First Man 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 81
from 6 reviewers
Review Date:
First Man's deeply personal journey into Neil Armstrong's life, paired with stellar 4K UHD visuals & sound, wins high acclaim.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 82
First Man's UHD Blu-ray shines with filmic grace, blending high-tech visuals and period authenticity to superbly capture Armstrong's moon landing saga.
Audio: 86
The Dolby Atmos track delivers an immersive, detailed audio experience, balancing dramatic intensity with natural soundscapes, exceptional clarity, and enveloping silence, enhancing the cinematic journey into space.
Extra: 68
First Man UHD features in-depth extras including deleted scenes, behind-the-scenes featurettes, and an insightful audio commentary, all highlighting the meticulous effort to authentically capture Armstrong's story.
Movie: 84
First Man: An intimate, deep dive into Neil Armstrong's journey, balancing personal loss with the monumental first steps on the Moon.
Video: 82
"First Man" on 4K UHD Blu-ray delivers an exceptional viewing experience that leverages its mixed-media origins to provide a visual feast that both enthusiasts and purists will appreciate. Shot on a combination of 16mm, 35mm, and 65mm film, the movie has been carefully upscaled from a 2K digital intermediate to 3840 x 2160p resolution, maintaining the filmmakers' cinematic vision with fidelity. This upgrade supports HDR10 and Dolby Vision, bringing a dynamic range that significantly enhances the visual impact of scenes, from the nuanced textures of earth’s landscapes to the stark and unyielding darkness of outer space. The grain characteristic present, especially pronounced in the 16mm footage, is a deliberate artistic choice that adds a gritty, authentic texture to the earlier parts of Neil Armstrong’s story, closely mimicking documentary footage from the era.
The 4K UHD presentation excels in its color representation, boasting a wide color gamut that brings out rich, bold colors across the spectrum, effectively utilizing Dolby Vision to enhance and stabilize hues for more vivid and lifelike images. Shadows and blacks are rendered with remarkable depth, maintaining detail and texture even in the most challenging of lighting conditions. This is particularly evident in scenes depicting the vast emptiness of space and the intricate details of the spacecraft and astronauts’ suits. The transition between different film stocks is not only a nod to the period but also serves as a narrative tool, marking the progression towards but the clarity and immensity of the moon landing, captured in breathtaking 65mm IMAX detail.
Lastly, the choice to present lunar sequences in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio contrasts sharply against the wider scenes shot on earth, drawing viewers into the historic moment with an almost overwhelming clarity. Despite the inherent softness due to its source material and artistic intent, which might not appeal to all, this presentation achieves a remarkable balance of authenticity and spectacle. The 4K UHD Blu-ray enhances every frame, from the intimate grains of film to expansive cosmic vistas, making it an indispensable upgrade for both aficionados of historical narratives and home cinema connoisseurs alike. Notably, the encoding is finely tuned to maintain consistency without any noticeable compression issues, further underlining the technical prowess behind this release.
Audio: 86
The Dolby Atmos soundtrack of the "First Man" 4K UHD Blu-Ray presentation is a thorough engagement for audiophiles and a testament to the blend of technical acumen and emotional depths that this audio mix brings to the table. From the word go, listeners are hurled into the visceral reality of space exploration. The opening scenes within the cockpit encapsulate this with a symphony of rocket roars, structural rattles, and the astronaut's palpable breaths, inviting viewers into an almost tactile experience. This sensatory journey is punctuated by stellar moments of silence, embodying the void of space with a striking impact. Audio fidelity is exemplary across the board; dialogue remains crisp and is astutely positioned, enhancing immersion without distracting from the cinematic spectacle. Enhanced by a natural bass and immersive use of the surround channels, the mix excels in delivering both the ferocity of rocket launches and the subtle dynamics of quieter moments, making it truly 'out of this world'.
The Atmos track's dynamic range is utilized fully, capturing the nuanced layers of ambient sounds, directional audio cues, and occasional discrete overhead effects which amplify the thematic elements and on-screen action without overwhelming them. Particularly in spaceflight sequences, such as the Gemini 8 and Apollo 11 missions, the sound design meticulously pans across and above, creating a convincingly immersive soundfield. However, despite a generally robust use of height channels, there's a yearning for an even deeper exploration here, especially in scenes ripe with potential for a full atmospheric immersion. The score's delicate integration provides depth and texture, complementing rather than competing with the film’s sound effects.
