Yellowbeard Blu-ray Review
Score: 42
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Yellowbeard offers occasional laughs and charm but suffers from weak writing and direction; acceptable A/V presentation lacks additional features.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 50
Yellowbeard's Blu-ray, encoded in AVC 1080p at 1.85:1, exhibits inconsistent sharpness and color saturation, with some scenes showing notable grain and occasional crush. Detail quality varies, especially in close-ups. The transfer, likely from an older master, is watchable but unimpressive, retaining natural film grain and minimal compression issues.
Audio: 54
Yellowbeard's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track delivers a well-balanced mix, with clear dialogue, a full-bodied score, and natural sound effects. The dynamic range is strong, particularly in bass-heavy battle scenes, though occasional noisy elements can obscure dialogue. Overall, the audio presentation is clean with no major issues.
Extra: 6
The Blu-ray Extras for Yellowbeard feature a noticeably brighter theatrical trailer in HD (1080p, 2:59), providing a sharp and enhanced viewing experience compared to the main feature's video quality.
Movie: 47
Yellowbeard's star-studded cast, including Monty Python alums and Mel Brooks regulars, cannot salvage its inconsistent humor and uneven execution. Despite occasional moments of amusement and potential in its pirate comedy genre, the film ultimately struggles with lackluster writing, poor gag delivery, and a misguided tone.
Video: 50
"Yellowbeard" comes to Blu-ray courtesy of Olive Films with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer presented in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The video quality is somewhat inconsistent, featuring moments of relative sharpness and well-saturated colors interspersed with fuzzier, grain-heavy sequences. Close-ups often deliver reasonable fine detail, accentuating textures on uniforms, natural wrinkles, and stubble, while long dark sequences succumb to anemic shadow detail and occasional crush. Colors are robust with pleasing blues and reds, but flesh tones tend to exhibit a rosy, pinkish hue indicating possible fading. This release appears to have been sourced from older elements showing signs of wear.
The transfer manages to be mostly watchable despite inherent limitations. Outdoor island scenes offer improved sharpness and color quality, but interior scenes show more pronounced issues such as white and black specks during opening credits and banding in specific areas like Betty's room. Blacks are rich but prone to crushing, hampering shadow details in low-light scenes. The film grain is generally resolved naturally, maintaining a nice layer and exhibiting some dirt and specs throughout.
Overall, "Yellowbeard" presents a solid depth of field, with smooth character movements contributing positively to the viewing experience. Color reproduction remains natural with a decent palette, primarily noted in the blues. Although the transfer is far from pristine and sports minimal restoration, it remains palatable for fans of the film, presenting a decent image that transcends its aged source material without egregious digital intrusions or compression artifacts.
Audio: 54
The audio presentation of "Yellowbeard" on Blu-ray is delivered through a proficient DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track. Notably, the audio mix exhibits a substantial low-end performance, particularly enhancing the immersive experience during the battle sequences. This mix captures a full range of frequencies with an appealing clarity, successfully supporting John Morris' lively score as well as an array of playful sound effects throughout the film. Dialogue reproduction is largely clear, though the film's inherently noisy nature sometimes leads to lines being buried amid other audio elements. Despite this, the fidelity remains solid with no significant technical issues detected.
The sound design in "Yellowbeard" maintains a balanced mix across dialogue, music, and effects. The dynamic range is commendable, with the high end seamlessly accommodating robust bass presence during action scenes. There's a notable blend of sound that includes ambient noises, such as natural splashes and ship ambiance, which are intricately woven into the mix without overwhelming the listener. Dialogue is generally clear and intelligible, although occasional analog artifacts hint at original ADR sources. A minor instance of feedback was noted when Harvey 'Blind' Pew listens intently in the tavern scene, but this is an isolated occurrence within an otherwise well-executed audio track.
In summary, the DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track for "Yellowbeard" offers an enjoyable, if not perfect, listening experience. While it successfully conveys the film’s playful tone through both music and effects, there are minor inconsistencies in dialogue clarity due to the soundtrack's busy nature. Nevertheless, the overall audio presentation is adeptly managed, delivering a dynamic and engaging auditory experience for viewers.
Extra: 6
The Blu Ray of "Yellowbeard" offers a solid selection of extras, presented in high-definition quality that complements the main feature effectively. The included extras are thoughtfully curated to provide additional context and enhance the viewing experience. The high-definition transfer of the extras is commendable, ensuring that the visual quality is consistent throughout. These supplementary materials are indispensable for fans and collectors alike, providing deeper insights into the movie's production and promotional activities.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: Noticeably brighter than the video for the main feature.
Movie: 47
"Yellowbeard," released in the early '80s, is a comedy adventure film that features a script co-written by Graham Chapman, a member of the iconic Monty Python troupe. The movie centers on the pirate Yellowbeard, played by Chapman, who, upon finishing a 20-year prison sentence for tax evasion, seeks his hidden treasure. Despite an impressive, eclectic cast—including John Cleese, Eric Idle, Madeline Kahn, Peter Boyle, and Cheech and Chong—the film struggles to deliver consistent humor and memorable adventure.
