Respect Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 6 reviewers
Review Date:
Respect's Blu-ray delivers an engaging tribute to Aretha Franklin, with outstanding visuals and sound, propelled by Jennifer Hudson's stellar performance.
Disc Release Date
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 79
The Blu-ray presentation of "Respect" delivers a solid 1080p transfer with a vintage, filmic quality that subtly captures the era's essence through mildly desaturated colors and strong detail. Despite its lack of 4K UHD, the AVC HD transfer offers gratifying clarity, accurate skin tones, and stable black levels, ensuring a pleasant viewing experience without significant flaws.
Audio: 89
Respect's Blu-ray boasts a remarkable Dolby Atmos soundtrack, primarily accentuating vocals and instrumentals with crisp, balanced clarity and dynamic range. While height channel engagement is subtle, the soundstage is immersive, enriching lively concert scenes and church services with atmospheric depth and seamless audio integration.
Extra: 51
The Blu-ray extras for "Respect" offer a concise yet immersive look into Aretha Franklin's legacy, focusing on Jennifer Hudson's transformation, director Liesl Tommy's vision, and the authentic production design. While featurettes lack depth, they provide valuable insights into the film's artistic and musical undertakings.
Movie: 75
Respect offers a compelling exploration of Aretha Franklin's life, powered by Jennifer Hudson's exceptional performance and a solid supporting cast. It navigates her soulful journey with adept direction, though occasionally glossing over complexities for a more polished narrative. A must-see for music fans and admirers of the Queen of Soul.
Video: 79
The Blu-ray release of "Respect" from Universal presents a technically robust 1080p transfer that provides viewers with a filmic and immersive experience. The 2.39:1 AVC HD rendering is consistent, accentuating the movie's period-specific aesthetics set from the 1950s to the 1970s with its mildly desaturated colors and muted palette. These deliberate choices in color composition offer a vintage appearance, enhancing the historical setting while gracefully avoiding the over-saturation that could detract from its authenticity. Despite avoiding vividness, the black levels are consistently solid, and white balance remains accurate throughout. Skin tones achieve a natural look, alongside strong fine detail capture that faithfully highlights facial features, clothing textures, and set elements. The visual experience is consistent with a new release Blu-ray without significant source or encoding issues.
Audiovisual enthusiasts might note the absence of a UHD release, which somewhat limits the presentation's modern "glossy" expectations but maintains clarity in its own right. The cinematography, characterized by a flat and film-like quality, bridges the gap between traditional and contemporary viewing experiences. While background details are clear and well-defined, the picture scale does reflect average definition primarily intended to complement the movie's stylistic narrative. Universal’s Blu-ray captures the film's moody aesthetic without compression artifacts, offering decent shadow delineation which prevents crush. The AVC encode portrays well the gritty ambiance without any processing flaws detected. Although the visual fidelity does not present an emphatic "wow factor," it nonetheless provides a seamless and pleasant viewing experience faithful to the director's vision of Aretha Franklin's storied life, rich in history and emotional depth.
Audio: 89
The Dolby Atmos audio presentation on the "Respect" Blu-ray offers an impressively dynamic and immersive listening experience that perfectly complements the film's musical and dramatic elements. While the mix isn't overly aggressive, it effectively utilizes the height channels for atmospheric effects, creating a tangible sense of immersion that enhances the onscreen narrative. The soundstage is notably broad, allowing for precise and engaging placement of audio objects, which involves viewers in key scenes, especially during bustling church services and vibrant concert performances.
Vocals take center stage in this mix, with Jennifer Hudson's powerful singing resonating clearly across a wide soundstage, demonstrating excellent clarity and presence. The mix's emphasis on music leverages a finely balanced dynamic range, capturing the wide highs and substantial lows inherent in soulful genres. Instrumentals are delivered with balanced power, while the bass maintains a significant impact throughout various scenes. Furthermore, dialogue is expertly prioritized, ensuring sharp and precise clarity even amidst the powerful musical backdrops.
Ambient effects are seamlessly integrated, enriching the overall auditory experience without overshadowing crucial elements. The track comes alive during concert sequences, showcasing rich, crystalline tones that fill the space effortlessly. This consistent audio quality showcases the distinct stereo separation and strong bass frequencies while retaining clean and subtle atmospheric nuances. Though some may desire an increased use of discrete height channels for more surround activity, the presented mix remains a standout feature that highlights Hudson's vocal prowess exceptionally well. Complementary to the English Dolby Atmos are alternative audio options: French 5.1 Dolby Audio, and Descriptive Video Service (DVS), with optional subtitles in English SDH, Spanish, and French.
