Man on Fire Blu-ray Review
Score: 56
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Fox's Blu-ray releases offer stunning visuals yet scant extras, dividing fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 69
Man on Fire's Blu-ray transfer dazzles with its fidelity to Scott's vision; rich colors, deep blacks, and pristine clarity honor the original grit and vibrance, blending technical excellence with artistic intent.
Audio: 64
Despite high expectations, Man on Fire's DTS-HD MA audio impresses with well-defined bass, clear dialogue, and immersive sound fields, though its action sequences feel slightly restrained compared to other titles.
Extra: 6
Fox's release is disappointing with minimal extras, just four trailers, for 'Man on Fire,' a stark contrast to the richer content on its DVD version, reflecting a persistent underwhelming effort.
Movie: 81
Man on Fire is an intense drama and action-packed thriller, led by Denzel Washington's masterful performance, exploring themes of vengeance, love, and redemption.
Video: 69
The Blu-ray presentation of "Man on Fire" offers a theatrically correct widescreen 2.4:1 transfer, utilizing an AVC MPEG-4 encoding at 29 Mbps which ensures that the video quality is top-notch, preserving the director Tony Scott’s intended visual storytelling with a rich palette and deep blacks. Detail in the video is exceptional, showcasing everything from the intricate textures of environments and characters’ skin to the crisp readability of street signs in the bustling cityscapes. The colors, versatile and vibrant due to Scott's use of varied film stocks, appear more defined than ever, particularly greens which are simply breathtaking. Additionally, flesh tones are portrayed with remarkable richness and depth, contributing to the visual authenticity and immersion.
While the presentation maintains fidelity to the source material, some viewers might note the film’s intentional gritty appearance and overly saturated colors at times. This aesthetic choice is not a flaw but rather a deliberate artistic decision, enhancing the narrative’s impact without compromising on clarity or detail in scenes not affected by these stylistic choices. The contrast between the intentionally gritty sections and the pristine clarity of others like outdoor scenes, highlighted by striking greens and lifelike images, underscores the Blu-ray’s capability to accurately render both artistic intentions and naturalistic detail.
In terms of technical excellence, the Blu-ray release exhibits a flawless print with no visible artefacts or edge enhancement, maintaining grain and texture where it belongs as part of the visual style. While comparisons with the SD version highlight substantial improvements in color vibrancy and detail clarity, this Blu-ray edition reaffirms its quality as a standout release. It raises questions about consumer expectations for HD content, ultimately proving its worth through its spectacular audiovisual presentation that respects and elevates the initial vision for "Man on Fire."
Audio: 64
"Man on Fire" on Blu-ray offers an engaging audio experience with its English 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track, alongside French and Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 alternatives. The primary DTS track, although inaccessible in its full glory due to limitations with some hardware like the PS3, still impresses when downmixed. The audio presentation shines with its excellently defined bass that lends an impactful and clear resonance to on-screen explosions and gunshots, effectively complementing the film’s intense moments without overwhelming the senses. The midrange and treble are also well handled, ensuring the score fills the room with an enveloping presence. Sound separation and the ambient effects create a wide, immersive sound field that adds a layer of audiovisual excellence, especially notable when the soundscape shifts seamlessly with the on-screen action to enhance the viewer's immersion.
Dialogue throughout is crisp, clear, and perfectly balanced against the backdrop of action and music, ensuring every word is distinctly heard without being overshadowed by the dynamic range of sounds. The action sequences, though not as thunderous as those found in other titles, are meticulously crafted with surround sound that places the viewer at the heart of the chaos. Sounds of tire squeals, helicopters, and the debris of explosions are rendered with an impressive clarity that complements the film's visual intensity.
Comparatively, while the DTS-HD MA track offers an improvement over standard definition audio tracks — notably in bass definition and sound separation — it doesn't represent as significant a leap as one might expect. The increase in bitrate indeed enhances the audio detail slightly, but perhaps not to the extent that wholly transforms the experience. Despite these minor caveats, the soundtrack provides a thoroughly satisfying and immersive listening experience that elevates the overall enjoyment of "Man on Fire," cementing its place as a solid auditory companion to the film's fiery visuals.
Extra: 6
The Blu Ray extra presentation of "Man on Fire" leaves much to be desired for those familiar with the comprehensive material once available on the double-disc standard definition release. Fox's decision to limit the extras solely to four 1080p theatrical trailers—including the film's own plus previews for "The Sentinel," "Mr. & Mrs. Smith," and "Entrapment"—is a stark underutilization of the Blu Ray format's capacity for supplementary content. This scant offering is a disappointment, particularly for a film of such caliber, and suggests that fans hoping for an enriched viewing experience will need to retain their DVD copies for any special features beyond these trailers. While clarity and definition in these previews are impeccable, the overall extras package does not meet the expectations for avid collectors and enthusiasts of "Man on Fire."
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer for Man on Fire: Theatrical trailer for the film itself.
- Trailer for The Sentinel: Preview of "The Sentinel."
- Trailer for Mr. & Mrs. Smith: Preview of "Mr. & Mrs. Smith."
- Trailer for Entrapment: Preview of "Entrapment."
Movie: 81
"Man on Fire" unfolds in a gripping narrative that conveys intense emotion, rich character development, and a relentless pursuit of vengeance, all while presenting an unflinching look into the harrowing reality of kidnappings in Latin America. The meticulous direction by Tony Scott elevates the film, giving it a gritty and raw aesthetic that distinguishes it from other thrillers. The attention to detail, especially in setting up the characters' relationships, is pivotal. By taking its time to develop the bond between Creasy (Denzel Washington) and Pita (Dakota Fanning), the film ensures that the audience is fully invested in their story, making the ensuing action and Creasy's quest for retribution all the more impactful and urgent.
