Robot Carnival 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 55
from 1 reviewers
Review Date:
Robot Carnival dazzles in 4K UHD, showcasing Otomo's genius with spectacular visuals and audio; a must-see anthology.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
DTS-HD MA
Video: 82
Released in stunning 4K UHD by Discotek, Robot Carnival shines with excellent color, subtle HDR, and options for 1.85:1 widescreen or 1.33:1 full frame, maintaining its filmic beauty despite minor specks.
Audio: 0
The release, with English and Japanese DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 and English subs, offers spectacular lossless audio that elevates the 4K viewing with its exquisite score and expert sound direction by Yasunori Honda, ensuring a magical experience.
Extra: 86
The release boasts a high-quality o-card slipcover with alternative artwork beneath, complemented by extras including a 22:30 HD documentary 'The Memory of Robot Carnival,' alongside original and teaser trailers in HD, enriching the viewing experience.
Movie: 86
Robot Carnival is a visionary anime anthology featuring top talents and exquisite animations, making it a must-see for fans of sci-fi and robots.
Video: 82
The release of "Robot Carnival" on 4K UHD Blu-ray by Discotek marks a significant upgrade in viewing quality for enthusiasts and collectors alike. Offered in a dual aspect ratio format, viewers can choose between a modern 1.85:1 widescreen presentation or a classic 1.33:1 full frame that caters to purists. Regardless of preference, both versions benefit from a native 4K UHD encode, ensuring that the animated anthology's artistic nuances are presented in spectacular detail. The default setting of the 16:9 widescreen version is a testament to Discotek's understanding of contemporary viewing standards, though it's noteworthy that this release is exclusive to 4K UHD, without a standard Blu-ray counterpart.
In terms of visual fidelity, the HDR (High Dynamic Range) implementation on "Robot Carnival" is both understated and impactful, enhancing the vibrancy and depth of the animation's color palette without overstating its effect. The color reproduction is exceptionally faithful to the original artwork, showcasing a wide spectrum of hues that breathe life into each segment. While there has been slight use of noise reduction, it does not detract from the overall viewing experience; instead, it contributes to a cleaner visual presentation. Despite minor instances of dirt specks visible on the print, these imperfections do not impair the inherent filmic quality that fans cherish, maintaining an authentic cinematic texture.
This 4K UHD presentation by Discotek not only highlights the meticulous care taken in preserving the animation's original aesthetics but also elevates the viewing experience through advanced video technology. The print's condition is commendably well-maintained, allowing the unique charm and creativity of "Robot Carnival" to be appreciated like never before. Through this release, Discotek solidifies its reputation for delivering high-quality anime restorations, offering both longtime fans and newcomers an exceptional opportunity to experience one of the genre's most imaginative works in unprecedented clarity.
Audio:
The audio presentation of "Robot Carnival" on 4K UHD Blu-Ray elevates the viewing experience to new heights, thanks to its meticulously crafted soundscapes in both English and Japanese versions. Delivered in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, the lossless audio encoding intricately preserves the nuance and dynamism of the film's expansive score, allowing viewers to become fully immersed in its enchanting musical journey. The clarity and depth of the sound bring a rich supplementary layer to the film's visual splendor, offering an auditory experience that is as compelling and evocative as the animation is visually.
Yasunori Honda's adept sound direction shines through in this high-definition presentation, capturing every audio nuance with precision and depth. Known for his work on series like "Black Lagoon" and "Dragon Ball Super," Honda’s expertise ensures that each auditory element, from the subtlest ambient noise to the most sweeping musical composition, is reproduced with exceptional fidelity. This ensures that audiences are not merely watching the film but are enveloped in its fantastical world, courtesy of an audio mix that complements and enhances the visual feast of "Robot Carnival."
The combination of the lossless audio encoding with the film’s score creates a mesmerizing auditory experience. Whether consumed in its original Japanese DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 with English subtitles or the equally compelling English version, the sound design and musical score are exquisitely presented, contributing significantly to the magical experience of viewing "Robot Carnival" on 4K UHD Blu-Ray. This presentation not only honors the original sonic vision of Yasunori Honda but also serves as a testament to the enduring power of high-quality audio in augmenting the cinematic experience.
Extras: 86
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Robot Carnival" boasts a meticulously curated selection of extras that complement its main feature splendidly. The packaging itself, with an o-card slipcover, starts off the premium experience, offering both the original and an alternate artwork option, catering to collectors' aesthetics. Key highlights include "The Memory of Robot Carnival" documentary, providing an insightful 22-and-a-half-minute journey into the making and impact of this cult classic. The selection is rounded off with trailers and a Blu-ray menu video, all in high definition, ensuring that enthusiasts have a well-rounded understanding and appreciation of the film's legacy in anime history.
Extras included in this disc:
- O-card Slipcover: Features original and alternative artwork under the slipcover.
- The Memory of Robot Carnival: A documentary delving into the film's creation and legacy.
- Original US Theatrical Trailer
- Blu-ray Teaser Trailer
- Blu-ray Menu Video
Movie: 86
Robot Carnival" emerges as a pioneering collection of short films, orchestrating a seamless blend of visionary storytelling and cutting-edge animation. Spearheaded by producer Kazufumi Nomura and brought to life by the animators at APPP, this anthology transcends ordinary narrative boundaries to explore futuristic realms where robots unravel the fabric of existence. Noteworthy for its eclectic voice cast, including Hikaru Kotono and Kei Tomiyama, the film's immersive universe is both an homage to and a leap forward from traditional anime. It is a continent-spanning journey through the minds of nine creative visionaries, cementing its status as an indispensable classic for aficionados of science fiction and robotic lore.
