Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 84
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Crouching Tiger's UHD update delights fans with improved visuals but isn't a standout in the 30th Anniversary Collection.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
DTS-HD MA
Video: 84
Sony's 2160p/Dolby Vision upgrade for Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon enhances clarity, color realism, and texture, though minor issues like artifacting persist; overall, a breathtaking yet not flawless improvement.
Audio: 83
Sony's UHD release reuses the superb Dolby Atmos track from the original, emphasizing clarity, immersion, and precise sound placements, ensuring an exemplary auditory experience for 'Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon'.
Extra: 81
The Sony Pictures Classics 30th Anniversary UHD of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon includes exclusive extras like deleted scenes with Dolby Vision, Ang Lee's intros, commentaries, retrospectives, making-of features, music videos in two languages, a conversation with Michelle Yeoh, a photo gallery, and the original trailer, but omits the 2016 cast photos and collage.
Movie: 96
Sony's 'Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon' UHD release in the 30th Anniversary Collection features Dolby Vision, with details and extras from the 2016 version, capturing its timeless action and drama.
Video: 84
Sony's 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" as part of its Sony Pictures Classics 30th Anniversary Collection brings to the home theater a visual feast that almost perfectly captures the film's cinematic magic. The upgrade to 2160p resolution with Dolby Vision HDR enhances the presentation significantly, delivering an image marked by outstanding clarity, lifelike detail, and a maintained filmic grain that contribute to a truly immersive viewing experience. The leap in visual fidelity over previous releases is noticeable, with textures, especially in ornate clothing and natural environments, showcasing an impressive complexity and vibrance. Flesh tones are natural, blacks are deep without loss of detail, and whites shine brilliantly, all demonstrating the strength of this transfer.
However, despite these commendable improvements in bit rate and the reduction of grain issues leading to a cleaner and tighter detail in the picture, some persistent problems from past releases like motion blur and occasional artifacting still detract from an otherwise stellar visual quality. These imperfections, while not ruining the viewing experience, are noticeable enough to temper expectations slightly. The Dolby Vision HDR does its part in enriching black levels and enhancing color accuracy—most evident in dynamic scenes and with natural colors popping with newfound intensity—but it's clear that some issues may be inherent to the master or perhaps overlooked in the transfer process.
This re-release, with its distinct and substantial enhancements in video quality, particularly in terms of color grading and depth, presents the film with a newfound realism and visual appeal that fans will appreciate. Nonetheless, while the Dolby Vision HDR transfer presents a marked improvement over previous iterations, especially in terms of color precision and depth enhancement, the presence of some residual artifacts and occasional motion blur suggests limits to the restoration process. It underscores a dual narrative of technological advancement and inherent source limitations that both elevates this edition above its predecessors and leaves a slight sense of wanting—an impressive yet imperfect homage to an iconic film.
Audio: 83
The audio presentation of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" in its 4K UHD Blu-ray release retains the original Dolby Atmos soundtrack, delivering an auditory experience that is both grandiose and nuanced. Sony's decision to port over the previously acclaimed Atmos track has proven to be wise, as this layer adds a compelling depth and immersion that is rarely matched. The soundtrack, rich in its musicality and immersive with its environmental sounds, establishes a broad and engaging stage for the film's action. Instrumentals are crystal clear, offering a stellar clarity that makes each sword clash and environmental nuance like rustling leaves or flowing characters resonate with precision and profundity. The dialogue maintains a crispness throughout, ensuring that each word is anchored firmly within the film's fantasy reality.
Ambient effects in this release exploit the object-based format of Dolby Atmos effectively, providing a discrete and immersive experience even in the most subtle moments of character interaction or the tranquility before a storm. The auditory environment is dynamic, with the latter portions of the film showcasing an impressive utilization of the Atmos capabilities. Scenes set within a bamboo forest or a rain-drenched confrontation are enriched with atmospheric sounds that bleed into the ceiling speakers, creating an enveloping dome of sound that enhances the visceral impact of the visuals. Rain and wind are not just heard but felt, creating an auditory experience that complements the film's visual grandeur.
