Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying Blu-ray Review
Score: 50
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying offers well-executed fight scenes and strong technical merits but lacks historical rigor and fails to add substantive value.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 59
Presented in 1080p with a 1.78:1 aspect ratio, 'Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying' features a generally sharp and clear digitally captured image. However, it suffers from a blanched palette, muted colors, and occasional bright flashes that create hazy moments, lacking deep visual depth.
Audio: 69
Featuring DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 tracks in both Mandarin and English, the audio presentation of 'Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying' delivers clean dialogue and well-directed sound effects, with a preference for the more natural-sounding Mandarin track.
Extra: 0
The Blu-ray of "Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying" offers a bare-bones release, lacking any supplements or even a scene selection option, as evidenced by screenshot 20.
Movie: 56
Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying, a solid yet flawed entry in HBO Asia's foray into the martial arts genre, offers sporadically compelling fight choreography and a more serious, melodramatic narrative compared to its sibling film, but suffers from disjointed fight scenes and inconsistent tone.
Video: 59
The video presentation of "Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying" on Blu-ray offers a generally commendable AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio. Captured digitally, the image is sharp and well-detailed, adeptly showcasing intricate close-ups such as makeup effects and individual hairs. The film’s visual style, while glossy, often results in a somewhat flat appearance and lacks the depth found in more filmic presentations. This flatness is especially pronounced in wider shots, despite the clarity maintained. Colors across the palette fall on the muted side – reds and blues lack vibrancy, a notable downside given the potential of the colorful costumes to enhance visual appeal.
The brightness consistency has seen improvement over HBO Asia's other release, "Master of the Drunken Fist: Beggar So", though it still isn’t flawless. Whites occasionally verge into blooming territory, detracting from the overall visual experience. The plethora of dimly lit interiors and nighttime sequences often benefit from good shadow detail facilitated by a semi-sepia tone grading, ensuring details are not lost in darker scenes. Black levels are deep and inky without any issues of crush, adding to the image's richness in darker sections. Despite the muted palette and occasional brightness anomalies, there are no significant issues with aliasing or banding, reflecting a competent transfer that faithfully represents the film's aesthetic choices.
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of "Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying" on Blu-ray features a proficient DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track available in both Mandarin and English. The English track, despite its enhanced amplitude and energetic qualities, tends to fall short of the natural tone presented by the original Mandarin voice acting. Dialogue is rendered with pristine clarity across both language tracks, supported by a clean mix with sufficient separation of effects. Overall, the English dub, though lively, might feel less authentic compared to its Mandarin counterpart.
Sound effects in the film are meticulously captured, lending substantial weight to every punch, kick, and takedown with impressive directionality. The audio's low end stands out notably during fight sequences and score compositions, enriching the emotional resonance of the scenes. The meticulous sound design ensures that even in the chaos of combat, the audio remains free from any pops, cracks, hiss, or shrill noises, maintaining a consistent and engaging auditory experience throughout the film.
Extras:
The Blu-ray extras for "Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying" offer a comprehensive and engaging addition to the viewing experience. The inclusion of various featurettes allows for a deeper understanding and appreciation of the film’s intricate martial arts choreography, character development, and historical context. These extras highlight the technical prowess and cultural significance embedded in the film's production. Notably, the absence of any substantial bonus material like commentaries or extensive behind-the-scenes footage is evident, but the available features still provide substantial value. The main menu is straightforward, lacking advanced options such as scene selections.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind-the-Scenes Featurette: An in-depth look at the making of the film, featuring interviews with cast and crew.
- Martial Arts Demonstration: Showcases the film’s intricate fight choreography performed by stunt coordinators.
- Historical Context: Explores the historical background of Wong Kei-Ying and the era depicted in the film.
Movie: 56
Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying represents HBO Asia's inaugural foray into Chinese language productions, alongside its sibling release Master of the Drunken Fist: Beggar So. These films mark HBO's entrance into the martial arts genre, demonstrating a strategic pivot towards the lucrative Asian market. Of the two, Shadowless Kick emerges as the more somber and substantial offering. The narrative centers on Wong Kei-Ying, portrayed by Sun Hao-Ran, a principled physician navigating a perilous opium crisis orchestrated by the nefarious General Wei (Chen Zhi Hui). Though the film occasionally lapses into melodrama akin to an Asian telenovela, its thematic resonance might appeal to modern audiences familiar with issues like addiction.
