The Girlfriends Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Criterion's Blu-ray release of Michelangelo Antonioni's 'Le Amiche' offers a stylish, ahead-of-its-time film with good video and audio from the 2008 restoration.
Disc Release Date
Video: 77
The Criterion Blu-ray of Michelangelo Antonioni's 'Le Amiche' offers a 1080p, 1.33:1 black and white transfer sourced from a 2008 2K restoration of the 35mm original camera negative. Despite some softness and minor imperfections, the image boasts excellent stability, nuanced grayscale, and pleasing depth.
Audio: 77
The Blu-ray's Italian LPCM 1.0 audio track delivers clear and clean dialogue with excellent clarity and stability, though dynamic movement and atmosphere are modest. Giovanni Fusco's score adds some depth, and there are no audio distortions, making it technically proficient given its age.
Extra: 31
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Girlfriends' feature insightful 1080p interviews with scholars discussing key themes such as alienation, relationships, and the cultural importance of fashion in Antonioni's films, supplemented by a comprehensive essay on Italian social dynamics.
Movie: 76
The Criterion Blu-ray release of Michelangelo Antonioni's 'Le Amiche' is a crucial addition to any cinephile's collection, featuring exceptional visual quality and insightful supplements that explore the director's evolving aesthetic. As a transitional work, the film merges traditional melodrama with Antonioni's emerging modernist style, examining themes of romantic dependency and societal roles among 1950s Italian women.
Video: 77
Presented in a 1.33:1 aspect ratio and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, Michelangelo Antonioni's Le Amiche arrives on Blu-ray with a 1080p transfer by Criterion. This release stems from a 2008 2K restoration of the 35mm original camera negative, supervised by film historian Carlo Di Carlo and undertaken by L'Immagine Ritrovata. The restoration, funded by Gucci and The Film Foundation, features a remastered original monaural soundtrack from a 35mm optical soundtrack positive. Image quality is impressively consistent, with depth and clarity well-maintained throughout, though minor digital rebalancing was applied. Key comparisons show no notable differences between this and Eureka Entertainment’s release, both utilizing the same restoration.
Overall, the image quality is commendable. Fried from the significant issues that plagued the old R1 DVD release, this Blu-ray presents improved fluidity and stable contrast levels, showcasing nuanced grays, whites, and lush blacks. The 35mm source print exhibits a light layer of grain, preserving textures in faces, locations, and the film’s stylish wardrobe choices. While some scenes lean towards softness, clarity remains strong without veering into artificial sharpness or heavy artifacts. The grayscale is well-balanced with natural whites, but occasionally black levels appear slightly light.
Though not the most striking black-and-white Blu-ray from its era, Le Amiche delivers an authentic and clean presentation. There are no significant damage marks or distracting artifacts visible in the image. Image stability is excellent, with no large damage marks, cuts, debris, stains, or torn frames to detract from the viewing experience. For those equipped with a Region-A or Region-Free player, this release provides an admirable exhibition of Antonioni’s developing cinematic style.
Audio: 77
The Blu-ray release of "The Girlfriends" exclusively features an Italian LPCM 1.0 audio track, supplemented with optional English subtitles. The dialogue emerges with exceptional clarity and stability, ensuring a consistently comprehensible auditory experience. Despite the single-channel format, the audio doesn't suffer from notable limitations, presenting Giovanni Fusco's score effectively when it occasionally widens the sonic landscape. Importantly, there are no disruptions such as pops, audio dropouts, or digital distortions, which speaks volumes about the quality of this restoration.
In terms of overall audio presentation, the track retains solid fidelity for its age. Ambient sounds such as crashing waves and passing vehicles provide a commendable presence, adding a subtle atmospheric depth. Although dynamic range is relatively modest and aligned with expectations for a mono track from this era, it remains quite proficient in delivering a full, clean sound without age-related imbalances or artifacts. The technical implementation here is consistent with high standards, making the audio presentation a notable attribute of this release.
Extras: 31
The Blu-ray release of "The Girlfriends" features a robust selection of extras that delve into the film's thematic depth and historical context. Film scholars David Forgacs and Karen Pinkus offer insightful commentary on the recurring themes in Michelangelo Antonioni's work, discussing alienation, class, and relationships in the 1955 film, "Le Amiche." Their interview also touches upon how Antonioni's visual style and narrative choices reflect broader societal changes in Italy. Additionally, Eugenia Paulicelli explores the significant role of fashion in the director's films and how it shaped Italy's post-war image internationally. These interviews, recorded in New York in 2016, provide valuable perspectives on both the film and its cultural backdrop. Furthermore, an illustrated leaflet featuring Tony Pipolo’s essay gives a comprehensive overview of the movie’s Italian stylistic elements.
Extras included in this disc:
- David Forgacs and Karen Pinkus: Scholars discuss the film's themes, visual style, and societal context.
- Eugenia Paulicelli: Analysis of the importance of fashion in Antonioni's work and its cultural implications.
- Leaflet: Illustrated essay by Tony Pipolo on "Friends - Italian Style."
Movie: 76
Michelangelo Antonioni's "Le Amiche" (The Girlfriends) on Blu-ray Review
Michelangelo Antonioni's 1955 film "Le Amiche" arrives on Blu-ray courtesy of Criterion, presenting a pivotal work in the director's early career. Centered on Clelia (Eleonora Rossi Drago), an ambitious woman who returns to Turin to manage a chic fashion house, the plot unravels around her entanglement with a group of affluent women, each grappling with their own romantic and existential crises. The narrative kicks off with Clelia discovering an unconscious Rosetta (Madeleine Fischer), leading to a deeper exploration of their intertwined lives. Antonioni deftly examines the superficiality and dissatisfaction permeating their relationships, all while maintaining a tonal balance between traditional melodrama and hints of modernist aesthetics that would define his later works.
