Madame Bovary Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 80
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Madame Bovary's 1949 adaptation by Minnelli, complete with striking production design, strong performances, and a superb Blu-ray presentation, is highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 90
Warner Archive's 1080p Blu-ray of 'Madame Bovary,' sourced from a recent 4K scan, offers a stunning visual presentation with lush, inky blacks, stable whites, and gorgeously graded grays. The meticulous transfer, free from compression artifacts or imperfections, beautifully showcases the film's art direction and cinematography.
Audio: 84
The DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio mix delivers a clean, crisp, and dynamic presentation, effectively balancing dialogue, ambient sounds, and Miklós Rózsa's grand score, with superior fidelity and tonal depth ensuring an immersive audio experience free of age-related artifacts.
Extra: 55
These Blu-Ray extras, including a 1949 MGM studio retrospective hosted by Lionel Barrymore, a delightful Tom and Jerry cartoon, and the vintage theatrical trailer, offer a well-rounded package that will appeal to classic cinema enthusiasts with their rich historical content and visually solid HD presentation.
Movie: 77
Vincente Minnelli's 1949 adaptation of 'Madame Bovary', starring Jennifer Jones, is a visually captivating re-telling that balances fidelity to Flaubert’s controversial novel with the constraints of the Hays Code. The Warner Archive Blu-ray presents a superb 1080p restoration complemented by Robert H. Planck's lush cinematography and Miklós Rózsa's acclaimed score.
Video: 90
Warner Archive's video presentation of Madame Bovary is nothing short of stunning, showcasing an impeccable 1080p transfer sourced from a recent 4K scan of the best-available preservation elements. The cinematography by Robert H. Planck beautifully supports MGM’s production and costume design, revealing a rich array of silvery grays, bright whites, and deep blacks with substantial levels of film grain. The fine detail is consistent and stable throughout, with no compression artifacts or other anomalies, making the film's visual authenticity and artistry stand out remarkably.
Presented in its original Academy aspect ratio of 1.37:1, the transfer excels in highlighting the intricate details of Emma Bovary’s gowns and the opulent interior settings crafted by art directors Cedric Gibbons and Jack Martin Smith. The high-clarity AVC MPEG-4 encoding faithfully captures the sumptuous cinematography, offering a film-like image with lush blacks, stable whites, and gorgeously graded grays that maintain the natural grain structure. The transfer is pristine, free from dirt specks, scratches, or any form of visual imperfections.
The visual treatment accentuates the textures of costumes, wallpapers, upholstery, and other set decorations with striking precision. Razor-sharp close-ups vividly capture actor facial details, reinforcing the rich visual depth of the presentation. Overall, Warner Archive has delivered an exemplary and immersive viewing experience that honors the original artistry of Madame Bovary, ensuring it stands as a benchmark for high-definition transfers of classic cinema.
Audio: 84
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track for the Blu Ray of "Madame Bovary" delivers an exemplary auditory experience, presenting a clean and crisp split-channel adaptation of the original mono source. The restoration has meticulously eradicated any major age-related wear, ensuring dynamic range is not compromised. Dialogue is superbly clear and easy to follow, seamlessly integrated with ambient effects and the grand score by composer Miklós Rózsa, known for his work on films like Ben-Hur and Spellbound. This mix allows both dialogue and sound effects, such as horse hooves and shattering glass, to coexist without competition, enhancing the overall listening experience.
Sound effects are sharp and atmospheric elements, such as rain, provide a nuanced backdrop to the action. The high fidelity and tonal depth of the soundtrack ensure that Rózsa's sweeping score fills the room with grandiosity, particularly evident in scenes like the ballroom sequence where the blend of dialogue, crowd noise, and music is effectively balanced. The mix's superior dynamic scale highlights the highs and lows of the romantic and dramatic compositions without any distortion, enveloping the viewer in a robust and immersive soundscape. Additionally, optional English SDH subtitles are included during the main feature, ensuring accessibility without interrupting the viewing experience.
