The Maze Blu-ray Review
Blu-ray 3D
Score: 80
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Maze offers a highly recommended Gothic-horror experience with superb 3D restoration, effective audio mix, and excellent bonus features, despite a debatable finale.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
Kino's Blu-ray of 'The Maze' is an exemplary 4K restoration with immersive 3D presentations funded by The Film Foundation. The 1080p transfer preserves fine film grain, spot-on black levels, and excellent grayscale, projecting significant depth even in confined spaces. The 3D conversion, executed by the 3-D Film Archive, showcases impressive object depth and frame composition, creating a tangible viewing experience with minimal crosstalk and pristine details.
Audio: 90
The Maze’s Blu-ray audio presentation, with a restored DTS-HD Master Audio 3.0 track, delivers clear dialogue and dynamic sound effects, effectively using the front soundstage for spatial awareness and atmospheric details, while Marlin Skiles' moody score enhances the film without distortion or age-related artifacts.
Extra: 67
The Maze Blu-ray extras include a highly informative audio commentary with Tom Weaver and others discussing the film, its 3D history, and restoration efforts, a brief but engaging interview with star Veronica Hurst about her unique experience in the film, and the original 3D trailer. A robust and enlightening package.
Movie: 63
The Maze's 3D Blu-ray release showcases William Cameron Menzies' atmospheric direction, perfectly leveraging 3D effects to enhance the suspense and environmental depth of a mid-century Gothic horror. Despite the somewhat dated and occasionally absurd climax, the film sustains a gripping, slow-burn mystery invigorated by stellar performances and intricate set designs.
Video: 83
Kino's Blu-ray release of "The Maze" delivers impeccable video quality, featuring rigorous technical efforts in both 2D and 3D presentations. The 2D version showcases a nearly flawless image, stemming from left and right 35mm film elements provided by the Paramount Archives and impeccably restored by PRO-TEK in a 4K scan. Although some minor wear-and-tear remnants and light wobble exist, they are trivial in the broader context. The restoration team preserved light grain and maintained textural consistency with robust details in faces, clothes, and atmospheric settings—especially the maze’s intricate hedges. The grayscale rendering is superb with deep blacks and exquisite shadow detail, giving a firm foundation to the atmospheric qualities of the film.
The 3D Film Archive's restoration is even more extraordinary, highlighting the film’s visual depth and spatial authenticity. The framing of objects and characters enhances the depth along the z-axis, significantly within the maze and castle interiors. Attention to detail extends to minor elements such as angled newspapers and flower vases, which utilize 3D space effectively. The standout moments include an opening sequence that draws viewers into the maze and scenes featuring dynamic object separation and tangible depth. This 3D presentation minimizes crosstalk effects and maintains sharpness and pristine grayscale, rivaling or even surpassing its 2D counterpart with a compelling three-dimensional experience.
Overall, "The Maze" in 1080p resolution, AVC/MVC codec, and original 1.37:1 aspect ratio confirms its video excellence. From rich black levels to superior contrast and sharpness, every frame is a testament to high-quality restoration work. This Blu-ray package is an exemplary demonstration of fine depth, rich details, and a thoroughly immersive 3D experience that is bound to captivate enthusiasts holding onto their 3D gear.
Audio: 90
"The Maze," presented on Blu-ray, features a restored three-channel stereophonic sound by Eckhard Böttner, achieving high fidelity through a DTS-HD Master Audio 3.0 lossless soundtrack. This track delivers exceptional audio quality, with fine front-stage coverage and effortless width that imbue scenes with a noticeable open-space ambience and musical richness. Fluid sound effects enhance the experience, whether it's splashes heard distinctly off to the left side around the 9-minute mark or more intensive climactic sounds in later scenes. Despite its age, the musical fidelity remains impressive, and dialogue is consistently clear from a centered positioning, enhancing the overall viewing experience.
The audio presentation adeptly keeps pace with the three-dimensional visuals of the film, particularly in how it handles natural and dynamic sound effects. From the eerie shuffles and limps behind the locked doors to the immersive dimensional effects as Kitty and Edith navigate the maze, the DTS-HD MA 3.0 stereophonic mix adds substantial depth and spatial awareness to the film's atmosphere. Marlin Skiles' score is effectively moody, maintaining the tension without overpowering other elements in the mix. This track notably avoids any hiss, pops, or age-related issues, ensuring an exceptional auditory experience that complements the film's tense and mysterious tone.