The film serves as a vital touchpoint in Antonioni's oeuvre, showcasing his evolving cinematic style. While the plot may initially seem conventional, it subtly incorporates existential themes and complicated character dynamics, reflecting societal roles and romantic dependencies. "Le Amiche" oscillates between moments of breezy interactions and underlying tragic loneliness, providing a textured exploration of its protagonists' inner lives. Notably, the film's visual style hints at the more abstract techniques Antonioni would later perfect: meticulous blocking, deliberate camera movements, and the strategic use of architectural elements emphasize emotional beats and transitions.
In conclusion, "Le Amiche" stands out not only as a compelling drama but also as an essential piece within Antonioni’s filmography. Its narrative complexity and visual sophistication provide insights into his burgeoning modernist style. This Blu-ray release is enhanced with insightful supplementary features and careful restoration, making it a valuable addition for both casual enthusiasts and devoted cinephiles.
Total: 68
Michelangelo Antonioni's "Le Amiche" emerges as a striking fusion of conventional melodrama and the nascent experimentalism that would define his later works. The film's exploration of relationships amidst post-war societal shifts is both perceptive and enduringly relevant. Criterion's Blu-ray presentation of "Le Amiche," derived from the 2008 restoration funded by Gucci and The Film Foundation, delivers a meticulously authentic visual and auditory experience. The restored high-definition transfer is stunning, preserving the film’s deliberate compositions and nuanced black-and-white cinematography with remarkable clarity and depth. Audio quality is equally robust, ensuring dialogues and ambient soundscapes remain pristine throughout the viewing experience.
While lacking the extensive array of supplements typical of Criterion releases, this edition includes interviews that offer valuable insights into the film's production and thematic undercurrents. These features, though limited, enhance the viewer's appreciation of Antonioni’s early artistic vision and the socio-cultural commentary embedded within the narrative. This release may not achieve the exhaustive extras found in other Criterion collections, but the available content effectively contextualizes the film within Antonioni’s oeuvre and the broader cinematic landscape of the period.
Without a doubt, "Le Amiche" stands as a testament to Antonioni's evolving genius. It provides a compelling look at post-war Italian society through a sophisticated lens that was ahead of its time. Criterion’s Blu-ray, anchored by the impressive 2008 restoration, ensures that this stylish and forward-thinking film can be enjoyed in its full glory by contemporary audiences. Highly recommended for both aficionados of Antonioni and those new to his groundbreaking work.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 100
During the restoration some very gentle digital work has been done to rebalance the image, but depth and clarity are consistently very pleasing (see screencaptures #1 and 12)....
Audio: 100
There are some segments where Giovanni Fusco's score opens up the film a bit, but the original sound design is hardly impressive....
Extras: 50
David Forgacs and Karen Pinkus - in this new video interview, film scholars David Forgacs and Karen Pinkus discuss some of the key themes in Le Amiche, the emergence of alienation as a key element in Michelangelo...
Movie: 100
Through Rosetta Clelia befriends a group of wealthy women and men -- Momina (Yvonne Furneaux, La Dolce Vita, Repulsion), an overconfident beauty who likes to be in control; Nene (Valentina Cortese, Day...
Total: 90
It is a very stylish film whose understanding of the evolving nature of relationships in post-war Italy was way ahead of its time....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The source print is in very good condition with a light layer of grain and a very clean look marked only by faint lines and other fleeting imperfections....
Audio: 80
Dialogue is clear and clean throughout with no balance or notable age-related issues, offering a relatively full quality....
Extras: 20
Eugenia Paulicelli (HD, 22 min) – Presented in 1080p with Dolby Digital 1.0 audio, this 2016 interview focuses on the movie's use of fashion and its place in Italy at the time....
Movie: 60
With hints of the abstract visual and narrative techniques that would pervade his later movies, the film rises above its otherwise conventional trappings to provide a cinematically compelling look at evolving...
Total: 60
The movie might not be on par with Antonioni's subsequent masterpieces, but this is still a worthwhile entry in his filmography....
Director: Michelangelo Antonioni
Actors: Eleonora Rossi Drago, Gabriele Ferzetti, Franco Fabrizi
PlotClelia, a young woman from Turin, returns to her hometown to open a new fashion salon. She quickly becomes entangled in the lives of three affluent and complex women after she saves Rosetta, a despondent young woman, who attempts suicide. Clelia's sense of responsibility leads her to befriend Momina, who is struggling to stay entertained in her fractured marriage, and the lively and independent Nene, an up-and-coming painter. Together, they navigate their careers, romances, and personal turmoils. Clelia's ambitions collide with the social intricacies of her new circle of friends, eventually guiding her to reflect on her own values and desires.
As Clelia continues to grow closer to these women, she witnesses their individual struggles and forms deeper bonds. Momina’s manipulative tendencies contrast sharply against Nene's passionate but tumultuous relationship with Lorenzo, a talented but insecure artist. Meanwhile, Rosetta’s fragile emotional state remains precarious despite the support from Clelia and others. The intertwined relationships and personal conflicts reveal much about societal expectations and personal aspirations amidst the backdrop of Italy's post-war recovery. Through Clelia’s journey of self-discovery and the interconnected paths of her new friends, the narrative explores themes of love, ambition, and the search for identity.
Writers: Cesare Pavese, Suso Cecchi D'Amico, Michelangelo Antonioni
Release Date: 08 Feb 1957
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Italy
Language: Italian