Escape from Alcatraz 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 75
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Escape From Alcatraz shines in 4K; a timeless film with technical nuances.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
Kino Lorber's Escape From Alcatraz 4K release dazzles with enhanced clarity and color, yet struggles with black crush in dark scenes, preserving the film's gritty essence.
Audio: 74
Both releases offer immersive audio with English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 & 5.1 tracks, enriching viewing through clear, atmospheric sounds and dynamic range, encouraging experimentation between tracks without age-related issues.
Extra: 71
This 4K Blu-ray release features insightful commentary by critics, captivating interviews with the screenwriter and actor, alongside a remastered trailer and a Clint Eastwood trailer gallery, enriching the viewing experience.
Movie: 91
Don Siegel's 'Escape From Alcatraz' gets a 4K release by Kino Lorber, enriching the true escape tale with new features & vintage insights, in a Region-Free package.
Video: 74
Kino Lorber’s 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Escape from Alcatraz" presents a significant upgrade over previous versions, offering viewers an impressive restoration sourced from a new 4K master. This Region-Free 4K Blu-ray/Blu-ray combo pack highlights the meticulous efforts put into preserving the film's original aesthetic while enhancing its visual clarity and detail. The transition to 4K with Dolby Vision HDR reveals a marked improvement in visual fidelity, notably in density levels and delineation during daylight scenes, which now boast superior clarity without any stability issues or digital artifacts marring the presentation. However, it’s important to note some instances of black crush that diminish details in darker scenes, a drawback that occasionally detracts from the otherwise stellar restoration.
Paramount's treatment of this classic film pays homage to its intentionally bleak and subdued palette, effectively maintaining the mood set by cinematographer Bruce Surtees, known as "The Prince of Darkness." This adherence to the film's original atmosphere doesn’t come at the cost of visual quality; the Dolby Vision HDR grading enhances the limited color scheme, ensuring that colors never feel oversaturated, and skin tones remain natural. The handling of film grain is mostly commendable, preserving the gritty texture essential to the film's character, though some grain management is noticeable during optical transitions. This minor inconsistency does little to detract from the overall transfer quality, which significantly outpaces that of previous releases in terms of clarity and detail retention, especially in tighter shots where textures and fine lines are more appreciable.
Despite a few areas where black levels could be better managed to avoid loss of detail in darker scenes, Kino Lorber’s release offers an undeniably superior viewing experience. The 4K restoration not only revives the film for a modern audience but also respects its original artistic vision, striking a careful balance between preserving atmospheric darkness and highlighting newfound details. This release exemplifies how advancements in home video technology can breathe new life into classic films, making "Escape from Alcatraz" a compelling watch in 4K UHD.
Audio: 74
The audio presentation of the 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Escape from Alcatraz" offers a robust auditory experience that faithfully complements the film’s atmospheric tension and dramatic nuances. Enthusiasts are presented with two primary audio tracks: English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 and English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1. Additionally, optional English SDH subtitles are available for those who require them. It is noteworthy that transitioning between the 2.0 and 5.1 tracks reveals a pleasantly versatile soundstage, both free from any discernible age-related distortions, making it beneficial for viewers to experiment with both options to enhance their viewing experience.
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, in particular, exhibits a slightly more pronounced presence when compared with the previous Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track from the Warner-issued disc, although the two are remarkably similar in quality. This newer track excels in delivering an immersive soundscape, with subtle environmental sounds—such as wind whistling through the prison, inmates coughing, and the echo of guards’ footsteps—as well as more bustling noises from the cafeteria and exercise yard scenes being cleanly articulated. These elements collectively create a palpable sense of scale and atmosphere that enhances the film’s setting.
Moreover, Jerry Fielding's eerie and suspenseful score is masterfully rendered across channels, further heightening the film’s tension and emotional depth. The careful balancing of ambient sounds with Fielding’s music ensures an engaging audio experience that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. Whether one opts for the classic 2.0 track or immerses themselves in the detailed 5.1 setup, the audio presentation of "Escape from Alcatraz" on this 4K release is meticulously crafted to support and elevate the visual narrative, making it a commendable component of this high-definition release.
Extras: 71
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Escape from Alcatraz" offers a judicious selection of extras that enriches the viewing experience with a blend of historical insights and technical commentary. The centerpiece is undoubtedly the new audio commentary by film historians Nathaniel Thompson and Steve Mitchell, who provide an in-depth analysis laden with production details and anecdotes, showcasing their deep research and genuine admiration for the film. Complementing this are exclusive interviews with screenwriter Richard Tuggle and actor Larry Hankin; Tuggle's discussion highlights the screenplay's evolution and its challenges, while Hankin offers an engaging account of his casting and experiences on set. Also included are a remastered vintage trailer for the film and a comprehensive Clint Eastwood trailer gallery, adding context to its place within Eastwood's storied career. The extras, although not voluminous, are thoughtfully curated to offer meaningful insights into the film's production and legacy.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Featuring Nathaniel Thompson and Steve Mitchell, provides a deep dive into the film's production and its significance.
- The Ghost of Alcatraz: An interview with Richard Tuggle detailing the screenplay's journey and evolution.
- Tales From the Cellblock: Larry Hankin shares his audition and filming experiences, including behind-the-scenes stories.
- Trailer: A remastered version of the original "Escape from Alcatraz" trailer.
- KLSC Clint Eastwood Trailer Gallery: A collection of trailers from Eastwood's films, showcasing his versatile career.
