The Little Drummer Girl Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 57
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Rushed screenplay and miscasting mar 'The Little Drummer Girl,' but Warner Archive's Blu-ray will please established fans with its adequate 1080p presentation.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
The Little Drummer Girl's 1080p/SDR transfer shines in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, boasting rich, organic textures and accurate colors. However, it lacks fine detail and can appear soft. Despite this, the encode is commendable with minimal macro blocking, making it the best home video release to date.
Audio: 72
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix for 'The Little Drummer Girl' adeptly splits the original mono track into two channels, delivering clear dialogue and well-balanced effects, though it falls short in providing the dynamic range and impact expected for an espionage thriller. Despite mild hiss in some scenes, the overall presentation is competent and distraction-free.
Extra: 6
The one-disc release features minimal extras, limited to a single 1:49 theatrical trailer presented in HD from an SD source, reflecting the boutique label's policy of carrying over existing supplements.
Movie: 50
The Little Drummer Girl's Blu-ray highlights its stunning locations and solid supporting cast, but the film falls short due to Diane Keaton's miscasting and a screenplay that inadequately condenses John le Carré’s dense novel, resulting in a rushed and confusing plot that lacks the necessary depth and tension of spy thrillers.
Video: 72
Warner Archive's release of "The Little Drummer Girl" presents the film in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, delivered in 1080p/SDR. The transfer effectively maintains a robust, film-like quality that is free from noticeable wear-and-tear. The color palette is well-represented, with an array of earth tones and muted colors punctuated by the occasional vivid hues found in specific costumes and backgrounds, as well as infrequent explosions. While the fine detail isn't as sharp as one might hope, and night scenes tend to be flat and murky, these aspects accurately reflect the characteristics of the original film stock.
Encoding appears to be a strong point, with bit rates hovering around ~30Mbps, avoiding common issues such as macro blocking or posterization. Despite the transfer stemming from an older HD master, which results in a somewhat soft image lacking in fine detail and grain retention, the overall presentation is solid and pleasing. Colors remain stable, with acceptable flesh tones, and there are no age-related issues such as splices or scratches.
The disc employs the AVC codec and splits the film into 26 chapters. For fans of the film, this Blu Ray likely remains the best home video option to date, though it is clear that Warner Archive's efforts resulted in a competent but ultimately middling transfer. The primary strengths lie in its faithful reproduction of the original filmic experience and a well-maintained encode.
Audio: 72
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray of "The Little Drummer Girl" employs a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix, which successfully transposes the original mono source into a two-channel configuration. Dialogue is clean and well-prioritized, ensuring clarity and coherence in both group conversations and individual lines. Background effects and diegetic music cues also achieve a satisfactory degree of punch and realism, contributing to an immersive experience. Unfortunately, mild hiss does appear in some scenes, likely a remnant from the original location recordings, but these instances are not overly distracting.
However, the mix falls somewhat short of its potential, particularly given the film's espionage genre which typically benefits from a more expansive sound design. While the basics of music, dialogue, and sound effects are competently handled, the track lacks the emotive force one might expect during more action-packed sequences. There is a noticeable lack of heft in explosive scenes, which could have benefitted from a more dynamic range. Despite its constraints, the mix is free of notable anomalies such as pops, crackle, and flutter, making it a reliable presentation overall. Optional English (SDH) subtitles are included during the main feature for accessibility.
Extras: 6
The Blu-ray release of "The Little Drummer Girl" presents a straightforward packaging with no additional inserts, focusing on maintaining the essence of previous editions. The bonus features are minimal but well-preserved in HD format, though the quality suggests they originated from an SD source. While the inclusion of additional extras would have enhanced the overall value, the available supplement provides a nostalgic glimpse into the film's original promotional efforts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Theatrical Trailer: A classic promotional piece offering a brief look into the film.
Movie: 50
George Roy Hill’s 1984 adaptation of John le Carré’s "The Little Drummer Girl" is an ambitious yet ultimately flawed spy thriller that struggles to capture the novel’s intricate narrative. The screenplay by Loring Mandel attempts to cram a substantial amount of plot into its 132-minute runtime, resulting in a rushed and sometimes confusing experience. The film follows Charlie (Diane Keaton), an American actress with strong anti-Zionist beliefs, who is manipulated by Mossad agents into infiltrating the Palestinian Liberation Organization. Despite the globe-trotting locales and rich source material, the film falters primarily due to miscasting and lackluster pacing. Keaton, in particular, is severely out of place for a role intended for a younger actress, which detracts significantly from the film's credibility.
Compounding these issues is Hill’s direction, which lacks the nuanced tension and depth necessary for a compelling espionage drama. Klaus Kinski’s performance as Mossad leader Martin Kurtz brings some much-needed gravitas, supported by notable actors like Yorgo Voyagis and Sami Frey. However, the film’s staid direction and softened political implications reduce the intricacy that le Carré meticulously developed in his novel. The rapid shifts in locations—ranging from London to Beirut—are visually appealing but do little to mask the missing narrative depth that would otherwise clarify character motivations and plot developments.
