Saving Private Ryan Blu-ray Review
Sapphire Series
Score: 77
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Paramount's Blu-ray of 'Saving Private Ryan' pulls no punches with a sparkling 1080p transfer, mesmerizing lossless soundtrack, and essential supplementary content.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 81
Saving Private Ryan's Blu-ray delivers a stunning 1080p transfer with faithful adherence to the film's gritty, washed-out aesthetic, exhibiting exceptional detailing, accurate blacks, and superb desaturated color palette; this release stands as a reference quality for both video and audio integrity.
Audio: 81
Saving Private Ryan's DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack is a masterful blend of immersive combat intensity and nuanced subtlety, with exceptional clarity and natural low end, although occasional lip sync issues have been reported on certain setups.
Extra: 61
While the extras on 'Saving Private Ryan' Blu-ray demonstrate occasional brilliance with standout features like the 'Omaha Beach' and 'Shooting War' segments, the package overall is disappointingly incomplete. Missing critical elements such as trivia tracks, audio commentaries, and exhaustive behind-the-scenes content, the collection fails to fully honor the film's legacy.
Movie: 86
Saving Private Ryan arrives on Blu-ray as a visually realistic, emotionally rich, and technically immaculate wartime masterpiece. Director Steven Spielberg's 1998 epic combines grittily intense combat sequences, a poignant storyline, and profound thematic elements, leading to a transformative cinematic experience that honors the sacrifices of the greatest generation.
Video: 81
Saving Private Ryan's Blu-ray release establishes a new benchmark for reference quality video presentation, capturing the film's iconic gritty realism with an unprecedented level of detail. Paramount's meticulous 1080p AVC MPEG-4 transfer retains the original 1.85:1 aspect ratio and faithfully reproduces Director Steven Spielberg's and Cinematographer Janusz Kaminski's intended desaturated, rugged visual aesthetic. The high-definition transfer reveals increased detailing beneath the film’s intentionally rough texture, with even minor objects like helmet bumps, uniform stains, and weapon scratches rendered vividly. The wartime segments, particularly the infamous Normandy invasion, showcase an almost disturbingly realistic texture where bomb-ridden building facades and debris add to the immersion. Close-ups reveal pores, dirt, grime, and even sweat and blood with stunning clarity.
The transfer’s desaturated color palette enhances resolution without diluting the film's grim visual tone characterized by heavy grays, browns, and greens. However, specific scenes, such as the squad's assault on a machine gun emplacement at an old radar station, exhibit intense color highlights that punctuate the overall bleakness. The film's heavy grain structure is beautifully preserved, providing an authentic film-like texture throughout. Blacks remain deep and enveloping, while shadow details maintain perfect balance without any crush or overly bright patches. Skin tones appear natural and accurate across various scenes, contributing to the picture's mind-blowing realism. Although occasional speckles are present, they complement the war-torn atmosphere rather than detracting from it.
Additionally, the encode caters to varying aesthetics within the film; grain levels and contrast adjust dynamically depending on the scene's context, switching from pronounced to nearly transparent, and from pitch-perfect to exaggerated. This dynamic range enhances the believability of battles juxtaposed against calm moments. Paramount has outdone themselves yet again, delivering a Blu-ray transfer that rivals their best efforts on previous titles like Star Trek and Braveheart, making Saving Private Ryan an essential showcase disc for both narrative impact and visual fidelity.
Audio: 81
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack for "Saving Private Ryan" is an exemplary auditory experience that lives up to the film's prestigious legacy. Both initial and concluding battle scenes are a true testament to the quality of the design, delivering an immersive and electrifying experience. The aural details in these high-intensity scenes are meticulously rendered – from the hum of landing crafts and crashing waves, to the cacophony of gunfire and explosions. Subtle environmental effects such as water rattling in a canteen and dislodged sand create a three-dimensional soundstage, making the viewer feel entrenched in the action.
Equally notable are the quieter moments, where subtler sounds elevate the overall experience. Atmospheric elements such as flags rattling in the wind, distant gunfire during quieter church and radar station scenes, and the natural crunching of typewriter keys all contribute to the film's depth. Dialogue is pristine and well-localized, maintaining clarity even amidst chaotic action sequences. Ensuring no excessive dominance, the bass remains powerful yet balanced, creating profound impact without overwhelming other sound layers. Additionally, the audio track features outstanding dynamics and superb localization.