Additionally, the disc provides both DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono and reconstituted 3.0 tracks, both wonderfully free of age-related artifacts such as hiss, crackles, and pops. The 3.0 track excels in using directional dialogue across the front soundstage while positioning Skiles' subtle yet moody score throughout the mix to excellent effect. This thoughtful audio presentation intricately enhances the overall atmosphere and style of "The Maze," making it a standout aspect of this Blu-ray release.
Extras: 67
The Blu Ray release of "The Maze" presents a commendable assortment of extras that enhance the viewing experience with rich, informative content. The audio commentary, hosted by Tom Weaver, is a standout feature, offering an expansive dive into the film's 1950s production, from the real historical inspiration to the intricate differences between the novel and the film. Additional insights from experts like David Schecter on the film score and Bob Furmanek on the 3D restoration process make it a captivating track. Veronica Hurst’s interview, though brief, adds a personal touch, discussing her casting and experiences on set. The original 3-D trailer is a nostalgic inclusion, completing this educational and entertaining package.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insights from historians covering the film's history, technical aspects, and restoration.
- Veronica Hurst Interview: Behind-the-scenes with lead actress.
- Original 3-D Trailer: Theatrical preview in both 2D and 3D.
Movie: 63
"The Maze" directed by William Cameron Menzies, masterfully combines elements of gothic horror and suspense to create an atmospheric and chilling narrative. Adapted from Maurice Sandoz's book, the film benefits significantly from its 3D presentation, which heightens the depth and immersion of both the titular maze and Craven Castle. The movie thrives on its slow-burn suspense, ratcheting up tension through mysterious occurrences and foreboding settings, all enhanced by eerie and intricate set designs. Richard Carlson leads the cast as Gerald MacTeam, who mysteriously ages and changes demeanor after inheriting his uncle's castle, while Veronica Hurst's performance as Kitty is particularly noteworthy for her determined and plucky character, driving much of the intrigue forward.
The narrative unfolds with Kitty Murray, deeply troubled by her fiancé Gerald's sudden and bewildering transformation after inheriting Craven Castle. Alongside her aunt Edith, Kitty ventures to Scotland to unearth the castle's dreadful secrets. The labyrinthine hedge maze and the enigmatic Keep Out sign amplify the sense of looming dread and mystery. A combination of skillful pacing, meticulous scene staging, and the expert use of 3D effects make the environments almost characters in their own right. The film's slow revelation of its central mystery, particularly in 3D, allows the audience to fully experience the spatial depth of the maze and castle, contributing greatly to the suspenseful atmosphere.
Despite its 1950s origins and some plot elements that modern audiences might find quaint or outlandish, "The Maze" retains its charm as a vintage horror gem. While some may find the climactic reveal somewhat absurd by contemporary standards, fans of old-school horror will appreciate its mood and methodical build-up. Oscar-winning production designer Menzies uses the limited budget creatively, delivering a film rich in atmospheric dread and visual intricacy, proving "The Maze" as a distinctly memorable entry in the genre.
Total: 80
"The Maze" Blu-ray offers a captivating return to classic gothic-horror, effortlessly blending atmospheric tension with subtle suspense. The 3D Film Archive's restoration team, led by Greg Kintz and Bob Furmanek, has delivered an impeccably restored 3D transfer that breathes new life into the film. The enhanced 3D effect is immersive, contributing significantly to the film's eerie and moody aesthetic. The visual presentation stands out exceptionally well, with high-definition clarity that maintains the movie's original charm while enhancing its atmospheric depth. Complementing the visual excellence, the audio mix is impressively balanced and effective, adding another layer of immersion to the viewing experience.
The narrative pacing of "The Maze" is skillfully handled, holding back major reveals and teasing the audience until the story culminates in a finale that's sure to spark varying opinions. While some may find the concluding moments laughable in a literal sense, they are undoubtedly metaphorically rich, challenging viewers to reflect on themes of perception, reality, identity, and truth. The thoughtful build-up ensures that the viewer is fully engaged and invested by the time the film reaches its climactic end. This nuanced storytelling is further highlighted by the addition of valuable bonus features, including a must-listen commentary, that provide deeper insights into the film’s thematic elements and production.
