Fafner: Heaven and Earth Blu-ray Review
蒼穹のファフナー Heaven and Earth
Score: 45
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Fafner: Heaven and Earth features compelling character arcs and solid audio, though it suffers from a sluggish pace, excessive technical jargon, and limited extras.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 34
The Blu-ray of 'Fafner: Heaven and Earth' features an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 1.78:1, marked by inconsistent image quality. While some scenes display vivid colors and strong detail thanks to the mix of CGI and hand-drawn animation, others suffer from softness and lack of definition, making the viewing experience uneven.
Audio: 69
Fafner: Heaven and Earth excels with its two Dolby TrueHD 5.1 mixes, offering expert voice work and immersive sound design, especially in battle scenes with clean dialogue and potent LFE. This stellar audio presentation surpasses the video quality, ensuring an engaging auditory experience.
Extra: 26
The Extras for the Blu Ray of 'Fafner: Heaven and Earth' are highlighted by a lively and engaging U.S. Commentary featuring Joel McDonald and Micah Solusod, who share behind-the-scenes anecdotes and discuss voice matching challenges in continuing the Fafner series. Additionally, viewers can enjoy a HD Commercial Collection and a Theatrical Trailer.
Movie: 41
"Fafner: Heaven and Earth," despite its emotional depth and impressive mix of CG and hand-drawn animation, often gets bogged down by excessive techno-babble and intricate references to its preceding series, potentially leaving newcomers confused, yet offering some satisfying resolutions for long-time fans.
Video: 34
"Fafner: Heaven and Earth" is delivered on Blu-ray by FUNimation Entertainment with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio. This high-definition presentation is somewhat inconsistent, akin to the varied quality of the narrative itself. The blend of CGI and traditional hand-drawn cel animation is striking at its best moments. CGI elements, especially the Festum and Fafner units, intermittently exhibit impressive detail and depth. However, they can also appear noticeably soft and poorly defined. Similarly, hand-drawn sequences alternate between vibrantly detailed and distressingly muted, lacking clear definition without a discernible pattern, suggesting an intentional choice by the animation team.
In scenes where the image quality excels, blacks are portrayed with commendable depth, colors are vivid, and the overall sharpness is notable. Motion appears smooth and detail is pronounced, providing a satisfying visual experience. Contrarily, the frequent lapses into softness result in a flattened image where intricate details become difficult to discern. This disparity occurs throughout the entire film, making it occasionally jarring and potentially distracting for the viewer. The unpredictability of the visual presentation detracts from what could otherwise be a more consistently immersive viewing experience.
Despite these inconsistencies, when the Blu-ray quality peaks, it delivers an engaging and visually appealing spectacle. Nonetheless, the shift between high-detail, vibrant scenes to softer, less defined moments prevents "Fafner: Heaven and Earth" from attaining the level of visual polish expected from a high-definition release.
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of "Fafner: Heaven and Earth" on Blu-ray is exceptionally well-executed, featuring two Dolby TrueHD 5.1 mixes in original Japanese and English dubbed versions. Both mixes provide expert voice work, delivering highly effective and immersive experiences with particularly impactful sound effects. During the battle sequences, the surrounds come alive with dynamic clashing sound effects, and the LFE channel offers floorboard-rattling bass that greatly enhances the viewing experience. Dialogue is prioritized, ensuring clarity and absence of any hissing or distortion.
In terms of technical performance, both the original Japanese and English dubbed versions surpass the video quality. The dialogue is anchored effectively in the center channel, consistently clear and clean. Action sequences leverage the surround speakers to great effect, encapsulating the viewer with robust and precise audio. The immersive soundscape is further bolstered by a well-balanced score that, while arguably cheesy, fits seamlessly within the film’s tone without overwhelming other elements. The subwoofer’s contribution is equally noteworthy, providing a satisfying rumble that enhances the overall audio dynamics of the film.
Extras: 26
The extras on the Blu-ray of "Fafner: Heaven and Earth" provide a treasure trove of content for fans, featuring an array of supplementary materials that delve deep into the creation and promotion of the film. Joel McDonald and Micah Solusod lead a lively and informative U.S. Commentary track, blending humorous anecdotes with behind-the-scenes insights, including McDonald's efforts to voice match with the original Fafner TV series' English dub cast. The commercial collection showcases promotional videos that highlight FUNimation's marketing efforts, encapsulating the excitement around the release. Furthermore, the theatrical trailer offers a polished preview of the film.
Extras included in this disc:
- U.S. Commentary: Joel McDonald and Micah Solusod provide humorous and informative insights.
- Commercial Collection: Promo videos that showcase FUNimation's marketing efforts.
- Theatrical Trailer: A polished cinematic preview of the film.
Movie: 41
"Fafner: Heaven and Earth" serves as a feature-length continuation of the "Fafner" anime series, diving headfirst into the unresolved storylines from its predecessor. This film’s narrative assumes a solid background knowledge of the original series, inundating viewers with intricate techno-babble and heavy references to themes and terms derived from both its universe and Der Ring des Nibelungen, which might alienate newcomers. However, despite its verbose tendencies, this film compensates with a certain emotional depth that outshines the series. The story centers around Kazuki and his poignant quest to find his friend Soushi, interwoven with thematic reflections on human nature and conflict.
