The Tall Target Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 75
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Tall Target delivers tense thrill alongside historical intrigue, with the Warner Archive Blu-ray providing a commendable A/V presentation.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 86
Warner Archive delivers a commendable 1080p/SDR transfer of 'The Tall Target,' sourced from a new 4K scan likely combining original negatives and secondary elements. Despite minor inconsistencies in black levels, the film’s noir-tinted cinematography shines with fine detail and organic grain, surpassing previous releases.
Audio: 86
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix presents a clean, authentic period sound with strong dialogue and minimal age-related artifacts, maintaining the dynamic range and providing an engaging audio experience true to its original one-channel source.
Extra: 41
The Blu-ray of 'The Tall Target' delivers engaging period-specific extras, including the 1949 'Mr. President' radio drama starring Edward Arnold focused on Abraham Lincoln, two restored 1951 Tom and Jerry shorts highlighted by 'Jerry's Cousin', and an over-the-top theatrical trailer.
Movie: 71
The Tall Target is a tense, tightly-paced thriller by Anthony Mann, capturing the intrigue of an historical assassination plot against Abraham Lincoln with an impressive ensemble cast. Dick Powell leads the way with strong direction and a few noir touches, enhanced by Warner Archive's quality Blu-ray presentation.
Video: 86
Warner Archive's Blu-ray edition of "The Tall Target" benefits from a restoration based on a new 4K scan of the finest available preservation elements, delivering a commendable 1080p/SDR transfer. The crispness of the film's noir-tinted cinematography is evident, particularly in shots likely extracted from well-preserved, first-generation nitrate negatives. The fine detail, solid black levels, and organic film grain are consistently well-executed throughout the film’s concise 78-minute runtime, echoing the meticulous restoration work involved.
While the majority of the presentation maintains a high standard, certain segments reveal minor inconsistencies. Opening credits and station backdrops appear noticeably smoother due to optical processes, and occasional softer shots disrupt the overall sharpness. Despite these disparities, these instances do not detract significantly from the viewer's experience. Overall, this high-definition presentation surpasses previous home video editions, offering long-time fans a visually refreshed opportunity to experience this classic.
The disc retains the film's original 1.37:1 theatrical aspect ratio using the AVC codec, reinforcing its authentic visual aesthetic. The grayscale in the black-and-white presentation enhances the film's occasional noirish atmosphere, though some black levels may not be as deep as observed in other high-quality transfers. Still, any criticism is minimal, given that image quality remains pristine throughout. Divided into 19 chapters, this Blu-ray edition of "The Tall Target" is a substantial improvement over prior releases and is likely to satisfy both newcomers and aficionados with its polished rendition.
Audio: 86
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix on the Blu-ray of "The Tall Target" effectively preserves the film's original sonic essence while providing a commendably clean auditory experience. Utilizing a split two-channel format, this presentation honors its source material with both precision and attention to detail. Dialogue remains robust and clear throughout, ensuring that the film's narrative flows seamlessly. Occasional age-related hiss is present but minimal, likely left untouched to preserve the dynamic range, an integral aspect of maintaining audio authenticity. This choice results in a natural soundscape that complements the period nature of the film.
The inclusion of background music and sound effects is thoughtfully executed, adding depth and a genuine atmosphere that enhances the viewer's immersion. The absence of distracting artifacts such as crackle or pops ensures an unblemished listening experience, aligning with expectations for a film of this era. This well-balanced audio mix never distracts, allowing viewers to engage fully with the cinematic experience without auditory interruptions. Additionally, optional English (SDH) subtitles are available for the main feature, providing accessibility without compromising on quality.
Extras: 41
The Blu-Ray extras for "The Tall Target" offer a compelling glimpse into the era, combining period-specific content with classic animation. The highlight is a 1949 radio broadcast from the "Mr. President" series, featuring Edward Arnold and focusing on Abraham Lincoln—a fitting thematic connection to the film's historical narrative. Additionally, the inclusion of well-restored Tom and Jerry cartoons provides a delightful touch of nostalgia. "Jerry's Cousin" is particularly noteworthy as it showcases an amusing storyline of Jerry and his strong cousin Muscles, creating a humorous dynamic with Tom. Similarly, "Slicked-Up Pup" enhances the collection with its light-hearted charm, although it follows a more predictable plot. The theatrical trailer offers a rare look at the original promotional efforts, exuding the dramatic flair typical of the period. Overall, these extras enrich the viewing experience, offering both context and entertainment.
Extras included in this disc:
- Mr. President: 1949 radio drama with Edward Arnold.
- Jerry's Cousin: Restored 1951 animated short featuring Tom and Jerry.
- Slicked-Up Pup: Another 1951 short with the iconic duo.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional piece.
Movie: 71
"The Tall Target," directed by Anthony Mann, unfolds as a taut political thriller set in the days leading up to President Abraham Lincoln's first inauguration. The film is anchored by Dick Powell's portrayal of John Kennedy, a New York police detective who becomes embroiled in the notorious assassination plot known as The Baltimore Plot. The historical intrigue is heightened by Mann's deft direction, which maintains a constant tension throughout this claustrophobic train-set narrative. The tight screenplay by George Worthing Yates and Art Cohn, coupled with ingenious cinematography, enhances the intense atmosphere, effectively capturing the perilous situations and secretive plot twists that Kennedy encounters on his mission, even as real history remains a fixed point.
