Dinner at Eight Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 74
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Dinner at Eight dazzles with a stellar cast and Warner Archive's exceptional 4K transfer, offering a must-see classic in pristine quality. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
Dinner at Eight dazzles on Blu-ray with a crisp 1080p presentation, sourced from a meticulous 4K scan, delivering exceptional clarity, contrast, and authentic grain. Detailed sets and costumes come alive in the 1.37:1 aspect ratio, with minimal blemishes, showcasing a pristinely restored cinematic gem.
Audio: 80
Dinner at Eight's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix delivers a pristine yet straightforward audio experience, free of age-related defects like hiss and crackle, with clean dialogue. While lacking directional sound, it impressively balances minimal effects and sparse music within a controlled and engaging soundscape.
Extra: 43
The Blu-ray extras for 'Dinner at Eight' feature a compelling 1993 documentary, 'Harlow: The Blonde Bombshell,' hosted by Sharon Stone, offering in-depth insights into Jean Harlow's captivating life and turbulent marriages. Also included is the entertaining 1933 satire 'Come to Dinner,' a sharp parody with talented impersonators, complemented by the original theatrical trailer.
Movie: 80
"Dinner at Eight" brilliantly merges melodrama and social satire, driven by unforgettable performances and George Cukor's deft direction, while Warner Archive's Blu-ray release impresses with a stunning 1080p restoration and exemplary DTS-HD Master Audio, solidifying it as essential pre-code cinema.
Video: 83
The Blu-ray release of "Dinner at Eight" by Warner Archive offers a commendable visual experience, grounded in a 1080p restoration derived from a meticulous 4K scan. This process captures the film's nitrate origins with remarkable detail, thanks to a thoughtful combination of multiple sources, although specific elements remain unspecified. The video quality shines through with minor blemishes, maintaining authenticity with minimal processing interference. The image radiates a purist-friendly vibe, featuring clear and natural fine grain visible across various shot compositions. While trace instances of posterization appear on darker shades, overall, the performance on this dual-layered disc meets high expectations. Occasional softness can be attributed to diversified source materials, yet these minor issues do not detract significantly from the nearly flawless depiction of this classic.
The masterful restoration replaces the aging 2005 DVD transfer with vibrant clarity and balanced contrast, bringing out deeper blacks and enhanced grayscale. All speckles and past imperfections have been erased, delivering a clean and crisp image that surpasses prior releases. Costumes and ornate set pieces are detailed sharply, reflecting precise costume textures and intricate decor within the opulent interiors. Key performances, from Jean Harlow's immaculate complexion to Lionel Barrymore’s distinctive pallor, are accentuated by enhanced close-up details. Despite reduced grain, enough remains to preserve its authentic celluloid essence.
Adhering faithfully to its original 1.37:1 aspect ratio, this modern transfer takes advantage of the AVC codec to deliver a sharp and richly detailed viewing journey through black-and-white splendor. Contrast has been adeptly managed to produce an enticing visual landscape devoid of age-related deterioration such as scratches or dirt. Divided into 27 chapters, Warner Archive’s presentation is a polished upgrade deserving of praise from enthusiasts and newcomers alike to this iconic 1930s cinematic jewel.
Audio: 80
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track on the Blu-ray release of "Dinner at Eight" effectively captures the essence of this classic film, enhancing the viewing experience with an impeccable audio presentation. True to its era, this mix is devoid of age-related anomalies such as hiss, crackle, or pops, creating a clear and distortion-free soundscape. The dialogue-driven nature of the film is preserved with expert clarity, ensuring that every quip and pointed remark is easily comprehensible. The reserved sound track maintains focus, with limited but rich music and effects that handle dynamic fluctuations effortlessly, enhancing the storytelling without overwhelming it.
While the audio mix isn't intended to deliver an expansive sonic spectacle, it succeeds in maintaining a well-controlled sound field that complements the film's 1080p visual transfer. Dialogue remains central, clean, and crisp, with occasional depth achieved in high-ceilinged or large interior scenes. The audio mix provides a subtle contrast in more confined settings, contributing to a varied yet consistently effective sonic experience. Notably, optional English (SDH) subtitles are available only during the film, which might disappoint those expecting subtitle support similar to earlier home video releases for extras.
