Always a tremendous raconteur, Barker, with that incredibly husky rasp of his, expands on the mythology of Mahogany and his brethren and how the movie differs from the source story....
Movie: 80
The commentary is excellent and very candid, the featurettes are a mixed-bag of EPK fun and bizarre Barker insight but, overall, the package is a strong one that I can recommend to fans of the genre, wholeheartedly....
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The film's primary set, the interior of the train, is given a cold, steely look, with grays and blacks and blues the predominant hues inside, with, of course, plenty of red blood splattered all over the...
Audio: 80
This is a dynamic soundtrack with effects that swoop across the soundstage, particularly during the scenes featuring the train roaring down the tracks....
Extras: 60
Clive Barker: The Man Behind the Myth (480p, 14:54) is a nice piece that features the famed Horror author discussing the original work in the first volume of his Books of Blood and goes on to speak about...
Movie: 80
One scene in particular, featuring a victim's eyes shooting from their sockets towards the camera in slow-motion after a smack to the back of the head, comes off as slightly less impressive than would...
Total: 80
The disc is a bit light in extras from a quantity standpoint, but certainly not in quality; however, the movie and the technical specs are enough to put the disc over the top....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
However other times, for example particularly in Leon’s darkened apartment, the picture often pulsates with a cloud of mosquito noise that’s so thick I could’ve used Mahogany’s meat hook to slice through...
Audio: 80
‘The Midnight Meat Train’ isn’t what I would call a dialog-heavy film, as Cooper’s character is often off on his own doing his photographer thing (not to mention Jones hardly had any lines to memorize),...
Extras: 60
The featurette covers everything from its evolution from storyboards, the traditional make-up and CGI effects involved, as well as the stunts and filming techniques that brought the scene to life....
Movie: 80
The explicit eyeball sequence may have been a little over-the-top, but the fact is it’s still innovative and brings something fresh to the table....
Total: 60
It’s really disturbing hearing how ‘The Midnight Meat Train’ was given the shaft by Lionsgate for no real reason whatsoever, but from what I hear, at least the film had a proper release in Mexico thanks...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
Deep defining blacks and revealing details in low lit backgrounds and shadows provide excellent depth and gradational highlights to the film’s pervading darkened sequences....
Audio: 90
This is sophisticated sound design that incorporates a vast number of sound effects that are intricately mixed to engage the listening position....
Extras: 50
Audio commentary with Clive Barker & Director Ryuhei Kitmaro Clive Barker: The man behind the myth – 15 minute documentary Mahogany’s tale – 5 minute featurette Anatomy of a murder scene – 9 minute special...
Movie: 60
Believing he’s finally on track for success, Leon’s obsessive pursuit of dark subject matter leads him into the path of Mahogany (Jones), the subway serial killer who stalks late night commuters, butchering...
Total: 73
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton...
Director: Ryûhei Kitamura
Actors: Vinnie Jones, Bradley Cooper, Leslie Bibb
PlotLeon, an ambitious photographer in search of the real city at night, becomes obsessed with exposing the darker side of urban life. His quest for raw, edgy material leads him to explore the subway system after dark, where he encounters a series of unsettling occurrences and mysterious disappearances. Striving to capture the ultimate photograph and propelled by a mixture of curiosity and bravado, Leon delves deeper into the underbelly of the city's nocturnal world. His girlfriend, Maya, is increasingly worried about the dangers of his night-time expeditions but cannot deter him from his path.
Leon's obsession grows as he stumbles upon a sinister figure who appears to be responsible for the disappearances on the subway—a silent, menacing butcher who rides the last train of the night. Despite warnings from a concerned subway worker and Maya's pleas, Leon's determination to expose the truth about the subway's dark secret drives him into a perilous investigation. As he gets closer to unveiling the mystery, Leon finds himself entangled in a terrifying reality that blurs the lines between hunter and prey, challenging his understanding of justice and pushing him to the edge of survival.
Writers: Jeff Buhler, Clive Barker
Release Date: 31 Oct 2008
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, United Kingdom
Language: English