Immaculate Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 1 reviewers
Review Date:
Immaculate's horror ambitions falter with B-movie execution and flat performances, marred by formulaic writing and lethargic direction despite its bloody moments.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 65
The AVC encoded 2.00:1 image for 'Immaculate' effectively handles its gothic interiors and textured settings, though it occasionally struggles with compression artifacts like banding and mild posterization. Despite these issues, colors are well-preserved, with natural skin tones and distinct greenery.
Audio: 75
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA mix delivers crisp dialogue and balanced emotional undertones, with clear scoring cues and defined instrumentation. Choral offerings and atmospherics enhance spatial depth, and sound effects are effectively utilized, complemented by a robust low-end during violent scenes.
Extra: 46
Director Michael Mohan's commentary enriches the Blu Ray extras of 'Immaculate,' though its value is slightly diminished by the omission of a theatrical trailer.
Movie: 36
Immaculate," Michael Mohan's nunsploitation thriller, struggles to engage, blending Catholic oppression with macabre elements yet failing to deliver suspense or compelling character arcs. Sydney Sweeney’s understated performance and a script by Andrew Lobel lacking in fresh concepts further hinder the film's impact.
Video: 65
The video presentation for the Blu-ray edition of "Immaculate" is encapsulated in an AVC encoded image with a 2.00:1 aspect ratio. The film's distinct aesthetic is characterized by its interplay of darkness and candlelight which is especially prevalent in the feature's myriad gothic interiors. However, the compression occasionally struggles, leading to instances of banding and mild posterization. Despite these compression issues, the detail remains commendably sufficient. The atmospheric depth of the catacombs and exterior environments is well-captured, providing a decently dimensional visual experience.
Skin textures are rendered with an acceptable level of precision, successfully portraying both weathered faces and youthful visages. The intricate details in costuming, like heavy habits and damp bathing outfits, exhibit a passable fibrous quality. The color palette effectively complements the film's darker tones, ensuring golden hues in candlelit scenes and maintaining the cooler ambiance of various living spaces. Notably, greenery and natural skin tones are reproduced with distinct fidelity. Overall, the delineation within scenes is adequate, ensuring a visually coherent and engaging viewing experience.
Audio: 75
In the realm of audio presentation, "Immaculate" on Blu-ray delivers a profoundly immersive experience through its 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix. Dialogue exchanges are rendered crisply, even with the challenge of heavy accents, ensuring no nuance is lost. Emotional peaks are well-managed, maintaining an equilibrium that prevents discordance. The score’s cues are meticulously defined, allowing every instrumental nuance to come through as the film's moods shift. Choral elements are particularly noteworthy, spreading into the surrounds with remarkable clarity, enhancing the auditory landscape.
Equally impressive is the use of atmospheric sound to establish a sense of location and environmental detail. Room tones and group activities are distinctly marked, creating a vivid auditory image of each scene's setting. Sound effects punctuate the release’s aural narrative effectively, adding to the film's tension and fear factors with precision. Additionally, the low-end frequency responses handle the weight of violent events admirably, providing a substantive impact without overwhelming other elements in the soundstage. This blend of technical details and precise balance makes for an engaging audio experience.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray release of "Immaculate" offers a highly satisfying array of extras that significantly enhance the viewing experience. The director's commentary provided by Michael Mohan is particularly insightful, delivering critical behind-the-scenes knowledge and explanations of creative decisions. Despite the absence of a theatrical trailer, the collection of supplementary materials ensures an in-depth exploration of the film's development and impact. Each extra is meticulously crafted, offering high production quality and relevant content that will appeal to fans and cinephiles alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary: Features director Michael Mohan discussing his creative process.
Movie: 36
"Immaculate," scripted by Andrew Lobel in his debut feature-length screenplay, attempts to combine Catholic oppression with macabre elements in an entry to the nunsploitation genre but falls short of delivering effective suspense. Directed by Michael Mohan, known for "Save the Date" and "The Voyeurs," the film lacks the requisite frights and tension to leave a lasting impact. Sydney Sweeney, starring as Cecilia, struggles to convey the depth of panic her role demands. The scene is set with her character moving from Detroit to an isolated Italian convent, where she prepares for final vows while contending with unexplained pregnancy. Unfortunately, the script and direction fail to exploit this intriguing premise fully.
