The Flame of New Orleans Blu-ray Review
Score: 63
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Flame of New Orleans offers charming performances and beautiful visuals, especially for Marlene Dietrich fans, but remains a visually appealing, light romantic romp.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 65
The Flame of New Orleans, presented by Kino Lorber in 1080p MPEG-4 AVC, features lush black-and-white cinematography with excellent clarity and superior grayscale, despite occasional print damage including intermittent white blotches and faint vertical lines. The detailed visuals honor its Oscar-nominated Art Direction.
Audio: 78
The lossless DTS-HD Master Audio mono track of 'The Flame of New Orleans' provides clear, distortion-free dialogue and rich, full vocals. Frank Skinner's score is rendered with excellent fidelity, and age-related artifacts like hiss and pops are effectively scrubbed away, creating a clean, lively audio experience.
Extra: 37
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Flame of New Orleans' include a spirited audio commentary featuring historians Lee Gambin and Rutanya Alda, balancing technical insights with engaging anecdotes, despite occasional errors and offensive language. Also included are trailers for related releases by Kino Lorber.
Movie: 60
The Flame of New Orleans shines with Marlene Dietrich's magnetism and Rudolph Maté's lush black-and-white cinematography, but its narrative charm is hampered by a slight script and censorship issues. Despite production challenges, the film provides an engaging, albeit somewhat underwhelming, romantic adventure.
Video: 65
The Blu-ray release of "The Flame of New Orleans" by Kino Lorber boasts a striking 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded high-definition presentation in the theatrical 1.33:1 full-frame aspect ratio. The renowned black-and-white cinematography by Rudolph Maté is beautifully rendered, with lush visuals elevating the viewing experience. Bright and vibrant imagery underscores much of the film, with excellent clarity, contrast, and a pleasing grayscale that honors Maté's sumptuous work. While there are instances of minor print damage, occasional specks, and vertical lines, these moments are not overly distracting to the overall presentation.
In terms of detail, the transfer enhances the textures and intricate design of the film's Oscar-nominated Art Direction-Interior Decoration, allowing viewers to appreciate close-ups and the glamour of Marlene Dietrich’s wardrobe in sharp detail. Crisp whites and deep blacks contribute to a strong grayscale spectrum, maintaining the visual integrity of celluloid through a healthy grain structure. Even when Dietrich’s face is partially veiled, the image quality captures the Hollywood glamor synonymous with the era. Despite some imperfections such as scratches, spotting, and flicker, the visual presentation remains consistently engaging and does not detract significantly from the overall enjoyment.
Overall, while "The Flame of New Orleans" may not reach the pinnacle of some recent Kino Lorber Dietrich transfers, it stands as a noteworthy and commendable effort. The few technical issues observed do not overshadow the otherwise impressive and lustrous visual quality that pays homage to this classic film.
Audio: 78
The audio presentation of "The Flame of New Orleans" on Blu-ray features a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono soundtrack that excels in clarity and depth. Dialogue reproduction is consistently superb and understandable throughout, with no notable issues related to hiss, crackling, or other age-related artifacts. The track retains an admirable fidelity, preserving the integrity of the original production while enhancing the listening experience. Additionally, Marlene Dietrich's singing vocals are rendered rich and full, contributing to the film’s vibrant soundscape.
Frank Skinner's lilting and romantic musical score benefits tremendously from this high-quality audio encode. It presents a wide dynamic scale that handles both subtle nuances and more pronounced sonic elements without distortion. This meticulous treatment ensures that all aspects of the soundtrack—from soft atmospheric layers to more prominent audio details—are crisp and distinct. Overall, the lossless DTS-HD Master Audio track offers a clean, lively audio experience that is well-matched to the visual quality of the film. Optional English subtitles are available, providing further accessibility.
In sum, the DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track enriches "The Flame of New Orleans" by delivering a robust sound mix characterized by clarity, depth, and professionalism. The absence of any age-related audio imperfections combined with an excellent reproduction of dialogue and music make this audio presentation a noteworthy complement to the film's visuals.
Extras: 37
The Blu-ray of "The Flame of New Orleans" includes a set of extras that, although limited, offer valuable insights and historical context for enthusiasts. The audio commentary, hosted by author/historian Lee Gambin and actress/film historian Rutanya Alda, delivers a lively and engaging discussion, blending Gambin’s detailed production analysis with Alda’s personal anecdotes and trivia about Marlene Dietrich. While some factual inaccuracies are noted, the commentary remains informative and compelling. Additionally, the disc features the original theatrical trailer and a selection of trailers for other classic films, further enriching the viewer's experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Lively discussion by author/historian Lee Gambin and actress/film historian Rutanya Alda.
- The Flame of New Orleans Trailer: Original theatrical trailer.
- The Blue Angel: Trailer for another Dietrich feature.
- The Song of Songs: Trailer for another Dietrich feature.
- The Spoilers: Trailer for another Dietrich feature.
- Pittsburgh: Trailer for another Dietrich feature.
- A Foreign Affair: Trailer for another Dietrich feature.
- No Highway in the Sky: Trailer for another Dietrich feature.
- Witness for the Prosecution: Trailer for another Dietrich feature.
- The Young in Heart: Trailer for another Dietrich feature.
Movie: 60
"The Flame of New Orleans" is an engaging romantic adventure, illuminated by Marlene Dietrich's stellar performance. Dietrich, as the ambitious Claire Ledeux, seamlessly blends charm with a touch of the risqué, embodying a character who must decide between two romantic interests: the wealthy Charles Giraud (Roland Young) and the thrilling Captain Robert LaTour (Bruce Cabot). The lead role capitalizes on Dietrich's magnetic presence, elevating a narrative that, while light and carefree, captivates the audience with its playful twists and turns.