Movie: 91
Don Siegel's "Escape From Alcatraz" (1979) receives a stunning presentation in 4K UHD Blu-ray/Blu-ray by Kino Lorber, marking a significant upgrade for this classic prison escape drama. The package comes rich with supplementary features, including exclusive new programs with screenwriter Richard Tuggle and actor Larry Hankin, new audio commentary by critics Steve Mitchell and Nathaniel Thompson, and a vintage trailer, providing a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look. The 4K restoration accentuates the film's gritty atmosphere and the claustrophobic intensity of Alcatraz, enhancing both the visual and auditory experience for the audience. The release is region-free, with optional English SDH subtitles for the main feature, ensuring broad accessibility.
The film meticulously recreates the infamous 1962 escape from Alcatraz by Frank Morris and the Anglin brothers, capturing the planning, execution, and the suspenseful aftermath of their daring attempt. Clint Eastwood's portrayal of Frank Morris delves into the psyche of a determined escape artist, while the supporting cast brings depth to the other inmates involved in the breakout. Siegel's direction, combined with Bruce Surtees' cinematography, encapsulates the essence of life within the prison walls, making Alcatraz itself a central character in the narrative. The screenplay by Richard Tuggle, refined to emphasize the prison's imposing nature, complements this by adding layers to the story that go beyond a simple escape tale.
"Escape From Alcatraz" stands out not only for its attention to detail and historical accuracy but also for the way it engages viewers in rooting for its protagonists, despite their criminal backgrounds. The tension built through meticulous planning and execution underlines the film as a classic of the prison break genre. With this 4K release, viewers are treated to an immersive experience that highlights the film's enduring appeal, offering both a visual feast and a suspenseful storytelling that keeps one on edge until the final moments.
Total: 75
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Escape from Alcatraz" expertly showcases the film's inherent classic nature and its detailed attention to the prison environment, effectively bringing to light how Don Siegel personified Alcatraz, elevating the narrative beyond a mere escape story. This release, sourced from a new exclusive 4K master prepared at Paramount Pictures, presents the timeless tale with a notable enhancement in visual fidelity, although not without its flaws. The darker scenes suffer from black crush, detracting from the otherwise meticulous restoration effort. Despite this, the package is enriched with compelling new bonus features, making it a significant addition for collectors and fans of the genre.
Clint Eastwood's portrayal of Frank Morris stands out as a distinguished effort in his illustrious career, immortalizing an anti-hero character in a film that transcends his previous roles. Marking the final collaboration between Eastwood and Siegel, "Escape from Alcatraz" is immortalized in this 4K edition that sports a dark and moody Dolby Vision HDR transfer complemented by two solid audio tracks for an immersive viewing experience. The inclusion of notable bonus features further enhances this release, offering fans an in-depth look at the making of this cinematic masterpiece.
In conclusion, while this 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Escape from Alcatraz" exhibits some visual imperfections, particularly in its darker scenes, its overall presentation and the addition of valuable bonus content firmly establish it as a must-have for enthusiasts of the film and collectors alike. Its technical merits aside, the release serves as a fitting tribute to the powerful collaboration between one of Hollywood's iconic actors and a revered director, capturing a pivotal moment in their careers. Recommended for those seeking to experience this classic escape film with enhanced visual and audio fidelity.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
This is very unfortunate all other areas of the new 4K makeover are unquestionably superior to their counterparts on the old Blu-ray release....
Audio: 80
I started viewing the film in native 4K with the 2.0 track but did quite a few switches to the 5.1 track....
Extras: 100
BLU-RAY DISC The Ghost of Alcatraz - in this brand new program, screenwriter Richard Tuggle recalls how the original version of the screenplay for Escape From Alcatraz was repeatedly turned down by top...
Movie: 100
It concluded that Frank, John, and Clarence ended up at the bottom of the ocean because their possible presence on the mainland was never detected....
Total: 80
The latter understands that the prison has a unique and powerful personality and treats it as a character....
High-Def Digest review by Matthew HartmanRead review here
Video: 80
Apparently, Siegel actually wanted to shoot it in black and white to capture the nature of prison and as such, outside of the inmates' uniforms and a few shots in the yard and the prison library, there...
Audio: 80
Sounds of wind or coughs in the cell blocks or the shoes of the guards walking the block have a nice clear presence to give a sense of scale and atmosphere....
Extras: 50
Headlining the pack is a new audio commentary featuring film historians Nathaniel Thompson and Steve Mitchell that’s a great listen....
Movie: 90
As the seconds tick away that tension and suspense rise as each risk to the plan is slowly uncovered so that by the time the big breakout happens, you’re sitting on the edge of your seat....
Total: 80
As the fifth and final collaboration with Don Siegel, it was a great film for the Master and the Apprentice to part ways....
Director: Don Siegel
Actors: Clint Eastwood, Patrick McGoohan, Roberts Blossom
PlotA hardened prisoner named Frank Morris, with a history of escape attempts, is transferred to Alcatraz, an island fortress-prison claimed to be escape-proof. Intelligent and resourceful, Morris quickly realizes the immense challenges of his new confines but observes the rigid routines and exploitable weaknesses of the prison. His arrival catches the attention of the strict warden, who takes a special interest in him due to his escape record. As Morris familiarizes himself with the ins and outs of the daily life within the walls, he begins to plot an escape, aware that this will be his most difficult challenge yet.
Morris makes allies with a few fellow inmates, including the eccentric Doc and the tough but loyal brothers Clarence and John Anglin. Together, they quietly devise an elaborate plan to break free from the notorious island prison. The group exhibits patience and ingenuity, covertly crafting tools and plans while under the constant watch of the guards and the ever-vigilant warden. As they prepare for their risky endeavor, the tension within Alcatraz rises, with every step of their plan carrying the risk of discovery and dire consequences.
Writers: J. Campbell Bruce, Richard Tuggle
Release Date: 22 Jun 1979
Runtime: 112 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English