In synthesis, "First Man's" audio presentation strikes a harmonious balance between dramatic intensity and technical precision. While primarily a drama, the film surprises with an auditory scope that extends well beyond expectations. The soundscape ranges from expansive flight sequences to intimate character moments, all delivered with exceptional clarity and spatial distribution. Though some may desire a more aggressive employment of bass and overhead channels in certain sequences, this soundtrack remains a reference-quality achievement. The meticulous attention to sonic detail—from the clanking of spacecraft interiors to the thunderous launches—coupled with well-prioritized dialogue and an evocative score, ensures an engaging audio experience that complements the visual journey. Indeed, this Dolby Atmos mix not only enhances the perception of space but solidifies "First Man" as a consummate example of how sound can elevate storytelling in film.
Extras: 68
The "First Man" 4K UHD Blu-ray distinguishes itself not just with its main feature, but also through an extensive array of extras, all conveniently placed on the UHD disc, rendering the included Blu-ray an interesting albeit superfluous addition. The highlight undoubtedly is the detailed audio commentary featuring director Damien Chazelle, screenwriter Josh Singer, and editor Tim Cross, delivering a comprehensive dive into the film's production, historical authenticity, and technical insights. This is complemented by a selection of deleted scenes including the poignant "House Fire" and "Apollo 8 Launch." The featurettes – ranging from the exploration of Neil Armstrong's character and historical significance in "Giant Leap in One Small Step," to the technical achievements in "Putting You in the Seat" and "Recreating the Moon Landing," – collectively provide an enriching backdrop to the cinematic experience. Offering an amalgam of technical discussions, historical context, and personal anecdotes, these extras underscore the meticulous craftsmanship behind "First Man." The inclusion of both a physical and digital copy further adds value for collectors and fans alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: In-depth discussion with director Damien Chazelle, screenwriter Josh Singer, and editor Tim Cross.
- Deleted Scenes: Includes "House Fire" and "Apollo 8 Launch."
- Shooting for the Moon: Damien Chazelle discusses his direction and vision for the film.
- Preparing to Launch: Insights into Neil Armstrong's story and its significance.
- Giant Leap in One Small Step: A look at Armstrong's personal life and character.
- Mission Gone Wrong: Focus on some of the film's stunt work.
- Putting You in the Seat: Discussion on the cinematography and visual style of "First Man."
- Recreating the Moon Landing: Behind-the-scenes look at crafting this iconic moment.
- Shooting at NASA: Exploring the authenticity gained from filming at real NASA locations.
- Astronaut Training: Detailing actors' preparation using NASA technology.
Movie: 84
"First Man" takes a remarkably human approach to the awe-inspiring story of Neil Armstrong, the first person to walk on the moon, focusing intimately on the decade leading up to the 1969 Apollo 11 mission. Directed by Damien Chazelle and written by Josh Singer, the narrative delves deeply into Armstrong's personal journey, both his colossal professional challenges and profound private sorrows, most notably the loss of his daughter. Portrayed with compelling subtlety by Ryan Gosling, Armstrong's character embodies a complex duality - a professional and a grieving father - that sits at the heart of this cinematic exploration. The film, while commemorating an epoch-defining American achievement, devotes itself to an in-depth character study rather than the broader technical aspects of the space race, inviting viewers to reflect on the emotional and psychological tolls endured by those involved.
Chazelle's directorial approach, emphasizing emotional depth over the spectacle of space travel, crafts "First Man" into a poignant narrative rather than a mere recounting of historical events. Cinematography by Linus Sandgren and Justin Hurwitz's score work in concert to immerse the audience in Armstrong's world, balancing the sheer physicality of space exploration with the internal, often turbulent journey of its main character. Despite occasional criticism regarding its stylistic choices and perceived cultural tone deafness, the film stands out for its focus on Armstrong's humanity amidst monumental achievements. The intimate portrayal is further enriched by Claire Foy's performance as Armstrong's wife, Janet, offering a nuanced look at the astronaut's life beyond his professional accolades.