While the UHD release also offers a Mandarin DTS-HD MA 5.1 track and an English dubbed version, the original Mandarin Atmos track remains unparalleled in delivering the nuanced and dynamic sonic landscape envisioned by Ang Lee. This Atmos mix not only captures the essence of the film’s action but elevates it, making "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" a reference-quality example of how audio can enhance cinematic storytelling. Overall, the Atmos track on this 4K UHD release is essential listening for both audiophiles and cinephiles alike, setting a benchmark in home theater audio presentation.
Extras: 81
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray release of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" in the Sony Pictures Classics 30th Anniversary boxed set offers an insightful collection of extras, albeit identical to those found in the 2016 UHD version, with the exception of the omitted Cast and Crew photos and Moments collage. These supplements provide a depth of insight and enrich the viewing experience, including two audio commentaries that delve into the creative process behind this cinematic masterpiece. Notable among the extras are the deleted scenes, now enhanced with Dolby Vision, offering a glimpse into what might have been. Each element, from retrospectives to music videos, contributes to an expanded appreciation of the film's artistic achievements.
Extras included in this disc:
- Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon: A Retrospective: Insightful look back at the film’s legacy.
- Anniversary Edition Introduction By Ang Lee: The director’s perspective on the film’s impact over the years.
- Deleted Scenes: Enhanced with Dolby Vision for improved quality.
- Audio Commentary: Featuring discussions by Ang Lee and James Schamus.
- Audio Commentary: With cinematographer Peter Pau.
- The Making of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon: Behind-the-scenes look at the film's production.
- Music Video: A Love Before Time (English Version): A musical piece from the film's soundtrack.
- Music Video: A Love Before Time (Mandarin Version): Mandarin version of the film's love theme.
- A Conversation with Michelle Yeoh: Interview with one of the film’s stars.
- Photo Gallery: Collection of images from the film.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer promoting the film.
Movie: 96
Sony's 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon," a cinematic tour de force directed by Ang Lee, brings the 2000 film into the high definition era with groundbreaking Dolby Vision video but opts to maintain its original audio and supplemental features from the 2016 UHD release. This exclusivity to the Sony Pictures Classics: 30th Anniversary Collection box set means that while no new ground is broken in terms of auditory enhancements or additional content, the visual fidelity enhances the already mesmerizing imagery and action sequences that define this epic tale. The lack of a standard Blu-ray disc and inclusion of all extras on the UHD disc itself emphasizes Sony's focus on delivering a premium, albeit niche, product for collectors and aficionados.
The narrative intricacies of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" are as compelling as its aesthetic achieve; the film weaves a complex tapestry of love, betrayal, and the quest for freedom. Centered around the storied Green Destiny sword, characters navigate their desires and duties within a visually stunning world crafted by Lee. The performances by Chow Yun-fat, Michelle Yeoh, and Ziyi Zhang bring depth to this emotionally laden martial arts drama, reinforcing its status as an enduring masterpiece in cinema. Their portrayals ground the fantastical elements, making the story's themes of love and destiny resonate strongly.
This release serves as a testament to Lee's directorial prowess and the film's cultural significance. While enhancements primarily cater to visual upgrades via the Dolby Vision format, they suffice to breathe new life into the film's exquisite landscapes and meticulously choreographed fight scenes. The packaging and presentation nod towards nostalgia with slipcover art reminiscent of previous editions but updated for this unique collectible experience. Despite some desires for more innovative extras or audio improvements, this edition remains a must-have for purists and newcomers alike, offering a definitive way to experience one of the greatest films of its genre in impeccable 4K UHD quality.
Total: 84
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" receives a breathtaking facelift in its latest 4K UHD Blu-ray release, now embellished with Dolby Vision color grading that magnifies the visual spectacle of Ang Lee’s masterpiece. The film, a beacon of the martial arts genre that uniquely weaves human drama with groundbreaking action, retains its allure, further enhanced by this technological upgrade. While already lauded for its pictorial elegance and the deftness of its storytelling, the addition of Dolby Vision brings a newfound vibrancy that elevates the viewing experience to uncharted levels. However, it's imperative to note that despite these improvements, the release is not without its imperfections. Some visual anomalies persist, reminding us that even the finest upgrades have their limitations.