Overall, this release's audio track superbly handles the film's needs, allowing viewers to remain engrossed in the narrative while appreciating the quality of this preservation effort. The audio restoration elevates "Dinner at Eight", aligning it with current standards and offering an enriching experience for both new viewers and long-time fans of classic cinema.
Extras: 43
This Blu-ray edition of "Dinner at Eight" offers a commendable collection of extras sourced from previous home video releases, providing both historic insights and entertainment. Key among the extras is the documentary "Harlow: The Blonde Bombshell," hosted by Sharon Stone, which delves deeply into Jean Harlow's life and career. It balances myth-busting with engaging storytelling, exploring her private life's tragedies and iconic Hollywood roles. Fans will appreciate the documentary's warm yet incisive approach to the star's biography. Accompanying this is the whimsical "Come to Dinner," a 1933 parody featuring talented impersonators poking fun at the original film's stars and plot in an amusing manner. This parody exemplifies the era's competitive studio culture with its sharp wit. Rounding out the selection is the original theatrical trailer, a nostalgic promotional piece.
Extras included in this disc:
- Harlow: The Blonde Bombshell: Documentary exploring Jean Harlow's life and career.
- Come to Dinner: 1933 satirical short parodying "Dinner at Eight."
- Theatrical Trailer: Original film preview.
Movie: 80
George Cukor's 1933 film, "Dinner at Eight," is a remarkable example of pre-code cinema that masterfully intertwines melodrama and social satire. This adaptation of the George S. Kaufman-Edna Ferber Broadway hit features an all-star ensemble, including Marie Dressler, John Barrymore, Wallace Beery, Jean Harlow, and Lionel Barrymore. These icons deliver captivating performances that play out against the backdrop of a high-society dinner thrown by Millicent Jordan (Billie Burke) and her husband, Oliver (Lionel Barrymore). The dinner party guests’ intersecting personal tragedies create a rich tapestry of farcical drama and biting humor. The film's portrayal of unraveling social elites amid the Great Depression resonates through its darkly comedic critique of vanity and ambition.
At the heart of "Dinner at Eight" is Marie Dressler's unforgettable performance as Carlotta Vance, an eccentric retired actress whose facial expressions and dialogue deliver both comedic and heartfelt moments. Her interplay with Jean Harlow's Kitty Packard—defined by acid humor—adds to the film's charm. Harlow's portrayal of the ambitious, vulgar Kitty and her exchanges with Wallace Beery, who plays her domineering husband, inject a crudeness that contrasts deliciously with the film's otherwise elegant setting. John Barrymore delivers a standout, poignant performance as Larry Renault, whose decline eerily mirrors his own life's trajectory.
Cinematographically, "Dinner at Eight" might seem straightforward, as George Cukor smartly employs a static camera that captures every nuanced expression and exchange with stage-like precision. Though the narrative may reflect its era, the strength lies in its performances. This production remains a testament to Cukor's directorial prowess and the cast's formidable talents. The Blu-ray release is noteworthy for its impeccable 1080p restoration and DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono soundtrack, preserving the film's legacy with impeccable clarity, akin to savoring a finely aged cinematic classic.
Total: 74
George Cukor's "Dinner at Eight" stands as a quintessential example of pre-code Hollywood cinema, showcasing an ensemble of legendary talents delivering a memorable comedy-drama. Despite its slightly overextended runtime, the film's sharp dialogue and unrestrained thematic approach resonate strongly, offering more emotional depth than many of its successors impacted by the Hays Code. Warner Archive's Blu-ray release excels previous editions, presenting the film with a breathtaking 4K-sourced transfer that revitalizes its visual allure, coupled with pristine lossless audio. Accompanying this remarkable restoration are all the cherished DVD-era bonus features.
In this visually rich Blu-ray edition, viewers are treated to a cinematic banquet starring luminaries such as Dressler, Beery, Harlow, and the Barrymores, whose captivating performances exemplify Hollywood's Golden Age. The meticulous restoration by Warner Archive enrobes the film in an added layer of splendor, making it an essential addition to any classic film aficionado's collection. This edition not only preserves but enhances the charm and spectacle of "Dinner at Eight," further solidifying its status as a timeless treasure.