However, there are some reported lip sync issues occurring specifically from chapter 15 onward, though this seems to vary across different playback systems. The misalignment occurs around the 2:06 mark during a character’s reminiscence about his brother’s girlfriend, but this glitch is inconsistent depending on the hardware used.
Ultimately, Paramount's delivery on the DTS-HD MA 5.1 track is a masterful achievement, accentuating the harrowing yet enthralling narrative of "Saving Private Ryan". This release truly encapsulates the tension and raw emotion of wartime, marking it as an essential reference for Blu-ray soundtracks.
Extras: 61
The extras on the "Saving Private Ryan" Blu-ray present a thorough, although somewhat uneven, examination of the film's production and its historical context. The features span across a dedicated second disc and offer an insightful look at both the movie's creation and World War II combat photography, narrated by Tom Hanks. Topics range from Steven Spielberg's childhood interest in WWII and the authentic recreation efforts for the film to the real-life stories of veterans. Particularly noteworthy are the detailed breakdowns of key scenes, such as the Omaha Beach invasion. However, the lack of a trivia track or comprehensive behind-the-scenes documentary is a missed opportunity.
Extras included in this disc:
- Shooting War: Chronicles WWII through combat footage narrated by Tom Hanks.
- Introduction: Spielberg shares his WWII fascination and childhood films.
- Looking Into the Past: Spielberg discusses the film’s historical research.
- Miller and His Platoon: Examines character attributes and actor-collaborations.
- Boot Camp: Highlights actors' military training for realism.
- Making 'Saving Private Ryan': Overview of filming processes, props, and settings.
- Re-Creating Omaha Beach: Insight into the filming of the iconic battle sequence.
- Music and Sound: Composer John Williams on music's role; sound design overview.
- Into the Breach: 'Saving Private Ryan': Behind-the-scenes with cast, crew, and veterans.
- Parting Thoughts: Final remarks from Spielberg and Hanks on the film’s impact.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer in high definition.
- Re-Release Trailer: Trailer focusing on critical reception.
Movie: 86
"Saving Private Ryan," directed by Steven Spielberg, remains one of the most defining war films ever conceived, capturing both the gruesome bloodshed and the spirit of heroism seen during World War II. The film is a meticulous portrayal of wartime experiences, where every frame is constructed to deliver an authentic sense of historical realism. Spielberg’s bold direction and Robert Rodat's screenplay navigate through the complexities of the soul and human condition against the backdrop of a harrowing mission to save Private James Francis Ryan (Matt Damon). As Captain John Miller (Tom Hanks) and his squad traverse the dangerous, Nazi-occupied French countryside, they encounter not only the enemy but elements that force them to face their own mortality, camaraderie, and inherent valor.
Spielberg’s craftsmanship is evident in his use of aggressive, visually-arresting techniques to transport viewers into the thick of battle. The Omaha Beach scene, in particular, is an unforgettable sequence encapsulating terror and chaos with a stunningly unvarnished gaze. His dedication to an immersive experience is further accentuated by the film's grainy, handheld camera work and washed-out color palette that imbues a vintage feel while utilizing modern filmmaking acumen. The juxtaposition of frenzied combat and intervals of deep, philosophical dialogues amongst soldiers provides a potent contrast, effectively capturing the duality of war—its brutality and its profound impact on the soul.
The ensemble cast rises to the occasion with nuanced performances that bring depth to their respective characters. Tom Sizemore, Edward Burns, Barry Pepper, Adam Goldberg, Vin Diesel, Giovanni Ribisi, and Jeremy Davies deliver compelling portrayals that allow each character to contribute uniquely to the film’s narrative. Themes of bravery, sacrifice, and human endurance permeate 'Saving Private Ryan,' making it not just a war film but an emotionally resonant human drama. Spielberg’s film remains a seminal work that honors the real-life sacrifices made during WWII while also reinforcing the timeless message about the fragility and valor of life amidst conflict.
Total: 77
The Blu-ray release of "Saving Private Ryan" stands as a monumental achievement, aligning itself with some of the most critical war films ever produced. This Steven Spielberg classic is enriched with a masterful cast who fully inhabit their roles, delivering an immersive portrayal of the brutal realities of World War II. The opening sequence, renowned for evoking visceral physical reactions, remains one of the most impactful cinematic moments, setting a precedent for the film's intense narrative journey. The Blu-ray transfer offers a pristine 1080p image and a mesmerizing lossless soundtrack, elevating the viewing experience to unparalleled levels of clarity and emotional resonance.