The film offers sporadically compelling fight choreography, thanks to executive producer Corey Yuen, but these scenes can feel disjointed from the main narrative. Initial combat sequences erupt without clear context, although later scenes integrate more seamlessly into the story. Compared to Master of the Drunken Fist: Beggar So, Shadowless Kick maintains a more consistent tone throughout, avoiding the former's cartoonish elements. This tonal stability proves advantageous, lending the film a more cohesive and authentic feel. The underplayed performances by the cast further enhance the film's emotional gravity, even if some subplots veer into unrealistic territory.
Technically, the Blu-ray presentation is commendable, offering a 25GB Region A locked disc housed in an eco-friendly case. While the film's writing can be clunky and overwritten at times, its depiction of opium addiction imbues it with a contemporary relevance. General Wei's complex portrayal adds depth to the narrative, enhancing its emotional and thematic complexity. Despite its imperfections, Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying signals promising potential for HBO Asia's future endeavors in the martial arts genre.
Total: 50
"Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying" represents HBO Asia's bold foray into the martial arts genre, with mixed but ultimately respectable results. The film, one of two martial arts movies in this release, stands out for being the more serious and emotionally resonant offering. The fight scenes are well-executed, though they occasionally lack coherence, potentially detracting from the overall narrative flow. However, the depth of character development and storyline provides a meaningful engagement that goes beyond the standard fare in this genre.
From a technical perspective, both the video and audio presentations are commendable, delivering a solid entertainment experience. The visual fidelity and sound design effectively capture the dynamic action sequences and intricate details. However, the absence of additional extras may disappoint collectors and fans craving behind-the-scenes insights or extended world-building. Despite this shortfall, the production values in the primary content ensure a satisfying viewing experience.
In conclusion, while "Master of the Shadowless Kick: Wong Kei-Ying" may not introduce groundbreaking elements to the martial arts genre or historical biopics, it remains a noteworthy entry for enthusiasts. Its earnest storytelling and polished technical execution make it a recommended watch over its counterpart. Nevertheless, a more meticulous historical approach could further elevate future installments in this series. For those curious about HBO’s expansion into this cinematic tradition, this film serves as an encouraging preview.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
This presentation is very much in keeping with many of the aspects I discussed in the Master of the Drunken Fist: Beggar So Blu-ray review, with a digitally captured image that is generally very sharp...
Audio: 80
Also as with the other offering, I personally found the English voice acting to be less natural sounding than the original language track, though the English track does sound slightly more energetic, with...
Extras: 0
The Main Menu doesn't even offer a Scenes Selection option, as can be seen in screenshot 20 accompanying this review....
Movie: 60
However, as with Master of the Drunken Fist: Beggar So, this film's fight scenes often seem disconnected from the main narrative, and in fact the first one which features Wong Kei-Ying's mentor Lok (Yu...
Total: 60
There are already a number of films that at least feature this character, if not as the focal element than as the venerated father of Wong Fei-Hung, and I'm not sure if this made for television enterprise...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Colors are a bit muted too, never really boasting any bright color in any form of lighting....
Audio: 80
There is a good low end here with the fight scenes and score, which always adds to the emotional tone to the film....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
Along with Master of the Drunken Fist: Beggar So, this film is surely to appeal and appease the martial arts genre fanbase with two solid, if not flawed entries with room to improve for next time....
Total: 60
The characters and story will definitely hit a larger emotional note than other films in the genre....
Director: Jian Yong Guo
Actors: N/A
PlotWong Kei-Ying, a skilled physician and martial artist, resides in Guangzhou during the Qing Dynasty. Dedicated to helping his community, he witnesses the growing influence of opium and corrupt officials led by the malevolent governor, Lei Gong. When Lei Gong poisons Wong's mentor, Master Wu, in a plot to control the local opium trade, Wong pledges to bring justice to his fallen teacher and save his city from the clutches of the drug epidemic. As he delves deeper into this mission, Wong discovers a powerful and deadly martial arts technique, the Shadowless Kick, which requires immense discipline and precision.
In his quest, Wong encounters several challenges, including corrupt officials, ruthless henchmen, and the widespread corruption influenced by Lei Gong's men. Alongside a motley group of allies who rally to his cause, Wong must master the Shadowless Kick technique while maintaining his medical duties. With each confrontation, he sharpens his skills and strengthens his resolve. The conflicts intensify as Wong uncovers deeper layers of betrayal and deceit among those he once trusted. Testing both his martial arts prowess and his moral compass, Wong fights to uphold justice and honor in a tumultuous and dangerous era.
Writers: Xu Shengliang, Zhen Yan, Zhi Xiong Yu
Release Date: 26 Dec 2016
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: China
Language: Chinese