Dark Tide Blu-ray Review
Score: 51
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite excellent video and audio quality, 'Dark Tide' is an overlong, sluggish film bogged down by excessive dialogue and lacks the thrills of a typical shark thriller.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
The Blu-ray of 'Dark Tide' boasts an impressive AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.35:1, with stunning South African location photography, excellent detail and depth, and vivid colors, despite some crushing in dark scenes and murky underwater sequences. Overall, it offers a high-definition presentation that elevates the viewing experience.
Audio: 68
Dark Tide's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround mix is a capable and immersive experience that effectively uses directionality, deep LFE, and realistic ambiance to generate tension and engagement, despite some clichéd underwater sound effects.
Extra: 6
Included is the HD trailer (1:50 and 2 min.), which is the only special feature available.
Movie: 21
Despite its stunning location photography and occasional moments of suspense, 'Dark Tide' flounders due to laborious pacing, CGI sharks, and a dull script bloated with insipid dialogue and clichéd plot twists, failing to capitalize on the inherent thrill of shark attacks.
Video: 68
Lionsgate Films presents "Dark Tide" on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer at a 2.35:1 aspect ratio. The transfer demonstrates strong visual quality, balancing rich, colorful environments with intricate details. South Africa's stunning locations shine, with rose-hued horizons and teal green waters vividly captured. Depth of field in wide exterior shots is particularly impressive, enhancing the naturally cinematic look of the film. Despite the film’s narrative challenges, the high-definition presentation elevates the visual experience. Several scenes leverage intentional darkness for artistic effect, especially during underwater segments, where murkiness and negligible shadow detail align with the filming conditions.
The 1080p high-def picture consistently provides great detail, from Halle Berry’s skin to the sleek texture of sharks. The vibrant colors of South Africa are aplenty—the water's murky blue, billowing white clouds, and grungy brownish-black seals deliver a textured visual feast. However, there is notable crushing in some sequences, particularly during a mid-film poaching scene that becomes nearly inscrutable due to its darkness. The underwater scenes often display softness but manage to remain compelling, particularly when featuring real shark footage that feels directly sourced from a nature documentary.
Overall, while "Dark Tide" might falter in its storyline, the high-definition visuals on Blu-ray provide a remarkably sharp and engaging viewing experience. Despite occasional issues with darkness and CG realism, the underwater and landscape shots deliver an effective and immersive aesthetic.
Audio: 68
The audio presentation of "Dark Tide" on Blu-ray features a robust and effective lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround mix that enhances the film’s immersive experience. The sound design is marked by strategically placed directional effects that heighten tension, particularly during the shark attack sequences. These moments are punctuated by jarring low-frequency effects (LFE) that deliver significant jolt-inducing impact, showcasing the dynamic range and fidelity of the track. Underwater scenes, albeit somewhat clichéd with their waterlogged audio textures, successfully evoke a palpable sense of immersion and claustrophobia, contributing to the film’s overall tension.
The surround channels are utilized impressively with environmental sounds like barking seals, rushing winds, breaking waves, and bustling docks adding a layer of realism and depth to the viewer’s experience. The big set piece towards the end showcases a whirlwind of sonic activity with excellent discrete channelization, maintaining the immersive quality throughout. Dialogue remains clear and intelligible across the board, ensuring that viewers never miss a line even amid the dense soundscapes. Underwater sequences feature enveloping bubbly gurgling sounds, which perhaps added in post-production, significantly enrich the audio atmosphere by making viewers feel submerged in the action.
Overall, “Dark Tide” achieves an effective audio presentation that, while not groundbreaking, is both capable and engaging. It meticulously leverages its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround mix to deliver an experience that is not only thrilling but also technically proficient.
Extras: 6
The Blu-ray of "Dark Tide" offers a meager selection of extras that may leave enthusiasts wanting more. With high-definition quality, the only included feature is the film's trailer, providing a succinct glimpse into the movie without additional behind-the-scenes content or cast interviews that could deepen appreciation for the film. Despite the high-quality transfer, the lack of substantive bonus material detracts from the overall value of the extras section.
Extras included in this disc:
Trailer: A high-definition preview of the film.
Movie: 21
"Dark Tide," while featuring Halle Berry and stunning South African coastal visuals, ultimately fails to deliver as a gripping shark thriller. The plot centers on Kate Mathieson (Berry), a marine biologist haunted by a traumatic shark attack that resulted in a gruesome death during a filming expedition. The film shifts into predictable territory as Kate, financially desperate, is coaxed back into the water by her estranged husband Jeff (Olivier Martinez) and a wealthy businessman requiring her expertise. This overwrought interpersonal drama dilutes the expected high-stakes tension, turning what could have been a taut thriller into a laborious, dialogue-heavy narrative.
