Romance on the High Seas Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 78
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
"Romance on the High Seas" shines with a fresh 4K transfer, lively Technicolor, catchy musical numbers, and Doris Day's breakout performance—highly recommended!
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 92
Warner Archive delivers an exceptional 1080p transfer from a new 4K scan of original nitrate negatives, showcasing Romance on the High Seas with exquisite Technicolor reproduction, impeccable clarity, and natural flesh tones. This meticulously clean transfer is free from artifacts, making for a visually stunning and immersive experience.
Audio: 82
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix provides clear, well-balanced dialogue and music, with notable depth and fidelity in both Day's vocals and Heindorf's orchestrations. Free of defects like hiss or pops, the mix expertly combines dialogue, sound effects, and background score, preserving the original theatrical experience exquisitely.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray extras for 'Romance on the High Seas' include immediate song access, a not-yet-remastered 1948 Bugs Bunny short, a sing-along featurette with classic Warner Bros. musical numbers, and a remastered HD theatrical trailer featuring a unique duet between Doris Day and Janis Paige.
Movie: 74
"Romance on the High Seas" is a delightful musical comedy, elevated by Doris Day's charming and sincere debut, catchy Jule Styne-Sammy Cahn tunes, and vibrant Technicolor cinematography. Supported by a talented cast and a solid script from the Epstein brothers and I.A.L. Diamond, the film's well-crafted mistaken identity plot ensures an engaging viewing experience. Warner Archive's Blu-ray release boasts an exceptional 4K-sourced transfer, making it a must-have for die-hard fans.
Video: 92
Warner Archive delivers an exceptional video presentation for "Romance on the High Seas," surpassing expectations with a meticulously crafted 1080p transfer. Sourced from a pristine 4K scan of the original nitrate Technicolor negatives, the transfer is exceptional in clarity, color accuracy, and detail resolution. This visual treatment enhances the viewing experience, making every frame sparkle with eye-catching vibrancy. Textures and fine details—down to the crispness of double-breasted suits and intricate furniture—are faithfully preserved, thanks to the absence of excessive noise reduction, compression artifacts, or banding.
The Technicolor palette is a standout element, featuring a beautiful range of coordinated interiors and lively hues from balloons, open markets, and tropical fruits. Skin tones appear natural and stable, adding to the realistic appeal. The deep black levels provide a solid foundation for the rich contrast spectrum, while bright whites help balance out the vivid colors. Additionally, the preservation of a fine grain structure maintains the celluloid feel, lending authenticity to every scene.
Overall, the transfer adheres to the original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.37:1, utilizing the AVC codec for impeccable sharpness and clarity. Each frame is free from nicks, marks, or scratches, resulting in a clean and pristine print. The attention to detail extends to costume textures and background elements, all vividly rendered without appearing garish. This high-quality transfer of "Romance on the High Seas" is not only visually stunning but also a testament to Warner Archive's dedication to preserving classic cinema in its most appealing form.
Audio: 82
The DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio mix of "Romance on the High Seas" delivers a robust audio experience that likely surpasses the original theatrical presentations. Dialogue and background effects are clear and well-balanced, with diegetic elements harmoniously integrated. The musical numbers, particularly the ones involving Doris Day, are a standout, highlighting her silky smooth voice with notable fidelity and tonal depth. The mix successfully handles the highs and lows of Ray Heindorf's lush orchestrations without any distortion, providing a seamless audio experience.
The sound mixing effectively creates the atmosphere of an ocean liner at sea, incorporating dialogue, crowd chatter, and occasional sound effects like foghorns to enhance the studio-bound action. The soundtrack showcases Jule Styne/Sammy Cahn tunes such as "Put ‘Em in a Box," "It’s You or No One," and "I’m in Love," with Day's performances accompanied by either a small jazz ensemble or a full orchestra. Each musical piece is delivered with excellent dynamic scale, ensuring the audio retains its richness and clarity throughout.
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track remains faithful to the era's sound, with no signs of age-related hiss, pops, crackle, or flutter. The dialogue is prioritized and easy to comprehend, expertly combined with the orchestrations and sound effects for an appealing mono soundtrack. Optional English SDH subtitles are provided, perfectly formatted with no sync issues. This audio presentation is both technically proficient and engaging, capturing the essence of the film's musical and narrative elements.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras for "Romance on the High Seas" provide a delightful blend of nostalgia and entertainment, carefully curated to enhance the viewer's appreciation of classic cinema. The vintage features, including a memorable Bugs Bunny short and an engaging sing-along session, transport audiences back to the golden age of film and music, despite some limitations in video quality. Each extra is thoughtfully presented, with highlights such as high-definition remastering of the theatrical trailer offering a refined viewing experience. This collection serves as an excellent companion to the main feature, celebrating the rich heritage of Warner Bros. musical productions.
