Promised Land Blu-ray Review
Score: 55
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Promised Land’s Blu-ray delivers excellent AV quality despite narrative flaws and minimal supplements, making it a solid but imperfect release.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
Promised Land's 1080p/AVC-encoded video presentation offers a film-like and faithful rendering with a subdued palette, natural lighting, and well-preserved grain. The transfer features good dimensional depth, stable sharpness, realistic textures, and clear detailing, although black levels and contrast could be slightly stronger. Overall, it’s an excellent high-definition video for an emotional drama.
Audio: 58
Universal's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for 'Promised Land' offers clear dialogue and a respectable soundstage. While front-heavy, it delivers ambient effects and Elfman's score effectively. Although lacking in power and depth, it suits the film's straightforward, documentary-like design well.
Extra: 21
The Blu-ray extras of 'Promised Land' provide a brief, straightforward look behind the scenes with an 11-minute EPK featurette heavy on interviews and film clips, complemented by a single extended scene with minimal additional dialogue.
Movie: 57
Despite solid performances and Van Sant's creativity, 'Promised Land' falters due to its heavy-handed sentimentality and an implausible plot twist. The film's strong environmental message overshadows its narrative, making it more a thinly veiled sermon than a balanced drama.
Video: 70
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Promised Land" is solidly executed, delivering a high-definition experience that's on par with newer releases. The 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer showcases colors that appear natural, albeit with a subdued palette that perfectly complements the film's tone. Skin tones are realistically depicted, offering defining texture and good tonal separation. Although black levels could be stronger, they are satisfactory overall, avoiding problematic crush and maintaining decent detail in low-light settings. The intentionally downplayed contrast, combined with stable sharpness and clarity, results in a presentation that remains true to the film’s vision.
Detail is commendable, particularly in close-ups where textures are revealing and refined. The encode maintains impressive dimensional depth, with artifacts, banding, and other digital imperfections notably absent. The finely rendered countryside scenes highlight visible fine lines in leaves and tree bark, as well as individual blades of grass. Even the smallest architectural imperfections and blemishes in the town are distinctive and clear. Although there is some inherent source-born noise in darker scenes, the overall image quality remains crisp and clean, contributing to a film-like presentation that aligns with the director's small-town aesthetic.
In summary, while it may not initially strike viewers as a standout, this video transfer reveals itself to be proficient and faithful to the filmmakers' artistic intent. The subdued color design and balanced contrast aid in crafting an authentic, emotionally resonant viewing experience. It’s an excellent high-definition transfer for a subdued yet compelling drama, capturing both the nuances of the rural setting and the naturalistic performances of the cast.
Audio: 58
Universal's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track for "Promised Land" offers an authentic yet understated audio experience that aligns perfectly with its documentary-like design. Dialogue is crisply rendered through the center channel, ensuring clarity and precision in every conversation, which is crucial given the film's dialogue-focused nature. While the aural perspective leans toward a front-heavy design, with limited but effective rear channel output, Danny Elfman's score fills the soundfield with a welcome fullness, subtly integrating ambient effects from key settings like the local bar and town hall meetings.
The front channels take precedence, creating a one-dimensional soundscape that is both refined and appropriately deep. The LFE output is notably restrained, yet reliably supports the overall mix. Rear channels are employed to provide a modest yet appreciable sense of envelopment, adding a nuanced layer to the viewing experience. Although it may lack extensive mid-range activity and low-frequency immersion, the lossless mix does commendable justice to the film's original sound design, maintaining a professional and engaging tone throughout.
In sum, the audio presentation may not deliver grand flourishes or sonic pyrotechnics, but it excels in delivering a faithful and personality-rich soundtrack. The channel separation and excellent dialogue clarity contribute to a wide soundstage that complements the character-driven narrative. The whole experience remains true to the film's intent, providing a reliable, nuanced audio backdrop that enhances the storytelling without overshadowing it.
Extras: 21
The Blu-ray extras for "Promised Land" offer a concise exploration into the film with a standard EPK featurette and a single extended scene. The 11-minute "The Making of Promised Land" provides an overview through interviews with cast and crew, supplemented by ample behind-the-scenes footage. However, it lacks depth and new insights for viewers seeking thorough behind-the-scenes knowledge. The extended scene, which includes minor dialogue extensions, adds minimal value to the overall experience, offering nothing significantly revelatory. While these offerings are appreciated, they may leave die-hard fans desiring more substantial content.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of Promised Land: Brief and superficial behind-the-scenes featurette.
- Extended Scene: Single scene with some additional dialogue.
Movie: 57
"Promised Land," directed by Gus Van Sant and starring Matt Damon, operates within the mainstream character-driven drama spectrum, featuring well-known actors and a strong narrative focus. The film revolves around corporate salesman Steve Butler (Damon), who arrives in a rural town to secure drilling rights for his company during immense economic hardship. Despite strong performances, particularly from Francis McDormand, the movie occasionally falters due to an underwhelming third act and a convoluted plot twist. Damon's portrayal of Butler captures a believable transformation from confident salesman to a man questioning his ethical and professional boundaries.