Overall, "First Man" recontextualizes Neil Armstrong's historic moon landing within a deeply personal framework; it is both a tribute to American innovation and a meditation on individual sacrifice. It challenges audiences to see beyond Armstrong's stoic public façade and acknowledge the emotional sacrifices made by both him and his family. This approach has placed "First Man" among other cinematic works that may initially defy contemporary expectations but ultimately gain appreciation for their innovative storytelling and empathetic portrayal of historical figures.
Total: 81
"First Man," directed by Damien Chazelle and brought to life on 4K UHD Blu-ray by Universal Pictures Home Entertainment, offers an intimate and deeply human portrayal of Neil Armstrong, the first man to walk on the moon. The film goes beyond the historic lunar landing to delve into the emotional and personal journey of Armstrong, played with stoic intensity by Ryan Gosling, supported ably by Claire Foy as his wife. This release impresses with its technical prowess, offering viewers an up-scaled picture that balances the fine grain of film with crystal-clear 4K imagery. Colors are vivid, blacks deep, and the overall visual presentation stays true to the filmmaker’s vision. The audio experience is equally immersive, featuring a Dolby Atmos track that ranges from the roaring launch of the rocket to the eerie silence of space, ensuring viewers are as close to the experience as possible.
However, where this 4K UHD package shines in visual and auditory presentation, it somewhat falters in its supplemental materials, providing a lighter fare than one might expect from such a monumental subject matter. Despite this, the extras included offer valuable insights into the film's production and the historical context of the story. The Dolby Vision HDR enhancement ensures that the quality surpasses its Blu-ray counterpart, making this a must-add for aficionados of historically significant cinematic works and 4K collectors alike.
In conclusion, "First Man" on 4K UHD is a fitting homage to Neil Armstrong's legacy and the Apollo 11 mission. Its technical merits are undeniable, offering an experience that is both emotionally compelling and visually breathtaking. Despite some misses in the supplemental content, the overall package comes highly recommended for fans of the genre, history buffs, and collectors seeking to bring the awe-inspiring story of human endeavor and space exploration into their living rooms. This release not only celebrates a pivotal moment in history but also elevates it into a profoundly personal journey through space and the human spirit.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 90
This film is grainy First thing to note – this film is grainy; particularly the 16mm stock, this is a cinemographic choice and has been retained in this UHD presentation....
Audio: 100
Indeed any of the rocket sequences during take-off are incredible, and tangible sense of being there....
Extras: 60
Audio Commentary – with director Damien Chazelle, screenwriter Josh Singer and editor Tim Cross who give a full and all-encompassing chat track that covers not only all the aspects of production using...
Movie: 70
Everyone knows the story of getting men to the Moon, but by taking a very personal look at the commander, and therefore what the toll was, we see the task as something different: a very human endeavour....
Total: 80
The extras are somewhat light considering the subject matter, but what there is covers good aspects of the film....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The UHD's improvements are subtle, but arguably critical, in elevating the filmed elements to a slightly higher plane where modestly improved textures, image clarity, grain refinement, and color accuracy...
Audio: 100
Light atmospheric supports gently envelop the listener in a few scenes, dialogue clarity and positioning are seamless, and musical fidelity, front and surround spacing, and balanced low end depth are also...
Extras: 100
Giant Leap in One Small Step (2160p/SDR 4:31): Another piece focusing on Armstrong the man and his family life and the film's commitment to portraying him rather than just the event for which he is known....
Movie: 100
Even without the benefit of peering into Armstrong's eyes in every Lunar shot, as the film often does in the time leading up to the moon walk, Chazelle and Gosling manage to convey deep, sincere, plainly...
Total: 70
It's brilliantly directed and photographed, exceptionally well performed, and the picture's ability to find a tonal balance between epic scale historical and astral awe and intimate character depth is...
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 95
Adding to the realism is the fact that Chazelle and cinematographer Linus Sandgren shot the first third of the film, depicting Armstrong’s test pilot days through the early Gemini program, in Super 16...
Audio: 100
The rattle-scream of the X-15’s frame, the metallic click of hose connections and seat harnesses, the woosh-BAM of RCS thrusters, the thunderous blast of rocket launches, the contained sounds of breathing...
