Michael Collins Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "Michael Collins," shot on 35mm film by Oscar-winning cinematographer Chris Menges, presents a detailed and film-like image that successfully captures the historical and atmospheric essence intended by both Menges and director Neil Jordan. The film, newly scanned from a 2K interpositive and color-corrected with an answer print as a reference, offers a desaturated palette that emphasizes earth tones like browns, grays, blacks, and greens, contributing to a historical texture distinctively representative of Dublin's worn and shabby locale. This effect is punctuated by deliberate contrasts, such as the vibrant red of a bouquet in one key scene, which stands out against the generally muted color scheme. The occasional jitter when text is present is minor compared to the overall high quality of the transfer.

Warner Archive Collection's 1080p, AVC-encoded Blu-ray, framed at an aspect ratio of 1.78:1, retains the integrity of the original 1.85:1 theatrical presentation while slightly opening up the image. The transfer's average bitrate of 30.99 Mbps, although below the usual target of 35 Mbps, results in an artifact-free image with impressive black levels and deliberate contrasts between warm and cool colors to create depth. The film’s massive crowd scenes and frequent stylized shots are handled with aplomb, maintaining strong detail and reduced colors. Natural lighting and practical location shooting allow for authentic performances and dynamic camera movements. Overall, despite some minor issues, this Blu-ray release of "Michael Collins" delivers a strong visual presentation that does justice to both the film's historical setting and its cinematic artistry.

The audio presentation of "Michael Collins" on Blu-ray features a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix that stands out particularly during scenes of urban warfare. The dynamic sound design immerses viewers in the chaos of the Easter Rebellion and the Irish Civil War, with intense artillery and gunfire effects that resonate powerfully through the surround channels. These high-intensity sequences are contrasted with scenes of public address and parliamentary debate, where crowd noise and environmental ambiance are effectively enveloped into the surround array. Additionally, quieter scenes maintain crystal-clear dialogue, ensuring every spoken word is intelligible, though viewers may need the English SDH subtitles to navigate the Irish inflections.

However, the track's overall engagement varies. While key scenes come to life vividly, the surrounds are underutilized during less action-packed moments, resulting in an audio experience that lacks consistent immersion. The front center speaker dominantly handles dialogue, leaving ambient noises like crowd cheering and environmental sounds to sporadically populate the surround channels. Despite this, the track exhibits solid separation, with no hint of muddiness, providing a serviceable home theater experience that likely mirrors the film's original theatrical sound. Notably, additional audio options include 2.0 Dolby Digital tracks in German, Spanish (Latin), and Spanish (Castilian), accompanied by a range of subtitle options in multiple languages, catering to a diverse audience.

The Blu-ray extras for "Michael Collins" provide a thorough blend of historical context, behind-the-scenes insights, and directorial perspectives, enhancing the overall viewing experience. The standout feature is Neil Jordan's commentary, recorded in 2015, combining historical education with technical production details, reflections on criticism, and contemporary observations about Ireland. Although Jordan speaks continuously, there are a few notable gaps. The "In Conversation with Neil Jordan" interview offers a brief yet informative introduction to the film's creation and historical basis. Particularly valuable is the "South Bank Show" episode, providing a comprehensive look at both the film's production and the history it portrays, featuring interviews with key figures including Jordan, Neeson, and biographer Tim Pat Coogan. Additionally, viewers can enjoy a remastered theatrical trailer and a collection of deleted scenes, the latter notably featuring an intriguing subplot involving a British trap for Collins through an arms dealer.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary with Writer/Director Neil Jordan: Historical lesson, production insights, and criticism response.
• In Conversation with Neil Jordan: Brief interview summarizing the project and historical events.
• South Bank Show: Detailed documentary on Michael Collins' history and film production.
• Theatrical Trailer: Remastered original trailer.
• Deleted Scenes: Includes subplot about British authorities trapping Collins.

Neil Jordan's "Michael Collins" represents an absorbing, multi-faceted portrayal of the eponymous Irish revolutionary leader, combining elements of historical epic, intimate character drama, and meditative gangster picture. Drawing on the complex and tumultuous life of Michael Collins, the film begins with his involvement in the Easter Rising of 1916, throwing viewers directly into the chaos and urgency of the rebellion. Liam Neeson delivers a powerful performance, embodying Collins' transition from soldier to statesman, while battling British forces through innovative guerrilla tactics. Supporting performances are strong, particularly Alan Rickman's inscrutable Eamon de Valera, though Julia Roberts' portrayal of Kitty Kiernan and her chemistry with Neeson remain less convincing.

The film’s narrative structure immerses viewers in Collins’ escalating conflict with the British authorities, highlighted by intense sequences such as Bloody Sunday. The meticulous attention to historical detail and dedication to capturing the era’s political intricacies make "Michael Collins" an educational yet engaging cinematic experience. However, some viewers may find themselves initially disoriented due to the film’s abrupt start and rapid pace of introducing historical figures and events. This historical immersion is counterbalanced with moments of personal drama, particularly through Collins' relationships with Harry Boland (Aidan Quinn) and Kitty Kiernan.

Technically, the Blu-ray release of "Michael Collins" is commendable. Enhanced by a fresh remastering under Jordan's supervision, it presents a visually stunning experience, cementing its place as a valuable addition to film collections. However, reviewers suggest prospective viewers might prefer an initial rental or streaming option to gauge rewatchability. Despite the mixed reception on certain casting choices and pacing issues, "Michael Collins" remains a richly rendered portrayal, capturing the duality of revolutionary fervor and personal sacrifice with finesse.

The Blu-ray release of "Michael Collins" provides an immersive and poignant view into the life and times of one of Ireland's most iconic historical figures. Directed by Neil Jordan, who earlier gained international acclaim with "The Crying Game," the movie distinguishes itself with a compelling narrative that intertwines historical events with deeply personal elements. Liam Neeson delivers a powerful portrayal of Michael Collins, drawing viewers into his tumultuous journey for Irish independence. The film's production period, marked by contemporaneous real-world conflicts and fraught political climates, lends it an acute urgency and emotional depth.

Warner Bros.’ transfer of "Michael Collins" to Blu-ray delivers robust visuals and commendable audio quality. The high-definition treatment enhances the film's dramatic and historical gravity, making it more engaging for both new viewers and longtime fans. Complementing the visual and auditory upgrades, the release includes an array of bonus materials. These extras, which consist of interviews, commentaries, and behind-the-scenes features, provide deeper insights into the film’s production and its historical context, further enriching the viewing experience.

Jordan's mastery lies in his ability to infuse large-scale historical narratives with an intimate emotional core. The film’s relevance is underscored by its timing, coinciding with significant IRA ceasefires and resumption of hostilities. Completing the viewing experience, the film encapsulates a mix of hope and sorrow that resonates even two decades post-release. "Michael Collins" remains a highly recommended addition to any collection. It's a documentary of a pivotal epoch presented with both technical excellence and heartfelt storytelling.