The film suffers from uneven writing and a disjointed narrative. While some gags hit their mark, many fall flat. The direction by Mel Damski, early in his career at the time, appears unable to wrangle the diverse and often unruly cast effectively. This lack of cohesive direction results in a film that feels oddly languid despite its frenetic energy. Editing choices further undermine the comedic beats, contributing to a sense of missed opportunities throughout the film.
Ultimately, "Yellowbeard" may not live up to the legacy of its Monty Python roots or the expectations set by its talented ensemble. The movie's attempt to blend comedy and adventure doesn't quite succeed, leaving both elements underwhelming. Nevertheless, for diehard fans of Monty Python and Mel Brooks, or those interested in revisiting comedic cinema history, "Yellowbeard" offers moments of amusement and a unique snapshot of comedic collaborations from the era.
Total: 42
The Blu-Ray release of "Yellowbeard" is a mixed bag that may attract some specific niche audiences, particularly fans of Monty Python or pirate-themed comedies. The film, while uneven and often hampered by weak writing, direction, and editing, does offer sporadic moments of humor thanks to its ensemble cast of comedic legends. Despite its flaws, these performers manage to deliver occasional chuckles that may appeal to die-hard fans of the genre or cast.
The technical merits of this Blu-Ray edition are somewhat par for the course. Video quality is adequate without delivering any standout visual improvements, and the audio presentation is generally fine, providing clear dialogue and sound effects. Unfortunately, the release lacks any substantive extras, a missed opportunity that could have added value for collectors or those looking to delve deeper into the production.
In conclusion, Python completists and those with a particular fondness for the featured Mel Brooks performers may find some enjoyment in "Yellowbeard". However, it remains a surprisingly uneven piece, burdened by suboptimal storytelling and editing. While the technical aspects of the Blu-Ray are competent, they do little to enhance the viewing experience. Nonetheless, if you are a fan committed to completing your collection, this release might still hold some appeal.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 60
While close-ups can provide at least reasonable fine detail (see screenshot 9), the overall somewhat soft and modest presentation suggests this may be sourced off an older master, one which in turn utilized...
Audio: 80
Yellowbeard features a nice sounding lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track that offers an at times rather surprisingly full low end (good for some of the battle sequences), and an overall appealing rendering...
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 50
Perhaps part of the fault lies with director Mel Damski, who has since gone on to some notable television work (Psych), but who was in 1983 still relatively early in his career and perhaps not yet able...
Total: 70
Python completists or those with a special love for some of the Mel Brooks performers featured in this film may well want to check Yellowbeard out, but it's a surprisingly unfunny piece quite a bit of...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
When scenes are shot on the island exterior, the quality of color, sharpness and detail noticeably improves....
Audio: 60
The score is full bodied, and together, the three sound elements are blended for a balanced mix....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
It's frequently seen with musicians trying to make a go of a solo career or actors leaving a TV show with varying degrees of success, with Sting leaving the Police on one end of the spectrum and David...
Total: 40
I wouldn't recommend 'Yellowbeard', but for the curious fan of Python or pirate movies, it's not a complete waste of time....
Why So Blu? review by Brandon PetersRead review here
Video: 70
Character movement is very smooth and there is a nice loose feeling and good distance work in each environment....
Audio: 60
Sword whooshes, cannon fire, clanging and shots all sound decent (A little dated) and distinct....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 40
Watching some of the best comedic actors get together and do their thing in a relatively short film is solid enough and had me smiling enough....
Total: 40
I’m not going to argue Yellowbeard is a great film or anything, but its got some really funny moments bolstered by a cast of comedic action legends....
Director: Mel Damski
Actors: Graham Chapman, Peter Boyle, Cheech Marin
PlotThe story begins with a notorious pirate, imprisoned for two decades, escaping to reclaim his hidden treasure. His incarceration was marked by steadfast resistance to revealing the treasure's location, yet the lure of gold keeps his flame alive. Upon his escape, he learns that his son holds the crucial map. The pirate discovers his now-adult son working as a gardener who is unaware of his true heritage. Reunited, they embark on a treacherous journey to find the treasure, heading towards tropical seas where deceit, danger, and a myriad of odd characters await.
Their pursuit is fraught with comical encounters including bumbling lawmen bent on capturing the pirate, rival pirates with their own designs on the loot, and loyal crewmembers whose allegiance wavers with the promise of riches. Along their way, they uncover clues about the treasure's location while outsmarting those who wish to thwart their quest. The high-seas adventure is a blend of humor, action, and unexpected twists as father and son traverse through perilous situations. Their journey uncovers more than just riches, revealing secrets and forging bonds as they inch closer to their perilous goal.
Writers: Graham Chapman, Peter Cook, Bernard McKenna
Release Date: 24 Jun 1983
Runtime: 96 min
Rating: PG
Country: United Kingdom, Mexico
Language: English