In terms of technical execution, "Robot Carnival" is a feast for the senses. The animation quality, thanks to talents like Akira Yamakawa and Yuji Sawai, coupled with Toshiaki Morita's evocative cinematography, creates a visually stunning tapestry that captivates from the first frame. The character designs, a collaborative effort from powerhouses such as Atsuko Fukushima and Hiroyuki Kitazume, imbue the anthology with a unique aesthetic. Additionally, the score, featuring maestros Joe Hisaishi and Masahisa Takeichi, weaves a sonic landscape that elevates the narrative to new heights, making the film not just a visual but an auditory masterpiece as well.
At its core, "Robot Carnival" is a testament to the power of collective creativity. Directed by luminaries including Katsuhiro Otomo and Hidetoshi Ōmori, each segment reflects a unique perspective within the shared theme of robotic innovation and existential exploration. The anthology format allows for a rich diversity of stories and styles, making it a groundbreaking venture in the realm of anime. Essential viewing for enthusiasts of the medium, "Robot Carnival" offers a transcendent experience that challenges and delights, securing its place as a landmark in animated filmmaking.
Total: 55
Robot Carnival" emerges on 4K UHD Blu-ray as a spectacle of artistic prowess and intricate storytelling, further cemented by the involvement of renowned filmmaker Katsuhiro Otomo. This anthology showcases an array of narratives, each imbued with a unique visual and thematic identity, yet collectively reflecting the filmmakers' grand vision. The transfer to 4K UHD is nothing short of remarkable, presenting viewers with a pristine 2160p video quality that elevates the viewing experience to new heights. The audio component is equally impressive, boasting a lossless audio track that encompasses the viewer in a dynamic auditory landscape.
The technical specifications of this release are noteworthy, highlighting the meticulous care taken in upgrading the film for 4K enthusiasts. The inclusion of high-quality extras adds value, making it a comprehensive package for fans and newcomers alike. Viewers are treated to a visual feast that is both epic in scope and intimate in detail, enhanced by the technological advancements employed in this release. The preservation of artistic integrity while embracing the latest in home entertainment technology is commendable.
In conclusion, "Robot Carnival" on 4K UHD Blu-ray is an indispensable addition to the collections of cinephiles who appreciate the confluence of groundbreaking animation and storytelling finesse. With its visually arresting presentation, immersive audio, and enriching bonus features, this release exemplifies how technological advancements can breathe new life into classic films. It stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of "Robot Carnival," ensuring that its artistic achievements continue to resonate with audiences across generations.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 90
The high dynamic range HDR implementation is both subtle and beautiful throughout the entire presentation....
Audio: 0
The lossless audio encoding was spectacular and a great accompaniment to seeing the film on 4K....
Extras: 90
The art-work underneath the slipcover features impressive alternative art- work (if one chooses to display two forms of key art with the package)....
Movie: 90
Fans of Otomo's Memories (which also provided an important selection of short stories in a similar anthology form) will find plenty to appreciate about Robot Carnival and the magic it offers....
Total: 60
The filmmaking is spectacular and the epic quality of the production is on full display throughout the film....
Director: Atsuko Fukushima, Hiroyuki Kitakubo, Hiroyuki Kitazume, Kôji Morimoto, Takashi Nakamura, Yasuomi Umetsu, Manabu Ôhashi, Hidetoshi Ômori, Katsuhiro Ôtomo
Actors: Kôji Moritsugu, Yayoi Maki, Keiko Hanagata, Kumiko Takizawa
PlotIn a dystopian landscape, a mammoth, rusting robot lumbers across the desert, approaching a peaceful village. It is a derelict traveling circus, "Robot Carnival," announcing its arrival with vast explosions and the blaring of its ominous theme. The villagers, initially unaware of what the approaching spectacle holds, are quickly enmeshed in its surreal and destructive pageantry. This is the framing story that introduces the anthology of diverse tales that orbit around the central theme of robots and technology in varying states of harmony and conflict with humankind.
Each segment of the anthology explores unique narratives, ranging from whimsical to tragic, all through the lens of animated science fiction. These stories include a Frankenstein-inspired tale of a scientist breathing life into a creation that spirals out of control, a poignant struggle of an android unable to express her human-like feelings, and a satirical comedy about an inept robot attempting household chores with disastrous consequences. Rendered through differing styles of animation, the sequences probe the multifaceted relationship between robots and their creators, ranging from allegorical critiques of industrial society to heartfelt examinations of the seemingly inescapable loneliness in a technologically saturated world.
Writers: Hiroyuki Kitakubo (scenario), Hiroyuki Kitazume (scenario), Kôji Morimoto (scenario), Takashi Nakamura (scenario), Yasuomi Umetsu (scenario), Tom Wyner (dialogue: english version), Manabu Ôhashi (scenario), Hidetoshi Ômori (scenario), Katsuhiro Ôtomo (scenario)
Release Date: 21 Jul 1987
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Japan
Language: Japanese, English