Coming Home Blu-ray Review
归来 Gui Lai
Score: 70
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Sony's Blu-ray release of 'Coming Home' stands out with its complex performances, excellent video, standout audio, and a few extras. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 71
Featuring a muted gray-heavy palette with splashes of crimson, 'Coming Home' on Blu-ray offers strong resolution, bold contrasts, and excellent depth in black levels. While minor noise and banding are present, Sony's 1080p transfer faithfully captures the director's aesthetic vision with cleanly rendered details and commendable clarity.
Audio: 80
Far from being just a dialogue-driven film, 'Coming Home' boasts an incredibly dynamic and well-engineered audio track. Dialogue is transparent and balanced, while the surround mix utilizes the entire system, creating immersive, lifelike environments with precise spatial cues. An enriching audio presentation.
Extra: 46
Featuring rich insights in Mandarin with English subtitles, the Blu-ray of 'Coming Home' includes an engaging commentary and Toronto Film Festival Q&A with Director Zhang Yimou, unraveling the source novel, cast performances, film's styling, and historical context. Additional materials: theatrical trailer and Sony previews.
Movie: 81
"Coming Home" excels in delivering a deeply moving narrative that explores the undying power of love amidst the stark backdrop of the Chinese Cultural Revolution. Zhang Yimou's nuanced direction, coupled with stellar performances and a poignant color palette, underscores the film's themes of perseverance, sacrifice, and emotional authenticity.
Video: 71
The Blu-Ray video presentation of "Coming Home" is a visually compelling experience, meticulously crafted to capture Director Zhang Yimou's artistic vision. The film’s stylized visual design features a muted chromatic scheme that harmonizes aesthetically with its thematic elements and setting. The color palette largely consists of shades of gray, black, and sepia, punctuated by strategic splashes of crimson and pale secondary hues, with occasional warm golden accents to break the monochromatic essence. The 1080p transfer from Sony is commendable, maintaining fidelity to the director's intent while showcasing robust textural clarity and formidable detail.
Fleshtones are natural and well-balanced, with facial textures oscillating between precise and slightly lacking in intimate finesse. The contrast is boldly managed, lending whites a striking presence with minimal loss of detail in grays. The video excels in resolution, achieving clean rendering with discernible refinement and delineation that notably enhances depth and fine details in objects, clothing, and physical features. Black levels exhibit excellent depth, appearing punchy even in conjunction with mixed light/dark elements, although they fall short of being inky. Despite minor occurrences of banding and noise, these elements are rarely distracting.
The high-definition transfer reveals the intricacies of patterned garments, worn surfaces, and other minute environmental details with an admirable level of intimacy and clarity. This visual precision underscores the film’s somber mood, influenced predominantly by its gray-heavy façade and digital source photography. Overall, the Blu-Ray video presentation of "Coming Home" achieves a satisfying high-definition experience, preserving the film’s intended emotional and visual impact with both technical excellence and artistic fidelity.
Audio: 80
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray edition of "Coming Home" is distinguished by its impeccable blend of dialogue clarity and environmental immersion. The soundtrack, though heavily reliant on dialogue, is meticulously balanced within the front soundstage with transparent realism and lucid texture. This ensures that every conversation is rendered with precision and depth, essential for a film rich in emotional exchanges. Furthermore, the surround mix is expertly engineered to fully utilize the entire audio platform. It captures the acoustic nuances of diverse environments, integrating spatial ambience and musical extensions into the rear channels, which enriches the overall audio experience and harmonizes beautifully with the source material.
Despite initial impressions that "Coming Home" might feature a predominantly front-heavy, dialogue-driven soundtrack, it surprisingly delivers a robust, dynamic, and expansively engineered auditory experience. The film opens with a rumbling train sequence, where the sound's lifelike heft and sense of movement are vividly portrayed as it transitions seamlessly across channels. This sophisticated placement of sounds continues throughout the film with highlights like the immersive sensation of driving rain saturating the stage and the nuanced detail of rain pelting windows. Street-level ambiance and the carefully prioritized, center-grounded dialogue also stand out for their full-bodied richness. Music enjoys effortless spacing and definition across the spectrum, making this audio presentation a remarkable listening experience from beginning to end.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray release of "Coming Home" offers an insightful look into the film's production and themes through its thoughtfully curated extras. The audio commentary with Director Zhang Yimou provides a comprehensive analysis, covering the original source novel, cast performances, technical intricacies, and more. The commentary is in Mandarin with English subtitles, ensuring accessibility for a broader audience. Additionally, the Toronto Film Festival Q&A session features an in-depth discussion with Yimou, focusing on the historical context of the film and his creative intentions, also presented in Mandarin with subtitles and an English translator. These supplements enrich the viewing experience, offering valuable context and a deeper understanding of the film’s artistic and technical elements.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Zhang Yimou discusses various aspects of the film.
- Toronto Film Festival Q&A: Pre- and post-screening insights with the director.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional material for the film.
- Previews: Additional titles from Sony.
