Midnight Cowboy Blu-ray Review

Criterion Collection’s Blu-ray release of "Midnight Cowboy" benefits from an impressive 4K digital restoration, despite being presented in 1080p/AVC High Definition rather than the anticipated 4K Ultra HD format. The meticulous restoration process undertaken by the Criterion Collection brings the film to life in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio. Utilizing a Lasergraphics Director film scanner for 4K resolution, this transfer drew from the 35mm original camera negative and a 35mm interpositive when necessary. Significant restoration techniques, including MTI Film's DRS and Digital Vision's Phoenix, were employed to remove thousands of instances of dirt, debris, scratches, and stabilize grain, resulting in a remarkably clean and stable image.

Technically, the Criterion release vastly improves upon previous editions. The restoration process has addressed numerous imperfections endemic to earlier transfers. The color correction closely adheres to director John Schlesinger and cinematographer Adam Holender's vision, rejuvenating the intentional stylistic choices - from hallucinations to flashback sequences. Saturation of vivid primaries and stability of colors, especially in the psychedelic party scene, highlight the quality of the color palette. The density and clarity across various lighting conditions have been notably enhanced, producing superior depth in visuals. Grain structure remains evident but consistently managed, preserving the film’s authentic texture.

Detail is paramount in this release; from Voight’s self-assessment in reflective surfaces to the gritty portrayal of late 1960s New York streets. The restoration captures and exhibits every nuance: gritty textures on streets, sweat beads on Hoffman's face, and accumulated dirt on Buck’s leather jacket are vividly rendered. Black levels have achieved pitch-perfect depth with no haze observable in prior releases. This Criterion edition is unquestionably the definitive digital presentation of "Midnight Cowboy," effortlessly surpassing presentations in legacy formats but leaving room for an eventual 4K Ultra HD release.

Criterion's Region B-locked, UK Blu-ray release of "Midnight Cowboy" presents dual audio options for an immersive experience: the authentic LPCM 1.0 mono track and the expansive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 remix. The original monaural soundtrack, sourced from the 35mm magnetic track, stands out as the favored choice, offering a superior alignment with the film's historical identity. The mono presentation remains clean and free of any age-related audio defects, delivering clear dialogue, John Barry's evocative score, and the period-specific tunes with impactful precision.

While the DTS-HD MA 5.1 remix broadens the soundstage, adding environmental ambience and background score effects, it does not significantly enhance the film's visceral qualities. The surround sound mix, although not overly immersive, effectively brings the bustling New York backdrop to life but can feel excessive in comparison to the more intimate mono track. Dialogues are firmly centered and prioritize clarity, preserving the gritty atmosphere intrinsic to Midnight Cowboy's essence.

In essence, both audio tracks have commendable qualities; however, the LPCM 1.0 mono mix is distinguished by its robustness and authenticity. It ensures a faithful auditory experience to match the film’s poignant narrative without unnecessary embellishments, making it the preferred choice for cinephiles seeking an accurate representation of this classic film.

Criterion's UK Blu-ray release of "Midnight Cowboy" presents an impressive array of extras that blend newly produced content with archival gems. This extensive collection includes multifaceted commentaries and thoughtful interviews that enrich the understanding of the film's production and legacy. Director John Schlesinger's 1991 audio commentary is particularly illuminating, offering detailed insights into the film's creation. Cinematographer Adam Holender's selected-scene commentary adds a rich layer of technical expertise, focusing on the film's visual style. The set also revisits two substantial documentaries from the 35th Anniversary DVD, along with a selection of engaging interviews and behind-the-scenes footage that provide a comprehensive look at the people and processes behind this iconic film.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Original 1991 commentary track by John Schlesinger and Jerome Hellman.
• After Midnight: Reflecting on a Classic 35 Years Later: Interviews with cast and crew discussing the film's history.
• Controversy and Acclaim: Examination of the controversy surrounding the film’s release.
• Michael Childers Interview: Recollections from Schlesinger’s personal assistant and life partner.
• Adam Holender Interview: Detailed discussion on the film’s visual style and key sequences.
• The Crowd Around the Cowboy: Behind-the-scenes footage from the 1969 shoot.
• John Schlesinger Interview: Archival interview focusing on themes of homosexuality in his work.
• John Schlesinger BAFTA Tribute: Compilation of tribute excerpts from a 2002 BAFTA event.
• Jon Voight interview (The David Frost Show): Discussion on Voight's entry into film and comedy.
• Jon Voight Screen Tests: Hilarious vintage screen tests for the film.
• Waldo Salt: A Screenwriter's Journey: Award-winning documentary on Salt's career.
• Trailer: Restored theatrical trailer for "Midnight Cowboy".