Extras: 51
The Blu-ray release of "Respect" includes a robust selection of five featurettes that dive deeply into various aspects of the film's production and the legacy of Aretha Franklin. These extras, although brief, offer insights into the meticulous care, passion, and respect given to telling the Queen of Soul's story. Jennifer Hudson's portrayal is highlighted through her transformative process, committed vocal and instrumental training, and capturing the nuanced mannerisms of Franklin. The extras also celebrate director Liesl Tommy’s artistic vision and the authenticity brought to the film through detailed production design discussions. Significant attention is given to the historical and musical influences that shaped Franklin's evolution during her time at Muscle Shoals. A separate DVD copy and a digital code for purchase convenience accompany this release, though the digital code is limited to iTunes.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of Respect: Examination of story elements, themes, and live music recording.
- Becoming Aretha: Jennifer Hudson's journey into portraying Aretha Franklin.
- Capturing a Legacy: Celebrating Liesl Tommy’s direction and artistic influence.
- From Muscle Shoals: Exploration of Muscle Shoals’ impact on Franklin’s sound.
- Exploring the Design of Respect: Focus on the film’s authentic set and costume design.
Movie: 75
The Blu-ray release of "Respect" presents a compelling biopic of Aretha Franklin, blending deft storytelling with superb performances, notably from Jennifer Hudson. As a cinematic endeavor, the film covers the first thirty years of Franklin’s life, capturing her tumultuous journey from a young gospel singer to a global superstar. Emphasis is placed on the personal and professional adversities Franklin faced, such as navigating a domineering father, an abusive marriage, and maintaining spiritual faith amidst the trappings of fame. Director Liesl Tommy ensures that the narrative, while predictable in its rise-fall-redemption arc, stays engaging by deeply integrating Franklin’s spiritual roots and challenges into the storyline.
Hudson’s portrayal of Franklin is both respectful and electrifying, masterfully balancing vocal prowess with emotional depth without slipping into mere imitation. Supporting cast members, including Forest Whitaker as Franklin’s father and Marlon Wayans as her husband, provide strong performances that augment the central narrative. Whitaker, in particular, is praised for his compelling representation of the controlling minister, adding layers to the dynamic between Franklin and the patriarchal figures in her life. Despite some criticism for potentially sanitizing or glossing over more controversial elements of Franklin's life, "Respect" is lauded for its truthful depiction of the artist’s struggles with self-assertion and musical excellence.
Technical details elevate the viewing experience, with excellent sound design featuring Dolby Atmos and a visually sharp 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 video codec. The film's musical scenes, notably Hudson performing in renowned recording studios, are both vibrant and intimate. The inclusion of actual footage of Aretha Franklin's later performances enriches the film’s narrative arc. Overall, "Respect" is a well-crafted tribute to Aretha Franklin’s life and enduring legacy, providing an insightful glimpse into her world for both avid fans and newcomers alike.
Total: 77
Universal's Blu-ray release of "Respect" masterfully showcases the remarkable talent of Aretha Franklin through a vibrant portrayal by Jennifer Hudson. Directed by first-time director Liesl Tommy, the biopic artfully balances the high energy of Franklin's public persona with the intricacies of her private life, offering a comprehensive view that both fans and newcomers will appreciate. The film's pacing effectively manages its considerable runtime, ensuring constant engagement. Universal's Blu-ray presentation excels with a sharp video transfer and an impressive Dolby Atmos audio track, though the absence of a 4K UHD version is noted.
The disc provides valuable extras that dive into the film's meticulous design process, shedding light on production decisions. Costume designer Clint Ramos went to great lengths to authentically recreate period-specific costumes, enhancing the film’s intimate connection to the 1960s era. Production designer Ina Mayhew’s depiction of Aretha’s Detroit home and other key locations brings a palpable authenticity to the background settings, rendering them as integral components of the storyline. These detailed elements contribute significantly to the film's immersive experience.
In conclusion, "Respect" is a technically polished and dynamically engaging portrayal of Aretha Franklin’s life and legacy, powered by Jennifer Hudson's stunning performance. The Blu-ray edition does justice to the Queen of Soul with its superior audiovisual quality, making it an essential addition for admirers of Franklin's music. Despite its lack of a 4K release, this Blu-ray comes highly recommended for its compelling storytelling and pristine presentation.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
While there's no absolute vividness and punch and pop to speak of, the grounded palette is beautifully presented for the array of clothing hues and other critical location and support elements....
Audio: 90
While discrete height channel usage is not one of the track's priorities, the top end does finely compliment the entire soundtrack to bring life to bustling church services, lively concerts, and other...
Extras: 50
The Making of Respect (1080p, 7:20): Exploring key story elements and themes, the real Aretha Franklin, the film's commitment to exploring the character's real inward journey, Hudson's work and key cast...
