Over the Edge Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Over the Edge is a brilliant portrayal of youthful rebellion with standout performances and an engaging soundtrack; both Shout and Arrow releases offer unique merits.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
Shout Select's BD-50 release of 'Over the Edge' employs a new 2K scan with an MPEG-4 AVC encode, showcasing enhanced color saturation and improved clarity over previous versions, despite some grain and de-noising. With a steady 32 Mbps bitrate and solid contrast and black levels, it notably elevates the visual experience.
Audio: 82
Shout's Blu-Ray of 'Over the Edge' offers a well-rendered 2.0 DTS-HD Master Audio Dual Mono mix, featuring clean dialogue and impactful music by 1970s rock icons. While not as punchy as expected and with minor sibilance in dialogue, the sonic presentation retains clarity and dynamic depth, with optional English SDH subtitles available.
Extra: 73
The Blu-ray of "Over the Edge" offers a compelling mix of both archival and new content, including insightful audio commentaries, fresh interviews with director Jonathan Kaplan and screenwriter Charlie Haas, a retrospective documentary by Arrow Video, and a restored educational short. Shout's release enriches the film's legacy, despite some minor presentation limitations.
Movie: 80
Jonathan Kaplan's 'Over the Edge' is a vibrant tale of teenage rebellion miscast as a gang film during its initial 1979 release, but later found cult status amongst Gen X with its unflinching portrayal of adolescent unrest. Renowned for its authentic performances and a gripping rock soundtrack featuring icons like Van Halen and The Cars, the film explores the dangers of neglected youth in a planned suburban community, deftly capturing the essence of teenage turmoil with narrative finesse and a chaotic, yet enthralling finale.
Video: 72
Shout Select’s Blu-ray release of "Over the Edge" showcases an impressive MPEG-4 AVC encode on a BD-50, presenting the film in its original 1.85:1 theatrical aspect ratio. Leveraging a new 2K scan from the interpositive, this edition demonstrates notable enhancements over previous Warner Bros. DVD and Arrow Video transfers. With thick but film-like grain retention, the video maintains a nostalgic yet clean authenticity, subtly improved through de-noising and brightening techniques evident in outdoor scenes—like those featuring a clearer, slightly bluer sky. Colors, particularly primaries such as red, blue, and green, display richer saturation compared to earlier presentations, enhancing the overall visual vibrancy.
Detail remains consistently sharp, reinforcing the film's aesthetic fidelity. While some minor ringing is present, it does not detract from the overall viewing experience. The contrast and black levels have been meticulously adjusted, allowing for a substantial uptick in visual depth and clarity, especially visible in exterior sequences that now exhibit genuine sharpness and texture. Shout's execution in rendering vivid color and improved visual dynamics is commendable, substantiated by an efficient 32 Mbps encoding that ensures robust picture quality throughout the 95-minute runtime.
In conclusion, this Blu-ray edition by Shout Select stands out with a technically adept transfer that elevates "Over the Edge" beyond its original presentation constraints. Despite the film's basic cinematographic roots, this release brings forth an authentic, engaging viewing experience marked by visual clarity and vibrancy.
Audio: 82
The Blu-ray release of "Over the Edge" offers a robust audio presentation through a DTS-HD Master Audio Dual Mono format at 1699 kbps, 24-bit, highlighting the film’s dynamic rock soundtrack. The monaural mix is impressively clean, devoid of any unwelcome hisses or pops, ensuring clarity in dialogue and music. While Shout's mix may not deliver the punchiness found in Arrow's single mono track, its clarity and precision are noteworthy. The inclusion of an isolated music and effects track further enriches the listening experience, catering to those who appreciate focused audio elements.
Nevertheless, some sibilance in the dialogue is apparent but minor, maintaining overall comprehension and quality. The audio encapsulates each guitar twang and bass line with integrity, even reproducing music with an admirable depth given the mono constraints. Though a full stereo remix could enhance the musical presentation, this version stays true to the original theatrical sound, effectively balancing dialogue and music.
With contributions from notable 1970s rock acts like Cheap Trick and Van Halen, the soundtrack becomes a nostalgic auditory journey. The clarity of the vocals paired with dynamic music emphasizes key emotional beats within the film. Optional English SDH subtitles are available, aiding accessibility without detracting from the immersive mono experience. Shout’s edition honors the original audio's intent while presenting it with a contemporary quality that resonates well with both new audiences and those familiar with the film’s history.