The cinematography by Linus Sandgren utilizes broad, sweeping shots to emphasize the pastoral beauty of the Pennsylvania landscape, juxtaposed against the looming threat of industrial encroachment. Van Sant's unique visual style is evident, applying subtle yet arresting composition techniques that breathe life into the film's setting and underline its thematic concerns. The supporting cast, including John Krasinski as a dedicated environmentalist and Hal Holbrook as an informed local teacher, enrich the narrative and bolster the film's environmental message without delving too deeply into overt political territory.
Despite its flaws, such as the clunky plot twist that disrupts narrative flow and adds unnecessary melodrama, "Promised Land" carries an earnest core that examines the clash between corporate interests and environmental stewardship. The script highlights Damon's journey from a capitalist advocate to someone deeply conflicted about the morality of his work, rather than just preaching its viewpoint. This focus on character development makes the film more engaging, even as it wrestles with delivering its heavy-handed message effectively.
Total: 55
"Promised Land" under the direction of Gus Van Sant and featuring Matt Damon takes a stab at addressing the environmental concerns associated with hydraulic fracturing, wrapped within a personal journey narrative. While it occasionally stumbles with an implausible twist that dilutes its central message, the film compensates through strong performances, particularly from Frances McDormand. The Blu-ray edition enhances the viewing experience, delivering exceptional video and audio quality, though it falls short in the supplementary materials department.
The technical execution on this Blu-ray is noteworthy, providing a high fidelity visual and auditory experience. The AV presentation is pristine, capturing the film's aesthetic nuances with clarity. However, the lack of substantive supplemental content may disappoint those looking for deeper insights or behind-the-scenes materials.
In conclusion, while "Promised Land" falters in delivering a convincing narrative towards the end, the Blu-ray release bolsters its merits with superior picture and sound quality. Fans of the film will appreciate this edition, but for others, it might be more suited for a rental to assess its appeal.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 90
Artifacting, banding and the like are nowhere to be found either, and the only issue worth mentioning is the inherent, source-born noise that crops up when the lights go low....
Audio: 80
Dialogue is clean and clear on the whole, LFE output is restrained but reliable, and the rear speakers are bristling with ambient effects, even though the soundscape tends to be rather front-heavy by design....
Extras: 20
The Making of Promised Land (HD, 11 minutes): Heavy on film clips and talking heads, this short, superficial behind-the-scenes EPK is appreciated but far from revealing....
Movie: 60
Krasinski smears it on thick, sure, but he means well, even if his charisma is decidedly small screen; Holbrook is fantastic, injecting measured gravitas early on and quiet resolve throughout; DeWitt is...
Total: 60
Earnest and sincere for a stretch, manipulative and implausible in the end, Promised Land is a message movie that nearly forgets its message....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The color palette also feels largely restrained and downplayed, but everything appears accurately rendered and clean with only primaries providing some sense we're watching in HD....
Audio: 60
In this respect, conversations are loud and clear, allowing the listener to take in every syllable uttered and appreciate the unique dialect of the area in which the plot is set....
Extras: 0
The Making of Promised Land (HD, 11 min) — Brief, straightforward EPK piece shows interviews with cast & crew and lots of BTS footage....
Movie: 60
The emotional journey is on his personal belief in this capitalist pursuit, which can potentially produce harmful reactions, and a sudden challenge that forces him to question the ethics of that belief...
Total: 60
Though showing a few minor hiccups in the narrative, the film is well-made and well-intentioned, and it ultimately proves to be entertaining and satisfying....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 86
Images offer good dimensional depth, stable sharpness, and clarity but exhibit opulent high level detail and glossy video quality....
Audio: 80
Aural perspective is one dimensional with emphasis on the front channels however venue replicating effects and diffuse ambience is fed to the rear channels which provide a limited but effective sense of...
Extras: 30
(HD) Extended scene (HD) The making of Promised Land – 10 minute featurette My Scenes bookmark feature Bonus DVD Digital Copy Ultraviolet Digital Copy...
Movie: 60
Corporate salesman Steve Butler (Damon) has been dispatched to the rural town of McKinley with his sales partner (Frances McDormand) to offer much-needed relief to the economically hard-hit residents in...
Total: 64
16x9 Screen Marantz AV8801 11.2 Channel Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-103 Universal Disc/3D...
Director: Gus Van Sant
Actors: Matt Damon, Frances McDormand, John Krasinski
PlotSteve Butler, a corporate salesman for a natural gas company, arrives in a rural town with his partner, Sue. Their mission is to secure drilling rights from the local landowners, promising economic prosperity in exchange for natural gas exploration. The town's economic struggles make the offer seem appealing to many residents. However, when a respected schoolteacher, Frank Yates, raises concerns about the environmental impact, the community becomes divided. These doubts are further fueled by the arrival of environmental activist Dustin Noble, who launches a strong opposition campaign, highlighting the potential dangers of hydraulic fracturing.
As Steve and Sue work to sway the town in favor of the drilling project, Steve begins to question the morality of his work and the real costs to the community. The narrative becomes a personal journey for Steve, who grapples with his own values and beliefs as the townspeople decide their future. The escalating tension between corporate interests and environmental responsibility serves as a pivotal backdrop, creating a richly layered story that examines the complexities of progress, sustainability, and ethical responsibility.
Writers: John Krasinski, Matt Damon, Dave Eggers
Release Date: 04 Jan 2013
Runtime: 106 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, United Arab Emirates
Language: English