Le Magnifique Blu-ray Review
The Magnificent One The Man from Acapulco
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Le Magnifique's new Blu-ray offers a fun cinematic experience, but the outdated, problematic master hampers overall visual quality despite universal appeal.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 57
Le Magnifique's Blu-ray presentation by Kino Lorber in 1080p MPEG-4 AVC (1.661:1) frame is marred by problematic digital corrections, resulting in a smeary appearance and loss of detail in dark areas. While color grading and image stability are commendable, issues with DNR and compression affect fine details in motion.
Audio: 75
The Blu-ray of 'Le Magnifique' offers French and English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 tracks with clear and sharp audio, though the French track is preferable for better lip sync. Some action scenes lack depth, but the dynamic intensity and Claude Bolling's versatile score are commendable.
Extra: 56
The audio commentary by critics Berger, Mitchell, and Thompson offers an engaging and insightful deep dive into 'Le Magnifique,' covering its cultural touchpoints, exaggerated violence, and filmography context, and is complemented by a vintage trailer in French with English subtitles, enhancing appreciation for the film.
Movie: 81
Le Magnifique (1973) Blu-ray by Kino Lorber is a hilarious, multilayered parody of spy films, boosting outrageous action, clever mockeries, and standout performances, particularly by Jean-Paul Belmondo. The film's unique charm is enhanced with exclusive audio commentary and vintage trailers, delivering both visual spectacle and insightful context.
Video: 57
Presented in an aspect ratio of 1.66:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, Le Magnifique's Blu-ray transfer by Kino Lorber exhibits a 1080p resolution. Unfortunately, the release sourced from an older master provided by StudioCanal demonstrates several technical shortcomings. The transfer retains a digital sheen due to extensive digital corrections, leading to a notably smeary appearance. When observing darker scenes, the transfer reveals a lack of detailed nuances, often presenting vast chunks of undifferentiated black instead of proper shadow detail. The reduction of grain and the presence of sporadic electronic noise generate a harsh visual experience, particularly pronounced on larger screens. Despite these flaws, the color grading impressively honors Philippe de Broca's stylistic intent and the image stability remains commendable.
Shot on 35 mm film with Panavision equipment by cinematographer Rene Mathelin, Le Magnifique maintains its original 1.66:1 aspect ratio as framed for European theatrical presentations. The image integrity is generally clean, but textural issues arise due to either digital noise reduction (DNR) or compression challenges, even with a high bit rate. Fine detail remains present in static scenes but deteriorates notably during motion, illustrated starkly in sequences such as the park scene around the 01:13:30 timestamp where sand and grass details become obscure. Despite these image stability concerns, the color balance is well-executed, faithfully representing Mathelin's artistic vision through varied hues and earth tones that mirror the film’s complex narrative structure. Overall, while there are evident deficiencies in digital handling, the fundamental elements like color grading and framing meet a professional standard.
Audio: 75
The Blu-ray edition of "Le Magnifique" offers two primary audio tracks: French DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 and English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, both with optional English subtitles for the French track. The French audio track is particularly recommended due to its superior fidelity, as the original post-synced dialogue integrates better within the context of the film's production era. Despite some limitations inherent to the period's audio recording techniques, Claude Bolling’s dynamic score emanates impressive clarity and depth.
Both audio tracks deliver commendable clarity, sharpness, and balance, ensuring an engaging aural experience. While the overall dynamic intensity is adequate, the action sequences could benefit from more substantial depth, which would enhance the viewing experience. Importantly, no encoding anomalies were detected during our evaluation, pointing to a well-executed transfer. The English dubbing track is marred by notable lip-sync issues, particularly with Bisset’s performances originally rendered in French, making the French audio track the preferred option for an authentic auditory experience.
Extras: 56
The extras on the Blu-ray of "Le Magnifique" are a true cinephile’s delight, providing insightful content that enhances the overall viewing experience. The audio commentary by Howard S. Berger, Steve Mitchell, and Nathaniel Thompson stands out for its detailed exploration of the film’s historical and cultural context, the careers of primary actors, and several unique cinema trends. Their distinct perspectives ensure a rich, multifaceted analysis that complements the film's themes and layers. Particularly intriguing is Berger’s focus on “dummy deaths” and their thematic relevance. The vintage trailer, with its English subtitles, is a nostalgic touch, bringing viewers closer to the original release ambiance.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary: An in-depth audio commentary by critics Howard S. Berger, Steve Mitchell, and Nathaniel Thompson.
- Trailer: Vintage trailer for "Le Magnifique" in French, with English subtitles.