Denzel Washington's portrayal of Creasy stands out as a career-defining performance, displaying a depth of character that showcases his versatility and exceptional talent. Washington's Creasy is a complex figure, a man tormented by his past and consumed by a desire for justice, whose relationship with Pita brings a glimmer of humanity to his otherwise hardened facade. The support cast, including Christopher Walken as Rayburn and Marc Anthony as Samuel, complements Washington's powerful performance, while Tony Scott’s distinctive directing style adds to the film's intensity, rendering its action sequences both frenetic and profoundly disturbing.
The narrative thrust of "Man on Fire" is propelled by its exploration of themes such as redemption, revenge, and the capacity for personal transformation against a backdrop of unabated violence and corruption. The film does not shy away from depicting the brutality of its world, making it a compelling, albeit unsettling, watch. The tension is palpable throughout, driven by both the storytelling and the stylistic elements that Tony Scott employs, making "Man on Fire" an unforgettable experience that resonates with audiences long after the credits roll.
Total: 56
The Blu-ray release of "Man on Fire" by Fox stands as a double-edged sword for aficionados of high-definition media. On one hand, the transfer delivers breathtaking clarity and an auditory experience that's as close to flawless as one gets, boasting the capabilities to truly leverage the nuances of DTS-HD. The visual presentation is undeniably marvelous, enhancing Tony Scott's masterfully brutal direction and the film's intense emotional landscape, from seething vengeance to profound love. However, this comes at a surprisingly sparse offering, notably devoid of the supplementary materials that often enrich a collector's appreciation and understanding of the film. This absence feels particularly poignant when juxtaposed against the previous SD version, which, while not matching the Blu-ray's visual and auditory fidelity, was packed with extras that added substantial value.
"Man on Fire" itself is a film that polarizes with its raw depiction of revenge fuelled by the deepest of human connections and loss. The portrayal of Creasy's descent into vengeance is both harrowing and visually compelling, rendered here with an intensity that benefits significantly from the high-definition upgrade. Despite the lack of bonus content, the quality of this release does offer something for those invested in technical excellence and who seek to experience the film in the best possible presentation. It becomes a test of what one values more: the pure sensory experience or the behind-the-scenes insights into the creation of a film.
In conclusion, while this Blu-ray release does fall short in offering a comprehensive package that celebrates every facet of "Man on Fire," it undeniably elevates the viewing experience for those prioritizing picture and sound quality above all. It's recommended for fans and newcomers alike who can appreciate the film’s technical merits and are willing to overlook the absence of additional content. Yet, it's a decision each fan will have to weigh, considering whether the upgrade is worth the investment for an enhanced yet solitary viewing experience.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 90
Yes the colours are much more vibrant, yes the detail is clearer, in some places much so, but it is not that much of an improvement over the outstanding quality of the SD....
Audio: 90
It has wonderfully defined bass, from the score to the gunshots and explosions, there is plenty to rattle the furniture and take the wind from your lungs....
Extras: 10
Considering the wealth of extra material available for this film and presented on the double disc SD this is a rather poor show from Fox, but nevertheless what we've come to expect....
Movie: 80
Watching it is a rewarding experience and one cannot help but be drawn into the plight and the vengeance....
Total: 70
Personally, I'm such a sucker for the new format, though, that this is my preferred version and the one that will be spun from now on....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The look adds rather than detracts from the impact of the film, and the image as a whole on this release is phenomenal....
Audio: 80
Nevertheless, the action is engrossing and frightening and the good sound effects and excellent music add to the power and terror of each scene....
Extras: 10
Fans of Man on Fire will have to hang onto their DVD copies if they want access to any special features....
Movie: 90
It lends a hard edge to the more frenetic and dangerous sequences in his films, and it raises the palpable tension and fear where applicable....
Total: 80
Therefore, fans may be reluctant to upgrade, but the difference in quality is, to me, worth the price of the disc....
Director: Tony Scott
Actors: Denzel Washington, Christopher Walken, Dakota Fanning
PlotIn Mexico City, the kidnapping of children is on the rise, and wealthy families live in fear of their loved ones being snatched for ransom. Amidst this climate of dread, former CIA operative and U.S. Marine Force Recon officer, John W. Creasy is hired as a bodyguard for 9-year-old Pita Ramos, the daughter of industrialist Samuel Ramos and his American wife Lisa. Worn down by his past experiences and struggling with alcoholism, Creasy is initially indifferent towards his job and his charge. However, Pita's lively and innocent nature gradually breaks through his defenses, and he forms a close bond with the child, giving him a renewed purpose in life.
The newfound stability in Creasy's life is shattered when Pita is abducted in broad daylight during a piano lesson. Despite his efforts to prevent the kidnapping, Creasy is severely wounded during the incident. Filled with guilt and rage from his failure to protect Pita, he vows to exact vengeance on those responsible. As he recovers from his injuries, Creasy becomes a man driven by an inexorable will to seek and deliver retribution, embarking on a relentless pursuit of justice that draws him deep into a dangerous labyrinth of corruption and crime. His quest propels him against a cabal of powerful adversaries who underestimate the lengths a man will go to save the child he has come to love as his own.
Writers: A.J. Quinnell, Brian Helgeland
Release Date: 23 Apr 2004
Runtime: 146 min
Rating: R
Country: Switzerland, United Kingdom, United States, Mexico
Language: English, Spanish