It's easy to dismiss The Maze's finale as silly, and out of context it certainly is. It's a movie that, considering its endgame, requires a gradual appreciation as the viewer comes to terms with what, exactly, it means, more in a metaphorical sense than a literal one. It speaks to an interesting point that should be relevant still today about perception and reality, identity, and truth. Literally, it's laugh-out-loud absurd. Metaphorically, it's much more challenging. Whether it works in the movie's immediate context is up for debate, but there's no mistaking that the film is otherwise an exceptionally well-crafted moody and mysterious experience that's made all the better by its 3D presentation, which on this Blu-ray is the beneficiary of a startlingly intense and highly enjoyable 3D restoration by Greg Kintz, Bob Furmanek, and everyone at the 3-D Film Archive. Also boasting quality sound and a couple of excellent extras, including a must-listen commentary, this release of course comes very highly recommended and is an early contender for a spot on the year-end top-10 list.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
When Kitty and Edith arrive at the castle on a foggy night at the 18-minute mark, three on-screen characters are slightly offset, and that additional spacing -- they're not bunched up but rather spread...
Audio: 100
Additionally, various small details around the castle help build atmosphere, while some more intensive screams and (spoiler-free) climactic sound effects are pleasantly robust and well defined....
Extras: 80
The track begins with Weaver covering the real history behind the castle that inspired the story and the film, differences between the novel and the film, the film's technical construction, reviews and...
Movie: 80
The film is wonderfully atmospheric as it allots the vast majority of its runtime to environmental suspense, slowly unraveling the central mystery as small clues beget a larger trail which eventually leads...
Total: 60
Whether it works in the movie's immediate context is up for debate, but there's no mistaking the the film is otherwise an exceptionally well crafted moody and mysterious experience that's made all the...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
There is a slight bit of speckling here and there in the image, but nothing too distracting or serious enough to negatively affect the 3-D experience....
Audio: 100
Sound effects are dynamic with a strong presence and help give the image a sense of dimension and spatial awareness....
Extras: 60
The Audio Commentary is a fountain of information about the film as well as the effort that went into the restoration of the elements to produce this Blu-ray....
Movie: 60
Some may find the resolution to the mystery a bit on the silly side, but fans of vintage horror should get a kick out of it just the same and appreciate the bone-chilling ride along the way....
Total: 80
The Maze is a trip through classic gothic-horror where the setting and sound are just as horrifying as what you see....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 90
The sense of depth is almost constantly palpable, not just in shots of the maze but in the corridors and staircases of the castle and in various rooms which seem to gain in size by half again in 3D. Objects...
Audio: 100
Both tracks are wonderfully free from age-related artifacts like hiss, crackle, and pops, and the 3.0 track makes use of most effective directional dialogue across the front soundstage while Marlin Skiles’...
Extras: 70
Audio Commentary: film historian Tom Weaver serves as host and primary commentarian offering background on the original book, the film’s tortured history to final production, and background on the key...
Movie: 60
But Oscar-winning production designer William Cameron Menzies helming the movie makes sure the atmosphere is moody and filled with a sense of impending dread, and several sequences are nicely paced, especially...
Total: 70
Another Golden Age 3D gem The Maze has been redeemed by the 3-D Film Archive for fans of subtle Gothic suspense complete with a really superb 3D rendering, a most effective new soundtrack mix, and some...
Director: William Cameron Menzies
Actors: Richard Carlson, Veronica Hurst, Katherine Emery
PlotGerald MacTeam, a Scottish aristocrat engaged to an American woman named Kitty, abruptly calls off their engagement and retreats to his ancestral castle in Scotland after learning of his uncle's mysterious death. Concerned and bewildered by his sudden change in behavior, Kitty decides to follow him to Scotland, accompanied by her aunt Miss Margaret Dillingholm. When they arrive at the foreboding castle, they are met with a cold reception and find that Gerald has undergone a puzzling transformation, becoming reclusive and secretive. Intrigued and alarmed, Kitty and her aunt begin to investigate the eerie grounds and Gothic architecture, particularly the high maze that seems to hold a sinister secret.
As they delve deeper, strange occurrences unfold within the castle's walls, and the women uncover an atmosphere thick with tension and fear. The cryptic behavior of servants, unusual nocturnal activities, and Gerald’s increasingly erratic actions hint at some dark hidden truth connected to the family legacy. Their quest for answers leads them deeper into the maze's labyrinthine structure, compelling Kitty to confront unimaginable horrors in her determination to uncover the terrible mysteries that have consumed her fiancé and the MacTeam lineage.
Writers: Daniel B. Ullman, Maurice Sandoz
Release Date: 26 Jul 1953
Runtime: 80 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English