Extras: 55
The Blu-ray release of "Madame Bovary" offers an impressive collection of extras that delve deeply into MGM's storied history and provide light-hearted entertainment. The disc features a rich mid-length studio retrospective titled "Some of the Best," narrated by Lionel Barrymore. This documentary commemorates MGM's 25th anniversary and showcases iconic scenes from classic films such as "The Big Parade," "The Broadway Melody," "Mutiny on the Bounty," and "The Wizard of Oz." Additionally, it includes the Hanna-Barbera cartoon "Love That Pup," highlighting the antics of Tom and Jerry with the first appearance of Tyke. Completing the extras is the original theatrical trailer, offering nostalgic insights into the film's initial promotion. Overall, these supplementary materials are not only historically significant but also provide enjoyable viewing for classic cinema aficionados.
Extras included in this disc:
Some of the Best: Mid-length documentary celebrating MGM's 25-year anniversary with clips from classic films.
Love That Pup: An HD restoration of a 1949 Tom and Jerry cartoon featuring Spike and Tyke.
Theatrical Trailer: The original promotional preview of "Madame Bovary."
Movie: 77
Vincente Minnelli’s 1949 adaptation of Gustave Flaubert's controversial novel Madame Bovary embodies the challenges and rewards of transforming provocative literature into film during Hollywood's Golden Age. The screenplay by Robert Ardrey skillfully navigates the restrictive Hays Code, avoiding explicit details while preserving the narrative’s core dynamics through a framing device where James Mason portrays Flaubert defending his work. Jennifer Jones, cast as the titular Emma Bovary, delivers an engrossing performance that captures her character’s complex journey marked by unfulfilled desires and moral ambiguity. Though trimmed to 114 minutes, Minnelli’s direction and Ardrey’s script maintain the essence of Flaubert’s material, aided by Robert H. Planck's evocative cinematography and Miklós Rózsa’s lush score.
The film excel in translating Emma’s emotional and psychological turbulence to the screen. Minnelli leverages dynamic camera work and compelling set pieces, most notably in the ballroom sequence where Emma’s fleeting liberation is rendered through swirling cinematography and a crescendoing musical score, showcasing both Emma's euphoria and her husband's disconnection. This scene, among others, highlights Minnelli’s flair for infusing dramatic narratives with lyrical and visual finesse often reserved for his musical films. The supporting cast, including Van Heflin as the oblivious Charles and Louis Jourdan as Emma’s lover Rodolphe, complement Jones' portrayal by offering nuanced performances that underscore the film's themes of aspiration and betrayal.
Despite not being as celebrated as Minnelli’s more prominent works, Madame Bovary remains a poignant reflection on societal constraints and personal dissatisfaction. Its success is not merely due to its narrative faithfulness but also its cinematic execution, making it an enduring piece that combines sophisticated technical elements with profound storytelling. Warner Archive’s Blu-ray edition further elevates this classic through a meticulous restoration that enhances both the visual and auditory experience, ensuring that Madame Bovary continues to captivate modern audiences with its enduring relevance and artistic brilliance.
Total: 80
Vincente Minnelli's 1949 adaptation of Gustave Flaubert's "Madame Bovary" stands as an engaging, if somewhat subdued, take on the classic novel. Screenwriter Robert Ardrey crafts a narrative that navigates the constraints imposed by the Production Code, capturing the essence of Flaubert while softening some of the novel's more scandalous elements. The film benefits from robust performances from its leading trio—Jennifer Jones, Van Heflin, and Louis Jourdan—and is bolstered by MGM's trademark dedication to costume dramas. This production's art direction and set decoration, both Oscar-nominated, along with lush cinematography and a sumptuous musical score, contribute to a visually and aurally pleasing cinematic experience.
The Warner Archive Blu-ray release of "Madame Bovary" impresses with a high-caliber restoration that does justice to Minnelli's elegant direction. The HD master struck from a 4K scan of preservation elements results in stunning visual clarity, while the remastered audio allows audiences to appreciate the film's rich soundscape with renewed depth. Additionally, the Blu-ray includes a selection of vintage supplements that offer further insight into the production, enhancing the overall value of this release. This meticulous presentation serves to elevate the 1949 version of "Madame Bovary," which often does not receive the recognition it warrants.