Berry's portrayal of the emotionally scarred Kate is earnest but overshadowed by a disjointed plot and an over-reliance on clichéd tropes. The supposed unique selling point of Kate being the only person daring enough to free-swim with great whites lacks novelty, undermined by familiar "Shark Week" episodes showcasing similar feats. Director John Stockwell fails to build consistent suspense, opting for protracted sequences of underwater footage interspersed with ineffective attempts at heightening music. As a result, the film's 114-minute runtime feels bloated, detracting from the sporadic moments of shark-induced terror.
Though equipped with occasional visually striking set pieces, "Dark Tide" struggles with credibility, especially during CGI-laden shark attacks that fall flat compared to the stock footage of real sharks. The third act's chaotic storm sequence injects some needed action but is hampered by poor visibility and an unfocused execution. Dialogue between characters about their washed-out relationships adds little substance and further stagnates the already sluggish pacing. In essence, "Dark Tide" is an uneven blend of melodrama and thriller that squanders its potential and ends up being a tepid addition to the shark film genre.
Total: 51
"Dark Tide," featuring Halle Berry, is a film that disastrously diverges from the compelling tension inherent to shark-based thrillers. Regrettably, it replaces this tension with an overabundance of dialogue focused on relationships and personal introspection, resulting in a drawn-out and monotonous narrative. The film's inclination to dwell more on its characters' emotional tangles rather than harnessing the inherent thrill of its oceanic setting renders it an unfortunately lackluster experience. This significant misstep in maintaining pace and excitement undercuts its potential, leaving viewers disengaged and yearning for action that never arrives.
The saving grace, if any can be found, lies in the technical quality of the Blu-ray release. From a purely technical standpoint, "Dark Tide" is presented with notably superior video and audio quality. The high-definition visuals enhance the film’s underwater scenes, offering a crisp and immersive viewing experience that sharply contrasts with the film's otherwise uninspired content. The audio mastering is equally commendable, providing clear dialogue and vibrant soundscapes that heighten what minimal excitement exists.
In conclusion, despite its excellent Blu-ray presentation, "Dark Tide" ultimately flounders in its execution as a thriller. The overemphasis on dialogue and character development at the expense of action results in a pacing and tonal imbalance that fails to captivate. This film, regrettably, lacks the ingenuity to breathe new life into a well-worn genre and is best approached with tempered expectations or simply avoided altogether.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
The underwater photography, while incredibly effective most of the time, obviously has the appearance of softness due to the filming conditions, and shadow detail is negligible throughout these sequences,...
Audio: 90
The big set piece that caps the film is a whirlwind (literally) of sonic activity, with some nice use of discrete channelization and once again really good immersive qualities....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 30
In the case of Dark Tide, employment entails a patent bait and switch tactic that promises something akin to Jaws: The Reckoning and instead plops its characters down into a turgid interpersonal melodrama...
Total: 40
There's a reason this film was never screened for critics before its mercifully short theatrical exhibition and why in fact it was so quickly dumped into the home video marketplace....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
It's detail is optimal especially; from Berry's perfect skin to the sleek bodies of the sharks under the water, everything seems to feature great detail....
Audio: 80
The music builds throughout the channels and then the bass kicks in suddenly when a shark lurches toward human prey....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 20
One wonders about the sanity of people who will jump into the water with great white sharks after they've placed floating fish parts directly above themselves, but such is the life of a shark diver....
Total: 40
...
Director: John Stockwell
Actors: Halle Berry, Olivier Martinez, Ralph Brown
PlotKate, a shark expert traumatized by a close encounter with a great white shark, has withdrawn from ocean diving and now gives educational tours about the sea. Her idyllic life is disrupted when her ex-boyfriend Jeff shows up with a lucrative proposition: to take a thrill-seeking millionaire, Brady, and his son on a dangerous shark-watching expedition. Though hesitant at first, financial pressures and Jeff’s insistence compel Kate to reluctantly take up the offer, leaving the safety of coastal waters to venture back into the perilous open sea, known for its aggressive shark population.
As Kate leads the expedition, tension escalates between her, Jeff, and Brady, with rising stakes both emotionally and physically. The initial excitement of observing sharks quickly turns into a desperate struggle for survival as the creatures become increasingly aggressive. The team's lack of experience in handling such danger becomes apparent, pushing each character to their limits. The voyage tests Kate’s leadership, their personal relationships, and their resilience against nature's deadliest predators. As conditions worsen and trust begins to fracture among the group, they must find a way to navigate through the treacherous waters without falling victim to the very sharks they set out to observe.
Writers: Amy Sorlie, Ronnie Christensen
Release Date: 12 Apr 2012
Runtime: 114 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, United Kingdom, South Africa, Germany, France
Language: English