In conclusion, Warner Archive has crafted an exceptional Blu-ray package that is both a technical triumph and a celebration of cinematic history. "Dinner at Eight" in its newly restored form is a visual and auditory feast that continues to delight and inspire admiration for its enduring brilliance. Whether you are revisiting this beloved classic or experiencing it for the first time, this Blu-ray edition offers an unparalleled viewing experience. Highly recommended for collectors and enthusiasts of classic cinema.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
It's a remarkably pure image that only suffers from trace amounts of posterization on some of the darkest black and most complex gradients but, for the most part, runs flawlessly on this dual-layered disc....
Audio: 80
Although its mostly reserved DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio mix isn't designed to be a sonic spectacle, Dinner at Eight's lossless audio track nonetheless impresses with a tightly-controlled sound field that,...
Extras: 50
Harlow: The Blonde Bombshell (47:01) - This 1993 Turner Pictures documentary, hosted by Sharon Stone and directed by Tom McQuade, takes a look at the life and career of silver screen queen Jean Harlow...
Movie: 80
Essentially, this nearly two-hour production centers around a high-society dinner party that almost never happens... much to the dismay of New York City matron Millicent Jordan (Billie Burke, The Wizard...
Total: 80
It's been a perennial favorite of classic film fans and has enjoyed several good-to-great home video releases over the years, but Warner Archive's Blu-ray easily tops them all with a stunning new 4K-sourced...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
All of the speckling, occasional white blotches, and faint scratches that plagued the DVD have been meticulously erased, leaving a clean, vibrant, beautifully balanced image that sports excellent clarity...
Audio: 80
There are no exterior scenes in the film, so effects are minimal, and the characters' largely dignified decorum keeps things quiet indoors, too (except during Harlow and Beery's screaming matches)....
Extras: 40
With style, warmth, and insight, the documentary covers Harlow's three tumultuous marriages, including the shocking suicide of her second husband, MGM executive Paul Bern; her blockbuster debut in Howard...
Movie: 80
Her priceless facial expressions steal every scene in which she appears, and though she grabs the lion’s share of laughs (including the flat-out guffaws that always follow her immortal final remark — one...
Total: 80
Stargazing has never been so much fun, as Dressler, Beery, Harlow, the Barrymores, and the rest of the MGM gang put the gold in Hollywood's Golden Age....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 100
The image is sharp as a tack, all the better to see the lush, detailed sets and Adrian costumes in all of their black and white glory....
Audio: 100
Dialogue has been recorded expertly and has been mixed with William Axt’s background music and the various sound effects for a first-rate listening experience....
Extras: 50
Harlow: The Blonde Bombshell (47:01, SD): excellent overview of the life and career of Jean Harlow hosted by Sharon Stone....
Movie: 90
Jordan’s fluttery wife (Billie Burke) is anxious to score society points by inviting some of New York’s finest including one-time matinee idol Larry Renault (John Barrymore) for a Friday night dinner at...
Total: 90
George Cukor’s Dinner at Eight is one of those classic comedy-dramas that most everyone has seen clips from even if he hasn’t seen the entire film, but one owes it to himself to experience the entire delightful...
Director: George Cukor
Actors: Marie Dressler, John Barrymore, Wallace Beery
PlotSocialite Millicent Jordan is eagerly preparing for a high-profile dinner party intended to impress an English aristocrat and advance her husband Oliver’s struggling shipping business. However, a series of personal dramas unfold as each invited guest grapples with their own issues. Oliver is stressed about saving his failing business and dealing with an unscrupulous businessman, Dan Packard. Meanwhile, Carlotta Vance, a former star now financially ruined, seeks to sell her stock in Oliver’s company, adding to his woes. Packard's young wife Kitty attempts to mask her lack of social grace and harbors a secretively lascivious affair, exacerbating tensions further.
As preparations progress, personal and professional turmoils cascade through the invited guests' lives. Dr. Wayne Talbot juggles his medical practice while maintaining an extramarital affair, unaware his wife is closing in on the truth. Millicent and Oliver's daughter Paula is embroiled in her own heartache after discovering her fiancé, Ernest DeGraff, is having a romance with another woman—a famed actor nearing ruin named Larry Renault. The varied tensions and intersecting storylines meld as characters, each dealing with personal crises and hidden motives, converge under the pretense of an elegantly planned dinner that quickly becomes anything but serene. The dinner party is set to begin, carrying the weight of tenuous relationships and unspoken truths that threaten to unravel in full view.
Writers: Frances Marion, Herman J. Mankiewicz, George S. Kaufman
Release Date: 12 Jan 1934
Runtime: 111 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English