Extras included in this disc:
- Song Selection: Immediate access to all 11 of the main songs featured in the film.
- Hare Splitter: A classic 1948 Bugs Bunny short in SD quality.
- Let's Sing A Song From the Movies: A 1948 sing-along featurette with classic songs from Warner musicals.
- Theatrical Trailer: A remastered HD promotional piece for the film.
Movie: 74
Michael Curtiz's "Romance on the High Seas" remains an exceptional entry in the Golden Age of Hollywood musicals, marking the debut of Doris Day, whose radiant performance catapulted her to stardom. The film, initially slated for Betty Hutton, saw Day fill the role when Hutton became pregnant—a serendipitous twist that resulted in Day's charming screen presence. She delivers a polished, unaffected performance, showcasing her vocal prowess and endearing warmth. The story revolves around Elvira Kent (Janis Paige) and her husband Michael (Don DeFore), intertwined with mistaken identities and romantic mix-ups. Day, tasked with impersonating Elvira on a cruise, captivates audiences with her natural charisma, making her the heart of the film.
The film benefits immensely from its talented ensemble cast, including Jack Carson as the private detective, and a slew of supporting actors like Oscar Levant and S.Z. Sakall. Notably, the screenplay by Julius and Philip Epstein, with contributions from I.A.L. Diamond, ensures the plot maintains a brisk, engaging pace despite its convolutions. Busby Berkeley's choreography, while not as flamboyant as his previous work, still impresses, particularly in "The Tourist Trade". The musical score by Jule Styne and Sammy Cahn is another highlight, with standout numbers including the Oscar-nominated "It's Magic". Day's renditions of these songs are magnetic, further solidifying her breakout status.
Technicolor cinematography by Elwood Bredell adds to the film’s allure, giving it a vibrant and visually striking quality that enhances the exotic shipboard and port settings. Warner Archive Collection’s Blu-ray release does justice to this visual splendor, providing a 4K-sourced transfer that surpasses previous editions. The disc's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track ensures the delightful score is heard in clear detail. While the bonus features may be sparse, the high-quality transfer underscores why this edition will please die-hard fans and new viewers alike. In essence, "Romance on the High Seas" stands as a testament to Day’s lasting impact and the film's enduring charm.
Total: 78
Review of "Romance on the High Seas" Blu-ray Release
Michael Curtiz's "Romance on the High Seas" remains a delightful cinematic gem over seven decades later, largely due to its sharp script, infectious musical numbers, and standout performances, particularly the breakout role of Doris Day. This film also serves as an excellent time capsule, showcasing the era's outstanding production design and impeccable detail. Warner Archive has done justice to this classic with a stellar Blu-ray release, featuring an exceptional 4K-sourced transfer. The visual and audio fidelity of this disc is among Warner Archive's finest efforts, making it a noteworthy addition to any collection of classic comedies and musicals.
The film thrives on its light-hearted, tuneful charm, vivid Technicolor visuals, and an exemplary cast, making it an ideal piece of escapist entertainment. Doris Day's debut performance is a highlight, capturing the audience with her fresh-faced charm and velvet-toned voice. Her renditions of songs like "It's Magic" and "Put 'Em in a Box, Tie 'Em with a Ribbon" are timeless, underscoring her natural talent. Directed by Michael Curtiz with his usual flair, the film features spirited performances from Jack Carson, Janis Paige, and Don DeFore. The new restoration brings out the vibrant Technicolor hues and crisp audio, making it seem like the musical was produced just yesterday.
Though the bonus features could offer more depth, Warner Archive’s release still stands out for its exceptional transfer quality and nostalgic value. The inclusion of theatrical trailers and vintage supplements adds to the viewing experience. In conclusion, "Romance on the High Seas" on Blu-ray is highly recommended for fans of classic musicals and Doris Day aficionados. This release not only preserves an important piece of cinema history but also enhances it with modern restoration techniques, making it a must-have for any classic film collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 100
Fine detail and textures are perfectly resolved, from crisp double-breasted suits to stylish furniture and other props, while the silvery sheen of its nitrate stock also contributes to the film's extremely...
Audio: 90
No obvious defects could be detected including sync issues, drop-outs, volume fluctuations, hissing, or pops -- just pure, unfiltered audio that reliably gets the job done, often with several layers that...