In conclusion, Warner Archive's Blu-ray release of "Madame Bovary" is a commendable effort that breathes new life into a classic film adaptation. With its faithful yet tactful rendering of Flaubert's narrative, supported by strong performances and high production values, this edition is essential for aficionados of classic cinema and literary adaptations alike. Highly recommended for its impressive technical merits and comprehensive extras, this Blu-ray reaffirms "Madame Bovary" as a significant entry in the canon of literary adaptations.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
Not surprisingly, MGM's typically lavish production and costume design, not to mention the great visuals by cinematographer Robert H. Planck (who had already filmed another perpetual literary adaptation...
Audio: 90
As such, conversations sound clean and easy to follow, foreground and background effects are mixed well without fighting for attention, and there's more than enough room left over for the memorable original...
Extras: 60
Hosted by Lionel Barrymore with contributions by Lewis Stone, who worked for the studio before the merger that provided its long-standing name, the bulk of this piece features clips from such films as...
Movie: 70
This prevents Minnelii's film from being the definitive version it could (and probably should) have been... but luckily the production as a whole stays well above water thanks to clear fundamental strengths,...
Total: 70
That said, it gets by on solid production design and sturdy performances by its three top-billed stars, at least attempting to stand out from the ever-growing pile of film and TV versions....
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 95
The art direction by Cedric Gibbons and Jack Martin Smith is rich and luxurious in scenes that take place in the homes of wealthy individuals, typical of the MGM style of the period....
Audio: 95
Sound mixing is excellent, with dialogue, ambient crowd noise and music blending effectively, particularly in the ballroom scene....
Extras: 75
Lionel Barrymore narrates as scenes from The Merry Widow, Flesh and the Devil, Tell It to the Marines, Min and Bill, Trader Horn, Mutiny on the Bounty, San Francisco, The Wizard of Oz, The Good Earth,...
Movie: 90
Published the following year in book form, this work of literary realism is today regarded as Flaubert’s masterpiece....
Total: 89
With the Production Code still in full force, the script had to deftly deal with the novel’s more graphic content, but the film captures the essence of Flaubert, casting likable Jennifer Jones in order...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Lush, inky blacks, bright, stable whites, and gorgeously graded grays combine with excellent clarity and contrast to produce a stunning film-like image that keeps the natural grain structure intact....
Audio: 80
A wide dynamic scale embraces the sweeping highs and weighty lows of the romantic and melodramatic music without any distortion, while superior fidelity and tonal depth help the score fill the room with...
Extras: 40
The film also promos a number of upcoming 1949 MGM movies like Border Incident, The Red Danube, Edward My Son, The Secret Garden, Intruder in the Dust, Little Women, Take Me Out to the Ball Game, In the...
Movie: 80
Though Jones and the dashing Jourdan create palpable sexual chemistry, she and Heflin click in a more delicate, but equally effective manner that serves the film well....
Total: 80
Minnelli's elegant direction, top-notch performances from Jones, Heflin, Jourdan, and Mason, Oscar-nominated art direction and set decoration, lush cinematography, and a glorious musical score all combine...
Director: Vincente Minnelli
Actors: Jennifer Jones, James Mason, Van Heflin
PlotEmma, a farmer's daughter with dreams of a life of luxury, marries Charles, a simple and kind-hearted country doctor. Disappointed by her dull, provincial life and uninspired marriage, she yearns for romance and excitement. Her dissatisfaction deepens after attending a lavish ball, igniting her desire to escape the monotony of her existence. She convinces Charles to move to a more affluent village, hoping to find greater fulfillment there. However, her attempts to integrate into high society only lead to further disappointment, as she struggles with financial constraints and a stifling domestic routine.
Restless and seeking solace, Emma embarks on a series of illicit love affairs, believing they will provide the passion and thrill she craves. She becomes increasingly reckless in her pursuit of pleasure and luxury, engaging in deceit and financial recklessness that lead to mounting debts. As Emma's life spirals out of control, the toll on her and those around her becomes increasingly severe.
Writers: Robert Ardrey, Gustave Flaubert
Release Date: 23 Jan 1950
Runtime: 114 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English