The film comprises a commendable ensemble cast that enhances its thrilling narrative. Powell shines as a resourceful protagonist whose vulnerability is realistically portrayed amidst mounting threats. Supporting performances are notable, with Adolphe Menjou presenting a dual-layered performance as Colonel Caleb Jeffers, concealing his true intentions under a gregarious facade. Will Geer delivers a memorable performance as the officious conductor caught between order and chaos. While some roles, such as Paula Raymond's Southern belle, could have been further developed, Ruby Dee’s portrayal of Rachel, a slave with growing awareness of freedom, provides depth and poignancy.
Mann keeps audiences captivated through skillful pacing and strategic twists that make each train cabin encounter feel crucial and consequential. Despite its inevitable historical outcome, the film balances historical context with fictional tension, supported by Bronislau Kaper's engaging score. Warner Archive's Blu-ray release further elevates the experience with enhanced video and audio clarity, providing a vivid presentation of this unique and engaging narrative that combines elements of noir with historical drama. "The Tall Target" succeeds in delivering an astute, engrossing cinematic experience that invites viewers into a well-crafted tale of suspense and historical intrigue.
Total: 75
Anthony Mann's "The Tall Target" excels as a historical drama that brings a thrilling suspense to the era just days before Abraham Lincoln’s inauguration. The film tackles the failed assassination attempt with a palpable sense of urgency and intrigue. While the outcome is historically predetermined, Mann skillfully keeps viewers engaged through tight pacing and strong performances. However, certain elements crafted to fit 1950s sensibilities may feel somewhat contrived. Despite these slight drawbacks, the film delivers a compelling narrative that is both entertaining and thought-provoking.
The Warner Archive's Blu-ray release of "The Tall Target" elevates the film’s visual and audio quality significantly. The presentation boasts a clear image resolution and well-balanced sound that enhance the viewing experience. Additionally, the Blu-ray includes a selection of thoughtful extras that delve deeper into the film's context and production, making it a valuable addition for enthusiasts of classic cinema. These features particularly highlight the underrated aspects of the film, offering insights that could appeal to both dedicated fans and curious viewers alike.
In conclusion, "The Tall Target" stands as an engaging historical thriller underscored by excellent direction and performances. The Blu-ray edition successfully revitalizes the film with impressive A/V quality and insightful bonus material. While the narrative includes elements that cater to its 1950s audience, its tension-filled storytelling and historical significance make it a recommended watch. Whether you're revisiting this classic or discovering it for the first time, the Blu-ray presents an opportunity to appreciate Mann’s work in its best possible form.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
But as evidenced by these direct-from-disc screenshots, the film's noir-tinted cinematography is held together very tightly from start to finish, with the best-looking shots absolutely looking like they...
Audio: 80
Age-related wear-and-tear is largely kept in check with small but noticeable amounts of hiss remaining in a few conversations and other exchanges; it's nothing too distracting, of course, and was likely...
Extras: 40
This one-disc release ships in a keepcase with attractive poster-themed cover art and a few period-specific extras....
Movie: 70
Naturally Kennedy later confronts the mystery man and, when a fraction of the mysterious plot is uncovered, it soon expands to include several more passengers hiding in plain sight....
Total: 70
History can't help but spoil the outcome, yet it also leads to a few unfortunate elements that "sweeten" its narrative to appease 1950s audiences which, aside from a few other nitpicks, keeps it from reaching...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 90
The film looks very good indeed with its black and white grayscale adding a noirish feel to the proceedings on occasion....
Audio: 100
Dialogue is strong and masterfully recorded, and the background music and frequent sound effects give a very authentic period feel to the movie....
Extras: 50
Mr. President (29:31): 1949 radio drama with Edward Arnold Animated Shorts (HD): two 1951 MGM shorts: Jerry’s Cousin (6:47), Slicked Up Pup (6:24)...
Movie: 80
Without his official badge and papers, Kennedy finds himself often unable to defend his position of authority thus adding to the hopeless anxiety that has been woven into every frame of the film, and as...
Total: 80
Anthony Mann’s exciting thriller The Tall Target deserves to be far better known, a taut tension-filled adventure with excellent performances and quite a few surprises....
Director: Anthony Mann
Actors: Dick Powell, Paula Raymond, Adolphe Menjou
PlotIn this suspenseful period piece set during a tense moment in American history, we follow the determined efforts of John Kennedy, an honest and upright New York police detective. As he boards a train bound for Baltimore, Kennedy is burdened with a heavy mission: thwarting an assassination attempt on President-elect Abraham Lincoln. Kennedy, who has received anonymous tips regarding the plot, understands the gravity of his task, yet he finds himself isolated when his superiors dismiss his concerns as mere paranoia. With only his instincts and resolve, he must navigate a web of deception and danger aboard the train.
As Kennedy delves deeper, he encounters an array of passengers, each potentially linked to the ominous conspiracy he's trying to unravel. Among them are Ginny Beaufort, an enigmatic young woman, Colonel Caleb Jeffers, a cagey Southern gentleman, and Jeffers' secretary, Lance. With each passing hour, Kennedy races against time to identify the conspirators. The claustrophobic confines of the train amplify the tension as suspicions run high and tensions mount. Kennedy's own safety becomes increasingly precarious, forcing him to rely on his sharp wits and resourcefulness in a high-stakes battle of wits. As events reach a fever pitch, Kennedy finds himself at the heart of a perilous game, where only his tenacity and keen sense of justice can avert national tragedy.
Writers: George Worthing Yates, Art Cohn, Daniel Mainwaring
Release Date: 17 Aug 1951
Runtime: 78 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English