The core of the film rests on the evolving dynamics between Kazuki and a mysterious child, Kurusu, who heralds changes in the ongoing battle against the Festum aliens. This new character’s enigmatic nature and telepathic connections add intriguing layers to the story, contrasting the duller moments crammed with endless scientific exposition. Viewers familiar with the series will appreciate the emotional undertones rooted in Kazuki’s journey, even though deciphering the plot may prove challenging due to the incessant jargon. Notwithstanding, the animation itself is noteworthy, blending CG and hand-drawn techniques to deliver visually compelling action sequences, albeit infrequent.
Overall, "Fafner: Heaven and Earth" delivers a mixed experience. While it attempts to balance storylines across supporting characters, it’s the primary arc focused on Kazuki that truly resonates. The film strikes an authentic emotional chord during its climax but doesn’t escape its share of interminable dialogues that might test even the most dedicated fans. The sporadic action set-pieces are engaging, but viewers are likely to find the profuse scientific discourse somewhat off-putting. Although imperfect, "Fafner: Heaven and Earth" embodies a memorable continuation for those deeply invested in the series’ lore.
Total: 45
"Fafner: Heaven and Earth" on Blu-ray provides a mixed viewing experience that is likely to elicit divided opinions among anime enthusiasts. Technically speaking, the visual presentation is less than perfect. There are noticeable issues that detract from the overall viewing quality, preventing it from reaching its full potential. In contrast, the audio quality is robust and engaging, offering a solid enhancement to the film's more intense sequences. The film's pacing is another area of concern; it maintains a slow tempo at times, potentially testing the patience of viewers unfamiliar with the original series.
The most compelling aspect of this feature lies in its central storyline involving Kazuki, Kurusu, and Soushi. This narrative thread manages to evoke a surprising emotional depth, particularly as the film crescendos towards its climax and denouement. Unfortunately, many of the supporting characters' arcs are inadequately developed, leaving these segments feeling incomplete and some dialogues overly laden with tech jargon. This surplus of scientific exposition can become tedious, detracting from the film’s overall engagement potential.
In conclusion, "Fafner: Heaven and Earth" stands as a superior crafted piece compared to its predecessor series but is hampered by excessive verbiage and underdeveloped subplots. It is best suited to fervent fans of the franchise who are invested in uncovering more about key characters like Soushi. However, for newcomers or those exploring mecha series for the first time, this film might not serve as the ideal introduction to the genre.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
This same inconsistency carries over to the hand drawn elements, where at times line detail is very strong, colors are vivid and the image is nicely sharp....
Audio: 90
These are both highly effective mixes featuring expert voice work (see the Supplements section below for some information on the dub cast) and some extremely well done immersion, especially in the battle...
Extras: 40
This is a typically chatty FUNimation commentary, though there's some interesting information imparted as well, including McDonald's attempts to "voice match" this outing with the previous Fafner television...
Movie: 50
Anyone coming to Fafner: Heaven and Earth without a solid foundation in the television show is going to be at least momentarily confused, and maybe even more than that, as this film rushes headlong into...
Total: 60
But a lot of the other supporting stories are left sadly underdeveloped and when every few minutes we get scientists launching into another round of "tech-speak", it can almost make someone wish the Festum...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 20
Now I know there was mix of CG and hand drawn animation here, but throughout the whole film, things tend to soften....
Audio: 80
The surround speakers boast the numerous sound effects from the heavier action sequences nicely and never seem over done....
Extras: 20
McDonald is one of the head guys in charge of the U.S. version of the film and the voice of Kurusu, and Solusod is the voice of Kazuki....
Movie: 40
I think you will get the gist of the story, but with all of the character references to the series and all of their backstories, it could get a little overwhelming....
Total: 40
For fans of the series, I recommend this, as you will definitely enjoy, but for newcomers, this might not be your cup of anime tea....
Director: Toshimasa Suzuki, Takashi Noto
Actors: Makoto Ishii, Ryohei Kimura, Marika Matsumoto
PlotTwo years after a devastating conflict with the alien Festum, the survivors on Tatsumiyajima Island struggle to rebuild their lives. The island inhabitants try to maintain a semblance of normalcy, harboring the emotional scars and memories of those lost. Kazuki Makabe, a young pilot who fought valiantly against the Festum, finds himself haunted by the mysterious disappearance of his friend, Soushi Minashiro. Life takes an unexpected turn when a new Festum threat emerges, putting the island in grave danger once more. Amidst this turmoil, Kazuki discovers a cryptic message that may lead to Soushi, fueling his determination to uncover the truth.
As the island prepares itself to fend off another enemy assault, various secrets about the nature of the Festum and the island’s own hidden technologies begin to surface. New alliances are formed, and old ones are tested while the residents rally to protect their home. Conflicting emotions and unresolved grievances come to the forefront, challenging Kazuki and his fellow pilots to confront both external threats and their inner demons. With each revelation, the stakes rise, compelling the island’s defenders to face harrowing decisions that could change the fate of humanity.
Writers: Tow Ubukata
Release Date: 25 Dec 2010
Runtime: 92 min
Rating: TV-14
Country: Japan
Language: Japanese