The film's atmosphere hints at underlying malevolence, starting strong with a harrowing escape attempt by a young nun that sets up an initial sense of danger. However, this sinister undertone wanes as the narrative shifts focus to mundane explorations of convent life and religious health care practices. Cecilia meets Sister Gwen (Benedetta Porcaroli) and Father Sal (Alvaro Morte), who introduce her to the facility's routines and relics, including a sacred nail purportedly used in Jesus' crucifixion. Despite these elements, the plot meanders without meaningful progression or suspense, reducing impactful moments—like Cecilia's miraculous survival from childhood trauma—into mere anecdotal additions rather than pivotal plot points.
Mohan’s direction centers heavily on creating mood rather than tension. Key reveals and exploratory sequences lack the emotional punch needed to move the narrative forward effectively. The potentially shocking twist of Cecilia’s virgin pregnancy fails to evoke a strong response from either the character or the audience, leaving much of the film in an uneventful limbo. Ultimately, "Immaculate" does not succeed in making its sinister premise compelling, mostly due to an underwhelming script and lackluster character development, which together squander an opportunity for truly disturbing cinematic storytelling.
Total: 62
The Blu-ray release of "Immaculate" is marked by an uneven pacing that finds its stride in the final act. Director Nathan Mohan attempts to build tension through Cecilia's journey, but he often falls back on horror clichés, including predictably staged chases through creepy convent catacombs. Instead of achieving the haunting, atmospheric dread that the premise suggests, the film leans into B-movie territory, delivering more gore than genuine scares. The technical aspects of the Blu-ray are competent, with clear audio and visual fidelity, though the direction falls short in maintaining a gripping horror narrative.
The performance of Sydney Sweeney as Cecilia is another notable weak point. Sweeney fails to evoke the necessary curiosity, danger, or despair that her character's arc demands. Her portrayal often feels flat, resorting to excessive screaming that fails to carry emotional weight. This is particularly jarring given the film's reliance on her character to anchor the story. Despite the high production values and clear visuals, the writing and pacing never fully commit to either a psychological or visceral horror experience, instead opting for a middle-of-the-road approach that could leave many fans wanting more.
In conclusion, "Immaculate" on Blu-ray may satisfy hardcore horror enthusiasts looking for a quick fix of blood and conventional scares, but it misses the mark on delivering a compelling and cohesive narrative. The film’s technical presentation is solid, with commendable clarity and sound quality, but ultimately, lackluster direction and uninspired performances diminish its potential. A more adventurous script and captivating lead could have elevated it considerably.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 70
Detail is acceptable, handling the gothic interiors of the church and textures in secret areas....
Audio: 80
Sound effects are appreciable, with the endeavor using a lot of aural events to conjure its fear factor....
Extras: 50
...
Movie: 40
Exploratory sequences are included to add a level of mystery, with Cecilia spotting marks on patients she can't explain, and she's offered time with Father Sal and his devotion, protecting a nail he claims...
Total: 60
Cecilia would probably be more interesting with someone else in the part, but real thespian might still has to deal with writing that's never adventurous, sticking with formula, while direction is lethargic,...
Director: Michael Mohan
Actors: Sydney Sweeney, Álvaro Morte, Simona Tabasco
PlotCecilia, a young woman struggling with a dark past, escapes to a remote Italian convent seeking solace and redemption. Enclosed within the convent's ancient walls and under the watchful eyes of the strict and enigmatic Mother Superior, Cecilia attempts to find peace and purpose through ritual and prayer. Her solace is disrupted when a series of sinister and inexplicable events befall the convent, leaving Cecilia to question her sanity as she experiences haunting visions and uncovers cryptic messages seemingly meant for her.
As Cecilia delves deeper, she discovers that not everything is as it appears within the convent. The nuns harbor secrets of their own, and the malevolent forces at play prove to be more palpable than spiritual. Cecilia's quest for redemption turns into a battle for survival as she confronts the hidden truths and forces lurking in the shadows. The line between reality and delusion blurs, drawing Cecilia into a chilling quest to uncover the darkness that threatens to consume not just her but everyone around her.
Writers: Andrew Lobel
Release Date: 22 Mar 2024
Runtime: 89 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Italy
Language: English, Italian