Movie: 81
Philippe de Broca's 1973 film, Le Magnifique, provides a delightful explosion of outrageous antics and brilliant satire, encapsulating the heights of comedic cinema. Starring Jean-Paul Belmondo as both superagent Bob Saint-Clar and his creator, a despondent novelist named Francois Merlin, the film layers flamboyant espionage with satirical self-awareness. Its action sequences are outlandishly exaggerated, highlighted by surreal feats such as construction worker-killers using a helicopter to drop a phone booth into the ocean, where it meets a befittingly ridiculous end. This blend of exaggerated action and playful parody is complemented by Jacqueline Bisset’s portrayal of the muse and femme fatale, who seamlessly transitions between the treacherous Tatiana and the oblivious neighbor Christine.
The genius of Le Magnifique lies in its self-referential devastation of not only spy films but their parodies, creating a double entendre of comedic narratives. The film’s humor is profoundly nuanced, with a great deal of mockery that remains potent due to the superb performances of its cast. Belmondo is entirely in his element, effortlessly switching personas from an over-the-top action hero to a hapless romantic writer. This combination crafts a compelling juxtaposition that fuels the film's whimsical yet sharp-edged humor. Furthermore, the stunt work is notable; Belmondo’s commitment to performing his own stunts infuses the film with authentic energy and risk, adding to the immersive spectacle.
In essence, Le Magnifique triumphantly oscillates between genres, delivering a cinematic adventure that defies normativity and embraces its wildly multifaceted identity. Its technical brilliance and narrative eccentricity ensure that this film remains a vibrant cornerstone in the landscape of both comedy and satire, making it a timeless classic worth revisiting.
Total: 66
"Le Magnifique" offers a delightful mix of exotic action, humor, and romance, making it an ideal summer film. Featuring the charm and talent of Jean-Paul Belmondo, the film is a fine example of Philippe de Broca's work, designed to entertain both die-hard fans of French cinema and newcomers alike. However, it's important to note that the Blu-ray release suffers from being sourced from an older, problematic master, giving the movie a somewhat unappealing digital appearance.
While one might hope for a master comparable to those used in high-quality StudioCanal releases like "The Professional" and "The Outsider," this Blu-ray unfortunately falls short. Despite its technical shortcomings, Kino's new Blu-ray still stands as the best available option for experiencing "Le Magnifique," especially if you lack access to a theater screening.
In conclusion, while "Le Magnifique" deserves a spot in any film enthusiast’s library for its universal appeal and engaging content, consider waiting for a discounted price due to its less-than-ideal visual presentation on this Blu-ray release.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 50
Grain is completely eliminated and in certain areas there is actually foreign electronic noise that produces plenty of harshness....
Audio: 90
However, I think that there are a few areas where the action footage could have a bit more depth....
Extras: 40
As usual, these gentlemen share plenty of interesting information about the era in which Le Magnifique was produced and the type of fun it offers, the careers of some of the principal actors, and a few...
Movie: 80
Yes, it does help that the actors doing the mocking are much better than the ones assisting Agent 077 as well, but there is a different type of attitude in Le Magnifique that is instantly felt, and it...
Total: 50
It's got all the exotic action and humor you might require to be entertained the right way, plus a decent dose of romance for your partner as well....
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 80
Fine detail is visible whenever everything is static, but as soon things are in motion, those same textures are occasionally smeared (the scene in the park starting at about the 01:13:30 mark is a prime...
Audio: 75
The entire film was post-synced, so the dialogue doesn’t integrate that well anyway, which is typical of European films of the era....
Extras: 80
The group discusses their own experiences of seeing the film for the first time, its shocking level of exaggerated violence, how it pays homage to specific cultural touchpoints from its era, and how much...
Movie: 90
Le Magnifique is a hilarious and multilayered 1973 comedy from director Philippe de Broca which manages to parody not just spy films of the era, but also the parodies of spy films, such as the Matt Helm...
Total: 81
Le Magnifique may not be that familiar to those who are not already fans of de Broca, Belmondo, or French cinema in general, but it has many universal qualities which should appeal to film fans of any...
Director: Philippe de Broca
Actors: Jean-Paul Belmondo, Jacqueline Bisset, Vittorio Caprioli
PlotFrançois Merlin, a humble and frustrated writer of spy novels, lives in Paris. He escapes his mundane existence by immersing himself into the fictional world of Bob Saint-Clar, a fearless and dashing secret agent invented by Merlin. Saint-Clar undertakes thrilling missions, battles villains, and saves beautiful women, all with unflinching bravado. His latest adventure centers around rescuing the captivating Tatiana from the evil clutches of Colonel Karpov while navigating various exotic locations and perilous situations.
In his real life, Merlin faces a series of frustrations including interactions with his overbearing editor. However, he draws inspiration from Christine, his charming neighbor, whom he envisions as Tatiana in his stories. The lines between Merlin’s reality and Saint-Clar’s fictional escapades blur as he begins to lose control over both his character and his own life, leading to unexpected twists and alterations that radically reshape his narrative.
Writers: Philippe de Broca, Vittorio Caprioli, Jean-Paul Rappeneau
Release Date: 23 Nov 1973
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: N/A
Country: France, Italy, Mexico
Language: French, English, Albanian