Technically, the film shines with its production design, art direction, and period costumes by Ren� Hubert, which enhance the storytelling. Clair's sophisticated direction combined with Rudolph Maté’s lush black-and-white cinematography imparts a romantic aura that aligns well with the film's setting. Despite some script limitations and censorship issues that led to cuts, the screenplay by Norman Krasna retains its charm, bolstered by deft editing by Frank Gross. The ensemble cast, including notable performances from Mischa Auer, Andy Devine, and Theresa Harris, fills in the comedic gaps left by Dietrich's more reserved comedic approach.
Overall, while "The Flame of New Orleans" may not rival the best comedies of its time or fully unleash Clair’s Lubitsch-like flair, it offers an artistic and delightful journey for fans of classic cinema. The movie sustains viewer interest through its charming characters and opulent visual appeal, even if its narrative may feel slightly fleeting. Dietrich's allure remains the centerpiece, making it a worthwhile viewing experience, especially for her admirers.
Total: 63
René Clair's "The Flame of New Orleans," released in 1941, stars Marlene Dietrich in a delightful yet lightweight romantic comedy. Renowned for her captivating screen presence, Dietrich elevates the film with a quality lead performance that endears her to fans old and new. The plot centers around sexual manipulation and a comedic masquerade, set against a visually appealing period backdrop. Despite its charming presentation and some clever moments, the film struggles to stand out within its genre.
Technically, the Blu-ray offers a good but not exceptional video transfer, maintaining the essence of the original cinematography. The audio quality is solid, preserving the period atmosphere René Clair intended. However, the movie’s pacing only truly picks up in its second half, making the first portion more of a slow burn. This uneven pacing may deter casual viewers, although dedicated Dietrich enthusiasts will find it a valuable addition to their high-definition collections.
In conclusion, "The Flame of New Orleans" is a charming diversion with impressive performances, particularly by Marlene Dietrich. While it may not be a masterpiece, its allure and historical value make it worth watching, especially for dedicated fans of the actress. Check it out.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 80
While the opening and closing credits of the film are window-boxed the rest of the picture fills the standard 4:3 framing....
Audio: 80
Featuring a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio mono soundtrack, The Flame of New Orleans has clear vitality and depth to the sound-mix....
Extras: 60
The release also includes the following trailers promoting other releases by distributor Kino Lorber: The Blue Angel (SD, 3:43), The Song of Songs (SD, 2:42), The Spoilers (SD, 1:48), Pittsburgh (SD, 2:05),...
Movie: 70
An entertaining experience with a solid performance by Marlene Dietrich The Flame of New Orleans is a charming and sweet confection of adventure and romance that will win the hearts of audiences looking...
Total: 70
Released precisely forty-eight years before my date of birth (on April 25th, 1941), The Flame of New Orleans is a charming diversion which has a quality lead performance by the beloved Hollywood actress...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
A healthy grain structure maintains the look and feel of celluloid, but never overwhelms the image, which remains pleasing - if not consistent and pristine - throughout....
Audio: 80
A wide dynamic scale handles all the highs and lows of Frank Skinner's lilting, romantic music score without a hint of distortion, and all the dialogue is easy to comprehend....
Extras: 20
Alda shares some titillating trivia (whether James Stewart really impregnated Dietrich - resulting in a subsequent abortion - on the set of Destry Rides Again and whether Dietrich really slept with three...
Movie: 60
On-set turbulence between Dietrich and co-star Cabot, a second-rate Clark Gable, also disrupted production (she reportedly thought he was a lousy actor and grew impatient with his lack of preparation and...
Total: 60
A good but not exceptional video transfer and solid audio make The Flame of New Orleans worthy of a purchase for Dietrich aficionados, but if you're not a Marlene maven, this enjoyable but forgettable...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 80
In the main, the image is beautiful, often lustrous with a strong grayscale featuring crisp, clean whites and deep blacks....
Audio: 100
Dialogue has been excellently recorded, and it has been mixed with Frank Skinner’s background score and the sound effects with much professionalism....
Extras: 40
Audio Commentary: Film historian Lee Gambin offers interesting observations on the film (though I didn’t appreciate the gay characters being referred to as “pansy” and “faggot” by Gambin) interrupted three...
Movie: 60
Dietrich wears a succession of elaborate Rene Hubert gowns that are showstopping in their opulence (her introduction at the opera swathed in virginal, sparkling white is rather extreme even for her), and...
Total: 60
While it looks beautiful, it’s rather like cotton candy: sweet to taste but rather insubstantial in the final analysis....
Director: René Clair
Actors: Marlene Dietrich, Bruce Cabot, Roland Young
PlotIn the bustling city of New Orleans, Claire Ledeux, a charming and mysterious woman, poses as the Countess Claire Ledoux, a supposed French aristocrat. Her goal is to marry a wealthy man to secure her financial future. She catches the eye of rich and respectable banker Charles Giraud who is captivated by her beauty and poise. However, complications arise when she crosses paths with Robert Latour, a rugged and adventurous sea captain. Claire finds herself torn between the comfort and security offered by Charles and the thrilling unpredictability that Robert brings into her life.
As Claire navigates her tangled emotions, her past and present begin to collide in unexpected ways. Her façade becomes difficult to maintain as both Charles and Robert vie for her affection, each representing different aspects of the life she aspires to lead. This love triangle pushes Claire to question her own desires and intentions, setting the stage for a series of heartfelt and humorous events. The narrative progresses with a mix of romance, comedy, and societal impressions as Claire grapples with her choices and the impending consequences of her deception.
Writers: Norman Krasna, René Clair
Release Date: 25 Apr 1941
Runtime: 79 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: French, English