Movie: 81
"Coming Home" presents an intimately poignant exploration of undying love and the human spirit's resilience, set against the turbulent backdrop of the Chinese Cultural Revolution. Centered on Lu Yanshi (Chen Daoming) and Feng Wanyu (Gong Li), the narrative begins when Lu, a political prisoner, returns home after years of incarceration only to discover his beloved wife suffers from amnesia and cannot recognize him. Refusing to accept their separation, Lu remains unwavering in his devotion, nurturing their bond through gentle acts of love and reminiscence. The film, adapted from Geling Yan's novel "The Criminal Lu Yanshi," dismisses cinematic flash for sincere, heartfelt storytelling, capturing the profound essence of the human condition.
Director Zhang Yimou masterfully orchestrates this tender story with a focus on visual and emotional subtleties. His use of a gray-dominant color palette interspersed with muted primaries sets a somber yet hopeful tone that mirrors the characters' internal and external struggles. This visual restraint enhances rather than overshadows the stellar performances. Chen Daoming compellingly portrays Lu's dual existence—as both a political prisoner and a free man wholly devoted to reuniting with his wife. Gong Li, in a complex role that demands reserved emotional expression, delivers a nuanced performance that evokes deep empathy. The film’s themes of forgiveness, sacrifice, and eternal love resonate powerfully through their restrained yet potent chemistry.
"Coming Home" breaks away from grandiose cinematic traditions to embrace a soulful narrative driven by authentic emotions and intimate character studies. In doing so, it achieves a higher purpose: it moves the audience with its touching portrayal of unyielding devotion and the depths of the soul. The direction, performances, and thematic richness collectively underscore the film’s success in evoking a heartfelt connection that transcends its historical backdrop.
Total: 70
"Coming Home" on Blu-ray delivers a powerful and authentic drama that vividly portrays love and devotion amidst harrowing circumstances. The film excels in showcasing deeply complex performances that effectively bring the characters' emotions to life, enveloping the viewer in a poignant narrative. The Blu-ray presentation from Sony upholds high technical standards, offering impressive video quality that captures the film's intricacies with precision. The standout audio provides an immersive experience, greatly enhancing the impact of the dramatic moments.
The Blu-ray edition also includes a modest selection of bonus features, which, while not extensive, add valuable context and depth to the overall experience. These extras provide insights into the film's production and themes, making them a worthwhile addition for viewers who appreciate behind-the-scenes content.
Overall, the exemplary video and audio quality, coupled with the film's emotional depth and technical craftsmanship, make "Coming Home" on Blu-ray a highly recommended addition to any collection. It is a showcase of how technical excellence in home media presentation can elevate and complement outstanding filmmaking.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Garments are particularly stout, showcasing very fine fabric details, such as stitching and frays, with commendable intimacy....
Audio: 100
Perhaps more impressive is the way rain gently pelts windows as heard from inside, trickling off to a side and creating a striking sense of place and environment....
Extras: 40
Toronto Film Festival Q&A with Zhang Yimou (1080i, 18:48): Prior to a screening, the director shares a few thoughts on the film, the history of the time period depicted in it, his hopes for the film, and...
Movie: 90
The movie's soulful theme and moving story of love's perseverance are accentuated by terrifically underscored direction from Zhang Yimou, who manages to find an intimacy of story through his photography,...
Total: 80
Love and devotion, even under the most unimaginably trying circumstances, are the dominant themes, accentuated by remarkably complex performances and terrific technical craftsmanship....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 88
Resolution is discerning as the video is cleanly rendered with appreciable refinement and delineation that enhances depth as it reveals fine detail in objects, clothing, and physical features....
Audio: 86
This is primarily a dialogue driven film however there are elements in the film that require use of the entire system so its ability to clearly render them is essential....
Extras: 60
...
Movie: 80
A stranger within his own family, Lu is determined to awaken his wife's memory through gentle displays of unconditional and eternal love....
Total: 79
Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player Samsung UBD-K8500 Ultra HD Blu-ray Player Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo"...
Director: Yimou Zhang
Actors: Gong Li, Daoming Chen, Huiwen Zhang
PlotDuring the final years of the Cultural Revolution in China, a man named Lu Yanshi is released from a labor camp and returns home to his wife, Feng Wanyu, and their teenage daughter, Dan Dan. Despite their years of separation and the incredible hardship they endured, Lu is desperate to reunite with his family and reclaim the life they once had. However, Lu discovers that Feng, who has deeply suffered psychologically from their separation and the turmoil of the era, doesn't recognize him due to a severe psychological trauma known as dissociative amnesia. As Lu attempts to reconnect with Feng and navigate through her memory loss, their relationship faces emotional challenges.
Meanwhile, their daughter Dan Dan, an aspiring ballet dancer whose dreams were thwarted by her family's political struggles, holds a complex mixture of anger and loyalty toward her parents. Her interactions with them reveal the generational impact of the Cultural Revolution on Chinese families. Confronted by Feng's fragmented reality and Dan Dan's internal conflicts, Lu endures an agonizing struggle to help Feng reclaim her identity and heal old wounds. The story poignantly explores themes of love, loss, and hope against the backdrop of a society deeply scarred by historical upheaval.
Writers: Geling Yan, Jingzhi Zou, Xiaofeng Zhou
Release Date: 16 May 2014
Runtime: 109 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: China
Language: Mandarin