John Schlesinger's 1969 film "Midnight Cowboy" remains an enduring, complex exploration of loneliness and human connection set amidst the gritty backdrop of New York City. Adapted from James Leo Herlihy's novel, it follows Joe Buck (Jon Voight), a hopeful Texan aspiring to be a high-end hustler in the big city. His journey quickly turns sour, pushing him into an unlikely friendship with Enrico "Ratso" Rizzo (Dustin Hoffman), a street-savvy conman. Through fragmented flashbacks and surreal dream sequences, the film intricately portrays their psychological scars and shared struggle for survival in an unforgiving urban landscape. The raw narrative, remarkable directorial vision, and iconic performances by Voight and Hoffman elevate the film to cinematic legend status.

The technical brilliance of "Midnight Cowboy" is apparent in Adam Holender's compelling cinematography and John Barry's evocative score. The film blurs the lines between reality and nightmarish hallucinations, setting a precedent emulated by future filmmakers. Distinguished by Oscar-winning achievements, this was the first X-rated film to secure the Best Picture award, later re-rated to an R. The juxtaposition of Joe's naive optimism with Ratso's grim practicality creates a tapestry of hope and despair, as they navigate a world where their dreams repeatedly collide with harsh realities. Their poignant bond, unmarred by overt sentimentality, underscores the brutal yet tender nature of their friendship.

Substantial in its impact, "Midnight Cowboy" retains its relevance through powerful storytelling and indelible character studies. It paints a stark picture of ambition dashed by societal indifference, yet never loses sight of human resilience. The Criterion Blu-ray release meticulously preserves this masterpiece, offering comprehensive supplemental features that delve into its creation and enduring influence. This film is a striking commentary on human endurance and connection, echoing timelessly across decades as a touchstone of American cinema.

John Schlesinger's landmark 1969 film "Midnight Cowboy" is an iconic entry in the golden era of 60s and 70s Hollywood cinema, exuding bold attitude, unique visual style, and fearless acting. Featuring standout performances by Dustin Hoffman and Jon Voight, this gritty film captured the essence of its time with an uncompromising narrative and earned its place in history as the only X-rated film to ever win an Academy Award for Best Picture. The Criterion Collection's Region B-locked UK Blu-ray edition delivers an exceptional presentation through a meticulously executed 4K restoration, offering stunning visual fidelity and superb audio quality.

This release from Criterion is laden with a wealth of supplementary content that elevates it to a definitive edition. Highlights include an insightful audio commentary by director John Schlesinger and producer Jerome Hellman, as well as a comprehensive video essay by cinematographer Adam Holender. These features delve into the stylistic choices and the artistic vision behind the film, providing an enriched viewing experience. Moreover, the beautifully restored mono audio track and the hours of additional bonus material underscore the thoroughness of this edition, making it an indispensable acquisition for both fans and newcomers.

In conclusion, "Midnight Cowboy" remains a tough but essential classic that every film enthusiast should experience. The Criterion Blu-ray edition not only honors its legacy with impeccable restoration but also provides extensive insights into its creation. Truly, this release is highly recommended for its historical significance, stellar performances, and outstanding technical presentation. Whether you are revisiting this masterpiece or exploring it for the first time, this Blu-ray edition is a must-have for any serious collector.