The Big Parade Blu-ray Review
Score: 67
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
'The Big Parade' restoration by Warner, a must-see classic film marvel.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
Warner's restoration of 'The Big Parade' impresses with clarity, detail, and tints, proving their commitment to preserving classic films.
Audio: 65
The Blu-ray's DTS-HD audio masterfully presents Carl Davis' 1988 score, blending original themes and period songs, enhancing the storytelling with dynamic range and precise instrument clarity, elevating the silent film's impact.
Extra: 53
Comprehensive extras including a detailed commentary by Jeffrey Vance with King Vidor's insights, a vintage MGM studio tour, engaging digibook, and original theatrical trailer enrich the legacy of 'The Big Parade'.
Movie: 87
'The Big Parade' showcases the harrowing journey and emotional depth of WWI soldiers, emphasizing realism and the impact of war's brutality, earning its place as a groundbreaking and enduring cinematic achievement.
Video: 72
Warner Home Video's release of "The Big Parade" on 1080p, AVC-encoded Blu-ray is a testament to the studio's commitment to preserving their storied catalog. Utilizing a restoration process centered around the original camera negative, this edition breathes astonishing life into a film that has aged 88 years, making it a remarkable feat in film restoration. The resulting video quality showcases an unparalleled level of clarity and detail that is stunning for a silent-era production. The depth of the blacks and the nuanced spectrum of grays add a rich layer of texture, while the deliberate use of tints—varying blues for night scenes, warm ambers for interiors, and a distinct light magenta for the romantic denouement—enhances the visual storytelling without overshadowing the film's historic aesthetic. Additionally, a subtly integrated hand-tinted red cross imbues a singular frame with a burst of color, underscoring the careful attention to preserving and accentuating the film's original visual intent.
Despite minor preservation challenges such as missing frames and momentary narrowing of the image to conceal irreparable damage, the integrity of the film's presentation is largely maintained. The presence of grain, variable in intensity across scenes that required substitution with duplication negatives due to decomposition, authenticates the cinematic texture appropriate for a film from 1925. Detail levels are significantly preserved, showcasing crisp background elements and title cards with deep blacks and sharply defined letters that contribute to a surprisingly modern feel for such an antique film. This meticulous restoration highlights Warner’s unparalleled dedication to its legacy content, ensuring that "The Big Parade" not only remains accessible but also remarkably impactful for contemporary audiences.
Warner's stewardship in revitalizing "The Big Parade" exemplifies how older cinema can be made relevant and visually engaging through modern restoration techniques. The Blu-ray release, with its average bitrate of 25.84 Mbps effectively avoiding compression issues, ensures a viewing experience that respects the film’s original grain structure while presenting it in a way that retains its emotional and historical significance. The attention to grayscale variance and contrast enhances both the interior and exterior shots, providing a visual depth that complements the narrative. Warner's endeavor to present this silent classic in such pristine condition underscores a broader commitment to film preservation, celebrating cinema's heritage and showcasing the timeless nature of its visual storytelling.
Audio: 65
The audio presentation of "The Big Parade" on its 4K UHD Blu-ray release delivers an acoustically rich and immersive experience, underscoring the silent film's emotive power through a meticulously crafted DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 stereo track. Carl Davis' 1988 score, a nuanced amalgamation of original compositions by William Axt and David Mendoza, serves as the auditory backbone. Davis not only incorporates but revitalizes period-specific melodies such as "Over There" and "You're in the Army Now," ensuring the track's fidelity to the era while enhancing the visual storytelling with his orchestral sophistication. The resulting synergy between Davis' auditory narrative and director King Vidor's visual craftsmanship significantly elevates the film, demonstrating the transformative potential of film music when aptly executed.
The execution of the track showcases an exceptional dynamic range, from the tightness of its bass that avoids boominess to the refinement of high notes that never approach harshness. Instruments are distinguished with precision, allowing for an appreciative acknowledgment of the score's compositional complexity. Even in the absence of traditional sound effects, the score vividly conveys the clamor of battle through innovative use of percussion, proving more impactful than actual sound effects might have, thanks to Vidor's rhythmic approach to scene staging and editing.
Despite being front-heavy, the audio mix successfully envelops listeners, courtesy of a warm, depth-rich sound profile performed by the English Chamber Orchestra. The mix, however, exhibits modest use of surround channels, relying instead on robust stereo separation to create spatial awareness. With no distortion or audio imperfections present, and a subtle yet discernible presence of diegetic sounds such as steam whistles and explosions, "The Big Parade's" audio track serves as a testament to the enduring relevance and potential of silent film soundtracks to convey depth and emotion purely through music.
Extras: 53
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "The Big Parade" offers an exceptional suite of extras that cater to both history buffs and cinema aficionados. A standout feature is the comprehensive commentary by historian Jeffrey Vance, leveraging his deep knowledge and unique access to oral histories from director King Vidor himself, providing a rich narrative that spans the film’s making, its cultural impact, and its lasting legacy. The inclusion of the 1925 Studio Tour provides an unparalleled glimpse into the workings of the MGM studio, encapsulating the era’s filmmaking process with rare footage of early Hollywood luminaries. Paired with a meticulously crafted digibook filled with essays by film scholar Kevin Brownlow, detailed illustrations, and a reproduction of the original film program, this release is not just a celebration of "The Big Parade" but a homage to the Golden Age of cinema itself. The extras elegantly bridge the past with the present, offering viewers a comprehensive understanding of both the film's historical context and its technical achievements.
Extras included in this disc:
-
Commentary with Historian Jeffrey Vance (and Director King Vidor): Draws from a rich tapestry of sources to offer an in-depth look at the film's production, history, and impact.
-
1925 Studio Tour: A silent tour providing an exhaustive view of the MGM Culver City studios, showcasing the industry’s inner workings during its nascent years.
-
Theatrical Trailer: Offers a contemporary glimpse into the film’s original promotional efforts, highlighting its standing in cinematic history.
-
Digibook: Features fifty pages of text by Kevin Brownlow, illustrations, and a reproduction of an original twenty-five cent program from the film's release.
-
Movie: 87
"The Big Parade," King Vidor's 1925 silent epic, stands as a monumental achievement in cinematic history, especially in its presentation on 4K UHD Blu-ray. Delving deep into the heart of World War I, Vidor eschews the glorification of war to present a raw, unvarnished look at the human condition amidst the chaos of conflict. Through the journey of Jim Apperson (John Gilbert), a privileged youth turned soldier, and his comrades from varied backgrounds, the film explores themes of love, loss, and the stark reality of war. This intimate focus within the grand spectacle of the war paints a compelling portrait of personal transformation and the indelible scars left by warfare.
Vidor’s cinematic techniques were groundbreaking, integrating realism with artistic flair to immerse viewers in the soldiers’ experience. Scenes ranging from the camaraderie and daily mundanities of military life to the harrowing battles in Belleau Wood and trench warfare underscore the film's dynamic range. Notably, the delayed introduction of conflict - nearly ninety minutes in - amplifies anticipation, making the ensuing battles not just visually stunning but emotionally resonant. The strategic use of color tinting and meticulous staging contribute to the film’s timeless appeal, bridging the gap between silent film era storytelling and modern sensibilities.
The Big Parade’s contribution to war cinema cannot be overstated. Its influence permeates subsequent classics like "All Quiet on the Western Front," setting a precedent for anti-war narratives. The film's commercial success and prolonged theater run underscore its impact on both audiences and the future of filmmaking. Vidor's ambition to create a lasting piece that transcends its era was unequivocally realized, offering a cinematic experience that is both a historical artifact and a relevant commentary on the human cost of war.
Total: 67
"The Big Parade" on 4K UHD Blu-ray presents a captivating restoration work that shines a tantalizing light on King Vidor's epic. Warner Bros., leveraging the MGM library it acquired, has illustrated an unwavering commitment to film heritage through this meticulous endeavor, ensuring no aspect of the film's original grandeur was overlooked. This release reaffirms the studio's capability and dedication towards preserving cinematic history, with an outcome that is visually and audibly exemplary. The film itself, a poignant narrative entrenched in the adversities of World War I, retains its emotional and artistic prowess, bridging the years to strike a chord with modern audiences.
Warner's presentation of the classic is nothing short of a collector's gem, featuring state-of-the-art video and audio restorations that breathe new life into this silent cinema cornerstone. Despite its lengthy runtime and occasional pacing challenges, "The Big Parade" remains a comprehensive representation of action, romance, comedy, and drama, encapsulating the volatile ambiance of its era. The inclusion of concise but enriching supplementary materials, coupled with elegant digibook packaging, bolsters the overall appeal of this release, making it a must-own for aficionados of classic films.
In conclusion, "The Big Parade" 4K UHD Blu-ray is an exemplary showcase of Warner Bros.' dedication to film preservation and a testament to the timeless relevance of King Vidor's masterpiece. The meticulous restoration ensures that every frame of this epic narrative is presented with the highest fidelity, preserving the film's historical significance and emotional depth. While it might not eclipse contemporaneous works in terms of sheer impact, its expansive portrayal of human experiences during war renders it an indispensable addition to any serious film collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
Every so often, the edge of the image will narrow in slightly for a frame or two, then return to the standard Academy ratio of 1.37:1; this has presumably been done to hide damage beyond the ability of...
Audio: 80
Davis' score is a masterly demonstration of just how much storytelling a skillful composer can supply, especially in the battle sequences, where various percussion instruments fill in the sounds of weapons'...
Extras: 70
The disc is packaged inside one of the most detailed digibooks that Warner has produced to date, with fifty pages of illustrations and detailed text by film scholar Kevin Brownlow....
Movie: 100
The last hour of the film shifts into a much darker tone, both thematically and visually, as Vidor takes his trio of soldiers and their company to war and stages one bravura sequence after another demonstrating...
Total: 90
Despite reports of its recent recovery, MGM lacks both the financial wherewithal and, currently, the in-house expertise to undertake a restoration of the delicacy and magnitude required by a film of this...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Amazingly, only a couple of errant nicks and marks dot the source material, allowing for full immersion in the tale, and I could detect only one missing frame, right around the 2-hour-8-minute mark....
Audio: 80
Accents, like the piercing steam whistle and a few exploding shells, possess fine presence and healthy low-end tones, but the subwoofer - like the film itself - stays silent....
Extras: 20
"All that has followed is balderdash!"), while the Vidor excerpts cover the background of the film, various reshoots, how the famous gum-chewing scene evolved, and his experiences at several premiere showings....
Movie: 80
No doubt about it, 'The Big Parade' is a big picture, but despite its wide canvas and cast of thousands, it manages to maintain an effective intimacy as it focuses on three men from divergent backgrounds...
Total: 60
Though a bit bloated and draggy in places, the story's core emotions always come through, and the artistry and spectacle still dazzle some 88 years after the movie's premiere....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
While there are some minor issues on display such as missing frames that cause the film to jump a tiny bit every now and then, but if that’s the extent of complaints about a movie this old, then you’re...
Audio: 80
It works especially well during the scene in the forest where the men are forced to march even in the face of sniper fire, because Vidor timed the actor’s march to a metronome to give them the appearance...
Extras: 80
In one of the most comprehensive commentaries that I’ve ever heard, film historian Jeffrey Vance gives a tour de force recap of the film’s history, the people who were involved in it, it’s impact on audiences...
Movie: 90
All of which had to be satisfying for the film’s director King Vidor who made the movie in the first place because he wanted to make something that mattered and that would have an impact on audiences and...
Total: 80
There’s a reason that this film stayed in theaters for two years straight so make sure you check it out...
Director: King Vidor, George W. Hill
Actors: John Gilbert, Renée Adorée, Hobart Bosworth
PlotIn the midst of World War I, a young American, son of a wealthy businessman, is swept into the patriotic fervor that leads him to enlist in the US Army. With little understanding of the realities of war, he departs for Europe, full of youthful enthusiasm and pride. His early days in the service are marked by camaraderie with his fellow soldiers and the lighter moments of military life, despite the looming shadow of conflict. This initial period showcases his adjustment to army life and the forging of enduring friendships with two fellow soldiers, a seasoned Frenchman and a big-hearted American, amid the backdrop of the idyllic French countryside.
As he adapts to his new surroundings, his life takes a turn upon meeting a charming French girl from a small village near the front lines. Despite the language barrier and the harsh realities of war that surround them, a deep bond forms between them, grounded in the simple joys and human connections that persist even in wartime. Their relationship blossoms against the backdrop of the picturesque but war-torn French countryside, offering a glimpse of hope and normalcy amidst chaos. However, the brutal realities of the front lines await, as the initial excitement fades into the harrowing truths of combat, testing the strength of their bond and the resilience of the human spirit.
Writers: Laurence Stallings, Harry Behn, Joseph Farnham
Release Date: 03 Dec 1925
Runtime: 151 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United States
Language: None