Extras: 75
This is a film that I would kill to see a feature-length “making of” documentary produced for, but those days seem to have passed in the home video industry....
Movie: 100
It’s a fascinating when a film is released at the wrong time, in the wrong cultural moment, to an audience that either doesn’t know what to expect of it or isn’t in the right mood for it....
Total: 93
It’s also a powerful and affecting experience that gives audiences the chance to understand Neil Armstrong as never before, to walk in his shoes, and to ride along with him on a journey that he – like...
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 80
Nevertheless, the 2160p transfer enjoys a notable uptick overall, showing significantly better clarity of the background information, exposing every nook and cranny of the space capsule's interior, the...
Audio: 80
The best moments, of course, are those involving space travel or when testing specific vehicles, sound effects which effectively and flawlessly pan in every direction and overhead, generating an immersive...
Extras: 40
Shooting for the Moon (HD, 4 min): Chazelle talks about his involvement in the production, adapting the historic event for the silver screen and working with Ryan Gosling....
Movie: 70
It's these sorts of moments that make First Man a wondrous and stirring film that splendidly humanizes a legendary figure of history, and on that front, the production should be commended, from the performances...
Total: 70
Although director Damien Chazelle's approach to the material is to a certain degree questionable and at times distracting, First Man is nonetheless a wonderfully satisfying telling of the Space Race and...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 95
This is a drama/biopic, set in the past, that features elements that make use of rich, earth toned colors, boldly applied contrast, and a distinctive visual aesthetic....
Audio: 88
The music score is subtly mixed over the platform so as to add natural depth to its orchestrated elements without drawing attention away from the thematic details of what is transpiring onscreen....
Extras: 80
Recreating the Moon Landing – Filmed in IMAX to show the vastness of the moon, find out all that it took to recreate the most famous moment in NASA history....
Movie: 80
A visceral, first-person account, based on the book by James R. Hansen, the movie will explore the sacrifices and the cost—on Armstrong and on the nation—of one of the most dangerous missions in history.”...
Total: 86
It comes to Blu-ray from Universal Pictures Home Entertainment in this Ultra HD Combo Pack featuring an excellent Ultra HD video rendering (which includes Dolby Vision HDR) that makes the most of the source...
Why So Blu? review by Brian WhiteRead review here
Video: 80
However since the footage here does not always pop three-dimensionally due to the softness employed (much of it shot on 16mm) that does make the image a little less deep, but nevertheless the picture is...
Audio: 90
Surround Sound Presentation: While this track is very front heavy because of all the drama, hence why the score is not perfect for those nitpickers, the rear channels pretty much capture everything we’ve...
Extras: 60
This one explores the fact that this was the first major film to not only showcase Armstrong, but explore the historic journey of Apollo 11.Giant Leap in One Small Step (HD, 4:31) –...
Movie: 90
Both actually put you in the driver’s seat here as you literally feel every bump and bruise Armstrong takes whether it’s maneuvering out of a death defying aerial situation or even the training he underwent...
Total: 80
While it may not have reference audio and video the emotional stakes and gravity of it all makes this 4K ultra HD Blu-ray release soar above the other competing choices....
Director: Damien Chazelle
Actors: Ryan Gosling, Claire Foy, Jason Clarke
PlotThe story is centered on the life of Neil Armstrong from 1961 to 1969, highlighting his journey with NASA during the years that led up to the historic Apollo 11 mission. Armstrong, a reserved, cerebral engineer and pilot, grapples with the pressures and grief ensuing from the perilous nature of his profession, especially after suffering personal tragedy when his young daughter succumbs to a brain tumor. The tale delves deeply into the sacrifices and costs on both him and his family, particularly the toll taken on his relationship with his wife, Janet.
As Armstrong immerses himself into the demanding Project Gemini and later the Apollo missions, the film captures the intensity and risk of space travel. The narrative follows the rigorous training, the camaraderie and sometimes friction between the astronauts, and the mounting tension as they prepare for a seemingly insurmountable goal – landing a man on the Moon. Armstrong's determination and the collective commitment of the team at NASA are set against the backdrop of public and political skepticism amidst the Space Race with the Soviet Union.
Writers: Josh Singer, James R. Hansen
Release Date: 12 Oct 2018
Runtime: 141 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Japan, China
Language: English