The technical offerings of this edition are commendable, with an active and engaging Atmos track complementing the improved visuals and a collection of bonus features that will surely appeal to both new viewers and longtime fans. This release is part of the 11-Film Sony Pictures Classics 30th Anniversary Collection, representing a polished albeit slightly flawed gem within an already remarkable lineup. The enhancements provided by the Dolby Vision transfer do offer visual improvements over its HDR10-only predecessor, but these might not justify the upgrade for all enthusiasts, given the lingering issues.
In conclusion, this 4K UHD release of "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" serves as a significant yet somewhat mixed blessing for aficionados of the film and 4K technology. While it presents a marvelous opportunity to experience one of cinema’s most enchanting tales with enhanced visual fidelity, the persistent anomalies prevent it from achieving absolute perfection. Nevertheless, for those entranced by the fusion of story and spectacle or collectors looking to complete their 30th Anniversary set, this edition remains a compelling, if not essential, acquisition.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
There is a rush of depth and intensity, of realism and accuracy, that surpass even the HDR grading....
Audio: 0
The film's elements play in expert harmony, with the added middle-back and top layer sound emplacements adding a greater sense of depth and immersion to the proceedings....
Extras: 100
This UHD release of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, as it ships in the Sony Pictures Classics 30th Anniversary boxed set, includes the same extras from the 2016 UHD, minus the now-extinct "Cast and Crew"...
Movie: 100
With Li Mu Bai's blessing, she entrusts the blade to Sir Te (Sihung Lung), but the weapon is stolen by the Jade Fox's apprentice, Jen (Ziyi Zhang), a confused girl hurtling towards adulthood and a life...
Total: 80
...
High-Def Digest review by Matthew HartmanRead review here
Video: 80
Some of the more noisy and distracting grain issues have been resolved to leave the image with a cleaner presentation and tighter details....
Audio: 90
Granted, there isn't a whole lot going on action-wise since much of the focus remains on the conversations and character interactions, but ambient effects occasionally bleed into the ceiling speakers with...
Extras: 70
Audio Commentary featuring Ang Lee with James Schamus Audio Commentary featuring Peter Pau Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon: A Retrospective Anniversary Edition Introduction By Ang Lee Deleted Scenes A Conversation...
Movie: 100
Pressed on a BD-100 disc, the disc is housed in a standard case with slipcover art, the insert art reflects seen on the 15th Anniversary “Cinema Series” release....
Total: 80
The new Dolby Vision transfer helps improve the visuals over the previous HDR10-only release but it still suffers from a number of anomalies keeping it from being a genuine show-stopper....
Director: Ang Lee
Actors: Chow Yun-Fat, Michelle Yeoh, Ziyi Zhang
PlotIn Qing Dynasty China, legendary swordsman Li Mu Bai decides to retire from his warrior life and bequeath his fabled sword, Green Destiny, to a benefactor. He entrusts this precious weapon to his old friend Yu Shu Lien, who runs a security company in Beijing. Before Shu Lien can deliver the sword to Beijing, it is stolen by a masked thief. As Shu Lien pursues the culprit, it becomes clear that the thief possesses skills only known to students of the Wudang martial arts sect.
The search for the stolen sword leads to the affluent Governor Yu's household and his daughter, Jen Yu, who is soon to marry into an arranged relationship. Beneath her aristocratic façade, Jen harbors the restless heart of a warrior and a secret life connected to the criminal underworld. As mysteries unfold, the paths of the characters intertwine in complex relationships ridden with unfulfilled love, honor, and betrayal. The quest to retrieve Green Destiny casts a spotlight on personal desires and the struggles between following one's heart and adhering to societal expectations.
Writers: Hui-Ling Wang, James Schamus, Kuo Jung Tsai
Release Date: 12 Jan 2001
Runtime: 120 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Taiwan, Hong Kong, United States, China
Language: Mandarin, Chinese