One-Armed Boxer Blu-ray Review
獨臂拳王 Du bei chuan wang
Score: 58
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
One-Armed Boxer delivers relentless action with a classic Shaw Brothers touch, complemented by Arrow's appealing supplements for enthusiasts.
Disc Release Date
Video: 58
Arrow Video's Blu-ray of 'One-Armed Boxer' presents a 1080p AVC encoded transfer, maintaining its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio, with original Mandarin and English monaural tracks. Although restored in 2K, occasional focus issues, slight color fade, and minimal print damage are present; however, grain resolution and detail in close-ups, along with clear facial definition and vibrant costume colors, enhance the experience.
Audio: 53
One-Armed Boxer offers three DTS-HD Master Audio Mono tracks, featuring two Mandarin versions and an English dub, adorned with Isaac Hayes' iconic 'Shaft' score elements. Despite crackling high-end and muddy bass affecting music clarity, dialogue remains consistently clear with optional English subtitles.
Extra: 66
The Blu-ray extras for 'One-Armed Boxer' are robust, including a 41-minute interview with Jimmy Wang Yu, insightful commentary by Frank Djeng, and a well-curated gallery of nostalgic trailers and imagery. Arrow's presentation is enhanced by a detailed insert booklet and distinct packaging, immersing fans in both the film's legacy and context.
Movie: 61
Relentlessly action-packed, 'One-Armed Boxer' blends frenetic combat choreography with nationalist themes, and though it lacks the refined choreography of later Shaw Brothers films, its inventive and surreal fight scenes offer distinctive charm. Featuring an unconventional narrative structure, it remains a cult classic.
Video: 58
The Blu-ray release of "One-Armed Boxer" by Arrow Video presents an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. The restoration was conducted in 2K resolution from original film elements by Fortune Star, offering both the original Mandarin and English monaural soundtracks along with an alternative Mandarin mono track featuring different musical scores. While the presentation maintains a reasonably intact palette, there are visible signs of wear with certain scenes displaying focus issues, likely originating from outdated aspects of the workflow. However, close-ups deliver commendable detail and the grain structure maintains a mostly natural appearance, with occasional spikes.
Though the 2K scan is decent, it can be described as unremarkable for a Blu-ray release, exhibiting minimal print damage with generally intact grain. The detail is often organic and clear, yet wide shots reveal slight sharpening which is minimally effective. The HD transfer captures facial definition effectively, positioning "One-Armed Boxer" appropriately for high-definition viewing. The color saturation shows signs of fading over time, yet primary colors have moments that shine, particularly with costuming in vibrant blues and reds. The backdrop's pale earth tones maintain consistency with few instances of visible dust and dirt, allowing the overall print to show limited aging effects.
The contrast levels contribute positively to the imagery by keeping it bright, albeit with modest black levels that do not achieve extensive depth. Despite minor flaws, this Blu-ray's video presentation successfully delivers an engaging and visually enjoyable experience for martial arts genre enthusiasts while preserving much of the film's vintage charm.
Audio: 53
The audio presentation of "One-Armed Boxer" on Blu-ray features two Mandarin tracks and one English track, all presented in DTS-HD Master Audio Mono. The Mandarin tracks are notable for their usage of borrowed cues from Isaac Hayes' iconic score for "Shaft," causing a mix of humor and disarray for Western audiences. These cues, unfortunately, are not seamlessly integrated, resulting in a jarring experience. Despite this, dialogue retains its clarity and timbre reasonably well, standing resilient against aging imperfections. Optional English subtitles are available for viewers seeking to maintain comprehension over occasionally challenging audio conditions.
Technically, each track is marred by a predominantly brittle high end; the music exhibits significant strain and can even verge on distortion due to a rampant muddy bass presence. This creates an audio environment where the nuances of both scores suffer tremendously, affecting the listening experience. The recognizable fight sound effects also fall victim to the malfunctioning top-end treble, although the dialogue remains consistently audible, albeit naturally worn and slightly scratchy over time. Despite these issues, the primary concern lies in the music's presentation rather than the spoken elements, which manage to uphold their integrity across each track option.
Extras: 66
The Blu-ray edition of "One-Armed Boxer" offers an engaging selection of extras, providing a comprehensive dive into the film and its legacy. Frank Djeng delivers insightful commentary that enriches the viewer's understanding of the film's context and production. The standout feature is a 41-minute interview with Jimmy Wang Yu, sourced from the Frederic Ambroisine Archive, which provides a candid look at his career, although users are warned about intermittent audio dropouts. The package is rounded out with various trailers, an image gallery, and more, showcasing Arrow's attention to detail and commitment to quality presentation. The disc is further enhanced by an informative insert booklet with essays and additional materials, complete with eye-catching reversible artwork.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary by Frank Djeng: Provides insightful analysis.
- Interview with Wang Yu: In-depth career discussion.
- Alternate English Credits: Alternate view of film credits.
- Trailer Gallery: Collection of promotional materials.
- Image Gallery: Collection of film stills.
- Insert Booklet: Includes essays and cast/crew information, with reversible artwork.
Movie: 61
The film "One-Armed Boxer" offers a relentless barrage of fight scenes, which begin as soon as the opening credits roll. Directed by and starring Jimmy Wang Yu, the film opens on a hyper-kinetic note, as Yu Tien Lung finds himself embroiled in an escalating conflict with the Hook Gang over a seemingly trivial altercation. The plot quickly dispenses with conventional exposition to deliver a nonstop sequence of combat. Remarkably, Yu is introduced with both arms intact, only to lose one nearly an hour into its brisk 90-minute runtime—a significant and somewhat delayed turning point considering the film's focus. Instead of traditional narrative development, the film opts for a photo montage to illustrate Yu's recuperation—a creative choice that has divided viewers but undoubtedly adds to the film’s distinctive style.