Extras: 40
Let's Sing A Song From the Movies (10:43) - This 1948 installment of WB's "Memories from Melody Lane" offers a brief look at classic songs featured in early sound films, including Billie Holliday's "Am...
Movie: 80
It might not be an bonafide career highlight for everyone involved, but Romance on the High Seas is still a very watchable and well-crafted film that still has the capacity to surprise and excite new audiences....
Total: 80
Although the bonus features leave something to be desired, this is otherwise a fantastic disc that belongs in the collection of any fan of classic comedy and musicals....
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 85
Though staged by Busby Berkeley, the musical numbers are presented rather routinely and don’t show off the choreographer’s flair for inventive and unusual camera angles....
Extras: 60
Movie: 75
Romance on the High Seas marked the movie debut of Doris Day, a band singer and recording artist who was hired for the film when songwriters Jule Styne and Sammy Cahn heard her sing at a party....
Total: 79
Theatrical Trailer – This unusual trailer features Doris Day and Janis Paige singing special lyrics that provide a bouncy preview of what the film is about....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Exceptional clarity and contrast, a lovely grain structure that preserves the feel of celluloid, and of course all that glorious, perfectly timed color distinguish this sublime effort that keeps us transfixed...
Audio: 80
Excellent fidelity and tonal depth make this musical sing, and a wide dynamic scale handles all the highs and lows of Ray Heindorf's lush, Oscar-nominated orchestrations without a hint of distortion....
Extras: 40
Vintage Short: Let's Sing a Song from the Movies (HD, 11 minutes) - This infectious 1948 installment of the Memories from Melody Lane series is comprised of select numbers from Warner musicals dating back...
Movie: 80
Carson, Levant, and specialty performer Avon Long all get a chance to sing too, but in a head-scratching move, the bubbly, underrated Paige, who possesses a powerhouse voice (she would later star on Broadway...
Total: 80
A brand new restoration that immerses us in a rainbow of perfectly pitched Technicolor hues, vibrant audio, and a couple of vintage supplements distinguish Warner Archive's scrumptious Blu-ray presentation...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 100
Sharpness (Warners hadn’t yet started hiding Doris’ freckles with too much pancake makeup), Technicolor reproduction, and contrast have all been dialed in expertly in this transfer which is also spotlessly...
Audio: 100
The Ray Heindorf orchestrations are very noticeable and redolent of the Warners sound of the era, and the songs and background score have been combined expertly with the well-recorded dialogue and sound...
Extras: 50
Hare Splitter (7:09, SD): Bugs Bunny cartoon Let’s Sing a Song from the Movies featurette (10:43, SD): four songs from Warners movies are shown in film clips followed by sing-along lyrics: “Am I Blue?”...
Movie: 70
Versatile director Michael Curtiz keeps the rambunctious mistaken identity movie plot humming along (Busby Berkeley stages the musical numbers with little of the flair he had exhibited in earlier musicals)...
Total: 70
The movie itself is above average entertainment, but Doris makes each of her songs special, and it’s for those and the disc’s outstanding video and audio transfer that it earns a hearty recommendation....
Director: Michael Curtiz, Busby Berkeley
Actors: Jack Carson, Janis Paige, Doris Day
PlotA wealthy couple, Michael and Elvira Kent, suspect each other of infidelity due to their constant separations and busy schedules. Michael cancels their planned anniversary cruise, claiming business obligations, but actually intends to stay back to spy on Elvira. Conversely, Elvira enlists a young nightclub singer named Georgia Garrett to take her place on the cruise under her name while she stays behind to catch Michael in the act. Georgia, thrilled at the opportunity for adventure and relaxation, agrees to the plan without considering the potential complications.
As Georgia embarks on the luxury cruise posing as Elvira, private detective Peter Virgil is hired by Michael to shadow "Elvira" and report back on any suspicious activities. Peter tailing Georgia leads to a series of comedic misunderstandings and romantic entanglements. Their interactions grow more complex as Peter finds himself increasingly charmed by "Mrs. Kent," all while remaining unaware of her true identity. Intrigue and chaotic romances unfold on the high seas, raising stakes and misunderstandings, but the true resolution of each character's dilemma only begins to surface halfway through the voyage, leading into a whirlwind journey of hidden truths and unexpected turns.
Writers: Julius J. Epstein, I.A.L. Diamond, Sixto Pondal Ríos
Release Date: 03 Jul 1948
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish, Portuguese