The Blu-ray release by Warner Archive does ensure high-quality audio-visual presentation, showcasing its scenic backdrops and occasional moments of technical prowess. Nevertheless, the film’s inability to balance its multifaceted storyline with coherent pacing remains a significant drawback. While enthusiasts of le Carré’s work might find some points of interest, this adaptation ultimately falls short, serving as a curiosity rather than a definitive portrayal of the author’s complex storytelling.
Total: 57
"The Little Drummer Girl," George Roy Hill's adaptation of John Le Carré’s espionage novel, often struggles to deliver the depth and intrigue expected from such a rich source material. While the film builds moments of compelling spy drama, the rushed screenplay and a notably miscast protagonist may hinder complete immersion. Nonetheless, fans of Hill's work can find some merit in this adaptation, making it worth a watch for those already familiar with his directorial style and legacy.
The Warner Archive Blu-ray release presents "The Little Drummer Girl" in a 1080p format, boasting a decent, though not spectacular, visual presentation. The lack of a new scan or restoration leaves some room for improvement in terms of picture quality. Additionally, the Blu-ray features only a single supplementary item, offering minimal added value to collectors and new viewers alike.
In conclusion, while the production value and execution may falter at points, this release holds its own weight predominantly for fans of George Roy Hill and John Le Carré. Established admirers may find enough intrinsic value to justify the purchase, but those unfamiliar with its context may wish to approach this Blu-ray with measured expectations.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
Fine detail isn't exactly tack-sharp and night scenes are predictably flat and murky, but both elements certainly look accurate to this kind of film stock: contrasts between light and shadow doing most...
Audio: 80
Group conversations sound natural and are rarely cramped by the narrow field, while diegetic music cues -- at least those not coming from a lo-fi car radio -- actually enjoy a surprising amount of punch...
Extras: 10
This one-disc release ships in a keepcase with poster-themed cover artwork and no inserts of any kind....
Movie: 60
My immediate knee-jerk reaction to The Little Drummer Girl doesn't seem too far removed from a general consensus upon its 1984 theatrical release: it feels rushed, several portions of its plot are poorly...
Total: 60
George Roy Hill's The Little Drummer Girl was the late, great director's second-to-last film (arriving between 1982's underrated The World According to Garp and 1988's Funny Farm); it builds a decent amount...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
If you’re a fan of the film already, then you won’t need much convincing to pick this one up, but it’s still definitely a middling transfer supported by a decent encode....
Audio: 60
You’d figure a spy film that’s supposed to be filled with tension and explosions would have a bit more boisterous of a track, but everything here is still resolved fine and music and dialogue are mixed...
Extras: 0
As for supplements, we get a single trailer presented in HD from what looks to be an SD source....
Movie: 40
While The Sting and Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid are certainly the more well-known entries in the director’s career, I grew up on watching Slap Shot and taking with me the kind of hilarity that can...
Total: 60
The new 1080p presentation on this Warner Archive Blu-ray release is decent but still leaves much to be desired given no new scan or restoration was performed....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 80
It’s never truly sharp (possibly it was filmed that way, but my memory of my one theatrical screening of the film is vague), but color is acceptable with good flesh tones....
Audio: 90
Dialogue, music (by Dave Grusin), and most of the sound effects are all professionally rendered though one might think some of the explosive blasts lack a bit of heft....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 60
Director George Roy Hill doesn’t always make things easy for viewers who have not read the book before partaking of the film, but eventually the narrative begins to smooth out into the second hour as the...
Total: 60
Fans of John Le Carré’s espionage novel The Little Drummer Girl may not find George Roy Hill’s 1984 film version fully satisfying, but with attention to detail and a little patience, the home moviegoing...
Director: George Roy Hill
Actors: Diane Keaton, Yorgo Voyagis, Klaus Kinski
PlotCharlie, a struggling American actress in London, is recruited by an Israeli intelligence officer named Kurtz for a covert operation. Masquerading as the lover of a Palestinian terrorist, she is tasked with infiltrating a terrorist network responsible for bombings in Europe. Charlie's life becomes a tangled web of deception as she undergoes intensive training to adopt her new identity. She faces psychological challenges and moral dilemmas, as she must convince everyone around her, including herself, of her new allegiance. Kurtz meticulously guides Charlie through this transformation, preparing her for the dangerous mission ahead.
As Charlie embeds herself deeper into her role, the line between her real self and the character she is portraying begins to blur. She finds herself increasingly conflicted about her feelings and her actions, especially as she interacts with members of the terrorist group and forms connections with them. The operation's stakes escalate when unexpected twists test her loyalty and resolve. Tension mounts, and Charlie must navigate a perilous path filled with lies, loyalty conflicts, and the looming threat of exposure. Each step brings her closer to the heart of the terrorist network and further from her past life, setting the stage for a gripping climax where her true allegiances will be put to the ultimate test.
Writers: Loring Mandel, John le Carré
Release Date: 19 Oct 1984
Runtime: 130 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English