Extras: 73
The Blu-ray release of "Over the Edge" offers an impressive collection of extras that provide deep insights into the film's production and legacy. Notably, the disc features two audio commentaries: one with director Jonathan Kaplan and others from the original team, and another from star Michael Kramer and journalist Mike Sacks, both providing an intimate and detailed look at the film's creation process and cultural context. Also included are new interviews with Kaplan and screenwriter Charlie Haas, where they recount their experiences and creative choices during the film's development. A notable addition is the retrospective documentary "Wide Streets + Narrow Minds," offering a comprehensive view through interviews with key cast and crew. The package is rounded out with educational shorts, trailers, and TV spots. Collectively, these features present a rich tapestry of behind-the-scenes stories and analyses that deep dive into the film's impact both upon release and subsequent years.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Director Jonathan Kaplan, Producer George Litto, and Writers Tim Hunter & Charlie Haas: In-depth insights from the original team.
- Audio Commentary with Star Michael Kramer and Journalist Mike Sacks: A fan-driven perspective on the film's cultural impact.
- NEW Watch Out for Children – Making OVER THE EDGE: Interview with director Jonathan Kaplan discussing his early influences.
- NEW Coming of Age – Writing OVER THE EDGE: Screenwriter Charlie Haas details the film's script evolution.
- NEW My Father Told Me – Scoring OVER THE EDGE: Kaplan reflects on his father's contributions to the film's music.
- Wide Streets + Narrow Minds: A seven-part retrospective documentary exploring the film's inception and legacy.
- Destruction: Fun or Dumb?: Restored educational short featured within the movie.
- Trailers: Collection of fully restored trailers from various international releases.
- TV Spots: Original US television promotional content.
Movie: 80
Jonathan Kaplan's "Over the Edge" presents a searing depiction of teenage rebellion and disaffection within a planned suburban community. Despite its initial box office failure due to misconceptions as a gang movie, it gained traction on pay-per-view and developed a cult following. The film, recognized for its authentic portrayal of adolescent struggles, is set in New Granada—a town designed for middle-class families but lacking in entertainment options for youth. This void leaves teenagers like Carl and Richie resorting to vandalism and petty crimes, reflecting the pervasive theme of young Generation X's aimlessness. The narrative's chaotic finale is amplified by a compelling rock soundtrack featuring artists like Cheap Trick and Van Halen, underscoring the film's energy and urgency.
"Over the Edge" draws significant influence from the “young people in revolt” genre, echoing classics like "Rebel Without a Cause" through its realistic portrayal of adolescent angst and defiance. While Kaplan crafts a gripping narrative with naturalistic performances from largely first-time actors, criticism arises from limited character development beyond Carl. The script by Charles Haas and Tim Hunter expertly illustrates Carl's decent nature being misdirected by peers, though side characters such as Richie and antagonistic elements like Mark’s conflict with Carl lack sufficient complexity. Nonetheless, editor Robert Barrère's expertise ensures narrative coherence and pacing, rendering this film a standout within its genre.
The depiction of youth anarchy in "Over the Edge" is both thrilling and authentic. Its raw portrayal of teenage alienation resonates deeply, heightened by thematic parallels with iconic films like "A Clockwork Orange." Despite earning a tame PG rating by today's standards, the film's provocative themes have made a lasting impact, influencing subsequent teen narratives. Notably referenced as Kurt Cobain’s favorite movie, it remains a salient example of how to portray adolescence with both sensitivity and edge. Its enthralling conclusion marks it as a quintessential depiction of youthful chaos and rebellion.
Total: 77
The Blu-ray of "Over the Edge" is a compelling release that captures the incendiary spirit of Gen X teenage rebellion. Featuring a nascent Matt Dillon, this film pairs raw anarchy with a dynamic soundtrack, including tracks from Cheap Trick, Van Halen, and the Ramones. Shout! Factory's version provides notable improvements in video quality compared to Arrow's edition, making it a preferred choice for those who prioritize visual experience. Although some of Arrow's exclusive materials are absent, Shout! Factory introduces its unique extras, striking a balance between retaining essential content and delivering fresh perspectives through new interviews and features.
The release is notable for its attention to both the technical and artistic elements of the film, presenting a transfer that appropriately addresses both cosmetics and historical integrity. While Shout! Factory's version may lack several of Arrow’s bonus materials such as the 2010 Q&A session, audio interviews, and specific retrospectives, it compensates with recent interviews with key cast members that provide deeper insights into the film's making.