Paramount's Sapphire Series has meticulously crafted this Blu-ray edition, providing ample space for the superb audio and video elements to shine independently. The release also includes a thoughtfully curated collection of extras that, while not voluminous, significantly enhance understanding of the film’s production and historical context. These supplements are full of rich insights and serve as crucial additions for aficionados seeking a deeper connection with the material. The technical presentation is flawless, capturing every nuance of Spielberg's intricate direction and Janusz Kamiński's haunting cinematography.
In conclusion, it wasn't just bullets and bombs that cleared the way for freedom, but also, and just as crucial to the war effort, the selflessness, courage, honor, and bravery of the men who fought. That selflessness, courage, honor, and bravery was for those in generations later who would view their actions with an understanding of the scale on which these men sacrificed all in the name of liberty. Paramount's Blu-ray release of "Saving Private Ryan" is the definitive edition of the film and a necessary addition to every movie library. With its exceptional technical quality and significant cultural impact, this Blu-ray is a must-own. "Saving Private Ryan" earns our highest recommendation as one of the best and most important films ever created.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
This high definition transfer brings with it vastly increased detailing, even underneath the rough-and-tumble and faded look the film employs; even during the bright, bloomy opening and closing scenes...
Audio: 100
Also impressive -- as much as any other sonic element in the film -- is the sound of distant gunfire and explosions that seems an almost constant companion throughout the picture, notably inside the Neuville...
Extras: 70
Next is Making 'Saving Private Ryan' (480i, 22:05), a solid examination of the process that was the construction of the film, featuring Director Steven Spielberg speaking on his style, the film's place...
Movie: 100
Less crucial to the dramatic elements of the picture but certainly helping in its pacing and structure is Spielberg's keen sense for comic relief through the Upham character; the director manages to earn...
Total: 90
Compared to those of its genre, perhaps only Glory -- a film that shares with Saving Private Ryan themes on the importance of freedom, respect, courage, and personal sacrifice for the greater good -- may...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
A few pans were jarring, made worse by the jumpy camera doubling the stuttering look, while some sequences left much to be desired in terms of clarity (the way that bugs are barely even visible on the...
Audio: 100
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix for the film makes it sound better than damn near any film ever made, so it's safe to say that justice has been served here, and there will be little to no room for any...
Extras: 60
While the extras are good, sometimes great, sometimes frustrating, the lack of a trivia track, audio commentary (obviously not with Spielberg, who doesn't do that sort of thing), PiP, or an exhaustive...
Movie: 80
There's something for nearly everyone, as we get not only realistic to the point of being nauseating warfare, but real, fleshed out characters, who act human, in the midst of the most inhuman acts ever...
Total: 80
Arguments can be made about the film and its message, but it's hard to fault the film, and it's famous opening sequence that can cause severe physical reaction may be one of the single-most effective bits...
Director: Steven Spielberg
Actors: Tom Hanks, Matt Damon, Tom Sizemore
PlotDuring the Normandy invasion of World War II, U.S. forces storm Omaha Beach in a brutal assault that results in heavy American casualties. Amidst the chaos, Captain John Miller and his squad survive the fierce battle and are tasked with a new mission: to find Private James Francis Ryan. Ryan is a paratrooper who landed somewhere in the French countryside, and all three of his brothers have been killed in action within days of each other. The Chief of Staff of the United States Army, General George C. Marshall, is moved by the Ryan family's loss and orders that James be found and sent home safely to his grieving mother.
Miller's team, composed of men from different backgrounds and with varying degrees of combat experience, embarks on this seemingly straightforward but morally complex mission behind enemy lines. The soldiers question the logic and value of risking their lives to save one man, debating the merits of such an order when so many have already died. As they journey through war-torn France, every town and skirmish potentially hides Private Ryan, and each encounter with German troops brings the grim reality of war into sharp focus. The squad witnesses the brutality and senselessness of combat, experiencing loss and moments of humanity, all while struggling with the implications of their orders and the rightness of their quest.
Writers: Robert Rodat
Release Date: 24 Jul 1998
Runtime: 169 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, French, German, Czech