The Counterfeit Traitor Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "The Counterfeit Traitor" by Kino Lorber showcases a meticulously crafted 1080p transfer sourced from a new 4K scan of the original 35mm camera negative. Paramount Pictures has executed a commendable restoration effort, presenting the film in its authentic 1.85:1 aspect ratio, encoded with MPEG-4 AVC. The visual presentation stands markedly improved over previous editions, such as the earlier Australian release, thanks to advanced image restoration techniques evident in this release.

Despite occasional minor blemishes and specks on the visual surface, which could benefit from further cosmetic enhancements, the clarity, delineation, and depth are remarkably robust. The grading is expertly handled, ensuring the primary colors are solid without being exaggerated, with a well-balanced temperature and color balance throughout. Image stability remains consistent, effectively handling challenging shadow areas without visible crushing.

While the missing opening Paramount logo might catch the attention of keen observers, this nuanced detail does not detract from the overall quality. Minor encoding optimizations could enhance grain consistency, but these are minor issues. The precision of the scan and mastering techniques provides superb visual fidelity, making this Blu-ray release the definitive home video version of the film to date. Note: This is a Region-A locked release, requiring appropriate playback equipment for access.

The Blu-ray audio presentation of "The Counterfeit Traitor" offers two significant audio tracks: English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 and English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1. Both tracks demonstrate remarkable clarity and sharpness, a testament to the recent and effective transfer process. The 2.0 track preserves the essence of the original mono soundtrack with notable improvements over previous releases, showcasing crisp dialogue and a clean sound mix free from typical audio distortions such as fluttering or popping.

On the other hand, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is not just an arbitrary upmix; it is evident that careful consideration was given to its creation. This track presents an enriched audio experience, effectively utilizing the surround capabilities to enhance Alfred Newman's music score while maintaining the integrity of the original sound elements. Dialogue remains clear and dynamically positioned within the soundstage, retaining its prominence without overshadowing other sonic elements.

In conclusion, this Blu-ray release is likely the definitive audio experience for "The Counterfeit Traitor" on home video. Whether one opts for the original mono representation in 2.0 or the more immersive 5.1 experience, both tracks offer significant advancements in audio fidelity, ensuring a superior auditory encounter devoid of the common anomalies found in older releases.

The Blu-ray release of "The Counterfeit Traitor" presents a carefully curated selection of bonus materials that enrich the viewing experience with historical and cinematic context. An exclusive audio commentary by noted film historian and writer Julie Kirgo provides a deep dive into the film's production intricacies, focusing on the cast, including a spotlight on actors like Hugh Griffith. This insightful track replaces any previous commentaries and stands as a unique offering for this release. The theatrical trailers, including a newly remastered original U.S. trailer, deliver nostalgia and promotional context, although they are devoid of subtitles. Additional bonus trailers from related films in the KLSC catalog further contribute to the retrospective charm. While some features from previous releases, such as a commentary with Lee Pfeffer and Paul Scrabo or the documentary "William Holden: The Golden Boy," are absent, the existing extras present substantial value for collectors and film enthusiasts.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary: Exclusive audio commentary by Julie Kirgo detailing film production and key actors.
• Theatrical Trailer: Newly remastered U.S. theatrical trailer for "The Counterfeit Traitor."
• Bonus KLSC Trailers: Trailers for various related films, enriching the historical context.

"The Counterfeit Traitor," directed by George Seaton and released on Blu-ray by Kino Lorber, is a skillful adaptation of Alexander Klein's novel based on the real-life exploits of double agent Eric Erickson during WWII. William Holden stars as Erickson, an American-born Swedish oilman coerced into espionage by Allies, posing as a Nazi supporter while gathering intelligence on German strategies. Despite Holden’s impressive career, his portrayal of Erickson tends to be unconvincing due to his Hollywood persona overshadowing the character's covert nature. The film remains faithful to its historical settings, enhancing its credibility through authentic locations, captured with atmospheric cinematography by Jean Bourgoin.

The narrative meticulously balances intense espionage suspense with character-driven drama. Erickson's evolution from a reluctant spy to a committed agent, influenced by his relationship with German socialite Marianne Möllendorf, played by Lilli Palmer, is compelling. Seaton’s direction skillfully navigates the dynamic between fact and fiction for dramatic purposes, highlighted in tense sequences like the perilous escape from Denmark to Sweden. Despite the film's leisurely pace, it deftly intersperses action and tension, avoiding contrived dialogues and maintaining audience engagement.

Supported by an ensemble cast, the film enriches its narrative layers. Lilli Palmer's portrayal of Marianne adds emotional depth that counterbalances Holden's detached performance. Hugh Griffith shines as the persuasive British agent Collins, while Ernst Schröder and other supporting actors contribute memorable performances that enhance the film's authenticity. "The Counterfeit Traitor" stands out as an understated yet compelling WWII film, offering a nuanced depiction of espionage and the moral complexities faced by those caught between allegiance and survival.

"The Counterfeit Traitor" Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber offers a richly executed restoration that highlights the film's merits as a classic espionage drama set against the WWII backdrop. While marketed as a historical thriller, the film exudes a Hollywood flair, focusing more on stylistic storytelling than strict adherence to historical accuracy. William Holden's portrayal of Eric Erickson is characterized by his signature charisma and is supported by a cast that complements the film's balance of romance and adventure. Although its wartime authenticity may be questioned, the performances and direction deliver an engaging experience, reflective of lavish Hollywood productions of the era.

The technical quality of this Blu-ray release is commendable, based on a new 4K master developed at Paramount Pictures. This results in a robust and attractive visual presentation with an organic feel that enhances the period setting. The HD transfer performed by Kino Lorber is noteworthy, capturing the movie’s atmospheric settings from Europe during the war with clarity and depth. Additionally, the inclusion of an informative commentary track enriches the viewing experience for both novices and cinephiles alike. This release stands as a significant upgrade from previous DVD offerings, though collectors may wish to retain their Imprint Blu-ray for any exclusive features not present here.

In conclusion, Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release of "The Counterfeit Traitor" effectively revitalizes this espionage tale for modern audiences, blending technical prowess with cinematic charm. It is highly recommended for enthusiasts of classic cinema seeking a refined edition of this noteworthy film. With its visual enhancements and supplemental content, it is a commendable offering for both longtime fans and newcomers to the genre.