"One-Armed Boxer" pushes martial arts drama to unapologetically vivid extremes. Competing schools and global fighters—ranging from Tibetan monks to Japanese martial arts masters—join the fray, tinging the film with nationalist tones reflective of early 1970s Hong Kong anxieties. While the fight choreography may not showcase the later Shaw Brothers' complexity, it compensates with enthusiastic ferocity and curious wirework techniques. The cinematics take an almost surreal turn with Wang Yu's enchanting new abilities post-injury, including outlandish feats such as upright movements from prone positions and high-octane torpedo-like attacks. These imaginative elements interject a surrealist flavor, ensuring the film is both bizarrely goofy and spirited enough to stand apart from its contemporaries.
In summary, "One-Armed Boxer" epitomizes the dynamic energy common to early martial arts cinema, albeit with its own unique idiosyncrasies. While its execution may wade into caricature, it remains an important milestone for connoisseurs of cinema history, heralding future evolutions in the martial arts genre and captivating audiences with sheer inventiveness and chaotic charm.
Total: 58
The "One-Armed Boxer" Blu-ray release from Arrow Video delivers a thrilling throwback to martial arts cinema, encapsulating the raw energy and action-driven narrative that defined early 1970s Hong Kong films. The film, under the vision of Jimmy Wang Yu and produced by Golden Harvest, hurls viewers into relentless crescendoing sequences of hand-to-hand combat that rarely allow room for reprieve. The storyline may be simplistic and somewhat predictable, leaning heavily on nationalism and classic revenge motifs, yet it masterfully sidesteps narrative pitfalls through sheer kinetic momentum and visceral fight choreography.
This release shines technically, though improvements could enhance the overall experience. The visual restoration impresses with much better clarity and color fidelity compared to previous versions, capturing the vibrant chaos of its fight scenes effectively. However, some remnants of grain and occasional inconsistencies in sound mix slightly detract from an otherwise solid transfer. Arrow Video compensates for these minor issues with a substantial array of supplements, enriching the viewing experience with insightful extras that delve into the film's historical and cultural significance and development process.
Ultimately, "One-Armed Boxer" is both a nostalgic delight for connoisseurs of Hong Kong cinema and a testament to the era's dynamic martial arts feats. Despite its structural unevenness, the relentless pace makes it an engaging watch. This Blu-ray is a worthy addition for collectors, offering a robust package that capitalizes on both filmic merit and supplementary content, celebrating a pivotal era in martial arts cinema conceived under Raymond Chow's strategic vision post-Shaw Brothers. Arrow Video's effort in presenting this cult classic ensures that it remains accessible and appealing to new and old audiences alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
While there does seem to be a bit of fade, as evidenced by slightly brown flesh tones and the like, on the whole the palette reproduction is probably one of this transfer's assets....
Audio: 60
One of the film's unavoidably hilarious aspects for Western viewers is going to be its use of a certain iconic Oscar winning score from a 1970s film classic that may have some viewers chiming in with a...
Extras: 80
Commentary by Frank Djeng Interview with Wang Yu (HD; 41:16) is another fantastic piece culled from the Frederic Ambroisine Archive....
Movie: 70
What's kind of curious about One Armed Boxer is its basic structure, which (per the above) takes almost an hour to get to the point where Chao Liu and the Hook Gang do in fact not just defeat Han Tui and...
Total: 70
Structurally, One Armed Boxer is perhaps understandably a little lopsided, and if its underlying plot premise is more than familiar, the action is so relentless that few will probably care....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
Wide shots leave behind the suggestion of slight sharpening, although it’s to minimal effect....
Audio: 60
Extras: 60
An interview with Jimmy Wang Yu dates back to 2001, running a hefty 41-minutes as the actor recounts his career....
Movie: 60
Even the traditional training montage cuts itself short, but a few minutes total, and after losing his arm, Wang-Yu’s recovery is recounted in a few still images, nothing more....
Total: 60
A pure Shaw Brothers delight, One-Armed Boxer is a mixture of nonsense, nationalism, and near constant brawling....
Director: Jimmy Wang Yu
Actors: Jimmy Wang Yu, Yeh Tien, Hsin Tang
PlotIn a small town in China, a martial arts school led by a skilled instructor stands as a popular hub for local students. The school finds itself in conflict with a rival dojo specializing in deadly techniques. Tensions between the two escalate when the antagonist school seeks to dominate the local martial arts scene by any means necessary. During a confrontation, the rival school hires a notorious group of assassins, consisting of various international martial arts experts, who launch a ruthless attack on the hero's school. In the chaos, the protagonist, a talented fighter from the peaceful school, loses his arm in a violent encounter. Defeated and devastated, the protagonist retreats, consumed by a desire for revenge but hindered by his newfound disability.
During his solitude, the fighter discovers an elderly herbalist who takes pity on him and teaches him unique techniques that maximize his remaining strength and agility despite his injury. As he trains, he transforms his handicap into a powerful asset, honing specialized skills that few can match. With renewed determination, he embarks on a journey to confront those who wronged him and restore honor to his devastated school. Along the way, he faces fierce adversaries, each adept in different fighting styles, testing his newfound abilities to their limits. Empowered by his mentor's teachings and driven by justice, he prepares for a final confrontation with those responsible for his suffering.
Writers: Jimmy Wang Yu
Release Date: N/A
Runtime: 93 min
Rating: R
Country: Taiwan, Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin