Borderlands 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 76
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite first-rate 4K technical merits and engaging cinematography, Borderlands struggles with a derivative plot and lackluster adaptation, making it ultimately skippable.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 86
Borderlands' 4K UHD presentation boasts a vibrant Dolby Vision and HDR-enhanced palette, with razor-sharp detail and inky black levels. Despite some inconsistent CGI moments and noticeable reshoot scenes that affect depth, the overall HEVC/H.265 encoded 2160p transfer remains visually stunning, capturing whimsical production design excellently.
Audio: 92
Borderlands dazzles with a dynamic Dolby Atmos track, delivering a fully immersive soundscape with engaging surround channel use and potent LFE bursts. Dialogue is clear while action sequences showcase striking spatial audio, making it a standout auditory experience.
Extra: 45
Borderlands' 4K UHD Blu-ray offers a robust 45-minute extras package showcasing the film's adaptation from game to screen. Engaging insights cover character introductions, stunts, weaponry, fashion, and VFX, though at times repetitive, yet these brief features exceed standard EPK content.
Movie: 43
Borderlands is a vibrant yet noisy spectacle lacking coherent storytelling and depth, marred by generic plotlines and studio interference, despite a strong cast including Cate Blanchett and Jamie Lee Curtis. The film's 4K UHD presentation offers visual allure, but struggles with a disjointed narrative and uninspired direction.
Video: 86
The 4K UHD Blu Ray video presentation of "Borderlands" is noteworthy for its visual clarity and color vivacity, delivered through a HEVC/H.265 encoded 2160p transfer with a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. The film, captured with Arri Alexas and completed with a 4K Digital Intermediate (DI), presents a visually engaging display that greatly enhances the detail and texture of both CGI and live-action elements. The application of Dolby Vision/HDR elevates the palette to unprecedented energy levels, providing significant highlights to certain signature elements such as Lilith's hair, which alternates between rust and bright orange tones depending on the scene. Both natural and computer-generated imagery benefit from this enhancement, producing striking renderings of costume fabrics, whimsical props, and even facial close-ups with admirable precision.
However, the video transfer is not without its inconsistencies. There are moments where obvious reshoots and rushed CGI become evident, affecting the overall image quality. During these scenes, the depth flattens and background effects lose their sharpness, making them appear as if actors are positioned in front of a green screen in less cohesive environments. Despite these occasional setbacks, when the transfer shines, it showcases bright colors, deep blacks, crisp whites, and impeccable detail.
Overall, the visual presentation excels in offering a strikingly sharp, detailed, and vibrant display that aligns well with the film's video game aesthetic. While some CGI elements fall short of photo-realism, they contribute to the intended stylistic atmosphere. The film's movements are depicted with outstanding depth and focus, ensuring an immersive viewing experience. This 4K UHD release stands as a solid reference for quality execution in capturing whimsy within a high-fidelity visual format.
Audio: 92
The audio presentation of the "Borderlands" 4K UHD Blu-ray release shines prominently with its exhilarating Dolby Atmos mix. Exploiting the full potential of an Atmos setup, this auditory experience cleverly utilizes every available channel—front/center, sides, rear, and height—to deliver an immersive soundscape. The dynamic Atmos speakers deliver vibrant overhead effects, notably during explosive sequences, such as when Tiny Tina’s bombs unleash chaos. Dialogue is crisply delivered and well-prioritized, maintaining clarity even amidst the relentless action. The sound mix effectively conveys environmental effects and spatially accurate directional cues, enhancing the audience's immersion in this action-packed environment.
This release showcases a robust use of LFE, ensuring that low-frequency extensions resonate powerfully throughout. The bass is profoundly deep, ensuring a visceral experience that complements the film's vibrant visuals. Distinct moments, such as driving through a giant tentacle monster's head or battling swarms of adversaries in caverns, exemplify the seamless integration of atmospheric sounds across the height and surround channels. Each scene feels thoroughly engaging due to the dynamic spread and active presence of incidental audio elements, maintaining a lively auditory field.
English, French, and Spanish options are provided for both audio and subtitles, ensuring accessibility for multiple audiences. Notably, the mix's dynamic range may seem marginally restricted due to its consistently high-intensity audio levels; however, quieter scenes do exist and provide moments of relative calm. Enriching the listening experience further, exceptional vocal performances are consistently rendered with clarity. The mix resonates with fans of video game adaptations, elevating the cinematic experience through its adept handling of audio elements. Overall, with the precise interplay of diverse sound elements, this release promises an auditorily captivating journey well-suited for any Dolby Atmos-equipped home theater system.
Extras: 45
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Borderlands" offers a compelling, yet concise selection of supplementary materials, spanning approximately 45 minutes. These extras provide intriguing behind-the-scenes insights into the adaptation of the popular video game to film. Eli Roth leads discussions on the transition from game to screen in "Borderlands: From Game to Screen" and "Bringing Borderlands to the Screen," emphasizing his influential role. "Meet the Team" introduces the film's main characters with a focus on Lilith, while "All Aboard the Death Choochoo" engages viewers with its exploration of the film’s stunt choreography. The quirkily named "Badonkadonk Time" showcases unique weaponry, complemented by "Fashion and Action on Pandora," which highlights the challenges of translating game aesthetics to film. Lastly, "High Tech Hellscapes" delves into the film’s VFX and production design, rounding out an engaging suite of features for fans and newcomers alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Borderlands: From Game to Screen: Eli Roth discusses adaptation from video game to film.
- Meet the Team: Introduction to principal characters, with emphasis on Lilith.
- All Aboard the Death Choochoo: Overview of stunt work in the film.
- Bringing Borderlands to the Screen: Further discourse by Eli Roth on film adaptation.
- Badonkadonk Time: Focus on unique weaponry used.
- Fashion and Action on Pandora: Details on adapting game design to the screen.
- High Tech Hellscapes: Examination of VFX and production design.
Movie: 43
The "Borderlands" 4K UHD Blu-ray movie has proven divisive among critics, hampered by a multitude of storytelling and execution issues that overshadow a star-laden cast comprising Cate Blanchett, Jamie Lee Curtis, Kevin Hart, and Jack Black. The cinematic adaptation of the popular video game series struggles to capture its essence, veering into a visually noisy yet narrative-lite spectacle. The plot loosely follows bounty hunter Lilith on her mission to save teenage Tiny Tina, a path littered with shallow humor and convoluted plot twists. Unfortunately, rather than engaging in rich storytelling, the film appears to revolve around a series of disjointed missions reminiscent of video game sequences but devoid of satisfying interactivity or emotional depth.
Technical production aspects, including set design, do creditably echo the game's vivid aesthetic. Still, these elements are largely undercut by subpar CGI and an editing process evidently marred by studio interference. Director Eli Roth's original vision remains speculative amidst reported post-production turmoil involving retake supervisor Tim Miller. The resultant shift from an R-rated vision to a more kid-friendly PG-13 rating leaves the film tonally confused and robs it of the visceral impact expected from Roth’s earlier works. Anders' character development is scarce, with performances suffering within a fundamentally impaired script. Despite some capable cast efforts, notably from Blanchett, the film struggles to maintain coherence or viewer engagement.
Ultimately, "Borderlands" falter as a cinematic endeavor despite promising components. Its lackluster box office returns reflect misalignment between audience expectations and delivery. Though the home theater format showcases the high production values more vividly, these technical merits scarcely compensate for fundamental story and pacing issues. Enthusiasts and newcomers alike may find themselves longing for a more compelling narrative and faithful adaptation of the beloved video game franchise.
Total: 76
"Borderlands" on 4K UHD Blu-Ray aims to translate the high-energy, chaotic charm of the renowned video game series into a cinematic experience. The film, directed by Eli Roth and bolstered by a solid cast, makes an earnest attempt to capture the vibrant production design and the spirit of the game’s universe. Despite these efforts, the adaptation suffers from a narrative that feels both derivative and uninspired. A PG-13 rating dulls the inherently mature and gritty essence of the source material, leaving viewers with a polished yet soulless iteration. While the storyline lacks originality, the technical aspects of the disc, including a premium Dolby Vision transfer and an excellent Atmos mix, undeniably shine.
The transition from game to film is a challenging endeavor, particularly for a franchise with such an expansive and detailed world as Borderlands. The decision to tone down the original's R-rated intensity seems misjudged, stripping the film of its potential edge and leading to a final product that feels more like a sanitized homage than an authentic adaptation. Coupled with indifferent editing choices and narrative pacing issues, audiences are left with a disjointed experience that struggles to justify its own existence. The bonus features, while enjoyable, are limited and leave aficionados wanting more.
Conclusively, "Borderlands" on 4K UHD Blu-Ray is a visual and auditory treat but undoubtedly falls short in its storytelling. The film is unlikely to satisfy die-hard fans of the game or appeal broadly to general audiences who have no inherent interest in the Borderlands universe. Unless you are a devoted fan willing to overlook its significant flaws, it would be advisable to procure this title at a discounted price or via rental options rather than purchasing outright. Ultimately, while it succeeds technically, it is a narrative endeavor best approached with tempered expectations.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 100
Despite the prevalence of CGI, most of which actually looks surprisingly sharp in this 4K presentation, there is such a glut of whimsical production design on display throughout the story that there are...
Audio: 100
Borderlands features a pretty bombastic Dolby Atmos track, one that takes full advantage not just of "traditional" surround channel engagement, but clear emanations from the Atmos speakers, as in the scene...
Extras: 60
Fashion and Action on Pandora (HD; 7:37) highlights translating the game design into the film....
Movie: 50
Variety just published an article detailing a perhaps surprisingly unbroken run of unmitigated box office disasters released by Lionsgate over the past several months, and though that old adage states...
Total: 60
Maybe due to the fact that advance word was so negative about this film, or perhaps also because I have never played the video game version and so had absolutely no frame of reference, my "expectations...
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 100
Regardless of your personal opinion on the film, I have to say that the 2.39:1 HEVC 4K image does look flat out amazing....
Audio: 90
Borderlands takes quite a few cues from some other films of the genre, but if you’ve got a full Dolby Atmos setup – this is what it was made for....
Extras: 50
Bringing Borderlands to the Screen – This is essentially an overlapping feature much like the first one, though we get more Eli Roth if that’s your thing....
Movie: 0
But these ensemble films are so hit and miss (mainly the latter) that it’s hard to imagine how they got greenlit in the first place....
Total: 60
And we all know that Eli Roth is a competent filmmaker, though this isn’t really in his wheelhouse....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
While there are a lot of great highlight points to celebrate, the image also suffers from the obvious reshoots and what looks like some seriously rushed CGI to get the film finished and in theaters ASAP....
Audio: 100
Given the big action sequences with guns blazing and massive creatures destroying things, there’s a lot going on to give this soundscape a full spread....
Extras: 20
While tackling different topics about making the film and bringing the world design of the game to life, they’re all rather brief....
Movie: 40
Then there are movies like Borderlands, a work that once probably had something going for it but bears all the hallmarks of top-level studio meddling for a boring soulless slog of one cliched plot beat...
Total: 60
That’s especially the case with a game series like Borderlands where there’s a level of near-infinite replay value for a game where you can spend dozens of hours playing it and still not finish it....
Home Theater Forum review by Sam PostenRead review here
Video: 60
There’s a LOT of scenes that just scream “shot in a dusty warehouse” instead of an alien planet tho, and the integration with CGI scene extension looks cheaply done....
Audio: 80
Points for using “How ya like me now” from The Heavy again, but a million points deducted for not including Cage...
Extras: 60
And it genuinely looks like they had fun making the film and didn’t see the bad reviews coming....
Movie: 70
What came out was a by the numbers adventure that should have been a Borderlands game series fan’s delight, but somehow it just falls flat....
Total: 50
I have a feeling that Borderlands will find it’s audience as a home release but the theatrical disaster means we will never see a sequel, and if there is one thing I reaallllly need it’s a full on Tiny...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
The focus is nice and neat with foregrounds and backgrounds both benefitting from some very nice lensing overall....
Audio: 100
This is not a static mix, and these height speakers deliver!Low-Frequency Extension: Bass booms for music and for action sound effects....
Extras: 40
Borderlands hits 4K Blu-ray with a variety of options – The standard option had an O-ring slipcover and the 4K Disc, Blu-ray and Code inside the standard case....
Movie: 20
I do take Roger Ebert’s words to heart that reviews shouldn’t aim to rip a bad film to shreds, and I also know that regardless of the negative reaction here and elsewhere the film will find an audience...
Total: 40
I’d say maybe find a way to rent this and see if you’d like to own it before committing, but even then, I continue to say to do this with caution....
Director: Eli Roth
Actors: Cate Blanchett, Kevin Hart, Edgar Ramírez
PlotOn the distant, lawless planet of Pandora, a notorious treasure hunter named Lilith returns in search of her missing daughter. She is reluctantly joined by an unpredictable team, each with their own agendas. Among them is Roland, a disciplined ex-soldier; Tiny Tina, a chaotic teenage explosives expert; and Claptrap, a clumsy yet endearing robot. As they navigate the treacherous landscapes filled with hostile creatures and bandits, the team is under constant threat. They soon realize that finding Lilith's daughter is intertwined with a legendary vault rumored to contain unimaginable riches and power. Their quest becomes even more dangerous when they cross paths with Hector, an ambitious military leader seeking control over Pandora’s potent resources to fuel his own tyrannical empire.
As alliances shift and secrets unfold, the team races against time to uncover the truths buried within Pandora's myths. They must outsmart Hector's formidable forces while confronting their own inner demons. Amidst high-octane action sequences, intense showdowns, and moments of unexpected humor, the core of the group is repeatedly tested. Each character must decide what truly matters in a world where loyalty is scarce and survival is all-consuming. The story blends dynamic character arcs with epic adventure, setting the stage for a thrilling narrative that explores themes of power, redemption, and the relentless pursuit of hope in a chaotic universe.
Writers: Eli Roth, Joe Abercrombie
Release Date: 09 Aug 2024
Runtime: 101 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Hungary
Language: English