Movie: 80
That is the path that the genre's latest, Respect, follows, but it does so in, dare say, a respectful manner as it keeps its focal character, the legendary Aretha Franklin, drawn to her spiritual roots...
Total: 70
It's well played, well made, and a pleasure certainly for Franklin's legion of fans but also for those who may know nothing about the star beyond her name the title song....
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 90
The film has a very light, warm feeling about it, though some of the musical numbers do bring out the best in what the image has to offer....
Audio: 100
The Dolby’s Atmos mix is a real winner here but ultimately the consumer gets one hell of a track....
Extras: 60
The Making of Respect – Explore the unique telling of this Aretha Franklin story, what the project meant to all involved and how music played a pivotal role in crafting this film....
Movie: 0
Not to be outdone by the cast, director Liesl Tommy, best-known for her work on TV’s Jessica Jones and The Walking Dead, does a fine job of rounding everything out....
Total: 70
There’s no denying that the story of Aretha Franklin was meant for the big screen and, truthfully, not many could have pulled it off....
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 95
The Dolby Atmos track is at its best in the rousing church and concert scenes, with worshippers and concert audiences, respectively, amen-ing or cheering....
Extras: 80
Movie: 90
The best ones focus on some form of personal adversity, whether it’s going against powerful fascist forces to do the right thing (Schindler’s List), overcoming physical disability to achieve great scientific...
Total: 90
Costume designer Clint Ramos strove to find a balance between the glamorous Aretha Franklin and her private life, and what she wore through the decades....
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 60
Universal gives Respect a technically sound transfer on Blu-ray which replicates the source material but it’s now more understandable why Respect was skipped for UHD....
Audio: 100
The soundstage is wide and impressive, creating a realistic atmosphere for Hudson’s vocal talent in different settings....
Extras: 20
A commentary would have been very helpful, MGM.The Making of Respect Featurette (07:20 in HD)Becoming Aretha Featurette (04:42 in HD) – Jennifer Hudson discusses how she always dreamed of playing Aretha...
Movie: 80
The narrative almost always elevates Aretha Franklin’s legacy at the expense of her family and associates, sometimes for drama, sometimes to paper over problems like two pregnancies before the age of fifteen....
Total: 65
...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Crystal clarity and excellent contrast distinguish this transfer that despite the lack of grain exudes a lovely film-like feel....
Audio: 80
The track really comes alive during the concert sequences, pumping out rich, crystalline tones that effortlessly fill the listening space and showcase the subtle nuances, impressive range, and unbridled...
Extras: 20
Featurette: "The Making of Respect" (HD, 7 minutes) - More of a celbration than a production chronicle, this slick piece looks at the influence of the church and gospel music on Franklin's life, the decision...
Movie: 60
Hudson, with her soaring vocals and intuitive performance, carries Respect, but Tommy also deserves credit for delivering a polished production that captures not only Franklin's essence but also the turbulent...
Total: 80
Jennifer Hudson brings the iconic singer to brilliant life in a powerful performance that overshadows the film's shortcomings....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 90
There are several set pieces that show off the track’s blend of music and, smaller object sounds that create a wonderfully involving listening experience, that broadens the soundstage....
Extras: 80
• The Making of Respect – Explore the unique telling of this Aretha Franklin story, what the project meant to all involved and how music played a pivotal role in crafting this film....
Movie: 70
is a biopic that touches first on the early parts of her life, followed by her struggles to find the music that would unleash the talent within her heart and soul....
Total: 83
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-RS2000 4K Ultra High Definition Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Director: Liesl Tommy
Actors: Jennifer Hudson, Forest Whitaker, Marlon Wayans
PlotThe film chronicles the journey of a young, talented singer from her early years in a supportive but complex household to her rise as a global music icon. Raised in Detroit, Michigan, she grows up singing in her father’s church choir, where she develops her powerful voice and finds refuge amid familial tensions. Surrounded by influential figures like her charismatic preacher father, she navigates both encouragement and control, striving to find her own voice. Facing personal challenges and societal pressures, she experiences a tumultuous path filled with triumphs and setbacks, all while trying to assert her artistic identity.
As she enters adulthood, she embarks on a professional music career, determined to succeed despite facing overwhelming obstacles. Aided by key relationships, both supportive and challenging, she discovers the power of her own voice. As her career takes off, she grapples with balancing public life and personal struggles, driven by a relentless pursuit of freedom and respect. Her journey is a tribute to resilience and self-discovery as she seeks to define her place in the world through music. Along the way, she becomes an influential figure whose impact extends far beyond mere performances, capturing the spirit of resistance and empowerment during cultural shifts in America.
Writers: Tracey Scott Wilson, Callie Khouri
Release Date: 13 Aug 2021
Runtime: 145 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Canada
Language: English