Piranha II: The Spawning Blu-ray Review

The video presentation of "Piranha II: The Spawning" on Blu-ray from Scream Factory is notably impressive. Scream Factory has utilized a new 2K scan of the original camera negatives, and the resulting transfer is markedly superior to any previous home video release. The MPEG-4 AVC-encoded BD-50 disc presents the film in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, rectifying the heavily cropped pan-and-scan editions of the past. The image quality is generally sharp and clean, although some scenes, particularly darker ones, do exhibit heavy grain – a testament to the low-budget nature of many 80s films. The grain, however, blends naturally into the texture without detracting from the overall visual experience. Fine details are especially prominent in underwater shots, with vivid color reproduction and luminous hues that recreate the film's theatrical charm.

Colors are rendered vibrantly but maintain a natural look. Sky and sea blues are clean and bright, while skin tones appear realistic, free from artificial manipulation. Despite occasional racy or gory scenes where there's a minor drop in clarity and color reproduction, the film looks exceptionally good throughout most sequences. The depth of field is well-handled, with foreground and background separation enhancing the cinematic experience, particularly in fluid movement scenes. Black levels are deep, managing to retain detail in very dark scenes, although some instances of detail loss do occur. Overall, the presentation is devoid of distracting noise and artifacts.

The efforts put into color correction are commendable, with minimal instances of print damage noted. The film's natural grain structure is preserved without any distracting digital noise reduction. Piranha II's Blu-ray debut stands as a testament to the high-quality restoration work Scream Factory has achieved, delivering the best possible viewing experience for fans of this cult classic.

The audio presentation of "Piranha II: The Spawning" on Blu-Ray features a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono mix, reflecting its low-budget origins. While it doesn’t provide an expansive or multi-dimensional sound experience, the audio is largely serviceable. Dialogue is mostly clear and discernible, although some scenes display dips in volume and wonky lip sync due to heavy ADR usage. There are no noticeable dropouts, hiss, or crackles, which is commendable for a film shot on such a modest budget in 1981. Steve Powder's score, specifically, stands out as a highlight—it’s both full and rich, well-separated along the front channels, and evocatively supports the film's atmosphere.

However, the audio track does have its limitations. Although the dialogue is intelligible for the most part, certain scenes exhibit minor issues with echo and other distortions. The low-frequency extension is virtually nonexistent, leaving the presentation somewhat flat. The effects, while balanced within the texture of the mono mix, do not provide substantial depth or dimension but are effective enough for a horror production of this genre and era.

Overall, the DTS-HD MA 2.0 Mono mix offers a faithful reproduction of the original monaural sound, with the score effectively complementing the narrative tension without overpowering other elements. Despite its technical flaws and budgetary constraints, it delivers an engaging if somewhat imperfect auditory experience typical of early '80s horror films. Optional English SDH subtitles are available for added accessibility.

The extras on the Blu-ray of "Piranha II: The Spawning" provide an insightful look into the film's production through engaging interviews and classic promotional material. Actor Ricky Paull Goldin's interview offers a nostalgic recount of his experience filming as a teenager in Jamaica, shedding light on James Cameron's precise direction. Special effects artist Brian Wade shares his early career memories, particularly his work on the piranha sculptures, which adds depth to understanding the film’s practical effects. Although the audio quality in Wade's interview could be better, his professional journey is compelling. Additionally, the disc includes a theatrical trailer for enthusiasts. Overall, these features are worth watching for fans interested in the film's behind-the-scenes aspects.

Extras included in this disc:

• NEW One Moment in Time: Ricky Paull Goldin on Piranha Part II: The Spawning: Goldin shares experiences of filming and working with James Cameron.
• NEW The Sky Has Teeth: Brian Wade on Piranha Part II: The Spawning: Wade discusses creating the piranha sculpts and other insights.
• Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional trailer for the film.

"Piranha II: The Spawning" stands as an intriguing piece in cinematic history, primarily for being the unofficial directorial debut of James Cameron. However, the production's notoriously tumultuous backstory significantly impacts the film’s final product, making it a curious case study rather than an artistic triumph. Initially brought on to steer a sequel to Joe Dante’s “Piranha,” Cameron's vision for a horror-comedy featuring Romeroesque flying piranhas was heavily compromised. Producer Ovidio Assonitis, notorious for his domineering involvement, sidelined Cameron early into filming, leading to creative rifts that ultimately resulted in a patchwork film. The film’s title card reads "Piranha II: Flying Killers," hinting at its chaotic development process with distributors insistent on distinguishing it from its predecessor.

The plot follows marine biologist Anne Kimbrough (Tricia O’Neil), investigating a series of deaths linked to genetically altered flying piranhas. Supported by her ex-husband Steve (played by a young Lance Henriksen), Anne battles dismissal and skepticism from locals while navigating personal and professional turmoil. The storytelling is marred by disjointed scenes that betray Cameron's original script, overlaid with forced nudity and implausible horror. Despite these flaws, certain elements hint at Cameron's nascent talents, specifically the underwater cinematography and effective staging during dive sequences. Yet, the film teeters between an Italian sex comedy and a horror flick, failing to firmly root itself in either genre.

Technically, the film flaunts some commendable underwater visuals, yet suffers from inconsistent execution in creature effects, primarily visible in the laughably constructed piranhas. Acting caliber varies widely, with Henriksen’s earnest performance standing out amidst generally subpar portrayals. Scenes intended to invoke horror often pivot unintentionally to comedy due to absurd dialogue and over-the-top scenarios. "Piranha II: The Spawning" remains a testament to low-budget exploitation cinema, simultaneously fascinating and flawed, providing more entertainment through its chaotic delivery than its genuine intent to frighten or amuse.

"Piranha II: The Spawning" has long stood as a testament to the peculiar charm of B-movie horror. Known for its laughable plot and sub-par performances, this film marks an early but colorful chapter in James Cameron’s career. Scream Factory's Blu-ray release has been met with a range of reactions, oscillating between disappointed nostalgia and thrilled amusement. This version showcases a new 2K restoration, enhancing the visual appeal despite inconsistent elements. The inclusion of the original theatrical mono track in DTS-HD MA 2.0 Mono format satisfies purists, though the absence of the Director's Cut and Cameron's personal involvement will irk some enthusiasts.

Focusing on cult appeal, Scream Factory has managed to cater to fans with an appreciation for the film's eccentricities. The video quality benefits significantly from modern remastering, although it's not without flaws that prevent a flawless presentation. Likewise, the audio reproduction faithfully captures the essence of the original track. Special features are modest, featuring interviews with cast and crew, but those hoping for more extensive archival content or a commentary from Cameron might find it lacking.

In conclusion, "Piranha II: The Spawning" is far from a classic but delivers a unique blend of horror and humor that can entertain when approached with the right mindset. This Blu-ray release is a commendable effort by Scream Factory to polish a cult favorite without losing its quintessential trashy charm. For those seeking the pinnacle of monster movies, look elsewhere. However, if you appreciate hilariously bad horror films, this Blu-ray edition deserves a spot on your shelf. It's a playful indulgence best enjoyed with a cold drink and a sense of humor. Recommended for cult film enthusiasts and completionists.