In conclusion, Shout! Factory’s Blu-ray release of "Over the Edge" is highly recommended for both seasoned fans and newcomers. While some content overlaps with Arrow’s previous release, it stands robust with its superior video quality and contributions that enrich the viewing experience. Its ability to vividly capture the essence of a classic youth-centered social commentary makes it a standout in any collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Stephen LarsonRead review here
Video: 80
One of the best examples is when the camera follows Carl and Richie in a convenience store (see frame grab #s 22-24, especially the last one)....
Audio: 90
Compared to Arrow's single mono track, I feel Shout's 2.0 mono doesn't have the same punchy and aggressive sound to it....
Extras: 80
An Interview With Screenwriter Charlie Haas (17:08, 1080p) - Haas details his days at the University of Santa Cruz where he got to know Tim Hunter, the newspaper article Hunter and he used as a basis for...
Movie: 80
Lloyd Leipzig, Orion's vice president for ad�vertising and publicity at the time, confided to longtime Los Angeles Times film critic Kevin Thomas in a December 1979 interview that it was this misconception...
Total: 80
It is also a transitional film in the sense that several Eighties movies would feature realtors and property developers as villains (e.g., The Goonies and *batteries not included)....
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 90
The good news is that the music is reproduced with some heft despite the fact that it’s in mono, with a decent amount of bass and dynamics....
Extras: 90
They offer a wealth of information about the cast and crew, including their filmographies (although obviously that’s a bit out of date at this point)....
Movie: 90
Even a horror film like The Exorcist tapped into those fears back in 1973, with Regan MacNeil’s scandalous behavior while under the influence of Pazuzu proving to be almost as terrifying as the demon itself,...
Total: 90
On the other hand, Shout! has the edge in terms of video quality, so unless you already own the Arrow version, this should be your first choice....
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 60
The 1.85:1 presentation is derived from a new 2K scan of the film’s interpositive, resulting in sturdy color rendition and fairly nice definition....
Audio: 80
The music is heard in excellent fidelity with enough dynamics to give the pivotal moments more impactOptional English SDH subtitles play in a white font....
Extras: 60
Interview With Jonathan Kaplan About His Father, Composer Sol Kaplan“Wide Streets + Narrow Minds” A 7-Part Retrospective Documentary (72:46 in HD) – Inexplicably Shout doesn’t let you watch this well-constructed...
Movie: 80
Over The Edge is an exception, painting a realistic portrait of adolescent struggles even if the exploitation flick goes over the top in its darker moments....
Total: 70
An incendiary expression of Gen X teenage rebellion and anarchy featuring a young Matt Dillon and rousing musical soundtrack boasting Cheap Trick, Van Halen, and the Ramones...
Director: Jonathan Kaplan
Actors: Matt Dillon, Michael Eric Kramer, Pamela Ludwig
PlotIn a planned suburban community known as New Granada, designed for families with plentiful housing but few amenities for youth, teens struggle with boredom and disenchantment. With limited recreational options, the teenagers turn to each other for companionship and entertainment, often leading to petty crimes, vandalism, and rebellious behavior. Authorities, preoccupied with maintaining property values and a facade of tranquility, largely ignore or dismiss the struggles of the town's youth. Among these disillusioned teens is Carl, who finds himself drawn into the excitement of this underground world, befriending Richie, a charismatic troublemaker. As tensions between the adolescents and the adults grow, a chasm widens, representing more than just typical teenage angst; it showcases the divide between generations and a system unable to understand or address the needs of its younger members.
As the teens' defiance escalates, frustrations boil over into open confrontation. Misunderstandings and lack of communication only deepen the rift between kids yearning for acknowledgment and adults striving for control. The community braces itself for a storm that threatens the very foundation of the town’s ideals. Against this backdrop, the teenagers’ bond strengthens as they organize and express their dissatisfaction in increasingly bold ways. They challenge the status quo, setting in motion events that could potentially alter the community dynamic forever. As they rally together, they reveal stark truths about societal neglect and the unintended consequences of ignoring youthful voices. The stage is set for a dramatic clash that could teach lessons or cause irremediable harm, leaving one to wonder about the fate of New Granada and its fiery young residents.
Writers: Charles S. Haas, Tim Hunter
Release Date: 07 Jul 1979
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English